If I were to receive this book as a student dissertation, I would return it with the comments that it was a reasonable draft that required considerable revision, that its organization and referencing were confusing, and that its content was unfocused and replete with digressive repetitions. There are undoubtedly some important observations and useful nuggets of information here, but it is hard to believe that the editors at Cambridge University Press knew what they were doing when they published this book in its current format.
This is a great pity. Of all the topics that contributed to the failure of the Camp David Middle East peace talks in 2000 and the peace process in general, the holy sites of Jerusalem was among the foremost. Of all the difficult topics that need to be addressed and require thorough preparation for future negotiations, the holy sites of Jerusalem is the most divisive. Thus, the intention of the book is sound but the execution disappointing.
The book is the outcome of extensive discussion carried out under the auspices of the International Human Rights Institute of DePaul University in Chicago, and it is clear that the author and participants have devoted a great deal of effort and thought to compiling the material. However, the result is a thin offering padded with contextual material and with discussion regarding negotiations and conflict resolution in general. It is not until Chapters 8 and 9 that we are presented with the core material relating to the topic of the title.
Before referring to content, I highlight some shoddy editorial and presentational issues that should have been picked up by the publishers. The referencing is so confusing as to render the book almost useless as a source: dates of works are presented in footnotes without publishing details; some titles are in capitals and others are not; there is a bibliography, but the works cited are scattered across several chapter divisions, making them difficult to locate; and Uzi Benziman's book of 1973 is used as a source for the establishment of diplomatic relations between the Vatican and Israel in 1994 (p. 50, n. 37)—all very basic undergraduate errors. The organization of the chapters into subheadings is bewildering; there seems to be a random use of capitals and italicized subheadings (e.g., Chapter 8, p. 132ff.), which leaves the reader completely lost as to the relationship among the different parts of the chapter. The beginnings of Chapters 4 and 6 seem to repeat themselves, and there is frequent jumping from policy discussion to discussions of general principle as if different texts were being put together. All this detracts from the content and suggests confusion regarding the overall picture being drawn.
One could overlook the presentational deficiencies if the content were impressive, but unfortunately it is not. The first three chapters are a rehash of existing studies in an attempt to contextualize the topic (and they demonstrate an overreliance on Israeli sources, in particular Tsimhoni). The next three chapters are also contextual in that they draw on insights from the field of conflict resolution but could be summarized much more concisely.
The most useful part of the book is Chapter 8, comprising a discussion of how to define a holy site or holy place. This is an important task in light of how holy places are used to further a nationalist agenda in Jerusalem. Here, Guinn makes a significant contribution in identifying how a phenomenological or functional approach based upon the criteria of “need for protection” rather than subjective criteria of “holiness” can be used to define a holy site. The advantage of this approach is that it is dynamic and can encompass long-term and short-term change. Some sites may be more holy at different times of the year and require protection on a graduated basis. However, even in this chapter, the organization of the material makes it difficult to follow. Key discussions on criteria are relegated unaccountably to footnotes (p. 133ff.) while the confusing subheadings make the argument difficult to follow. In addition, after concentrating on holy places, the text switches suddenly to the “holy basin” approach, only to be followed by a complete cessation of all references to it (p. 133). In a similar vein, a useful distinction between iconic and cultic sites is developed only to be changed to a sole focus on cultic sites without any explanation given. The result, despite the rich potential of the project, is a deeply unsatisfactory study that does not do justice to the participants or the funders of the project. A great shame.
