In the past decade, we have witnessed increased attention in political science to black gender politics in general and black women as political actors in particular. Meeting the call of Jewell Prestage's classic work, “In Quest of the African American Political Woman” (The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 515 [1991]: 88–103), black feminist scholars have sought to expand our understanding of black women's politics, both formal and informal. In Sister Citizen, Melissa Harris-Perry makes her own contribution to this burgeoning area of study, presenting an unconventional look at black women in politics in form and substance.
In terms of form, Harris-Perry attempts to disrupt mainstream political science's weddedness to quantitative research by drawing from a more diverse menu of methods. Although she includes statistical analysis, there is also discussion of the results of focus groups with 43 women in Chicago, New York, and Oakland. The book opens with an excerpt from Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937) as a segue into a discussion of the impact of Hurricane Katrina and what it tells us about the unique vulnerabilities of black women in the United States. Throughout, Harris-Perry liberally weaves poetry and fictional accounts into her broader narrative. In terms of substance, the author does not center her work on voting, political opinion, public policy, or more conventional political science fare. Although she sees her book as having implications for such concerns, she instead delves into the inner lives of black women, investigating how their emotions potentially influence and, in some cases, possibly forestall their politics.
The metaphor of the “crooked room” is the linchpin of Harris-Perry's investigation of emotion and black women's politics. Drawn from field-dependence literature, the crooked room suggests that black women are set in an environment that is inherently off-kilter. For the author, dominant, controlling images, such as Jezebel, Mammy, and Sapphire (or the Angry Black Woman), generate the confinement and disorientation of the crooked room. She sets herself the task of explaining its effects. In their effort to align themselves properly, some black women can adjust and find a truly balanced sense of self, while others are unable to “stand up straight” (p. 29). They, in effect, are “tilted” in this contorted environment (p. 29). Invoking political theory to suggest that politics is based not only on equitable distribution of goods but also on recognition by fellow citizens, Harris-Perry argues that the crooked room and its stereotypical images both confine black women and, more importantly, prevent them from being “seen” in the public sphere.
According to the author, shame is a ubiquitous emotion that is foundational to black women's experience of misrecognition. It involves an inherently “social” dimension in which individuals or groups are viewed as fundamentally unworthy; a shamed individual or group's identification with the “malignant self” understandably produces a desire “to withdraw, submit, or appease others” (p. 104). Although “reintegrative shaming” involves a positive function of affirming desirable social norms and limiting antisocial behavior, black people, especially black women, face a “stigmatizing shaming” that involves “Othering” (p. 108). Indeed, shame, for Harris-Perry, is the core of racism. In her chronological overview of black racial suffering—slavery, Jim Crow, lynching, migration, Daniel Moynihan's' report on the black family and welfare policy, among other things—she frames shame as a meta-experience of black life.
After setting out her analytical perspective, Harris-Perry turns our attention to examples of shame's impact and what she views as black women's sometimes crippling responses. In one example, she poignantly recounts the harrowing events following Katrina, the 2005 disaster in which the public's response and government inattention to the crisis showcased a lack of recognition for the plight of black women. Her assessment of Katrina echoes that of other scholars and journalists who examined the variety of ways in which the public and state's response to the levy breeches and the resulting mayhem served as a litmus test of current racial attitudes and government treatment of African Americans. Although the author spends less time on the neoliberal turn that occasioned the disaster in the first place and influenced its response (an approach employed by a variety of contributors to Cedric Johnson's edited collection The Neoliberal Deluge [2011], for instance), she adds to this discussion a painstaking documentation of racial and gender attitudes about the crisis, including the results of the Katrina Disaster Study, a project for which she was a lead researcher.
The book's final chapters center on the ways in which black women's efforts to counteract the crooked room, for Harris-Perry at least, are overwhelmingly set within the paradigm of the “strong black woman.” She, like other scholars, points out the debilitating impact of black women's embrace of this image: In supporting others, black women are often left burned out, physically sick, and without adequate social support. Although spiritual beliefs serve as a source of encouragement, the black church, because of its patriarchal leanings, presents its own challenges. Again, here, Harris-Perry draws on statistical modeling and analysis in order to parse the fine elements of affiliation, support, and spiritual imagination.
To be sure, in a moment when a post–black feminist interpretation of intersectionality seems to be drawing attention away from black women or even race as the subject of research, the author's focus on black women is more than welcomed. Also, her use of multiple methods, including literary analysis, fits within the contours of black feminist approaches. Her effort to speak to nonspecialists within political science and to the general public responds to calls to make scholarship available to broader audiences. Still, despite these interventions, Sister Citizen is, ironically, troubled by several misrecognitions of its own.
First, equating racism and sexism with shame leaves little room for understanding black people as creatively and imaginatively responding to challenges or the dynamism of human personalities. Throughout the text, Harris-Perry attempts to forestall criticisms by responding to anticipated arguments, including this one regarding a focus on shame. While addressing possible concerns is a potentially effective, well-worn element of good argumentation, her efforts generally fall flat. After making the case for shame's connection to racism, for instance, she explains that not everyone succumbs to its effects (pp. 123–24). But this “caveat” does little to dislodge the brunt of her general theory of shame, and not because of its brevity but because her argument depends on a static, general effect of shame that has to operate more often than not in order for her claims on its broad political impact to make sense.
Second, the crooked room metaphor does not recognize the diversity of black women's experiences and, arguably, promotes middle-class notions of respectability. By its nature, it suggests a central, inert space in and through which black women may merely respond. There is little sense that their ideological, material, or other differences mediate their experiences. Moreover, Harris-Perry's metaphor of “standing up straight” as a symbol for successfully responding to the contorted reality of a crooked room is an implicitly conservative, phallogocentric one, suggesting that the price of political recognition before the paternal, racial state is alignment with a discernable set of appropriate norms. Video vixens and Harris-Perry's own expression of anger during a televised discussion of hip-hop are models of “tilted” postures (pp. 29, 318–19 n. 2). Black clubwomen, well known for a politics of respectability, and women engaging in nonviolent protests, conversely, are examples of those who stand erect (pp. 31–32). Respectability politics may also explain the fissures in Harris-Perry's otherwise generally forceful critique of black female stereotypes. She conjectures, for instance, that “humiliated fury” and the “shame-rage spiral[s]” it creates may serve as a basis for the angry black woman stereotype (pp. 122–23), and she focuses on the perceived public shaming of white males and black faculty in the 2006 Duke lacrosse team “social disaster,” as opposed to the shaming of the black female who claimed to be raped.
Finally, the focus on recognition and the metaphor of the crooked room affirms the individualistic, self-help logic of this neoliberal moment, logic that is central to contemporary political demobilization. Tellingly, the book's closing chapter, which could usefully assess the ways in which the first black president's policies enhance or undermine black women's material well-being or (at least, in view of the book's agenda) recognition, centers instead on Michelle Obama as a model of a black woman who is putatively able to stand straight in the crooked room.
Given the increasing visibility of black women electorally and their centrality to public policy and political discourse, Sister Citizen, as well as other works on black women in politics, will surely draw attention within and beyond academe. For nonspecialists and the broader public, it provides a good introduction to research on myths on black women. For black feminists, it will undoubtedly provoke valuable debate.
