Despite being the subject of recent full-length biographies and a series of introductory and specialized works, Ulysses Simpson Grant remains among the most impalpable of American soldier-statesmen. The triumphant Union general-in-chief was the principal postbellum American, contends author Joan Waugh, but within a half century of his 1885 death, ambivalence had become the norm in evaluations of Grant. His once-lofty standing fell victim to Southern and national mythologies and attendant criticism of his battlefield management and two-term presidency. Figurative of his reputation's fall was the decrepit condition of his giant Upper Manhattan tomb, dedicated in 1897 with the pomp and circumstance befitting a conquering Caesar. Waugh, professor of history at the University of California at Los Angeles, is a thoughtful scholar whose work embraces the Civil War era and Gilded Age with emphasis upon its politics and political/military cultures; her volume, the latest in the University of North Carolina's Civil War America series, traces the curious course in public memory of one who, it can be argued, came to symbolize more than any other figure the twin tenets of union and freedom.
Studies of historical memory have been pervasive in Civil War literature over the last two decades. But as the author notes correctly, a focus on Federal remembrance has largely taken a backseat to untold volumes exploring the depth and course of Confederate identity. Yet this was not always so. “The end of the war,” writes Waugh, “brought forth a new nationalism sanctified by death and embraced by a majority of northerners and southern freedpeople, that made the Union Cause just as much the subject of myth and reverence as the [Southern] Lost Cause” (6). Subsequent professional scholarship and popular works, at various times reflecting antimilitarism, white supremacy, or a growing libertarian bent, called into question the presumed sanctity of the Union effort and its legacies; Grant's reputation as “butcher” and political ingénue consequently found a sure footing among a Southern and American society, and recent studies have attempted with only marginal success to dispel it. Waugh skillfully mines secondary and first-person sources in rediscovering Grant's place in the national memory, while her prose captures the motivations of an ex-president whose personal aim was to promote the cause of union against those who would craft a competing narrative of the war and the rancorous era of reconstruction that followed.
Waugh's study does not claim to be another biographical treatment of Grant, and readers well versed in operational military history, civil-military relations, or the course of the eighteenth president's political career will not find new ground broken here on these subjects. The early sections of the book, which take the reader from Grant's birth to his 1877 exit from public life, rather than present a composite look at the soldier-politician, focus instead upon the oft-recalled traits that made him appear to so many the quintessential American. In Grant, American citizens once saw the qualities—steadfastness in the face of adversity, singularity of purpose, and magnanimity in victory—that they aspired to realize in themselves. This first section, comprising nearly one-half of the volume's pages, sets up what Waugh calls the “heart of the book” (5): three chapters detailing the general's effort to capture the meaning of the Federal war effort in his classic Personal Memoirs, his death and the national outpouring of anguish it produced, and the national effort to erect a tomb suitable to the Victor of Appomattox.
These three chapters shine both as narrative history and for the analyses contained within. Chapter 4, for example, is a superior and sensitive treatment of Grant's Herculean effort to not only finish his memoir before cancer could claim his life, but perhaps more importantly to fortify his own position at the forefront of the Union cause, the political, military, and social crusade that preserved the territorial and political integrity of the republic and set in motion the wheels of emancipation and civil rights for African Americans. As popular as this interpretation once was—and as famous as Grant had become as its most visible agent—it nevertheless fell from prominence in the national narrative, eclipsed in the 1890s by the tide of Southern Lost Cause romanticism and its more benign handmaiden, sectional reconciliation. Stridently opposed in his lifetime to those who would idealize the Confederacy and its heroes (Grant's criticism of Robert E. Lee's military leadership is illustrative here), the general-president had nonetheless become the convenient foil—the corruptible spoilsman, the murderous military chieftain—in a competing and ultimately triumphant Southern story, told perhaps most artfully by the so-called Dunning School of reconstruction historiography. By the 1930s his reputation and that of the cause he had championed hit its nadir; only in the decades following the civil rights movement have historians such as Richard Current, Brooks D. Simpson, Jean Edward Smith, and Waugh revisited the image of not only aptitude but also greatness.
Waugh's work is significant and serves as a model of its genre, nearly to the level of Thomas Lawrence Connelly's path-breaking The Marble Man: Robert E. Lee and His Image in American Society, published over thirty years ago. Still, it is not without fault. Chiefly, the author throughout the volume appears to embrace, rather than consider, the Grant of Union legend and lore; as a consequence, the book at times assumes the air of romanticism that in other places it purports both to reveal and combat. Then, too, assertions that Grant's military reputation foundered in the first half of the twentieth century can be challenged by a perusal of the collected and influential works of British officer-historian and theorist J. F. C. Fuller. Finally, in placing Grant's reputational decline within the context of the decay of the Union cause, Waugh inadequately addresses the lasting (and paradoxical?) vitality of Abraham Lincoln as its—indeed the nation's—principal symbol. Yet these faults do not detract from the volume's larger achievement. Joan Waugh has crafted a unique glimpse into the elusive Ulysses S. Grant, a man at once simple and irreducibly complex. It serves as the definitive work detailing the eighteenth president's rise and fall in the American narrative.
