Current scholarship emphasizes the need to place America within a global context. This approach seeks to undermine exceptionalist narratives of American history while highlighting the linkages between the United States and the rest of the world. Even as the United States engaged in a series of domestic reforms during the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era, the turn of the twentieth century also marked the emergence of the United States as a global power. The growing influence of the United States prompted Americans to debate their nation's role in the world with its expanding government institutions designed to manage colonial populations. Americans considered how their nation's perceived racial and religious identity justified or challenged the creation of an American empire, and they considered how the United States reformulated its traditional isolationism to meet the needs of a modern industrial country.
The bureaucracy that arose to address the perceived needs of the American Indian population signals much about the nation's approaches to colonialism abroad. Cathleen Cahill's Federal Fathers and Mothers provides a social history of the Indian Service from the closing decades of the nineteenth century through the start of the Indian New Deal. Though earlier policy studies focused on legislators and prominent reformers, Cahill draws upon the underutilized personnel files of Indian Service employees to illuminate the lives and careers of the men and women tasked with assimilating American Indians. In addition, Cahill examines the internal and external pressures that fostered changes within the Indian Service during the Progressive Era.
Nineteenth-century Americans extended federal aid to those deemed worthy of compensation, particularly soldiers and public servants. The government also created programs to provide restitution to groups wronged by the United States. Though advocates of assimilation desired to uphold the reputation of the United States by honoring treaties with American Indians, they equated the confinement of American Indians to reservations with slavery. Policymakers designed social programs based on Reconstruction-era models to honor the spirit of treaties with American Indians while simultaneously eliminating Native cultures, encouraging the Native adoption of Euro-American gender norms, and providing American Indians with the skills needed to participate in a capitalist economy. Though these programs required the expenditure of millions of dollars, they would theoretically eliminate the need for future federal support to American Indians and satisfy the nation's debt to Native peoples.
Cahill's work supplements existing scholarship, highlighting the linkages between gender and colonialism, particularly Margaret Jacobs's award-winning White Mother to a Dark Race.Footnote 1 According to Jacobs, white American and Australian women justified their activism outside the domestic sphere by emphasizing their roles as mothers. Rather than using their influence to defend indigenous women from the power of the state, these reformers undermined Native women by critiquing their capacity to care for their children. Attacks on the alleged inferiority of Native homes and parenting styles justified the separation of indigenous children from their families in Australia and the United States. Cahill challenges these maternalist assumptions by demonstrating how the day-to-day experiences of Indian Service employees undermined policymakers' expectations. For example, leaders of the Indian Service assumed that white women—whether single or married—naturally possessed domestic skills and the ability to teach American Indian women how to cook, keep house, and make their own clothes. Yet, many female employees from urban areas satisfied their household needs by purchasing required items rather than producing them. Cahill also expands upon Jacobs's analysis by discussing the employment of married couples by the Indian Service. While previous scholars dismissed the hiring of married couples as nepotism, the Indian Service employed these couples to model Euro-American gender norms to Native communities while serving as fictive fathers and mothers.
One of the most important contributions of Cahill's book is her analysis of Native employees of the Indian Service. Scholars of American Indian history continue to urge the creation of studies emphasizing Native agency to cast American Indians as historical actors rather than as passive targets of governmental policies. The leaders of the Indian Service saw the employment of Natives as a means of teaching American Indians the value of work while reducing administrative costs. American Indians saw the Indian Service as a critical element in their economic security because prejudice often restricted Native men and women to manual labor. These economic restrictions, combined with the perquisites offered to Indian Service employees, made these government jobs attractive to American Indians. Native employees argued that their cultural background made them logical candidates to serve within their home communities. Even so, federal officials often placed American Indian workers on different reservations to break down tribal affiliations. This strategy had unintended consequences as the experiences of Native employees helped foster an intertribal identity by exposing them to the abuses suffered by other tribes and nations.
Overall Cahill provides an outstanding investigation of the Indian Service and its employees. Cahill's work bolsters scholarship, challenging the unidirectional impact of empire and colonialism by demonstrating the domestic consequences of imperialism.Footnote 2 Furthermore, the need to create a colonial bureaucracy to staff the Indian Service led to an expansion of the federal government that predated many Progressive Era reforms. In addition, the participation of women in the Indian Service predated and dwarfed the employment of women in the Children's Bureau and the Women's Bureau. These conclusions reveal the need for scholars to pay closer attention to how histories of colonialism and the American West fit within larger accounts of the development of federal power.
Susan Harris's God's Arbiters examines the debates surrounding the annexation of the Philippines to demonstrate the centrality of race and religion in the construction of American identities at the turn of the twentieth century. Annexationists and anti-annexationists both spoke of the country's divine mission and “believed that the United States was a nation of white Protestants under special mandate from God to represent freedom and fair dealing to the rest of the world” (13). Harris divides her study into three parts. The first discusses the economic, racial, and religious elements that shaped the debates about Philippine annexation. Harris next examines the issue of citizenship by exploring the ways in which American educators and writers discussed and portrayed citizenship in the United States and the Philippines. Harris concludes by analyzing English, European, Latin American, and Filipino conceptions of the extension of American power overseas.
Harris's focus on the religious rhetoric employed by critics and supporters of Philippine annexation echoes the conclusions of William Appleman Williams and Paul McCartney. Williams's study indicated Americans believed the extension of the United States' authority overseas served to promote humanitarian interests. Even as Americans promoted the idea of self-determination, they remained skeptical about the capacity of others to achieve their goals if they deviated from American examples.Footnote 3 McCartney called for scholars to avoid dismissing the religious and moral rhetoric of imperialists as a veneer to cover economic exploitation. McCartney's plea to treat the moralistic claims of imperialists seriously corresponds with Harris's assertion that religious and racial beliefs were central to American identities constructed at the turn of the twentieth century.Footnote 4
Harris illuminates the presence of religious and racial rhetoric in nineteenth-century textbooks presented to American schoolchildren and notes a tendency to associate Christianity with “civilization.” Schoolbooks facilitated the creation of national Christians, defined by Harris as “Americans who conceived of themselves, in their capacity as citizens, at the intersection of Protestant and national identities” (109). Elocution texts in American classrooms often included Bible stories, famous speeches, and narratives about American history. Similarly, textbooks produced for Filipino children promoted the adoption of American social, political, and economic values. Harris provides a particularly insightful analysis of Prescott Jernegan's A Short History of the Philippines, For Use in Philippine Schools. This textbook written in 1905 denigrated the racial heterogeneity of the Philippines while arguing that only homogenous populations had the capacity for self-government. Though the text did not explicitly discuss religion, Jernegan implied a hierarchical ranking of religions that privileged Protestantism over Catholicism.
One of the strengths of Harris's study is her analysis of the multitudinous parodies of Rudyard Kipling's poem “The White Man's Burden.” Harris examines the ways in which proponents and critics of the American annexation of the Philippines referenced Kipling's work to bolster their respective causes. The centrality of Protestantism to the nation's perceived identity is evident as American critics of empire inserted religious references within their parodies to cast imperialism as a hypocritical betrayal of the United States' divine mission. Harris also analyzes an African American parody of Kipling's work to demonstrate how non-white readers understood the poem's potential to justify the subjugation of colonial populations.
Harris could improve her analysis of the significance of race and religion by including a lengthier discussion of efforts by non-white or non-Protestant Americans to counter restrictive interpretations of American identity. For example, drawing upon Matthew Jacobsen's Special Sorrows would demonstrate the ways in which Irish, Polish, and Jewish immigrants interpreted the Spanish-American War and the Philippine-American War. Some connected Spanish misrule in Cuba to the conditions found in their homelands, but others embraced racial critiques of the Filipinos' capacity for self-government while simultaneously seeking inclusion within U.S. society for themselves.Footnote 5 Middle-class and wealthy Hispanic Americans made similar efforts to define themselves as white during the early years of the twentieth century.Footnote 6 Including these immigrant and minority voices would buttress Harris's deconstruction of the United States' mythical white Protestant identity.
Harris convincingly demonstrates the central role played by race and religion in the formation of American identities at the turn of the twentieth century. She effectively reveals how the fusion of religious and racial rhetoric permeated textbooks, popular culture, and the writings of ordinary Americans. Her analysis of the writings of Mark Twain, Albert Beveridge, Emilio Aguinaldo, and other prominent figures is capable, but it is unclear how these viewpoints reflected popular interpretations of American identity both at home and abroad. Supplementing these close readings of literary, cultural, and political sources with popular references would help illuminate the public's interpretations of these works. Nevertheless, Harris demonstrates the importance of analyzing the ideological justifications of American empire without dismissing religious rhetoric as irrelevant.
Christopher Nichols's Promise and Peril also considers the ways in which Americans viewed the United States' place in the world during the 1890s and the first several decades of the twentieth century. Rather than considering the racial and religious foundations of American identity, Nichols examines the changing conceptions of isolationism and challenges existing scholarship for dismissing isolationism as ineffective and unrealistic. Most studies of isolationism focus almost exclusively on two periods. The first era encompasses American debates about the First World War and ends with the United States Senate's rejection of the Treaty of Versailles and the League of Nations. Scholars have also devoted significant attention to debates about isolationism and neutrality between the mid-1930s and the United States' entrance into the Second World War in December 1941.
Earlier investigations of isolationism resulted in standard political histories that largely ignored the intellectual and cultural origins of these policies. Nichols remedies this omission by locating the roots of modern isolationism in the closing years of the nineteenth century and tracing its development through the 1930s. Nichols urges scholars to eschew the simplistic characterization of isolationism as a call for “cultural, economic, or complete political separation from the rest of the world” (2). Casting isolationism as monolithic policy obviates a comprehensive analysis of its varied forms that permitted its adherents to support a range of economic, cultural, and military engagements with other countries. Nichols's investigation of the intellectual creation and development of isolationism necessitates the book's focus on representative and well-known individuals including Senator Henry Cabot Lodge, W. E. B. Du Bois, Jane Adams, Eugene Debs, and Senator William Borah.
The 1890s not only marked the emergence of the United States as a world power, but also signified the origin of modern American isolationist thought within debates between imperialists and anti-imperialists. Americans had long pointed to the foreign policies of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and James Monroe to justify the avoidance of entangling alliances and opposition to the expansion of European power in the Americas. Senator Lodge and other proponents of territorial expansion denied that the creation of an American empire violated the axioms of the nation's founders. Instead, Lodge saw territorial annexation as a means of securing markets for American industry, enhancing American security, and permitting the United States to act unilaterally. Lodge reconciled this limited form of isolationism with the warnings of Washington and Jefferson by noting the continued rejection of permanent alliances with European nations. Nichols resolves the seeming contradiction between Lodge's expansionism and his later efforts to defeat the Treaty of Versailles by emphasizing Lodge's efforts to preserve U.S. autonomy in foreign affairs. Lodge rejected international mandates that compelled the United States to intervene in international disputes, but he supported the use of military power to promote American interests.
Though Lodge's limited isolationism permitted him to justify the extension of American authority overseas, anti-imperialists also drew upon isolationism to challenge military and imperial policies that threatened the nation's democratic institutions. Anti-imperialists likewise cited Washington, Jefferson, and Monroe to preserve what they viewed as the United States' traditional opposition to colonialism, militarism, and alliances with European powers.
Though the anti-imperialists had diverse reasons for opposing the creation of an American empire, they were unified in their belief that the creation of an overseas empire inhibited the United States' capacity to resolve domestic problems created during the rapid industrialization of the country. Nichols highlights the anti-imperialist contributions to isolationism through his discussion of the philosopher William James. James echoed other anti-imperialists by urging the United States to place greater emphasis on promoting prosperity, rights, and reform domestically while encouraging self-determination for others. He recognized the necessity of self-defense but believed the United States could better achieve its aims through cultural and intellectual exchanges rather than imperial conquests or military engagements.
Overall, Nichols achieves his objective of analyzing the shifting conception of isolationism presented by prominent Americans during the early decades of the twentieth century. He adeptly traces the transformations within isolationist thought while challenging simplistic characterizations of the policy. Isolationism has continued to carry negative connotations on account of public perception that American inaction during the 1930s facilitated and encouraged Nazi Germany's aggression. This belief enabled generations of American politicians to cast U.S. foreign policy as a binary choice between complete isolation from the rest of the world and an active series of engagements frequently requiring the use of military force. Nichols clearly demonstrates how this false dichotomy has obscured the complexity and depth of isolationist thought during the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. In addition, Nichols makes a cogent argument recasting the 1920s as a decade in which isolationists and internationalists cooperated and supported policies designed to promote world peace without restricting the United States' capacity to act unilaterally or form binding political or military commitments. Nichols explicitly restricted his research to thinkers and policymakers concerned with the United States' role in the world, but future scholars can draw upon Promise and Peril to consider how regular Americans understood and internalized these ideas.
Cahill, Harris, and Nichols each demonstrate the linkages between American foreign policy, colonialism, and the domestic history of the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era. Harris and Nichols reveal that many Americans—regardless of their views about the United States' proper role in the world—drew upon similar religious and historical references. Though not directly concerned with American policies overseas, Cahill demonstrates that the United States possessed an expansive and racially integrated colonial bureaucracy prior to the annexation of Hawaii, the Philippines, and Puerto Rico. The important linkages between America's colonial policies, American identity, and debates about the United States' place in the world demand further investigation. This research can illuminate the intersections between domestic and international histories while highlighting the influence of race, religion, gender, and culture.
