Simon Cordery is an associate professor of history at Monmouth College in Illinois, where his research fields include modern British social and political history, the transatlantic world after 1830, and American labor history. Cordery's current book is a contribution to the Women's Biography Series of the University of New Mexico Press. His subject, Mary Harris “Mother Jones,” is unquestionably one of the iconic figures of American labor and radical history. She joins such luminaries as Elizabeth Gurley Flynn and Emma Goldman in the pantheon of Progressive Era female political agitators.
Born in Ireland in 1837, the second of Richard and Ellen Harris's five children, Mary Harris emigrated to Canada at the age of fourteen or fifteen. She pursued a Catholic education, worked for a while as a teacher, and then opened a dress shop in Memphis, Tennessee on the eve of the Civil War. She married iron molder and trade unionist George Jones, with whom she had four children. In 1867 she lost her entire family to a yellow fever epidemic. Little is known of what became of her in the three decades following her personal tragedy, but by 1894 she was delivering speeches and raising money on behalf of Coxey's Army, and by 1897, at the age of sixty, she had reinvented herself as Mother Jones. She dedicated the remaining thirty-three years of her life to labor causes, most famously on behalf of the United Mine Workers of America in the early 1900s and 1910s.
Larger than life, Mother Jones presents certain challenges to biographers, as her memory serves a political function to admirers and detractors alike, rendering the historical Mary Harris almost as elusive as the historical Jesus, if significantly less well-known. In Mother Jones: Raising Cain and Consciousness, Cordery wisely relies neither on Mary Harris's polemical self-portrait as presented in her Autobiography of Mother Jones, nor on Philip S. Foner's essentially uncritical Mother Jones Speaks. Footnote 1 His goal is to offer a relatively objective though sympathetic narrative of Mother Jones's life and her contributions to American labor struggles in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries. Though Cordery is not explicit about his intended audience, his acknowledgments and his efforts to provide sufficient background for the uninitiated suggest that this volume is intended principally for undergraduate students in United States history survey classes.
A careful reading raises questions about what makes Cordery's book significant and unique. Cordery offers a factually accurate account of Mother Jones's career as an American radical and provides a plausible context for imagining the first half-century of her life—a period that she herself assiduously avoided recounting and analyzing in any depth. Much of this work, however, has already been accomplished quite effectively by Elliott J. Gorn in his highly acclaimed Mother Jones: The Most Dangerous Woman in America.Footnote 2 Cordery's annotated bibliography recognizes Gorn's work as “the best” (203). In that bibliography, rather than in the acknowledgments or in a preface, Cordery avers that one of the principal marks of distinction for his own biography “is a reliance on newspapers to explore specific moments in the life of Mother Jones” (204). True to his word, Cordery cites the New York Times and the Chicago Daily Tribune many, many times in his endnotes, with references to Edward M. Steel's edited volume, The Speeches and Writings of Mother Jones, comprising a significant portion of the remainder.Footnote 3 It is not evident, though, that the use of such sources brings forth any new evidence or prompts any fresh interpretations of Mary Harris's life.
Perhaps Cordery's most useful efforts surround the framing of Mary Harris's experiences in the years before she took up the mantle of activism. Cordery's interest in British history likely contributed to the attention he pays to Harris's Irish Catholic roots and their presumed influence on her incarnation as Mother Jones. Unfortunately, these connections appear somewhat generalized and conjectural, as in Cordery's assertion that “her immigrant background, her early travels, and . . . her devastating miseries would transform Mary Harris into Mother Jones. As an Irishwoman she knew political powerlessness and discrimination. As a Catholic in an age of revived Protestant nativism she witnessed and experienced prejudice and hatred” (29). As regards her apparent though ambiguous challenge to the dominant gender roles of her time, Cordery offers: “Her experiences with the fragility and unpredictability of human existence convinced her of the need to transcend the limited life choices open to women” (29). It would have been much better to frame these interpretations as possibilities rather than as facts and more useful in revealing how history is constructed rather than recounted.
Finally, Cordery describes Mother Jones's fluid associations with radical doctrine and militant action. She in turn opposed and supported trade unions, the Socialist Party, and the Industrial Workers of the World; sometimes attacked the Church and at others espoused Christian charity; violated feminine norms while defending motherhood and opposing women's suffrage; and at one time embraced Bolshevism and at another, Woodrow Wilson. While Mother Jones's unique personality shaped her often transitory and contradictory affiliations, Cordery could also have stressed the extraordinary shifts in the nature of radical thought in the United States from the Jacksonian era to the Great Depression—the span of Mother Jones's lifetime. In her own way, Mother Jones personified a century of astounding and unsettling change.
Simon Cordery's Mother Jones: Raising Cain and Consciousness breaks no new ground and is dry at times. Nonetheless, it provides a brief, serviceable overview of the life of an extraordinary woman and of a brutal period in the history of American workers.
