Growing up in a Suffolk market town in the late 1920s, my grandmother could never understand the 17th-c. English hymn “To Be a Pilgrim” (also known as “He Who Would Valiant Be”) sung during Sunday services at her local Baptist church. For her, it did not conjure images of John Bunyan’s The Pilgrim’s Progress but of the children of a local family with whom she went to school, who had the last name Pilgrim. Let’s just say that the personal hygiene of those children did not meet my Nan’s own very high standards: why on earth would anyone want to be a “Pilgrim,” she used to wonder. A century later I find myself coming full circle, although for very different reasons, asking why would anyone want to write about the archaeology of being a Roman pilgrim when it is seemingly so fraught with problems?
One answer, perhaps, is because it poses a challenge that feels like it should be solvable. After all, as evidenced extensively in this special section, by Alejandro Sinner and Víctor Revilla Calvo for Hispanic rural sanctuaries, by Louise Revell for southwest Britain, by Claudia Moser for central Italy, and by Lennart Kruijer for the kingdom of Commagene, it is well known that people in the Roman world sometimes traveled longer or shorter distances to engage in religious activities, and that they must have done this for particular reasons. In other words, there is plentiful evidence to show that people did make the choice to “be a pilgrim.” However, at the same time we find it almost impossible to make meaningful distinctions between the nature of religion performed at a sanctuary half a day’s walk or more from home and religion performed at a household shrine, or nearby street-corner altar, or temple. Both involved offerings, sacrificial acts, prayers, and bodily gestures, engaged the same range of divinities, and anticipated similar outcomes. In all these settings, ritual activities were concerned primarily with seeking the goodwill and protection of the gods, at a personal and communal level. Does this mean that all religion is a form of pilgrimage? “Certainly not,” state Anna Collar and Troels Kristensen unequivocably and no doubt correctly in their Introduction. The problem, then, is that the religion generated at these different places (and perhaps also on the way to and from them, as Moser’s study of the Via Salaria shows) is seemingly not distinctive enough to allow archaeologists to distinguish a fundamentally different quality of religious engagement for those who chose to travel. At least, not without resorting to cross-cultural and cross-temporal pilgrimage parallels that ultimately do little more than frame them as somehow “special.”
Present pathways
I suggest that our inability to distinguish sufficiently between religion when it was practiced at home or away is partly because our understandings of what constitutes “Roman religion” remain far too narrow and restrictive. Current models continue to emphasize ritual efficacy and careful repetition, and therefore similarity and stability, even as scholarship, including Kruijer’s excellent account of descending the staircase tunnel at Arsameia on the Nymphaios, increasingly reveals a much messier world of individuality, difference, and situational forms of religion dependent upon the presence of non-human things as much as human actors.Footnote 1 At the same time, our discipline still trains us to read archaeological evidence in ways that allow us to state with confidence that “this was a ‘religious’ site at which ‘Roman’ ‘religious’ activities took place,” but rarely much more than that, at any rate, nothing that can be used to identify pilgrimage as a discrete activity or indicate how it might have been valued differently.
We instinctively know that the reasons for traveling outside of one’s immediate context to perform ritualized acts must have played a role in how ancient people themselves distinguished between the quality or significance of these actions. However, while Sinner and Revilla Calvo document a substantial quantity of epigraphic evidence for travel that ranges from “visits to small shrines within the devotee’s immediate territory to medium- and long-distance journeys,” they also observe how difficult it is to identify the circumstances, intentions, or strategies behind it. Indeed, as Revell points out, basic questions persist about “why some cults were deemed worth the effort of traveling to,” while presumably others were not. Moser’s account of the Via Salaria implies that some travelers made a conscious decision to divert from its direct course and make their way along secondary routes to one of several nearby cult sites associated with Hercules to make offerings of the salt they carried. Nevertheless, this ephemeral aspect of the processes of sacred mobility remains almost entirely invisible from a traditional archaeological perspective, typically (although not in these cases) leading to the anachronistic imposition of assumptions based on medieval and much more recent engagements with sacred travel. Revell’s review of how cult sites such as Lydney Park have been studied reveals quite strikingly how easily a “shrine” that was apparently visited by people from beyond the local area can be transformed effortlessly by uncritical use of archaeological analogy into a “center of pilgrimage,” with all the inherited assumptions this entails around the availability of accommodation, access to ritual specialists, and in many cases also presumed opportunities for healing (both medical and divine).
Consequently, it is currently very difficult to write about being a Roman pilgrim without recourse to being a pilgrim in other (largely Euro-centric) cultural, historical, geographical, and religious contexts. The chapters in this special section intentionally work hard to circumvent this by beginning their investigations with the archaeological evidence itself, even as occasional hints of sanctuaries as places for travelers to rest and suggestions of expected physical hardship continue to evoke the hostels and the personal sacrifices of medieval and Christian pilgrimage itineraries.
Finding new pathways
Can this conundrum be solved? Certainly yes. The contributors to this special section direct us towards the necessity of adopting approaches to pilgrimage in the Roman world that fully embrace multiplicity rather than singularity. That is to say that, as a collective, they successfully generate analyses that neither depend on nor seek definitive or singular definitions of “who” Roman pilgrims were – we learn of individuals, small groups, and whole communities from the Hispanic evidence – or even “where” pilgrimage might or might not occur – everywhere from shrines, sanctuaries, watery places, and tunnels, to the road itself. They construct convincing new archaeological narratives by conceiving of pilgrimage as what Collar and Kristensen describe as a “distinctive methodological prism” through which to interrogate material evidence for ritualized activities, rather than making the identification of “pilgrimage” or “pilgrims” their desired destination. They therefore set us off in a positive direction towards thinking with pilgrimage, rather than necessarily about pilgrimage.
I would like to add a further suggestion: that this starting point can be enhanced and extended by more comprehensively embracing the posthuman framework advanced by Kruijer. Indeed, the relational perspectives he presents, which draw on new materialist and assemblage thinking, offer an especially important means of helping us to make better – or at least new and different – distinctions between the religion performed, generated, experienced, and rationalized in different settings. This includes the significance of mobility and flow for affecting distinctive forms of religious knowledge. Adopting such a standpoint, as I will briefly outline, has the potential to extend these investigations in ways that make it possible to write about Roman pilgrimage on its own terms as religion affected through motion. This reinforces Collar and Kristensen’s proposal that pilgrimage should be considered as something that “prioritizes mobility over fixity.” Encouraging posthuman perspectives that decenter human intentionality and consider how the material or non-human world may have contributed mutually to producing Roman pilgrimage, also responds directly to their call to foreground “the stuff” of pilgrimage. Although this theoretical position is most directly articulated in the present collection by Kruijer, all the papers gathered here provide valuable worked examples of its potential application.
In brief, assemblage thinking posits that on their own, neither human nor non-human things possess agency or have the capacity to generate difference.Footnote 2 Instead, this position emphasizes affect, defining this as the product of the different sets of relations that form between humans, between humans and non-humans, and between non-human things when they become gathered (“territorialized”) into relational assemblages.Footnote 3 When it comes to religion, ritual activities provide a very specific force (an “intensive process”) that territorializes certain human and non-human things into discrete relational assemblages that subsequently generate affect. That affect is experienced by the people involved in embodied and sensory ways, and as a result of the ritualized context, these experiences and changes to the world are rationalized as “religion.”Footnote 4 New materialist and assemblage thinking therefore aims to decenter, but not to entirely remove, humans from archaeological analyses and is therefore sometimes characterized as a posthuman or post-anthropocentric approach.Footnote 5
Assemblage thinking is especially beneficial in the context of pilgrimage. It encourages us to pay attention to all the multiple ritualized assemblages involved in Roman religion whenever it featured travel or movement, and not merely those formed at a chosen destination or at particularly notable locations enroute to it. It reminds us how traveling bodies and minds repeatedly came together with a host of human and non-human things during the course of religious mobility, but also how it was physical movement which caused them to move in and out of those different sets of overlapping relations. More specifically, sacred mobility acted as an intensive process that prompted travelers to become repeatedly territorialized, deterritorialized, and reterritorialized into multiple, potentially overlapping assemblages on a larger and more protracted scale than they might do in other less mobile contexts. That is, as they left home and traveled to their chosen destination they encountered and formed relations with multiple human and non-human things associated with that journey and the physical world through which they moved. Their ritual intentions caused them to engage with some of these in ways that continually generated religious affect, while others generated other embodied experiences of movement that reinforced their mobility and increasing distance from home, such as changing landscapes, inscribed milestones, local dialects or foodstuffs, and so on. At the same time, their choice to undertake a journey to a particular place associated with cult activities territorialized these multiple ritual and non-ritual assemblages, and their multiple affects, into one larger overarching ritualized assemblage. This informed how those experiences were collectively rationalized as a certain kind of religious act (one that we might retrospectively opt to describe as “pilgrimage”).
Consequently, experiences of repeatedly moving between assemblages such as those that I have just outlined ensured that instances of religion generated in association with mobility gained many additional layers. These layers were the outcome of the extent, duration, variety, and scale of movement that such mobility entailed compared with movement within the house, to the street corner, or to a temple in the local forum. They therefore had considerably greater depth and complexity in comparison with religion affected via the ritualized assemblages that formed in household or immediately localized contexts, affecting a qualitatively more intense and potentially more novel experience. It might be reasonably supposed that this was what made sacred travel “special” or “worthwhile” compared with the mundane and familiar patterns of everyday religion. By which I mean, acts of sacred movement were special not because of what people had in their minds to undertake, not because they were associated with additional effort or a greater degree of (both private and publicly advertised) piety, and not because they allowed people to forge personal relationships with a specific divinity. They were special because they were more vibrant, varied, and richer in potential due to the complexity of the multiple assemblages of which pilgrims became part.
More extensive work than space currently allows will be necessary to robustly demonstrate what I am proposing. Nevertheless, this process is already detectable in Moser’s examination of the Via Salaria as a braided network in which the movement or transportation of salt becomes a key component in shaping these repeated acts of territorialization. Salt, as much as movement, enabled a multiplicity of ritualized (and non-ritualized) assemblages to form, since as Moser suggests, travelers could use a small amount of the item that they were ostensibly transporting for other purposes as an offering, in want of an animal, votive model, inscription, or something else. Salt allowed ritualized assemblages to repeatedly form in ad hoc ways and in places that they might otherwise not, and to do so regularly, consistently, and intensively. Similarly, when Revell writes of the difficulties of distinguishing between “traveler” and “pilgrim,” of how a person might pause in a settlement and perhaps decide “that this was an appropriate place to give thanks for a safe journey so far, and ask for the rest to be free of danger,” we are reminded again of how those experiences entailed moving between a growing accumulation of ritualized and non-ritualized assemblages. Moreover, her focus on “the juxtaposition between earth and water” at Lydney Park, as well as its former use as a site of iron mining, spotlights the many potentialities for people to move in and out of differently configured sets of relations with a non-human world that was itself materially dynamic and changeable. They did this too with representations of those relationships captured by the temple’s mosaics and offerings, not to mention with a god whose identity could shift depending on the assemblages he was territorialized into (human hunter, hunter/hound, hound-like hunter). Kruijer’s assessment of the staircase tunnel, and its capacity to affect several discrete embodied experiences between its entrance and abrupt termination, generating layered forms of religious knowledge, might also be situated in the context of all the many relational assemblages – ritualized or otherwise – that led up to these moments at the tomb-sanctuary. These likely rendered a person’s descent of the staircase an even more intense experience, as the culmination of that successive layering of overlapping assemblages. The accumulated epigraphy at Monte do Facho spotlighted by Sinner and Revilla Calvo provides another thought-provoking example. Although these inscribed words might be especially short texts, comprising a largely uninformative collection of repetitive individual dedications to Lar Berus Breus, they too could play a crucial role in generating religious affect through multiple overlapping assemblages. By reading and engaging with all or some of these inscriptions, which the authors suggest may have formed social or familiar groupings, pilgrims became territorialized into another extended series of historical ritualized and non-ritualized assemblages in ways that emphasized the overlapping temporal and spatial assemblages that collectively comprised their own experience of pilgrimage. They temporarily joined an otherwise anonymous group, from places and times unknown to the current visitor but recognizable as people who had also encountered and moved between the same sorts of multiple assemblages that had shaped their own journey.
Pathways ahead
Previous approaches to Roman pilgrimage have not allowed for sufficient fluidity, preferring to privilege the person(s) and the place, and sometimes the (largely imagined) journey. In this sense, I agree with David Frankfurter’s words of caution about over-emphasizing or romanticizing the journey, albeit for reasons that he might not have anticipated.Footnote 6 By centering the journey we risk seeking to fix it, describe it, categorize it, measure it, and determine what it was about that route or that act of singular movement that was always and repeatedly significant, as we have done previously for pilgrimage places. That is, meaning is sought in being able to pin down something about its distance, difficulty, remoteness, links with myth-history, and so on. To grasp Roman pilgrimage, we instead need to find space in our models for other aspects of the non-human world and its inherent fluidity, as Kruijer has illustrated here, as well as ways to manage and appreciate the much greater degree of vibrancy that this contributed to how religion was affected, experienced, and subsequently understood. This is what an assemblage approach can facilitate. It encourages us away from restrictive tripartite models of home–journey–destination (and vice versa) that focus our attention on one or each of these at a time, towards models that reveal how the mobility of pilgrimage involved engaging in a multiplicity of quite messy and continually intersecting relational assemblages (both ritualized and otherwise). Again, Moser’s example of salt is a lens through which we can detect this in action: at some moments people and salt were territorialized into economic sets of relations, and at others into ritualized ones.
Although the theoretical lens may be slightly different, this is another way of underpinning exactly what Collar and Kristensen aim to do through their explicit framing of pilgrimage via the mobilities paradigm, highlighting how movement is the force that connects a range of practices, experiences, and types of travel. What I propose is that to their framework we add a deeper understanding of exactly what people were moving between: not merely between physical places or experiences, but between multiple, heterogenous, ever-changing sets of relations. In other words, movement between assemblages had the capacity to generate a deep layering of religious (and non-religious) affect, which territorialized people and a diverse range of non-human things in complex rhizomatic ways, rather than linear or rigidly networked ones. After all, many of our colleagues on this ancient pilgrimage journey have already pointed out repeatedly that we cannot define pilgrimage, and that we cannot say for certain what makes someone (want to be) a pilgrim.Footnote 7 Instead, we should do what this collection of papers compels us to do: think in a multiplicity of creative ways that can empower us to make a virtue of these uncertainties, turning them from a challenge into a positive force for a re-examination of our archaeological evidence. This will better position us to understand what set experiences of religion affected by pilgrimage apart from other forms of religious action, without needing to fall back on traditional explanations or analogy. This special section therefore presents us with the first step on the pathway to affecting a more posthuman conceptualization of what it really meant to “be a pilgrim.”
