Though virtually forgotten today, Laura Langford was a major Gilded Age impresario whose Seidl Society—a singular Brooklyn women's club that she founded in 1889—presented world-class concerts twice a day in summertime on Coney Island. Langford was also many other things, including a pathbreaking journalist and a prominent theosophist. As a subject of study illuminating the status of American women in the late nineteenth century, she is protean. Her significance may be gleaned by observing:
1. What she was able to accomplish;
2. What she aspired to accomplish but could not; and
3. The manner in which she presented herself in order to become an influential public personality.
The following account is extrapolated from my book Moral Fire: Musical Portraits from America's Fin-de-Siecle.Footnote 1 It draws on my earlier research on Wagnerism in America (the topic of my book Wagner Nights, An American History Footnote 2), as well as subsequent research into Langford's life story by Diane Sasson.Footnote 3
Laura Langford claimed to be born Laura Carter in 1848. She was actually born in 1843. Her father, Samuel Carter, was from southern Virginia. Her mother belonged to a prominent Tennessee family. Laura received an orthodox Calvinist religious education. The Nashville Female Academy, from which she graduated in 1860, was known as the nation's largest “school for young ladies.” Her home life, however, was less genteel. Not found in any biographical information she supplied after moving to Brooklyn is that Samuel Carter raced horses and managed hotels. He also supplied Governor Andrew Johnson with “pure whiskey.” He owned eleven slaves. The family responded to the Civil War with divided loyalties. When northern troops arrived in Nashville in 1862, Carter was cordial to the officers who lodged and dined at his St. Cloud Hotel. But Laura was arrested for spitting on Union soldiers from the hotel porch.
This tangled tale grows more tangled: in June 1862, Laura Carter married a Union officer, Junius B. Holloway of Richmond, Kentucky. Like the Carters, the Holloways were slave-owning Unionists. The marriage proved precipitous. Holloway was captured by Confederate forces, then paroled, then dismissed from the Union army, then arrested as an accused Confederate guide. Laura had to intercede with Governor Johnson on his behalf. Their only child, George, was born in Nashville in 1864. Because Laura kept all this a secret, it is impossible to reconstruct the dissolution of the marriage. In 1871, she told Johnson, “The very name I bear is not my own and I despise it.” She subtracted five years from her age to erase her marriage years. She presented herself in the North as a childless genteel widow of distinguished southern stock.
The Carters left Nashville for New York in 1865. To generate some income, Laura undertook chronicling the nation's first ladies. Apparently, President Johnson's private secretary wrote letters to the living ex-presidents in support of the project. Holloway's purported connection to “first families of Virginia” buttressed these solicitations. She may have resided at the Johnson White House for a period of weeks—not for years, as she later claimed. She finished her book, The Ladies of the White House, in late 1869. By 1870, she had moved the family to Brooklyn and become a newspaper editor, first for the Daily Union, later for the Daily Eagle. She founded a short-lived Southern Women's Bureau to “assist Southern Women who desire to be educated in the various Professions and Arts.” With the expiration of the Women's Bureau, Laura Holloway found other causes and forums. In 1869, her head had been “read” by the phrenologist Samuel R. Wells, who identified benevolence as her strongest characteristic. Holloway's article “Personal Independence in Women,” published in The Phrenological Journal and Science of Health in 1874, urged individual initiative to counteract “social bondage.” Meanwhile, Holloway's parents had moved back to Tennessee—but not to their old homestead, as Laura later claimed. As for her son George, the 1880 Federal Census reported him living in Brooklyn with two Chinese who ran a laundry.
Taking stock of this saga—of loyalties northern and southern, of propensities rebellious and submissive—no coherent picture emerges. Laura Carter reviled Union soldiers and married one. She frequently—but by no means invariably—submitted to aristocratic or Victorian conventions of language and thought, yet was one of the first women to work fulltime for a major newspaper. She was equally a woman of daunting energy and the poised possessor of a deep and cultivated speaking voice laced with the languors of the south. As of 1884, the year she left the Eagle, and 1885, the year of the last of a series of hortatory books begun with Ladies of the White House, she had not nearly integrated these contradictory currents of her life and times. In the decades thereafter she variously became known as a clairvoyant, a theosophist (she studied with Helena Petrovna Blavatsky in London in 1884), and a Wagnerite. In 1890 she married Colonel Edward Langford, secretary and treasurer of the Brooklyn & Brighton Beach Railroad.
What She Could Do
According to the fifteen-page prospectus for the Seidl Society's 1894 Brighton Beach season, issued June 2, there would be fourteen concerts weekly—two a day—at Coney Island's Brighton Beach resort. Anton Seidl would again conduct an orchestra so seasoned that its repertoire included “OVER FIVE HUNDRED different works, by nearly ONE HUNDRED COMPOSERS.” The season would begin “with a characteristically beautiful program” on June 30 and conclude, ten weeks later, on September 3. A Beethoven symphony would be featured every Friday night for eight weeks running (the Ninth Symphony being omitted). New works by Goldmark, Godard, Grieg, and Dvořák would be heard. “The Classic Masters” would be represented by Beethoven and Mozart, the Romantics by “Schumann, Schubert, Weber and others.” The Americans Edward MacDowell, Frederick Converse, and Howard Shelley would be included. More earnest fare would be leavened by “light popular music.” Above all, “the Repertoire of the Concerts will include the most gigantic works by Richard Wagner,” with hefty doses from Tannhäuser, Lohengrin, Die Meistersinger, Tristan und Isolde, The Ring of the Nibelung, and Parsifal. Tickets for subscribers would cost only twenty-five cents per concert. What is more, pursuing its conviction that “women are indeed the Music of life,” the society—whose members were exclusively female—would pursue its “philanthropic work” in support of Brooklyn orphans and women of all classes and conditions, escorting them to the seashore free of charge for rest, relaxation, and enrichment “with the sympathy of Music, recognizing with Wagner ‘that its spirit, like that of Christianity, is Love, and that it excites within us, as soon as we are filled with it, the highest ecstasy of illimitability.’”Footnote 4
All of this was business as usual. An additional, novel feature of the 1894 summer season would be a series of four concert-length lectures on Wagner's Ring, written by Seidl himself—“the first instance that lectures have been delivered to the accompaniment of a FULL ORCHESTRA.” That the lectures would be read “by the President of the Seidl Society” proved of chief interest to the Brooklyn Daily Eagle, which two days later published a 2,000-word report under the headline:
THE WAGNER TRILOGY
Anton Seidl's Lectures at Brighton Beach This Summer
A Novel Idea of Interpreting the Great Composer's Masterpieces—The President of the Society Describes the Work Which Will Be Done in the Music Pavilion by the Sea.
The article took the form of an interview with the president in question: Mrs. Laura Holloway Langford, who called the lectures “the greatest educational feature of the season's work,” and continued, “My little part will be all the more smilingly performed because I appreciate the value of Mr. Seidl's exposition of Wagner's method and ideas.”
The Eagle's reporter ventured, “This one feature of the season, while looked upon as the most novel and attractive of all, has been commented upon with some anxiety, lest the size and openness of the music hall at Brighton may prove too much for the vocal powers of even a man.” Langford retorted, “No; the acoustic properties of the music hall are well nigh perfect.”
“But what if wind and tide are against you?” the reporter persisted.
“Wind and tide will not affect the music at the beach this summer and the precautions that will be made for the music will enable a speaker to be heard with clearness and distinctness. . . . The wall of the building on the ocean side will be padded.”
“Will not that be a costly and difficult thing to do?”
“We women, who are going to do it with the help of a man and a ladder and sufficient material, have not considered it a difficult matter.” . . .
“What promise have you of the success of the season?”
“The natural and inevitable result of persistent hard work, combined with the allied factors of public interest in orchestra concerts; a growing desire on the part of all sorts and conditions of people to improve themselves, musically and otherwise, and thus increase their enjoyment of life. . . . The four years of profit and pleasure afforded by Mr. Seidl and his orchestra there makes the prospect now one of almost sure success. . . . The benevolent work of the society is always upheld by generous hearts and willing hands.”Footnote 5
Beginning in fall 1890 the Seidl Society also presented a “winter season” at the Academy of Music. The 1890–91 schedule of eleven concerts (October to March) far exceeded the New York Philharmonic's concurrent schedule of six concerts (November to April) across the river. The initial program, on October 20, was all-Wagner, beginning with the Lohengrin Prelude and closing with the Liebestod from Tristan. The closing event, on March 19, was a Grand Parsifal Concert including music not heard at the Society's March 31, 1890, “Parsifal Entertainment.” An announcement read: “The Seidl Society has spared no outlay or effort to have the most notable musical event in the history of Brooklyn.” The Family Circle at the Academy of Music was entirely reserved for “working women who love music,” every member of the society having been invited to submit two names and addresses of women “who work for their own support and are considered suitable candidates for this courtesy.”
The society's special concerts included an 1896 “Free Cuba” benefit for Cuban soldiers wounded in the war with Spain. “Worker's” or “People's” Concerts, for which tickets were distributed at Brooklyn churches, featured waltzes, overtures, cornet and violin solos, and such ostensibly lighter Wagner as the act one finale of Lohengrin. Children's matinees were a defining feature of every summer season. With the support of the railroad/hotel, these included the train ride to Coney Island, beach time, lunch, and an afternoon concert. Thousands—from the Hebrew Orphans Asylum, Brooklyn's Howard Orphans Asylum, and other such institutions—took part annually. An “inflexible” rule required Seidl Society members to identify and accompany young “proteges.” Tents with cots were provided for tired bodies—and also milk, ice cream, chewing gum, and candy.
Context: Women and Music
In certain respects, Langford was by no means unique. It was mainly behind the scenes that many powerful woman shaped American musical life. Of America's first orchestras, Chicago's, founded in 1891, was managed by Anna Millar from 1895 to 1899. She was earlier the architect of a prescient subscription plan, securing commitments on a pledge now/pay later basis. As the orchestra's chief executive, she planned its first two East Coast tours, the second of which she stocked with celebrated soloists who she knew would be important for ticket sales and reviews. Her tenure was cut short by a scandal: she was discovered to have purchased lavish advertising space in the Musical Courier in return for good tour reviews. Her board, taken by surprise, refused to pay until legal action was threatened. She became a casualty of her own enterprise. Meanwhile, her conductor, Theodore Thomas, was buoyed by Rose Fay Thomas, his dynamic second wife and aide de camp, whose activities included chairing a three-day national convention of women's music clubs at the 1893 World Columbian Exposition.
The Chicago Orchestra catalyzed the Cincinnati Symphony, initiated in 1895 by the local Ladies Music Club. The orchestra's fifteen-member board was exclusively female, its president being Helen Herron Taft, wife of the future president. Taft later wrote that administering an orchestra she had found “at last, a practical method for expressing and making use of my love and knowledge of music.” Her successor, in 1900, was Bettie Fleischmann Holmes, heiress to the Fleischmann Yeast fortune. Though the Philadelphia Orchestra, founded in 1904, was run by men, its women's auxiliary committee proved an indispensable force in fund-raising and ticket sales. Committee president Frances Anne Wister found that the orchestra required “constant begging on the part of everybody,” given “the attitude of business men who felt that after a few years the orchestra should be making a return on the investment, or at least be self-supporting. Their opinion was that an institution that was a constant expense did not deserve the support of the community.”
In New York, Andrew Carnegie was the president of the New York Symphony as of 1890; his Carnegie Music Hall opened a year later. Carnegie was no informed devotee of concerts and opera, but his business sense told him that orchestras and concert halls should turn a profit. His wife, an avid amateur singer, exerted a crucial countervailing influence. But the woman who most influenced symphonic New York was Mary Sheldon, who resolved to create an orchestra comparable to Boston's. As leader of a group of philanthropic “guarantors,” she shaped and oversaw the transformation of the New York Philharmonic from an anachronistic musicians' cooperative to a cultural bulwark backed by great wealth. Like Taft in Cincinnati, she was married to an important man—a Republican Party operative who helped to put Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft in the White House—and knew the ways of power. It was Sheldon who went to Munich to seek advice from Richard Strauss and Felix Mottl, who engaged Gustav Mahler as her conductor, who raised large sums of money in support of greatly expanding the Philharmonic season between 1908 and 1911.
In Cleveland, Adella Prentiss, an accomplished pianist whose family friends included the Rockefellers, in 1901 began a concert series that for two decades brought leading orchestras to town. Victor Herbert, conductor of the Pittsburgh Symphony, said that Adella Prentiss Hughes—her husband of 1903, Felix Hughes, was a professional singer—knew “more about the business of music than anyone” and that he “would rather have her for . . . manager than any man in the world.”Footnote 6 In 1918, Hughes decided she had found, in Nikolai Sokoloff, the conductor for a Cleveland Orchestra—which she duly founded.
In Boston, Henry Higginson was the Boston Symphony, but his friend Isabella Stewart Gardner was a musical factor to be reckoned with. Like other local arts patrons of high prestige, Gardner hosted private concerts, including recitals by such luminaries as Busoni and Paderewski. Her Fenway Court had a music room so capacious that it was inaugurated by fifty members of the Boston Symphony. Here, Gardner occasionally presented distinguished public concerts with printed tickets.
In opera, Jeannette Thurber was a singular force whose American Opera Company, founded in 1885, was a visionary attempt to institutionalize opera in English in the United States. Just as Thurber's National Conservatory aspired to create a native symphonic canon, tutored by Dvořák, the American Opera Company aspired to create conditions conducive to a native repertoire of operas by and for Americans. Her touring company of 300 members idealistically eschewed glamour. The singers were mainly American-born. The sets and costumes were lavish, the chorus and ballet ample. Theodore Thomas conducted his world-class orchestra in the pit. The enterprise ran aground after two over-extended seasons.
Girding all this activity, one way or another, were women's music clubs of every description. Although self-improvement was typically the starting point for such endeavors, in countless communities, concerts by local artists and by touring artists and ensembles would not have existed without the support of clubwomen. According to the National Federation of Music Clubs, outside of large cities three-quarters of the nation's public concerts were managed by women's music clubs as of 1927. One such, in Columbus, Ohio, reached a remarkable pinnacle of activity and influence under the leadership of Elly May Smith from 1903 to 1916. The programs she established included community music schools in settlement houses, a Saturday Music Club, a student club, an Opera Club, a club choir, and an Altruistic Department presenting concerts in city, county, and state institutions.Footnote 7
Laura Langford, in this company, may be regarded as representative—or as singular. The Seidl Society concerts uniquely proselytized the Music of the Future at minimal prices. Its “Parsifal Entertainment” uniquely conflated high purpose, high culture, and high society. Unique, as well, were the Brighton Beach lectures with orchestral accompaniment. There was something of Henry Higginson in Langford's bold self-reliance, and also of Jane Addams, who gravitated to tales of great men, who yearned for a career of self-sacrifice, who was observed to be “keen, alert, and alive in every fiber.” Music club, philharmonic society, and shrine; settlement house and self-improvement agency, the Seidl Society was the Boston Symphony Orchestra and Hull House combined. Laura Langford became a singular hortatory force in the cultural life of New York City and its environs.
What She Could Not Do
Langford and Seidl both fervently aspired to create a permanent Wagner festival in Brooklyn, with fully staged operas. For Seidl, the alliance with Langford doubtless represented an opportunity to honor the Wagner legacy more completely than could his widow, Cosima, in Bayreuth. For Langford, Seidl signified an instrument for institutionalizing Wagner in Brooklyn as a morally fortified cultural bulwark.
In summer 1897, Seidl, long absent from Europe, returned to Bayreuth to lead Parsifal. In 1897–98, Seidl Society concerts resumed at the Academy of Music. A new and better Brighton Beach music pavilion was under discussion. A permanent Seidl Society chorus of 200 voices was announced, as was a new emphasis on American repertoire. Even the Musical Courier called the society's plans “nothing if not prodigious.” Then, on March 28, 1898, Anton Seidl died at the age of 47. The funeral, three days later at the Metropolitan Opera House, was a singular occasion.
Months later, on May 2, the Seidl Society held a memorial concert. Lyman Abbott delivered the eulogy. Emil Fischer, a much-loved bass in his final American performance, sang Wotan's Farwell. The program also included the Dream Music from Humperdinck's Hansel und Gretel, Liszt's Les préludes and Concerto pathétique (arranged for piano and orchestra), and, to close, Siegfried's Funeral Music, for which the audience was asked to stand. Langford rose to explain that, as Fischer was sailing for Europe that very day, Wotan's Farewell would be repositioned near the beginning of the evening. A newspaper account reported: “The audience manifested its pleasure on seeing the woman who has done so much for the advancement of music in Brooklyn, for generous rounds of applause greeted the brave little woman.” This short speech effectively ended Laura Langford's public career. A final clipping in the Seidl Society scrapbooks announces the possibility of an October concert at Plymouth Church with string orchestra and the organist William Carl; no such concert took place. A Seidl monument at Brighton Beach was advocated by the Eagle; none was erected. The Seidl Society ceased to exist.
In later life, Langford attempted to motivate a Shaker community in Mt. Lebanon, New York, to host indigent boys. The project proceeded fitfully and ultimately languished. In fact, her dream of Shaker regeneration led to her own isolation and impoverishment. By the 1920s, she was living reclusively with her brother Vaulx and nephew Charlie on the Upper Canaan land she had hoped would heal souls. The farm's assessed value had shrunk to $7,500. She mortgaged it three times and was reduced to begging friends for gifts or loans. She died in obscurity in 1930.
What She Had to Do
“What she does she does with all her might,” the Eagle wrote of Laura Langford. “She is not easily daunted by difficulties and ordinary obstacles have no terrors for her.”Footnote 8 Reports of Langford's activities, and the letters she wrote and received, document a tenacious and combative business personality. Whether acknowledging applause and bouquets onstage or sharing her aspirations and misgivings, she did not shrink from the public gaze.
Merely typical was an entanglement with Lillian Nordica. The Met's reigning Wagner soprano, Nordica was a singer closely linked to Seidl; he coached her assiduously in the big Wagner roles. Nordica was scheduled to appear at a Seidl Society concert in December 1894. Informed that a Metropolitan Opera engagement the same day would take precedence, Langford wrote not to Maurice Grau, who managed the Met, but to Nordica herself. She also released the letter to the press:
Dear Mme. Nordica—
It seems impossible to believe that you will consent to break a contract with the Seidl Society, made before your opera engagement, and until you tell me yourself I will not withdraw the announcement. . . .Your failure to sing will place the society in an awkward position before the public, and naturally, as its chief officer, I want to have a clear understanding with you before action is taken in the matter. If you will send reply by bearer of this note you will oblige yours sincerely.
Laura Carter LangfordIn reply, Nordica made it known through a representative that a delayed Atlantic crossing had forced a rescheduling at the Met. Seidl now commented to the Daily Eagle: “Certainly it looks queer. . . . Mme. Nordica was bound by contract to sing with us.” The Seidl Society was reported to be seeking “legal counsel.” Nordica felt forced to speak out directly; she told the Eagle she was a victim of “gross injustice”—the late arrival of a steamer constituted “force majeur.” Whereupon Langford told the Eagle, “Mme. Nordica's letter . . . . is well timed as an advertisement for her opera appearances here.” Next Seidl pointed that out that he, too, had obligations to Grau: “My case is precisely like that of Mme. Nordica, only I keep my word. Mme. Nordica agreed to sing at the Seidl concert before she made her opera engagement.” In a similar situation, he had foregone a conducting invitation at the Met in favor of leading a previously scheduled benefit concert for a Hungarian charity. Nordica was replaced on the Seidl Society program; a program note stated: “Owing to the violation of contract on the part of the soloist who was advertised to sing this evening, the Seidl Society has been compelled to change somewhat its original Wagner program.”
To the Musical Courier the gushing Seidlites were prone to “hysterics,” “rapture,” and “Seidlotry.” They adored bouquets and decorations, suffragettes and orphans. Earlier, in 1889, the Courier opined that it seemed “rather ridiculous” to serve “a Beethoven symphony after dinner.” The “bands of matrons” required “special cars” and “Seidl club rooms.” Their “struggles to found a Seidl cult were not calculated to attract real lovers of music.” And yet the same women were in 1895 equally castigated, in the same publication, for being insufficiently feminine: “There are a few of us who do not admire the earnest, manly women of the Seidl Society.” As of 1896, the Musical Courier further complained: “the press”—comprised of men—“has not been treated with the courtesy that insures attention, the whole scheme has been retained and carried on for the effort at personal aggrandizement of a few enterprising people.” A “narrow-minded policy”—that is, women only—“dictated the display of the names of a few women who sought social supremacy as the total object of their efforts.” They were humorlessly smitten and pretentious; they were boastful and combative. They were too feminine; they were too masculine.
Many of the women so engaged were subject to skepticism or ridicule. Millar was dismissed for bribing the press. Sheldon was denounced for bullying Mahler. Gardner ignited rumor and innuendo. Thurber was resented as a naïf. The conductor Erich Leinsdorf encountered Adella Prentiss Hughes in 1942 as a seventy-three-year-old Cleveland Orchestra board member. “She acted as if she were the Cleveland Orchestra,” he recalled. “There were some who not only disliked Mrs. Hughes with great passion but who would almost automatically vote against anything and anyone she promoted. She was, like many domineering women, truly formidable, full of vitality, peremptorily decisive, musically knowledgeable—which made her part of a small board minority—and so direct as to be considered by softer and less-outspoken people rather tactless.”Footnote 9
Conclusion
The central character of Willa Cather's 1916 novel The Song of the Lark is partly modeled on Olive Fremstad, the Met's leading Wagner soprano from 1903 to 1914 and an artist of fabled dramatic genius. Fremstad's great roles included Kundry, in Parsifal, who oscillates between extremes of submission and domination; who mutely serves Parsifal and the Grail Knights yet, commanded by the eunuch Klingsor, seduces and destroys. Writing of Fremstad and Kundry both, Cather observed for McClure's magazine in 1913:
[Kundry] is a summary of the history of womankind. [Wagner] sees in her an instrument of temptation, of salvation, and of service; but always an instrument, a thing driven and employed. . . . She can not possibly be at peace with herself. Mme. Fremstad preserves the integrity of the character throughout all its changes. In the last act, when Kundry washes Parsifal's feet and dries them with her hair, she is the same driven creature, dragging her long past behind her, an instrument made for purposes eternally contradictory. She had served the grail directly and Klingsor fiercely, but underneath there was a weariness of section and comforting—the desire not to be. Mme. Fremstad's Kundry is no exalted penitent, who has vision and ecstasies. Renunciation is not fraught with deep joys for her; it is merely—necessary, and better than some things she has known; above all, better than struggle. Who can say what memories of Klingsor's garden are left on the renunciatory hands that wash Parsifal's feet?
In the late Gilded Age, the perfect wife was an “instrument of temptation, of salvation, and of service,” “made for purposes eternally contradictory.” In the bedroom, she was a breeder. In times of trouble, she was a pillar. In times more ordinary, she was submissive, a helpmate. At all times, she was a paragon of rectitude. Wagner's women iconically embody all of this and more. They sacrifice themselves to redeem men. They bear heroic offspring. Unsuitably wed, they become scourges, Above all, they are oppressed. Kundry, Cather's “history of womankind,” inhabits the climactic pathology of the Wagner heroine in all her strength and weakness, utility and victimization.
Cather knew Fremstad. And Laura Langford knew Lilli Lehmann, who doubtless endowed Kundry, at the “Parsifal Entertainment,” with the high temper and authority she brought to all she did. Seidl was known to esteem Parsifal as Wagner's paramount achievement. That Parsifal was paramount for Langford, as well, is obvious from the extravagant trappings with which she presented it. Its appeal to her was manifest and manifold. Wagner's sources here include Greeks and Buddhists; no less than theosophy, Parsifal embodies an eclectic spiritual quest. Langford's own quest would lead her, Parsifal-like, in the direction of ideals of abstinence—with Mt. Lebanon's Shakers standing in for Wagner's celibate knights. The drama's core message—of redemption forged through pity and compassion—preaches sacrifice in the service of others. Kundry, its lonely, quintessential woman, both embodies such sacrifice and a complexity of consequences.
In Langford's personal saga of sacrifice and service, no motif emerges more poignantly than her contingent relationship to men. Her first husband drove her to disgrace and dissimulation. Seidl enabled her brief glory moment. With the death of Colonel Langford in 1902, she drifted into obscurity. Like Cather's Kundry, she was, finally, an instrument, a thing driven and employed. Her quest for a lasting peace was incessant but futile. Empowered, enslaved, she was a woman without a place. In limbo between fin-de-siècle stirrings and the New Woman to come, hers was a notable yet surrogate life.
