Based on interviews with sex workers, sex tourists and state agents, this fascinating ethnography underscores the centrality of class and neoliberalism in the analysis of sex tourism in San José, Costa Rica. With creative interludes and rich observations, Megan Rivers-Moore situates sex tourism as a ‘relational economy’ that brings together relationality and the production of value. Moreover, she refers to sex tourism as a ‘strategy for social mobility for all participants’ (p. 1). With a theoretical approach grounded in feminist analysis and transnational political analysis, Rivers-Moore argues that the state has adopted a stance of ‘permissive ambivalence’ in relation to the sex tourism industry – condemning it while simultaneously benefitting directly from it (p. 8).
Chapter 1 describes how Costa Rica has been portrayed as ‘exceptional’ and as the ‘Switzerland of Central America’, and framed in the tourist imaginary as ‘peace-loving, friendly, idealistic, beautiful and full of natural treasures’ (p. 20). This chapter also outlines the geographic demarcation of the sex industry in San José, in which street-level prostitution and brothels are in the red-light district while sex tourism occurs in the neighbourhood called Gringo Gulch. In Gringo Gulch, women work independently, payment is negotiated up front, the going rate for sex is US$100, and hotel guests must pay a ‘chica fee’ to bring a woman into their rooms (p. 24). Chapter 2 features interviews with sex tourists, most of whom are white working-class and lower-middle-class men in their early 30s to early 70s from the United States. This chapter also engages in an analysis of men's posts on Costa Rica Ticas, a sex tourism website that Rivers-Moore aptly describes as a ‘virtual homosocial space’ (p. 40). Some themes in the online discussions among sex tourists include discussing money, critiquing US women, portraying Costa Rican women as hypersexual, and seeking the often elusive ‘girlfriend experience’ (p. 58). Interestingly, these men position themselves as enlightened ‘good men’ vis-à-vis Costa Rican men, who they see as macho, violent and domineering (p. 43). Ultimately, Rivers-Moore theorises sex tourism as ‘a masculinizing practice’ comprised of ‘encounters that trouble the boundaries between intimacy and the market’ (pp. 36, 39).
Chapter 3 draws upon scholarship on affect, work and gender relations to theorise sex work as care work, which is an important contribution to the literature on sex work. This was inspired by women Rivers-Moore met in Costa Rica who take pride in the caring practices that they see as central to their work. These caring practices include listening to gringo clients talk about their problems, offering comfort and company, and performing desire (p. 76). Chapter 4 discusses the role of stigma in the lives of sex workers, and underscores how motherhood is ‘central to sex workers’ ability to combat stigma’ (p. 98). Rivers-Moore explores two dominant tropes of sex workers’ motives – they are either seen as ‘narcissistic individualists’ who prioritise personal consumption, or ‘selfless mothers’ who work to ensure the survival of their children (p. 91).
Chapter 5 uses archival materials and interviews with state employees to investigate the relationship between the state and the sex industry. Rivers-Moore notes that it was nearly impossible to get ‘straight answers’ from state officials about the sex industry, as many of them were confused about the legal status of sex work (p. 144). This chapter explores how the state has historically dealt with sex work in Costa Rica through public health campaigns, sanitary raids and repressive policies that targeted sex workers as vectors of disease (p. 129). It also mentions two non-governmental organisations (NGOs) for sex workers in Costa Rica: La Sala, a sex workers’ rights organisation, and Rahab Foundation, an evangelical Christian rescue project (p. 145). Ultimately, Rivers-Moore argues that ‘sex tourism marks one of a variety of efforts by the Costa Rican state to secure upward mobility during a period of declining public spending’ (p. 151). Chapter 6 focuses on migration and the ‘role of racialization in sex tourism’, describing how sex tourism in San José has become associated with foreign women from Colombia, the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua (p. 152). She points out the futility and spectacle of state immigration raids at hotels – which involve checking people's immigration status and arresting and detaining those without documentation – when most migrant sex workers are in Costa Rica legally and are rarely deported (p. 153). The ‘spectacle of cracking down on migrant sex workers’, she argues, ‘gives the impression that the state is serious about securing its borders while simultaneously allowing the sale of sex to flourish’ (p. 170). Ultimately, she argues that the focus on migrant sex workers ‘reflects state anxieties about racialized immigration as a threat to prosperity and advancement’ (p. 153). Furthermore, she contends that marking Gringo Gulch as foreign allows the rest of the city to ‘remain defined by morality, family values, and national belonging’ (p. 164).
Clearly, this book makes an important contribution to the transnational study of sex tourism. However, there were a few places where I wanted to see more expansion, details or elaboration. Firstly, Rivers-Moore argues that sex tourism is a class project of social mobility and advancement for sex tourists, sex workers and the Costa Rican state (p. 175), and even claims that this book engages in a ‘novel attempt to write class back into the sociological analysis of sex tourism’ (p. 8). But has class really been excluded or ignored in the literature on sex tourism? I am not so sure. Secondly, the argument about ‘permissive ambivalence’ is also central to the book. She defines this as ‘a central state strategy for upward mobility’ that ‘simultaneously allows moral condemnation and the enjoyment and encouragement of profits’ (p. 174). However, she never fully outlines the specific ways in which the state benefits directly from sex tourism. Thirdly, while she briefly explores the migrant sex workers from other Latin American countries, I would have liked to learn more about these women's experiences and motivations. Why did they leave their home countries for Costa Rica, particularly when several of their home countries have a booming sex tourism industry as well? Fourthly, she briefly mentions NGOs that target sex workers, such as La Sala, which is run by current and former sex workers. This would have been a fruitful area to elaborate with regard to their activism and how it fits with a broader context of transnational and transregional sex-worker activism. Finally, the methodological appendix is very insightful – with its discussion of her positionality and some of the practical and ethical dilemmas, false starts and missteps that she faced in 14 months of ethnographic fieldwork. However, I would have liked to see some of the information in the appendix included in the body of the book. Ultimately, despite these very minor critiques, I found this book to be compelling, engaging and ethnographically rich. I think it would be ideal for undergraduates, postgraduates and scholars of social sciences, Latin American studies, and gender and sexuality studies.
