In Tropical Cowboys, historian Ch. Didier Gondola reflects upon the history of Billisme, a youth subculture named after Buffalo Bill Cody, the American Western showman. Billisme was born in the 1950s on the streets of Léopoldville (today Kinshasa, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo). Inspired by the American Western film genre, young men dressed as cowboys known as Bills patrolled their neighbourhoods, engaged in bloody fights with rival bands, and preyed upon young girls from adjacent districts. For Gondola, Bills embodied a subversive masculine ethos, challenging both colonial expectations of subservient African males, and the ideal of the bookish évolué, the young Congolese intellectual. The author parallels the Bills’ embodiment of cowboys with Guy Debord's concept of détournement (literally meaning ‘rerouting’), which is a parodic performance of mainstream cultural codes that challenge the dominant social order.
Billisme emerges at the intersection of the cinematic Far West, Léopoldville's African quarters, or cités indigènes, and the long history of male countercultures. Mirroring this dynamism, Gondola's book also brings together different strands of scholarship. He effortlessly weaves gender theory with historiographies of Central Africa and of the American Frontier, shedding light on their unexpected commonalities. Tropical Cowboys furthermore relies on a brilliant interplay of written archives and oral memories collected from former Bills. The author manages to make informants vividly recall their past, and address potentially controversial topics such as the rape of young girls, or the existence of homosexual practices among the Bills.
Chapter One opens with a longue durée contextualisation, recounting the history of the ‘Big Men’ encountered in the Malebo Pool – Léopoldville's geographical basin. Drawing heavily on descriptions of local chiefs penned by Henry Morton Stanley during his exploratory travels along the Congo River, Gondola underlines the likeness between the bravado of precolonial rulers and the Bills’ own masculine ideals. This exercise sometimes feels rather forced since Billisme – a marginal subculture – is here compared to the higher echelons of the social hierarchy. Gondola's exploration of precolonial manhood performances is nevertheless pioneering. Historians of precolonial Congo have paid little attention to standards of manhood, and even the brutal years of early colonial rule remain (somewhat surprisingly) poorly explored in terms of gender.
Gondola's ample expertise on urban history comes into full play in Chapter Two, which is devoted to the ‘Colonial Cronos’ that Kinshasa became starting in the 1930s. Gondola uses the Greek mythical figure Cronos, who devours his sons, as a conceptual starting point to examine the ‘arsenal of oppression, emasculation, and infantilization’ that the colonizers deployed to control urban Africans, especially young men (43). Gondola specifically examines the effects of an expanding colonial economy on gender and social relations in the capital city, as well as the attempts by Belgian rulers to promote and socially engineer new norms of manliness. In Chapter Three, Gondola explores how Belgian paternalism and its missionary interventions proved key (although often in unintended ways) to the emerging cinematic literacy of Léopoldville in the 1950s (43). Belgian Catholic missionaries endeavoured to ‘civilise’ Congolese urban dwellers in many ways, including through the production of films that featured simplistic parables. The unexpected engagement of the public with such movies – the lively discussions of intrigue during screenings, or the enthusiastic calling for blood to spill as Christ was flogged on the screen – puzzled and frightened colonial observers. Similarly, Western-themed films were viewed by Congolese moviegoers in ways that colonial censors did not anticipate. Far from seeing these movies as a tale of European triumph over ‘uncivilised’ populations, the city's youth identified with the cowboys and their models of bravery and heroism.
At the core of this book lies an investigation of the complex ways in which Congolese Bills ‘tropicalized’ American Westerns to craft new standards of masculinity that both suffused and were fed by Kinshasa's urban culture. Masculinity, as Gondola reminds us in Chapters Four and Five, is performative. Bills are no exception in this regard, as their rituals and practices demonstrate. From bodybuilding to magical rites known as kamô, from their use of narcotics to the politics of their street names, Congolese Bills elaborated a behavioural repertoire in which mystical resources and physical strength asserted hypermasculinity. This posture also constituted a response to colonial anxieties and to colonial efforts to undermine male autonomy.
Gondola illustrates this dynamic by pointing to Léopoldville's night scene that served as a stage where ‘free women’ (ndumba), no longer constrained by precolonial patriarchy, acted to ‘emasculate’ Congolese men. By demanding material compensation in exchange for sex, Gondola contends that ndumba simultaneously deprived their partners of their earnings and of their pride. This claim is debatable. Indeed, one could defend an opposing interpretation, and assert that men who paid a high price to secure the affection of a sought-after female partner could enhance their virile status and improve their standing among their peers.
Readers also enter the visual realm in Chapter Five, with images of the 1960s by Congolese photographer Jean Depara. These photographs display the extent to which Bills’ bodies became sites of corporeal agency, encapsulating new notions of seduction and offering hints of the role played by sexual predation in their claims to manhood. Indeed, sexual violence lies at the heart of Chapter Six, one of the most original chapters in the book. In a very nuanced analysis, Gondola explores the Bills’ ‘Janus-faced relationship’ with women and their ambivalent performances both as protectors and predators (115). He demonstrates how Bills used rape to construct new registers of hegemonic hypermasculinities. Practices of amour forcé (forced love) or éboulement (literally ‘rock fall’), terms that Bills often used when alluding to sexual violence, were deeply embedded in this ‘Afro-Victorian colonial society’ that reified female bodies and marginalized rape in the legal system (122). In his analysis, Gondola does not shy away from the embarrassment and contradictions of his former Bills informants (whether they are cowboys or cowgirls, as women were also members of some gangs). Interestingly, Gondola also draws inspiration from recent writings on the current Eastern Congo ‘rape crisis’, highlighting the limits of the ‘rape as a weapon of war’ paradigm. This kind of fine-grained historical examination is exemplary, and it is precisely the kind of analysis that is often sorely absent from scholarly (and political) debates about present-day sexual and gender-based violence in the Great Lakes region.
In Chapter Seven, Gondola focuses on the figure of Jozef de Laet, known as Père Buffalo, the Belgian missionary who managed to spread the gospel among the Bills during a period that coincided with the end of Belgian colonialism and of Billisme. In the early 1960s, Père Buffalo worked alongside elder Bills, painting Jesus Christ to them as a masculine ideal, an example of bravery and high morality that they should emulate. Helping the Bills to find apprenticeships and employment, he also encouraged them to publish a magazine written in Hindoubill, the slang used by Léopoldville’s cowboys. As the Bills entered adulthood, and as the sociocultural environment of Billisme dramatically shifted, the movement steadily waned, as eventually do all youth subcultures.
Tropical Cowboys ends on a fascinating chapter that places the Bills in a longer history of delinquency in Kinshasa. Rampant poverty, limited opportunities for social mobility, and the chaotic growth of a city that has become the second largest of sub-Saharan Africa offer fertile ground for various collective identities to emerge among disenfranchised youth. Gondola successively evokes Shegues, the alleged ‘witch-children’ abandoned by their families; Kadogos, the child-soldiers of Laurent-Désiré Kabila's army; and; finally, Kulunas, the petty gangsters who terrorize today's urban dwellers.
Gondola remains careful in his genealogical evocation of these groups, rightly preferring to speak of ‘avatars’ rather than of ‘successors’. While the powerful narrative and meticulous analysis may sometimes overstate the importance of the Bills, this book nonetheless testifies to the extent to which a youth subculture can define a city's (and a society's) landscape. In so doing, Gondola makes an innovative and significant contribution to several fields in the history of Central Africa – urban cultures, of course, but also gender and masculinities, youth and violence. Beautifully written without ever being esoteric, this book furthermore invites an exploration of global circuits of cultural imagery and of local meaning-making in colonial and postcolonial Africa.
