In recent decades, political theorists have significantly revised their understanding of Athenian democratic thinking. By opening up the canon, shifting their focus from abstract principles to democratic practices, and employing an increasingly diverse range of interpretive approaches, they have collectively reconstructed a more robust and multi-faceted account of the Athenian democratic public sphere.Footnote 1 Despite its ecumenical ambitions and manifest successes, however, this project has been fettered by a singular focus on language as the medium of democratic politics. As can be seen in the gloss of one of its contributors, this body of work effectively limits the democratic public sphere to ‘the domain in which judgments and public opinion are shaped and formed through speech’.Footnote 2 This logocentric demarcation of democratic practice does not harmonize well with our own experience of modern politics, however, where public monuments, political imagery, and civic spaces play a critical role in the formation of political understanding and judgment, as well as starting points for discussion, debate, and disagreement.Footnote 3 It seems similarly out of tune with what we know about the ancient Greeks, who demonstrated a readiness to move between visual and verbal content in reflecting on political and ethical life, and who developed the very idea of theôria out of an extension of the process of seeing.Footnote 4 If, as political theorists, we can temper our habitual logocentrism and learn to attend more closely to the visual culture of Athenian democracy, we stand to add new dimensions to our collective reconstruction of the democratic public sphere and, in turn, to enhance our understanding of those texts that have long preoccupied our attention.
In this study, I will demonstrate how democratic visual culture might be placed into productive dialogue with textual and epigraphic evidence to shed new light on a question that has long frustrated students of Greek democratic thought, namely, how the Athenians initially conceived of and communicated the legitimacy of democratic rule in the early fifth century. Due to the lack of any remaining statement of democratic political philosophy from the period, political theorists often assume that such an understanding, if it ever existed, is beyond our reach, and many scholars simply avoid the question in their commentary on early democratic thinking.Footnote 5 Among those studies that have attempted to reconstruct an account of democratic legitimacy, the focus has predominantly been on the late fifth and fourth century, when the textual evidence is more robust.Footnote 6 Such studies, however, leave untouched the question of how the dêmos justified its rule in the period of its ascendency. Those who have offered an account of this sort, either by specifically addressing early democratic thinking or by making more general statements about the legitimacy of Athenian democracy, have focused on its egalitarian domestic institutions and the inclusive practices through which it determined collective policy. Sara Monoson, for instance, roots the legitimacy of democratic decision in its policy of isêgoria, the ‘equal ability of Athenian citizens to speak’ in the Assembly, and the ‘participatory ethic’ that it implied.Footnote 7 Josiah Ober has argued along similar lines.Footnote 8 For John Lombardini, democratic rule was justified by its more general commitment to isonomia, which he takes to mean the ‘equal distribution of power’, due to its ability to produce harmony through the balancing of disparate forces.Footnote 9 Vincent Rosivach alludes more implicitly to the legitimating force of democratic isonomia, noting its antithetical opposition to a form of rule that is explicitly identified as illegitimate: tyranny.Footnote 10
Athenian monumental artwork tells a different story. As art historians and classicists have noted, early democratic monuments are replete with heroizing representations of the dêmos, while gestures towards egalitarian institutions are all but absent.Footnote 11 Such a disposition towards heroic self-representation reveals more about early democratic thinking than the preferred aesthetics of historical commemoration. As Tonio Hölscher has argued, these monuments were ‘designed and erected as signs of power and superiority…they inevitably address[ed] the community and, precisely because of their public nature, challenge[d] it, provoking consent or contradiction’.Footnote 12 Athenian democratic monuments, in other words, made political claims upon their viewers. More specifically, I argue, one function of early democratic monuments was to impress upon their audiences the power and legitimacy of the new regime by suggesting its satisfaction of a heroic criterion of elite rule. As historians such as Lynette Mitchell have argued, heroic self-representation was a pervasive means by which archaic tyrants justified their political authority, and it served more broadly to differentiate elites from the general population.Footnote 13 Attending to early democratic monuments thus reveals the propensity of the new regime to project its claim to rule in terms that were neither explicitly egalitarian, anti-elitist, nor even anti-tyrannical. Rather, democratic claims followed a well-known pattern that had been long associated with the tyrannical households against which the Athenian democracy would oppose itself.Footnote 14
If this argument departs from previous work by political theorists, it builds more directly on Nicole Loraux's magisterial account of democratic self-representation in the epitaphios logos (‘funeral oration’). In her now classic study, she argued that the imperatives of praise in the elite-dominated culture of classical Greece compelled the genre's orators to heroize the Athenian collective. The result, in her account, was to construct an image of the city that might successfully compete in the aristocratic ‘agon of nobility’ only by effacing what was distinctively democratic about the city.Footnote 15 To an extent, my argument complements and extends that of Loraux. By considering monumental images rather than the topoi of the epitaphios logos,Footnote 16 and by placing these images within the context of archaic tyranny rather than classical oligarchy, I find that heroic ennoblement served the ends of political legitimation in addition to eulogistic praise. However, the cumulative result of these extensions also suggests a revision in Loraux's conclusion that the heroic self-conception of the Athenians left no consequential room for distinctively democratic features. As I will argue, early democratic monuments democratized the hero at the same time that they heroized the dêmos, drawing upon the inclusive nature of the new regime to contend that the most exceptional hero was a collective one.
Heroizing the dêmos in Fifth-Century Athenian Monuments
Before considering the elitist politics of heroic self-representation, it will be helpful to begin with an overview of the monuments in question and the various ways in which the democracy constructed its heroic status. In the decades following the reforms of Cleisthenes (508/7 BCE), and with increasing intensity after the Persian invasions, the Athenians marked the new order of their city by remaking its civic landscape. In addition to transforming the political infrastructure of the city,Footnote 17 the Athenians built a dizzying number of ‘trophies of victory’: monuments and temples with the explicit or implicit purpose of celebrating their victories in the Persian Wars.Footnote 18 Most iconic are those structures built under Pericles, including the Parthenon, the Erechtheum, the Propylaea, and the Sanctuary of Athena Nikê on the Acropolis; the Hephaesteum in the Agora; the Odeum on the southern slope of the Acropolis; and the reconstructed Telesterium in Eleusis and Temple of Poseidon in Sounion. Even before Pericles’ rise, however, the emergent democracy had already created a host of imposing monuments throughout Athens, Attica, and Panhellenic centers to mark its ascendance. In the decade between the Battles of Marathon and Salamis (490–480 BCE), the Athenians commenced building on an earlier Parthenon and Temple of Poseidon at Sounion, both of which would be destroyed by Xerxes’ forces while still under construction. The growing confidence of democratic Athens was furthermore on display in Delphi in the form of a swaggering treasury, to be discussed in detail below. The decades after Salamis also saw a stoa and memorial statuary erected along the sanctuary's Sacred Way, while in the Agora the Athenians built the famed Stoa Poikilê and a structure to house the supposed bones of Theseus. Cumulatively, these monuments projected Athenian power in a manner unprecedented for a Greek polis. In the words of an eminent art historian, ‘No other polis created so systematically an ideological topography of its political identity, based on the memory of its glorious achievements.’Footnote 19 Looking forward to the argument, we might add that no polis used the symbolic resources offered by such a topography to assert the legitimacy of its new regime so effectively.
The monuments to Athenian victory employed various artistic media and representational strategies to immortalize the early democracy's recent triumphs in a heroic register. On some, this effect was achieved through the immediate juxtaposition of recent scenes or personages with those from the epic cycle and pantheon. The Stoa Poikilê, for instance, housed a set of four paintings that included representations of Theseus’ expulsion of the Amazons, the fall of Troy, the Athenian victory at Marathon, and another Athenian battle that scholars cannot definitively place.Footnote 20 This collection encouraged the viewer to recognize parity between democratic exploits and the most legendary of heroic achievements, much as epinician odes ‘heroized’ athletic victors by framing their achievements with mythic parallels.Footnote 21 The epic quality of Athenian victory was further reinforced in the Stoa's painting of Marathon by the presence of Athena, Heracles, and Theseus on the battlefield, drawing upon a ‘long-established Greek pictorial tradition in which protector-gods were shown accompanying heroes…during their exploits’.Footnote 22 The Temple of Athena Nikê, constructed in the first decade of the Peloponnesian War, heroizes Athenian achievements in much the same way. Though scholars disagree over the specific subject matter of many of its reliefs, it is generally accepted that a representation of the victory at Marathon on its southern frieze—quite possibly modeled on the Stoa Poikilê's paintingFootnote 23—was juxtaposed with scenes of divine supervision and epic victory on other sides of the frieze and its pediments.Footnote 24
A second strategy might be likened to visual metaphor or analogy, in which heroic episodes are depicted in such a way that they allude to, and at times explain, the more immediate past without explicitly depicting it. The Athenian Treasury at Delphi offers an early and illuminating example of this approach to democratic heroization, utilizing an extensive depiction of Theseus’ labors to draw parallels between his expulsion of the Amazons from Attica and the Athenian victory over the Persians at Marathon.Footnote 25 The Cimonian Theseum put this episode to similar use. Built in the wake of Cimon's victory over the Dolopian pirates in Scyrus and the supposed repatriation of Theseus’ bones, the Theseum housed three or four paintings depicting various deeds from the life of its eponymous hero.Footnote 26 Among these paintings was a depiction of his Amazonomachy, in which the figurative identity between heroic past and present was underlined by the identification of one of the Amazons as ‘Dolope’; a clear gesture towards the recently defeated Scyrian pirates.Footnote 27 The Parthenon's metopes more subtly employed this analogical strategy by depicting four different legendary victories over threats to cosmic and civilizational order. Art historians recognize in the metopes a pattern in which gods and heroes protect Greeks from the transgressive, perverting, and often bestial other.Footnote 28 These scenes are widely understood to represent ‘predecessors and metaphors of the Persian Wars’, elevating the Athenians’ own victory to heroic status and collapsing the distance between epic and recent history.Footnote 29
The early democracy dedicated overwhelming effort and resources towards representing itself and its deeds in heroic terms. Such representations pervaded the public spaces of Athenian democratic life, most notably the Agora, and made dramatic interventions in Panhellenic sanctuaries. However, this overview offers only a superficial sense of what may have motivated such efforts and what may have been achieved through them. In pursuit of answers to these questions, it is helpful to turn towards parallels in the characteristic representation of the Athenian people in the epitaphios logos. The various topoi that constituted this eulogistic genre developed concurrently with the monuments under discussion,Footnote 30 and many, like these monuments, juxtaposed the Athenian present and its heroic past in an effort to ennoble the dêmos and its deeds by heroizing them.Footnote 31 Though the evidence is limited and predominantly from the fourth century, a central fixture of the genre appears to have been an iterative catalogue of exceptional exploits that extended from legendary times through to the Persian Wars. This mytho-historical narrative, perhaps largely codified by 479 BCE,Footnote 32 demanded that the listener consider the recent deeds of the Athenians as correlates to the epic past, glossing over the specific causes of any particular conflict to emphasize instead ‘the repetitive and exemplary enactment of a single [Athenian] arete’.Footnote 33 Through its stitching together of old and new, the catalogue thus erased any meaningful division of epochal time in order to emphasize the constancy of the Athenians’ heroic character and achievement, offering a verbal analogue in both content and effect to monumental images like those in the paintings of the Stoa Poikilê and the reliefs of the Temple of Athena Nikê.
Loraux argues that the heroic ennoblement of the Athenian dêmos was driven first by the encomiastic purpose of the epitaphios logos genre. To achieve this end, she argued, the Athenians were impelled to assume a preexisting, elitist framework dictating what was praiseworthy in classical Greece.Footnote 34 Further force was given to this constraint by the need to construct a public self-representation that was impervious to criticism from the oligarchic ‘other’, whom Loraux identifies as the standard-bearer for aristocratic values and a constant, if implicit competitor in the bid for praise. The endowment of the Athenian people with heroic aretê (‘excellence’) and the elevation of their deeds to heroic status worked within this set of constraints to place the democracy on a level with their elitist counterparts. Thus, according to Loraux's argument, heroic self-presentation was the price of entry into the aristocratic contest for honor and affirmation, but it came at the cost of erasing what was distinctively democratic about the city's regime. A democracy that imagined itself in heroic terms, she concluded, must cease to imagine itself in democratic terms.
I will return to this conclusion below. At present, Loraux's argument acts as a helpful reminder that an understanding of what the Athenians were doing in their self-heroizing monumental representations must take into consideration the sociopolitical context within which they were offered. In considering these representations, as well as the appropriate context for understanding their effect, it will nevertheless be illuminating to move beyond Loraux's focus on both the eulogistic imperatives of the epitaphios logos genre and the context of fifth- and fourth-century oligarchy. If heroic representation served the purpose of praise, a look at the earlier context of archaic tyranny and elitism will help to demonstrate that it was not limited to this function. It could also serve the related end of justifying exceptional political power such as that of the tyrant.
Heroic Legitimacy and Archaic Tyranny
Given the post-archaic propensity to equate tyranny with illegitimate rule, the idea of an established criterion of legitimacy for archaic tyranny may seem counterintuitive. However, as the recent work of Lynette Mitchell has best demonstrated, such a criterion existed, and it was ‘fundamentally heroic’, as tyrannical rulers attempted to construct themselves as ‘living heroes for their communities’.Footnote 35 Central to this effort was proof of heroic or divine lineage, just as proving the absence of the same was a powerful way to delegitimize a ruler's claim.Footnote 36 Yet tyrants and other elites who vied for political power were not able to secure their claim solely on birth alone. They were also expected to enact their possession of heroic aretê—and thus to reinforce the legitimacy of their power—through the accomplishment of heroic deeds. Mitchell identifies three prominent spheres in which politically legitimizing heroic achievement was recognized: superiority in battle, victory in Panhellenic athletic contests, and the founding of new cities.Footnote 37 We might add to this list the demonstration of a privileged relationship to and sponsorship by supernatural forces such as the Olympic pantheon, as well as conspicuous displays of wealth and elaborate dedications in centers of Hellenic elitist culture such as Delphi.Footnote 38
Elites made skillful use of dedications of this type, as well as in other forms of monumental and commemorative imagery, to celebrate their victories, proclaim their privileged relationship with gods, represent their superhuman aretê, and thereby project their heroic status. They did so in part through the pervasive dedication of tripods, which were intimately tied to military and athletic victory, and which Ian Morris has identified as the characteristic ‘gift of heroes’.Footnote 39 But elite dedicators were able to represent their heroic status in other, more visually provocative ways as well. As Catherine Keesling has argued, for instance, kouroi and korai statue types represented the dedicators according to divine and heroic visual templates, not according to a strict physiognomic likeness, thereby blurring the lines between elite, hero, and divinity.Footnote 40 The resultant images were intentionally multivalent, combining visual ambiguity with explicit dedicatory inscriptions to endow the represented elite with aspects of the divinity or hero with which they were melded.Footnote 41 In this way, such images effectively performed elite possession of heroic aretê by representing their dedicators according to a superhuman type and impressing upon the viewer their exceptional power and status.
Archaic elite statuary, and especially that erected by tyrannical rulers, thus provides a critical precedent and model for the self-heroizing monumental imagery found in early democratic Athens. In using images of Theseus and other heroic figures to stand in for the democratic collective, the democracy closely replicated elite efforts to create multivalent images that assimilated the dedicator to an easily recognizable heroic type, thus affirming and projecting the legitimacy of their power. For the Athenians, Theseus proved to be a particularly effective image for this purpose. As a heroic king of Athens credited with the synoecism of Attica and, often, with the founding of the democracy as well, Theseus established a heroic pedigree for the ruling dêmos.Footnote 42 (Another vehicle for doing so was the myth of autochthony, which became increasingly predominant in the wake of the Persian Wars, and whose visual representation on fifth-century Attic vases is explored by Jacquelyn Clements in this volume.) At the same time, Theseus’ legendary expulsion of the Amazons from Attica and recovery of Minos’ ring from the depths of the Aegean made for easy allusions to the democracy's victories over the Persian invaders and thalassocratic ambitions.Footnote 43 The Athenians thus found in Theseus a figure that could effectively symbolize their heroic legitimacy by representing both their inherited endowment and recent performance of aretê.
The early democracy thus closely followed the sociopolitical imperatives of the wider Greek world by constructing its legitimacy in heroic terms. Locally, however, their claim likely functioned as a direct response to the tyrannical rule of the Peisistratids. This household, and especially Peisistratus himself, appears to have been deeply invested in the type of heroic politics described above: they claimed descent from Nestor and the Neleids of Pylos, filled the civic landscape with monumental building projects, and featured readings of Homer in the newly instituted Panathenaic games.Footnote 44 The most dramatic evidence of Peisistratus’ use of heroic self-representation to legitimize his power, however, comes in a curious story told by Herodotus (1.60.2–5). Describing a ploy to return the tyrant to Athens after his initial expulsion, Herodotus describes the transformation of a tall, strikingly beautiful peasant woman named Phuê into the likeness of Athena. Once dressed in armor and taught to hold a godlike pose, the conspirators placed Phuê next to Peisistratus in a chariot heading for the Acropolis and announced to the Athenians that the goddess herself so honored their former ruler that she was escorting him back into the city. The supposedly clever Athenians, Herodotus notes, lapped up the deception: believing that Phuê was indeed Athena, they immediately reinstated Peisistratus as tyrant.
While accepting its veracity, Herodotus appears to have found the story ridiculous, and the episode works in his text to subvert both the famed intelligence of the Athenians and the pretensions of elite politics. If we look past Herodotus’ flippancy, however, we find an illuminating illustration of heroic legitimation at work in Athens. Peisistratus’ restoration appears carefully constructed to resemble that of a hero returning home to rectify the political disorder that occurred in his absence. In this, the echoes of Odysseus are perhaps most obvious, but parallels with Heracles and Diomedes have been noted as well.Footnote 45 The use of the chariot and the supposed escort of Athena draw upon recognizably heroic symbols, and the construction of Peisistratus as an epic hero invited the Athenians to express their acceptance of, and thus the legitimacy of, his heroic authority to rule.Footnote 46 We need not think, as Herodotus apparently did, that the Athenians actually believed Phuê to be Athena, or that their enthusiasm for Peisistratus’ return depended upon this belief. More plausible, it seems, is W.R. Connor's argument that the Athenians willfully played their part in a ritual of legitimation that blurred the lines between mythic precedent and contemporary political reality.Footnote 47 In doing so, they demonstrated an early willingness to endorse the elitist criterion of heroic legitimacy that they would eventually use to justify their own, collective ascension to power.
The early democracy's use of this elitist criterion of legitimacy, as well as its explicit engagement with Athens’ tyrannical past, find their most explicit verbal expression in the hermai erected to commemorate victory at Eion in 476/5 BCE. After describing the Athenians’ defeat of the Persian forces in an epic register, the epigrams on these hermai introduce a Homeric parallel to reinforce the heroic quality of the victors:
The move from Menestheus, the legendary king of Athens during the Trojan War, as a ‘commander’ (kosmêtêr) to the Athenians at large as ‘commanders’ (kosmêtai) parallels the heroic transference implicit in the monumental imagery discussed above. The Athenians at large assume the heroic aspect of their epic king and are said to participate in his unique virtue. At the same time, by focalizing this transference through the title of kosmêtês, the epigram points to the fact that the Athenians win more than mere praise through this heroic endowment. Literally meaning ‘orderer, director’, the title kosmêtês implied authority and could be used in reference to a legislator, an elected official, or Zeus himself.Footnote 49 This epigram thus deploys the heroic ennoblement of the Athenians—a heroic aretê both inherited and demonstrated in their recent victory at Eion—to justify their power over others. Just as Menestheus could rightfully claim to command in Troy, the Athenians might now claim to command in the collective effort against the Persians.
By placing these epigrams on three hermai, the Athenians invoked the specter of their former tyrannical rulers at the same time as they asserted the heroic exceptionalism of the democratic collective, for the very form of the monument foreshadowed the complex history of the claims it contained. In the Athenian popular imagination, it was the Peisistratid Hipparchus who introduced hermai into Athens as a way of marking the passage from rural demes to the urban center. Yet, as Robin Osborne and Josephine Crawley Quinn have argued, the gaze and phallus of the hermai came to bear distinctly democratic connotations in the fifth century.Footnote 50 In interpreting this set of contrasting associations, the typical function of the herm itself appears paramount: it primarily served as a marker of ‘boundaries and transitions…mediating the public/private divide in the doorway to a house’.Footnote 51 Such a marker, simultaneously bearing democratic and tyrannical connotations, would seem uniquely well-suited for the assertion of the democracy's claim to heroic legitimacy. It announced that heroic rule had crossed a boundary from the private to the public, passing from a tyrannical household to a democratic collective.
Democratizing Elite Legitimacy: The Athenian Treasury in Delphi
By using monumental imagery to assert its heroic legitimacy, the democracy was able to make effective claims against previous and potential competitors for rule both in Athens and in the empire. Looking to the past, they superseded the Peisistratids’ claim to exceptional status and power rooted in heroic pedigree, aretê, and military success. Looking forward, they preempted elite claims in much the same way by ennobling all members of the dêmos and endowing them with the heroic exceptionalism that characteristically set elites apart. Concurrently, imperial dependents and external enemies alike met awe-inspiring representations of democratic capacity, serving both to demonstrate and to claim the legitimacy of its imperial power and to warn against the contestation of its heroic authority. If we follow Loraux's argument concerning the image of Athens that emerged from the epitaphios logos, the price of this heroic ennoblement was the effective erasure of what was distinctively democratic from this image. If, by this, we mean explicit reference to central democratic norms and institutions such as isêgoria, misthophoria (‘payment for service’), and sortition, Loraux's argument would seem to hold equally in reference to Athenian monumental imagery.Footnote 52 However, as I will attempt to show through a more detailed look at the Athenian Treasury in Delphi, there are other ways in which the uniquely inclusive nature of democratic rule played a critical role in the Athenian claim to heroic legitimacy. Though isonomic institutions were not the vehicle for this claim, their inclusive scope nevertheless allowed the dêmos to subsume the heroic achievements of any individual within a democratic framework, thus ensuring the superiority of the collective claim to heroic capacity.
Built in the years immediately after the Athenians’ victory at Marathon,Footnote 53 quite possibly within the footprint of a structure built by the Peisistratids,Footnote 54 the Athenian Treasury in Delphi makes for a particularly revealing case study of how monumental imagery served the ends of democratic legitimation. In addition to featuring an early and inventive use of heroic representation, the structure works in other ingenious ways to redirect elite status for the ends of the community. As Richard Neer has argued, the function of the Treasury, its manner of celebrating the victory at Marathon, and even the design of its facade all served to establish Athenian claims within the economy of elite prestige and to co-opt the symbolic capital of individuals for the emerging democracy as a whole.Footnote 55 Moreover, the Treasury performed these functions in a traditional center for the achievement and projection of heroic status.Footnote 56 Such status could be won in Delphi through athletic competition and consultation with the oracular god, and it was visually represented through the ostentatious monumentalization of military victory and lavish dedications to the god. The oracular seat thus served as an eminently appropriate venue for the democracy's entry into the elite arena of monumental politics.
A detailed look at the Treasury's function, design, and explicit commemoration of the Battle of Marathon provides an important framework for understanding the effect of its imagery. The basic function of the Treasury, or thêsauros, was to house Athenian votive offerings to the god Apollo. Such offerings were typically made by elites in an attempt to give thanks for some past support or to ensure future favor, but they also served to demonstrate the status, excellence, and magnificence of the dedicant. Indicating as they did outstanding achievement, divine sponsorship, and exceptional wealth, such votive dedications were a central means by which elites might project heroic exceptionalism. The Athenian Treasury, however, served to communalize and, quite literally, politicize these votives by enclosing them within a civic frame, thus deftly redirecting the legitimizing force of elite display.Footnote 57 Placed within this context, votives now served to reinforce the status of the polis as a whole rather than to symbolize the exceptionalism of the elite dedicant. At the same time, the grandeur of the Treasury itself, built from costly Parian marble and lavishly decorated, served to establish communal superiority over the elite individual. It effectively overshadowed the splendor of any single votive, demonstrating a level of magnificence that exceeded the capacity of any one household.Footnote 58 The Athenian Treasury thus served a democratizing agenda, simultaneously asserting the inferior status of elites while appropriating the symbolic resources accrued by their dedications for the emerging democracy as a whole.
The democratization of elite prestige was also a paramount consideration in the Treasury's placement, design, and explicit commemoration of Marathon. Built upon a hairpin turn in Delphi's Sacred Way, the Athenian Treasury dominated the viewers’ line of sight just as they caught their first glimpse of the Temple of Apollo. This Temple was widely recognized as a potent symbol of the largess of one of Athens’ most elite families, the Alcmaeonidae, who had administered its completion with renowned munificence.Footnote 59 Most notably, the Alcmaeonidae went beyond the terms of their initial contract and constructed the eastern facade of the Temple in Parian marble at their own expense.Footnote 60 The Athenian Treasury sat in perfect position to mediate the Delphic visitors’ reception of the Temple, and it encouraged identification between the two structures through various architectural and artistic strategies. The sculpture of the Treasury's front-facing pediment, for instance, which depicts the epiphany of Athena, appears to directly echo that of the Temple, which depicts the epiphany of Apollo.Footnote 61 In addition, the Treasury's extravagant use of Parian marble, an otherwise odd choice for an Athenian treasury, mirrors the Alcmaeonidae's use of the same.Footnote 62 (At the same time, it one-upped the Temple by constructing the entire building in this costly material, not just the facade.) In these and other ways, the Athenian Treasury prepared the Delphic visitor's experience of the Temple in such a way that the two became essentially linked, allowing the city to appropriate the prestige won by the Alcmaeonidae and to communalize it, much as it did with the individual votives housed within the Treasury's walls.
The Treasury's communalization of elite status was even more aggressive in its explicit commemoration of Marathon. In this, it went beyond merely politicizing the self-assertion of the elites and sought to erase their distinctive contributions to the victory altogether. An inscription on the treasury's base announced that ‘the Athenians [dedicate this] to Apollo [as] first-fruits from the Medes from the Battle of Marathon’, marking the collective people as both victor and dedicator.Footnote 63 Directly above this inscription, ten statues were erected depicting the eponymous heroes of the Cleisthenic tribes, thus representing the Athenian people through images that allude directly to its democratic regime while bestowing a heroic guise upon them. The popularizing politics of both inscription and statuary are thrown into relief by other dedications commemorating Marathon, made in the names of Miltiades and Callimachus. Miltiades, for his part, dedicated his helmet in Olympia with the inscription ‘To Zeus, from Miltiades’, thus ‘personaliz[ing] the victory at Marathon by omitting all mention of the Athenian hoplites who did the fighting’.Footnote 64 The posthumous dedication made in the name of Callimachus on the Acropolis, on the other hand, shows an attempt to integrate personal achievement into that of the civic body, noting that the glory won through his leadership was shared with the ‘men of Athens’.Footnote 65 The Athenian Treasury, however, eschews any acknowledgment of the role that elite leadership played in the Marathon victory. Inverting the strategy of Miltiades, ‘the Athenians’ claim all credit for the victory, enveloping the contribution of their leaders within the democratic collective.
It is in the metopes of this structure, where every detail seems to work towards the end of accruing elite legitimacy for the regime as a whole, that the Athenians first monumentalized the labors of Theseus and paired them with those of Heracles.Footnote 66 Theseus’ expulsion of the invading Amazons appears to have occupied the metope sequence extending across the front-facing facade of the Treasury, while the rest of his labors spread across the southern long wall, thus hovering above the inscribed base and the statuary of the eponymous heroes.Footnote 67 This placement encourages the viewer to see Theseus not merely as an Athenian hero but as a representation of the Athenians as a heroic collective. Starting with the base's inscription, the viewer moved from a verbal reference to the collective Athenians upward to a set of images known to represent Athenian collectives in heroic form. Thus primed, one looked up further to Theseus, a figure already associated with the unification of the Athenian people through synoecism and the introduction of democracy.Footnote 68 The eponymous heroes thus created a visual bridge between this figure and ‘the Athenians’ of the base, reinforcing for the viewer the unifying, representative function of the images of Theseus.
The heroic representation of the democratic collective on the Athenian Treasury worked as part of a larger, highly intentional effort to claim for the popular regime the heroic prestige and legitimacy that had previously been the exclusive province of elites. In this effort, the expansively egalitarian nature of the democracy was often overshadowed by the explicit symbols of elite prestige. However, the uniquely inclusive nature of the democracy was neither entirely absent nor inconsequential, as Loraux's argument suggested that it would be. Rather, it was directly instrumental in invoking the overwhelming degree of heroic aretê upon which its claim to legitimacy rested. Just as the democracy took ownership over the contributions of individual elites by collectivizing the elite votive offerings and the Alcmaeonidae temple, the democratic hero only grew larger by subsuming the aretê of individuals and representing it in a single image. It was in this ability to appropriate the efforts of potential competitors, to redeploy individual exploits as collective achievements, that the uniquely democratic character made itself felt. Thus, even if equality and inclusion did not act as legitimating principles in themselves, as many political theorists have assumed they did, they served the ends of heroic legitimacy by ensuring that the most exceptional hero was a democratic collective, not an elite individual.Footnote 69
Conclusion
Monuments matter for the study of Greek political thought, not only for the avowed values and self-understandings that they reveal, but for the political claims that they make. Political theorists profit by taking these claims seriously as constitutive elements of the democratic public sphere, and by approaching early democratic visual culture as a critical means of accessing modes of democratic thinking that cannot be found directly in the literary record. In this study, I have shown that such an approach can change our perception of how Athenians understood themselves as a political collective, as individual citizens, and as justified rulers over others. More specifically, I have argued that the claims made by democratic monumental artwork give us reason to doubt the widespread belief that early Athenian democrats, like many modern theorists of democracy, prioritized egalitarian institutions and principles in their initial attempts to justify the newfound power of the people. If later theorists, both in the classical and modern periods, came to see tyrannical and democratic regimes as antithetically related, especially on the subject of legitimacy, we must be careful not to project these familiar views back onto the early Athenian democrats. Rather, these Athenians saw far more continuity between their nascent democracy and the tyrannical regime that it replaced than these later views can accommodate. Equally, this study challenges the belief, most forcefully articulated by Sheldon Wolin, that it was through participation in deliberative institutions that the Athenian dêmos came to understand itself as a collective agent.Footnote 70 Rather, if we follow the evidence provided by monumental artwork, this collective awareness appears to have been significantly constituted by the successful projection of their power against others, as well as the collective mythologizing of these successes.Footnote 71
In addition to denaturalizing the relationship between egalitarian principle and the legitimacy of participatory government, this reorientation of our thinking about early democratic legitimacy aids in understanding how the Athenians made sense of the relationship between democracy and imperial rule. If popular rule was legitimated primarily by a principled commitment to equality and self-governance, the dêmos would have been forced to compartmentalize their thinking about the legitimacy of their regime at home and abroad, either offering different criteria for asserting the latter or accepting that it altogether lacked such a claim. However, when we shift away from an egalitarian and institutional understanding of legitimacy to one rooted in collective, heroic aretê, we find a legitimizing claim that served equally to justify the kratos (‘power’) of the dêmos in Athens and over other poleis. The heroically legitimated rule of the dêmos knew no borders, even if the ability to participate in this rule was significantly bounded. Non-Athenians were excluded (not to mention women, metics, and slaves), while elites could participate as members of the heroic collective, but they were denied space from which to assert their own elite exceptionalism within the collective. Those who felt dispossessed and disgruntled by the democracy's claim to heroic rule came to contest its legitimacy in the language of tyranny, and this was a charge for which the democrats had themselves paved the way. It is, therefore, no surprise that the dêmos met these criticisms with such ambivalence.Footnote 72
Recognition of the heroic and tyrannical debts of early democratic thinking would seem to exacerbate the historical distance between our own reflections on democracy and those of the Athenians who first coined the term. Though such distance is often keenly felt when considering the dramatic institutional, social, and economic differences that separate us from antiquity, it is easier to imagine that, at a conceptual level, the relationship between equality, freedom, and democracy has remained fairly constant. However, by decentering the role of equality in early democratic self-representation, and by locating the latter within a distinctly archaic and heroic frame, we lose even this sense of theoretical continuity. At a greater level of abstraction, however, we may find that thinking about democracy in heroic terms is deeply, if disconcertingly, pertinent at the present moment. Though academic philosophers continue to identify the exceptional legitimacy of democratic institutions with a commitment to egalitarian principle, democratic citizens appear far more willing to embrace an understanding of authorized power that incorporates elements of nativist exceptionalism, blurs the line between democratic and autocratic institutions, and indulges in a nostalgia for a past greatness that justifies contemporary policies of exclusion and domination. In such a moment, reflecting on early Athenian thinking about democracy may provide an illuminating parallel and, given the tumultuous end of the Athenian fifth century, an important cautionary tale.Footnote 73
