Professor Elizabeth Leonard has written an important biography of Joseph Holt that clearly deserved the prestigious Lincoln Prize, co-winner, awarded in 2012 by the Gilder-Lehrman Institute of American History and Gettysburg College. A member of a slaveholding Kentucky family, Holt played an important role in saving his state for the Union in 1861 and in serving as the US Army's judge advocate general during and after the Civil War.
Leonard describes Holt's antebellum evolution from southern rights' advocate to staunch opponent of secession in 1860–61. Holt first came to the attention of national Democrats when he gave a brilliant speech at the party's convention in 1835. During the next two decades, he became influential in the Democratic Party, though he never ran for public office. Holt lived in Mississippi from 1835 to 1842, where, as a lawyer, he amassed a fortune. Despite the fact that he was a loyal Democrat, he never agreed with the extreme southern rights' position of the state's Democrats. Returning to Kentucky in 1842, he brought thirteen slaves from Mississippi and sold all but three when he moved to Louisville. One of the strengths of Leonard's book is her account of Holt's private affairs at every stage of his life, which is based on the seldom-used Holt family papers in the Library of Congress. Holt's involvement with women, even when he was married, challenged nineteenth-century moral standards.
As the sectional conflict between the North and the South deepened during the mid-1850s, Holt, like other border slave-state leaders, expressed concern about the future of the Union and their communities if caught in the middle of a civil war. He denounced extremism in any form, including abolitionism, and concluded that the sectional division over slavery would destroy the republic of the Founders unless moderation prevailed on both sides. Nonetheless, in 1856 he campaigned for southern-leaning James Buchanan, a Pennsylvania Democrat, for President, and he attacked the new anti-slavery “Black Republican” Party, which he misleadingly identified with the abolitionists. When Buchanan became President, he appointed Holt commissioner of patents and, in 1859, Postmaster General. After southern members of Buchanan's cabinet resigned and followed their states into secession in December 1860, Buchanan appointed Holt secretary of war. In this position, he was immediately confronted with the Fort Sumter crisis in Charleston harbor. During the two months before Lincoln's inauguration, Holt adopted a policy, which Buchanan timidly approved, of demonstrating federal military strength while avoiding aggression or war. He also ensured that the defenses around Washington were adequate to prevent an anticipated secessionist attempt to disrupt the inauguration of the new President on 4 March.
After the war began in April, members of Holt's family pressured him to support Kentucky's secession. However, he became more committed to the Union cause and Lincoln's policy to suppress the southern insurrection. When Kentucky's governor and legislature adopted a policy of armed neutrality in the war, Lincoln, fearing that this was “treason in effect,” dispatched Holt to Kentucky for an all-out effort to maintain the loyalty of their native state. Holt's campaigning in print and speeches before two critical state elections during the summer of 1861 played a major role in securing Kentucky's abandonment of its neutrality policy. Along with other state Unionists, Holt in September 1861 obtained Lincoln's immediate revocation of General John C. Fremont's order freeing slaves in Missouri lest Kentucky reverse its decision to support the Union. However, it is doubtful that Holt, as Leonard writes, exclusively blamed “the leading slaveholders” of the South for deceiving the southern masses into secession (146). Secession was a populist and reactionary movement against the perceived threat of an anti-slavery regime in Washington, not merely a conspiracy by powerful slaveholders. At this time, Holt, along with other Unionists in the border states who were slaveholders, supported slavery.
For his efforts in Kentucky and his recognized abilities as a lawyer, in September 1862 Holt was appointed by Lincoln judge advocate general, the government's premier adjudicator of military law. He also had responsibility for handling the cases of civilians sentenced by military courts. Holt adopted a hard-line policy of dealing with such cases, which made him a lightning rod for critics of the Lincoln administration.
In April 1865, Secretary of War Edwin Stanton gave Holt the authority to try by military commission the conspirators in the Lincoln assassination, a task Holt pursued with a vengeance. Leonard provides a superb account of the trials and Holt's controversial and failed efforts to implicate Jefferson Davis in the assassination. The military commission condemned four conspirators to death, including Mary Surratt, who was convicted on circumstantial evidence. They were immediately hanged. For the remainder of his life, Holt had to defend himself from the charge that he had withheld from President Andrew Johnson the recommendation of the majority of the trial commissioners for the commutation of Surratt's sentence to life imprisonment. As Leonard concludes, Johnson had received the recommendation from Holt, but refused to intervene.
