1. Introduction
Soap film bursting is a ubiquitous process that governs the lifetime of numerous hydrodynamic phenomena, such as the blowing of spherical bubbles by children, the closure of bubble caps on floating bubbles (Champougny et al. Reference Champougny, Roché, Drenckhan and Rio2016), and bubble coalescence (Yang, Kumar & Dutcher Reference Yang, Kumar and Dutcher2024). Despite their apparent simplicity, these processes have far-reaching consequences. In industrial contexts, for example, they influence the stability of foam in food processing, detergents, and materials engineering. In natural environments, bubble bursting at liquid–air interfaces is a key mechanism driving gas and aerosol exchange between the ocean and the atmosphere, thereby affecting climate-related processes (Blanchard Reference Blanchard1967; Deike Reference Deike2021).
Thin liquid film bursting consists of the opening of a hole bordered by a liquid rim where the collapsed material is collected. The rim velocity results in the balance between the surface tension forces and the increasing rim mass. Prediction of this speed has long been debated as Dupré (Reference Dupré1867), endorsed by Rayleigh (Reference Rayleigh1891), proposed an energy balance analysis that overestimates the measurement made by Ranz (Reference Ranz1959) using high-speed photography, nearly a century later. A corrected velocity based on momentum conservation was then proposed by Taylor (Reference Taylor1959) and Culick (Reference Culick1960). One of the original aims of the McEntee & Mysels (Reference McEntee and Mysels1969) paper ‘Bursting of soap films. I. An experimental study’ was to end this debate. In addition to validating the prediction from Taylor and Culick, they uncover a perturbed region of the thin film propagating in front of the liquid rim, which they called an aureole. This area arises from the rapid monolayer compression resulting in a surface tension drop, generating a Marangoni flow and a visible thickening of the soap film.
In a second paper, Frankel & Mysels (Reference Frankel and Mysels1969) developed an elegant Lagrangian theory of the aureole by assuming that surfactant remains at the interface (insolubility) and predicts a self-similar behaviour. The main result from this theory is that by measuring the film thickening, one can extract the surface tension evolution as the function of the monolayer compaction, allowing us to probe surfactant interaction in out-of-equilibrium condition. Motivated by this breakthrough, original laser interferometry set-ups were developed to demonstrate the self-similarity and measure out-of-equilibrium surface tensions of different solutions (Frens, Mysels & Vijayendran Reference Frens, Mysels and Vijayendran1970; Florence & Mysels Reference Florence and Mysels1974; Vijayendran Reference Vijayendran1975). In particular, due to the rapid compression, the Marangoni elasticity (the insoluble elasticity
$e=\varGamma _0\, \partial \gamma /\partial \varGamma$
, with
$\gamma$
and
$\varGamma$
the surface tension and surface concentration) can be extracted – a parameter that is otherwise difficult to measure.
The ‘soap film bursting series’ also highlights deviation from the Taylor–Culick prediction. For a very thin film (sub-micron), the retraction speed becomes large (
$\sim10$
m s−1), and the aerodynamic drag can no longer be neglected (Mysels & Vijayendran Reference Mysels and Vijayendran1973; Frens Reference Frens1974). The aureole also impacts the opening velocity as it can increase or slow down the rim depending on the surfactant dynamics and the geometry (Mysels & Vijayendran Reference Mysels and Vijayendran1977). This effect was recently demonstrated by Petit et al. (Reference Petit, Le Merrer and Biance2015): by using a highly insoluble surfactant, they show a drastic decrease of the opening velocity due to the aureole. Beyond this reduction in opening velocity, the authors also show that the aureole induces cracks (folding) in the soap films due to the high compression that were also studied later by Habibi & Krechetnikov (Reference Habibi and Krechetnikov2021). Furthermore, it has been suggested that the presence of the aureole plays a key role in film destabilisation and fragmentation, influencing the generation of droplets during bursting (Villermaux & Clanet Reference Villermaux and Clanet2002; Lhuissier & Villermaux Reference Lhuissier and Villermaux2009b
).
These previous studies on the modelling of liquid film retraction have all overlooked exchanges between the surface and the bulk of the soapy film. The monolayer was assumed insoluble, and the self-similar theory was used to perform high-frequency interfacial rheology. However, such an assumption is quite restrictive since the aureole extends linearly with time, surfactant residence time in the aureole increases, and the desorption process will occur at some point. This relaxation was observed 50 years ago by Florence & Frens (Reference Florence and Frens1972), and later by Wen, Chang-Jian & Chuang (Reference Wen, Chang-Jian and Chuang2003) on larger films (longer residence time) through deviation from the self-similar process. However, surface relaxation was not studied systematically, and a predictive framework taking into account desorption is still lacking.
In this paper, we introduce a new experimental set-up to track the aureole beyond the insoluble limit by using large films, in which surface relaxation cannot be neglected. This new configuration allowed us to reveal a previously unexplored regime of aureole development, and opens up the possibility of probing out-of-equilibrium surfactant dynamics. We show that at short times, the aureole grows linearly as predicted in the insoluble limit, then departs from the self-similarity to reach another stable regime with a constant length. We propose a new theoretical model taking into account the exchange between the surface and the bulk that successfully predicts the aureole behaviour in the soluble limit. Based on this theory, we predict a transition criterion from insoluble to soluble behaviour, and show that the exchange length
$h_\varGamma =\partial \varGamma /\partial c$
(with
$c$
the bulk concentration), quantifying surface/bulk exchange of a solution, can be extracted in addition to Marangoni elasticity.
The experimental set-up and the physico-chemical system used are first presented in § 2. Typical aureole behaviours are shown and discussed in § 3. The theoretical model developed in § 4 is compared with experimental results in § 5. The implications of the model are then discussed in § 6, and conclusions are drawn in § 7.
2. Experimental set-up and physico-chemistry
(a) Experimental set-up. (b) Photograph of the hole and aureole 2 ms after the start of the bursting. (c) Normalised brightness captured by the high-speed camera versus thickness measured by the spectrometer during 9 successive experiments of soap film drainage. The linear fit is indicated by the black line.

2.1. Set-up
Figure 1(a) schematises the experimental set-up. Inspired by the giant film set-up presented in Mariot et al. (Reference Mariot, Pasquet, Klein, Restagno and Rio2021) and Pasquet et al. (Reference Pasquet, Restagno, Cantat and Rio2023), a rod held on belts is pulled out of a tank containing a soapy solution by a stepper motor connected to a pulley–belt system, generating a vertical film of 18 cm width and 20 cm height. Pulling velocity was kept constant (0.2 m s−1), and the initial film thickness was varied by changing the drainage time from 3 to 10 s, leading to thicknesses ranging from 700 nm to 3
$\unicode{x03BC}$
m. The film is punctured using a heated needle mounted on an electromagnet causing it to open in a circular manner within a few milliseconds.
The soap solution is a mixture of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) (
$\gt$
99.0 %, 71725 Sigma–Aldrich) and dodecanol (DOH) (
$\gt$
98 %, 155455000 Thermo Scientific Chemicals) in distilled water. Three concentrations of SDS (5.40, 8.13 and 10.85 g l−1) were used, all above the critical micellar concentration (CMC) (2.33 g l−1). Different concentrations of DOH ranging from 5 to 100 mg l−1 were used to study its influence on the aureole dynamics. The equilibrium surface tension of the different solutions was measured using a Du Noüy ring tensiometer (KRÜSS K6). The bulk viscosity of each solution is close to that of pure water
$\mu =1\,$
mPa s. The different solutions used are listed in table 1.
The SDS and DOH concentrations for the different solutions:
$^*$
indicates that no DOH was added to the SDS solution;
$c_s$
is the SDS concentration, and
$c_{mc}$
is its CMC;
$c_d$
is the DOH concentration, and
$c_d^m$
is its monomeric concentration. The associated equilibrium surface tension is
$\gamma _0$
.

To precisely track the aureole spatio-temporal evolution, a quantitative fluorescence technique was used by adding fluorescein in the soap solution (1.2 g l−1), similarly to a previous study of Gros et al. (Reference Gros, Bussonnière, Nath and Cantat2021). The fluorescent dye is excited using a powerful blue LED (470 nm Thorlabs, SOLIS-470C). The film bursting is monitored with a high-speed camera (B
$\&$
W Phantom V2511) at 40 kfps, and a high-pass filter (
$\gt$
500 nm) is placed on the optical lens (ZEISS Planar T
$^*$
50 mm) to capture only the fluorescent emission. Note that we verify that photo-bleaching of the fluorescent dye remains negligible during the film bursting.
The fluorescence emitted by the film is linked to the absorbed light, in accordance with the Beer–Lambert law:
$I_e\propto I_0 (1-{\mathrm{e}}^{-\ln (10)\,\varepsilon c_f h})$
(Lakowicz Reference Lakowicz1983), where
$c_f$
is the fluorescein concentration,
$\varepsilon$
is its molar absorption coefficient,
$h$
is the local film thickness, and
$I_0$
is the incident light intensity. For
$c_f= 3.6\times 10^{-3}$
mol l−1,
$\varepsilon=4\times 10^6$
l mol−1 m−1, and film thicknesses ranging from 0.7 to 3
$\unicode{x03BC}$
m, we have
$\varepsilon c_f h\ln (10)\ll 1$
, allowing linearisation:
$I_e\propto I_0 h$
, and the emitted light is expected to be linear with the film thickness.
The method is first calibrated by simultaneously measuring fluorescence intensity and film thickness thanks to a spectrometer (Ocean Insight Flame-T-VIS-NIR-ES) connected to an optical fibre during film drainage before bursting; see figure 1(a). Images are first normalised by the LED beam shape, and the normalised intensity measurements are averaged along a horizontal line, where the thickness is uniform due to gravitational stratification, at the height corresponding to the optical fibre. Figure 1(c) shows a typical calibration curve where the intensity is linear with the thickness:
$I=ah+b$
, with
$a$
and
$b$
some constants depending on the incident intensity, exposure time and lighting background condition. Note that slight oscillations appear for small thickness due to thin film interference, but are damped for larger thicknesses where experiments were performed. The fitted calibration curve then enables the conversion of film brightness into an absolute thickness measurement.
A typical fluorescent photograph of the bursting 2 ms after the opening is shown in figure 1(b). The rim, where liquid accumulates, is very bright due to its significant thickness. The aureole appears in grey due to its thickening, and its front is highlighted by the blue dashed line. At larger
$r$
, the film at rest remains darker (but not black) due to its smaller thickness. Note that gravity induces a vertical thickness stratification, and to study the bursting over constant initial thickness, the opening dynamics is analysed exclusively on the horizontal axis, starting from the centre of the hole (i.e. the
$x$
-axis, indicated by the white dashed line in figure 1(b). Using the fluorescence calibration, we verify that the initial film thickness
$h_0$
is homogeneous within
$\pm 100$
nm on the
$x$
-axis.
2.2. Physico-chemistry properties
Different SDS–DOH mixtures were used to probe the influence of the physico-chemistry on the aureole. To model the compression and the exchange, two key parameters are needed: the Marangoni elasticity
$e$
characterising the change in surface tension induced by a insoluble compression, and the exchange length
$h_\varGamma$
, which quantifies the surface–bulk exchange of a monolayer. These quantities are classically derived for a one surfactant system. In this subsection, we derive the formula for the two-component layer studied here, by reducing the system to one equivalent component.
2.2.1. The SDS–DOH bulk equilibrium
Concentrations of SDS,
$c_s$
, used here are higher than the CMC, and the SDS exists in two forms: as a monomer with a concentration
$c_s^m=c_{mc}=8.1$
mM, and as micelles for the remaining amount with concentration
$c_s^M=c_s-c_{mc}$
. The DOH is poorly soluble in water and tends to dissolve in SDS micelles. A simple law of mass action is usually used to model the DOH distribution in monomer and micelles, and their respective concentrations are given by (Fang & Joos Reference Fang and Joos1992)
with
$c_d$
(
$c_d^m$
and
$c_d^M$
) the total (monomeric and micellar) DOH concentration, and
$K=4.67$
mol m
$^{-3}$
. The different solutions used in this study and their resulting monomer DOH concentrations are listed in table 1. Note that the lowest DOH concentration is a solution with no added DOH. An estimation of DOH traces is given based on the comparison of its surface tension measurements below the CMC in Kralchevsky et al. (Reference Kralchevsky, Danov, Kolev, Broze and Mehreteab2003). Two sets of experiments of the solution with
$c_s=28.2$
mM and
$c_d=0.25$
mM (
$c_d^m=2.67\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M) have been performed and are shown by separated measurement points to show the reproducibility.
2.2.2. Surface equation of state
The SDS and DOH co-adsorption above the CMC is usually modelled by a generalised von Szyszkowski–Langmuir law (Fang & Joos Reference Fang and Joos1992; Poryles et al. Reference Poryles, Lenavetier, Schaub, Bussonnière, Saint-Jalmes and Cantat2022). The surface concentrations
$\varGamma _i$
(with the subscripts
$s$
and
$d$
standing, respectively, for SDS and DOH) are given by
with
$\varGamma _{\infty }$
the maximum surface coverage,
$K_i$
the affinities in m
$^3$
mol−1, and
$c_i^m$
the bulk concentration of the component
$i$
in monomeric form. Note that to be more rigorous, the SDS counterions (Na+) should be taken into account as in Poryles et al. (Reference Poryles, Lenavetier, Schaub, Bussonnière, Saint-Jalmes and Cantat2022). Nonetheless, this complication does not change the value of the elasticity and exchange length calculated here, and it is therefore omitted. To reduce the number of components, we introduce the total surface concentration
$\varGamma =\varGamma _s+\varGamma _d$
expressed as
Using the Gibbs equation, the surface tension is given by
with
$\gamma _w$
the water/air surface tension,
$R$
the universal gas constant, and
$T$
the temperature. Surface tensions of different SDS and DOH concentrations were measured in order to determine the different parameters. To find the SDS affinity
$K_s$
,
$\varGamma _\infty$
is fixed, and we used the SDS value at the CMC without DOH measured at 40 mN m−1. Finally, surface tensions of solutions containing different DOH concentrations were used and fitted to obtain the DOH affinity
$K_d$
, as shown in figure 2. For a given
$\varGamma _\infty$
, this leads to a unique
$(K_s, K_d)$
pair found to be of the order
$({\sim}100,{\sim}0.5)$
M
$^{-1}$
. The ratio DOH/SDS adsorbed at the interface (
$\varGamma _d/\varGamma _s=K_dc_d^m/(K_s c_s^m)$
) is found to be
$\sim1/4$
for the highest
$c_d^m$
used, which highlights the important surface activity of the DOH (
$K_d\gg K_s$
). Note that solutions with higher DOH concentration than the one used in the bursting experiments were used to properly capture the surface tension evolution.
Evolution of the surface tension of SDS solutions for different DOH concentrations. The coloured curves correspond to the best fit of (2.4) for three different
$\varGamma _\infty$
values. Dashed blue line:
$\varGamma _\infty = 7\,\unicode{x03BC}$
mol m
$^{-2}$
,
$(K_s,K_d) = (0.7,282)$
M
$^{-1}$
. Red line:
$\varGamma _\infty =8\,\unicode{x03BC}$
mol m
$^{-2}$
,
$(K_s,K_d)= (0.5,189)$
M
$^{-1}$
. Dashed green line:
$\varGamma _\infty =9\,\unicode{x03BC}$
mol m
$^{-2}$
,
$(K_s,K_d) = (0.4,136)$
M
$^{-1}$
.

It is clear from figure 2 that several sets of parameters correctly adjust the surface tension data. To evaluate the elasticity and exchange length, here we will use a range of
$\varGamma _\infty$
values to give a range of possible values for these two parameters. From the literature on SDS–DOH adsorption coverage, a reasonable range for
$\varGamma _\infty$
is 6–10
$\unicode{x03BC}$
mol m
$^{-2}$
(Lu et al. Reference Lu, Purcell, Lee, Simister, Thomas, Rennie and Penfold1995; Poryles et al. Reference Poryles, Lenavetier, Schaub, Bussonnière, Saint-Jalmes and Cantat2022).
2.2.3. Marangoni elasticity
The Marangoni elasticity for a single species is defined as
Then for two components, by setting
$\varGamma =\varGamma _d+\varGamma _s$
, one can derive (Kralchevsky et al. Reference Kralchevsky, Danov, Kolev, Broze and Mehreteab2003)
Using the generalised von Szyszkowski–Langmuir adsorption, the Marangoni elasticity simplifies to
2.2.4. Surface relaxation
As already anticipated, deviations from the insoluble theory are expected to arise from surfactant desorption from the interface. One therefore needs to identify the relevant relaxation pathways of the SDS–DOH monolayer in order to model it properly.
First, for a surfactant to desorb from an interface, it may need to overcome an energy barrier. Anionic SDS surfactants form an electrical double layer, which can induce barrier-like desorption kinetics through electrodiffusion. However, in the present system, this effect can be neglected, as the double layer is expected to be strongly screened due to the high SDS concentration, and the desorption time is of the order of
$1\,\unicode{x03BC}$
s (Chang & Franses Reference Chang and Franses1995; Danov et al. Reference Danov, Kolev, Kralchevsky, Broze and Mehreteab2000).
Schematics of the different possible pathways for the monolayer compression to relax. Here, SDS is presented with red dots, and DOH with blue dots. Surfactants desorb from the interface in monomeric form, leading to a volume overconcentration that can relax by (a) monomer diffusion, (b) creation of new micelles, or (c) incorporation into existing micelles.

Relaxation is therefore assumed to be limited by transport in the bulk. Monolayer compression leads to an increase in the monomer concentration in the subsurface region. As schematised in figure 3, this local overconcentration can relax through several pathways: monomer diffusion, formation of new micelles, or incorporation into existing micelles (Aniansson et al. Reference Aniansson, Wall, Almgren, Hoffmann, Kielmann, Ulbricht, Zana, Lang and Tondre1976). To discriminate between these mechanisms, the different characteristic time scales are evaluated.
The micelle formation pathway in figure 3(b) is characterised by the so-called slow micelle time scale
$\tau _b=\tau _2 \sim 1$
ms (Aniansson et al. Reference Aniansson, Wall, Almgren, Hoffmann, Kielmann, Ulbricht, Zana, Lang and Tondre1976), or even longer in the presence of DOH (Patist, Axelberd & Shah Reference Patist, Axelberd and Shah1998). The SDS monomers can also be temporarily incorporated into existing micelles, as in the pathway in figure 3(c), with the fast micelle time scale
$\tau _1 \approx 10\,\unicode{x03BC}$
s (Folger, Hoffmann & Ulbricht Reference Folger, Hoffmann and Ulbricht1974; Aniansson et al. Reference Aniansson, Wall, Almgren, Hoffmann, Kielmann, Ulbricht, Zana, Lang and Tondre1976). However, micelles can accommodate only a limited number of additional monomers,
$\Delta N \approx 10$
, corresponding to the standard deviation of the micellar aggregation number distribution (Aniansson et al. Reference Aniansson, Wall, Almgren, Hoffmann, Kielmann, Ulbricht, Zana, Lang and Tondre1976). A micellar reservoir length can thus be defined as the thickness over which a surface excess
$\Delta \varGamma$
can be absorbed by existing micelles:
$h_M=\Delta \varGamma\, N/(c_s^M\,\Delta N)$
, where
$N$
is the mean aggregation number of a micelle, and
$c_s^M/N$
is the number of micelles per unit volume. In the present study,
$\Delta \varGamma \approx 2 \times 10^{-6}$
mol m
$^{-2}$
,
$c_s^M = 10$
–
$30$
mol m
$^{-3}$
, and
$N = 64$
for SDS (Aniansson et al. Reference Aniansson, Wall, Almgren, Hoffmann, Kielmann, Ulbricht, Zana, Lang and Tondre1976), leading to
$h_M \approx 0.5$
–
$1\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m. This implies that monomers must diffuse over a distance
$h_M$
for the concentration to relax back to the CMC. Relaxation through micelle growth is therefore characterised by
$\tau _c=h_M^2/D_m \approx 1$
ms, where
$D_m \approx 5 \times 10^{-10}$
m
$^2$
s−1 is the monomer diffusion coefficient. Finally, relaxation through monomer diffusion (figure 3
a) is characterised by the time scale
$\tau _a=h_\varGamma ^2/D_m\approx 100\ \unicode{x03BC}$
s, where
$h_\varGamma =\partial \varGamma /\partial c\approx 200$
nm is the depletion length estimated from (2.3).
Monomer diffusion is therefore expected to dominate the relaxation dynamics. Time scales associated with micelles,
$\tau _b$
and
$\tau _c$
, are similar to the aureole time scale
$L/u_c \approx 1$
ms, with
$L \approx 10$
mm the aureole length, and
$u_c \approx 10$
m s−1 the Taylor–Culick velocity, and part of the incoming flux can be absorbed by micelles. Nonetheless, in first approximation, we assume that micelle formation and growth are negligible, allowing us to simplify the problem and develop a more general model. This implies that SDS concentration exceeds the CMC as micelles can absorb only a limited amount of monomer. This hypothesis will be discussed later in light of the experimental results.
At equilibrium, DOH is mainly contained within SDS micelles, as shown by (2.1). Similar to SDS, relaxation through micelle incorporation is slower than DOH monomer diffusion, and we assume, in first approximation, that the DOH concentration also relaxes via monomer diffusion. The diffusion coefficient of DOH is similar to that of SDS (Minkov et al. Reference Minkov, Arabadzhieva, Salama, Mileva and Slavchov2019), allowing us to reduce the two-surfactant system to an effective single-species description using
$c = c_s + c_d$
, with the surfactants diffusing away from the interface at similar rates.
2.2.5. Exchange length
The variation of bulk concentration
$\Delta c=c-c_0$
, induced by a variation of surface concentration
$\Delta \varGamma =\varGamma -\varGamma _0$
, is derived from a linearisation of the adsorption isotherm, linking
$\varGamma$
and
$c$
at the interface, i.e. in the subsurface, around the equilibrium value
$(\varGamma _0,c_0)$
:
where
$h_\varGamma$
is the exchange length, also called the depletion length, representing the thickness of a layer containing the amount of surfactant required to re-equilibrate the interface. For a one-component system, this length is easily calculated and corresponds to the slope of the
$\varGamma (c)$
curve. For a two-component system, the equivalent exchange length is more complex to estimate, as the different species release different quantities.
Note that the adsorption law is a function of monomer concentration solely, micelles are usually assumed to not have surface activity, and exchange lengths are derived in term of monomer concentration. Nonetheless, DOH monomer concentration depends on the SDS micelle concentration as described by (2.1), but as previously discussed, we expected that micelles have barely enough time to form so
$c_s^M\approx cst$
, and the exchange length derivation can be performed with the SDS and DOH monomer concentrations.
For the two-surfactant system considered, the total surface concentration variation is a function of the two variables:
with
$\Delta c=\Delta c_s+\Delta c_d$
. As shown in Appendix A, the equivalent exchange length for the two species system is given by
with
$c_{i0}^m$
the initial monomeric concentration of the
$i$
th compononent. By applying the generalised von Szyszkowski–Langmuir equation (2.3) for SDS/DOH co-adsorption, the equivalent exchange length simplifies to
3. Rim and aureole trajectories
3.1. Constant rim velocity
(a) Space–time diagram of the reduced thickness
$\beta =h/h_0$
during the bursting for an initial film thickness
$h_0=1.1\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m, and the solution at
$c_s= 28.2$
mM and
$c_d= 0.25$
mM (
$c_d^m=2.67\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M). Red and blue dashed lines respectively represent the experimental rim and aureole trajectories. The blue line represents
$u_{a}'$
, the fitted initial aureole front velocity at
$\beta =1.1$
. The red line represents the fitted rim velocity
$u_{r}$
. Inset: zoom at the early stage. (b) The rim velocity (
$u_r$
) is represented in red, and the initial velocity of the aureole front (
$u_{a0}$
) in blue, both plotted as functions of the Taylor–Culick velocity
$u_c$
. The solid line is a 1 : 1 slope, and the dashed line is a linear fit from which elasticity is extracted.

Figure 4(a) shows the spatio-temporal evolution of the dimensionless film thickness
$\beta =h/h_0$
along the
$x$
-axis (where
$h(x,t)$
is the instantaneous and local measured thickness, and
$h_0$
is the initial thickness) for the solution
$c_s= 28.2$
mM and
$c_d= 0.25$
mM (
$c_d^m=2.67\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M). During the bursting, a hole is formed, and the rim at its edge expands over time. The trajectory of the rim is automatically detected (dashed red line) and follows a nearly straight line. The small deviations arise from the rim instabilities, flapping and ultimately digitation visible in the white area (Lhuissier & Villermaux Reference Lhuissier and Villermaux2009b
). These fluctuations are disregarded, and the rim trajectory is fitted by a straight line (solid red line) corresponding to a constant rim velocity
$u_r$
. The measured rim velocities of the different experiments (different initial thicknesses) are found to be in excellent agreement with the theoretical Taylor–Culick velocity
$u_c=\sqrt {2\gamma _0/(\rho h_0)}$
, with
$\rho$
the liquid density (considered to be the water value,
$\rho =10^3\,$
kg m
$^{-3}$
); see figure 4(b).
A clear thickened region is also visible in front of the rim (in blue) in figure 4(a), which corresponds to the aureole (see also the aureole profile in figure 10
a). The trajectory of an iso-thickening line
$\beta = 1.1$
is shown as a dashed blue line in figure 4(a). The aureole first grows quasi-linearly, then slows down to eventually stabilise at the rim velocity. In figure 4(a), as a guide for the eyes, the initial iso-thickening velocity at
$\beta =1.1$
, called
$u_a'$
, is represented by a blue line. It is clear that the aureole trajectory strongly deviates from the insoluble theory of Frankel and Mysels, which predicts a constant speed. Notably, previous studies missed this peculiar behaviour, as bursting was examined within a smaller frame, approximately 1.5 cm (inset of figure 4
a), where the aureole appears to grow at a constant speed.
The initial aureole front velocities
$u_a$
, corresponding to the extrapolation of the iso-thickening velocity at
$\beta =1$
as detailed in Appendix C, are found to be proportional to the Taylor–Culick velocity (see figure 4
b) as predicted by the insoluble theory. Using the expression found in two dimensions by Petit et al. (Reference Petit, Le Merrer and Biance2015) (which extends the one-dimensional modelling of Frankel & Mysels Reference Frankel and Mysels1969),
$u_a=\sqrt {E}u_c$
with
$E=e/\gamma _0$
, and fitting the experimental data, yields
$E=2.3\pm 0.2$
. Using (2.7) together with the fitted surface tension values in figure 2, one finds that the theoretically expected elasticity lies in the range
$E=[2,2.7]$
. Remarkably, this elasticity value is found to be similar to that of Florence & Mysels (Reference Florence and Mysels1974) for a comparable SDS/DOH solution. This indicates that at the beginning of the bursting, the surfactant monolayer can be considered insoluble. Then after 2 ms, the aureole front starts to slow down, to finally stabilise at the opening velocity. The surface starts to relax (surfactant exchange with the bulk), as suggested by Florence & Frens (Reference Florence and Frens1972).
For the solution at
$c_s=28.2\,$
mM and
$c_d= 0.25$
mM (
$c_d^m=2.67\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M), and two initial film thicknesses (i.e. opening velocity), plot of the size of the aureole, at the iso-thickening
$\beta =1.1$
, over time (in red,
$h_0=0.8\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m; in green,
$h_0=1.3\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m).

To better analyse this new regime, time evolution of the aureole sizes
$L$
of two different experiments are shown in figure 5. At first, the aureole grows linearly as predicted by the insoluble theory. Then as the front slows down, the aureole’s extension decelerates until it stabilises at a constant length. This clear transition reflects a shift from the insoluble behaviour, where surfactants have insufficient time to exchange between the surface and the bulk, to a soluble one, where surfactants start to desorb and diffuse from the surface. The final length of the aureole increases with the opening velocity, as shown by the two experiments with different speeds.
3.2. Decelerating rim
(a) Space–time diagram of the reduced thickness
$\beta =h/h_0$
during the bursting for initial film thickness
$h_0=1.1\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m and the solution at
$c_s= 28.2$
mM and
$c_d= 0.35$
mM (
$c_d^m=3.69\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M). Red and blue dashed lines respectively represent the experimental rim and aureole trajectories. The blue line represents
$u_{a}'$
, the fitted initial aureole front velocity at
$\beta =1.1$
. The red line represents the fitted initial rim velocity
$u_{r0}$
. The yellow line represents the fitted final rim velocity
$u_{\textit{rf}}$
. (b) For all SDS–DOH solutions, the initial (
$u_{r0}$
in red) and final (
$u_{\textit{rf}}$
in yellow) rim velocities and the initial aureole velocity front (
$u_{a0}$
in blue) are plotted as functions of the monomeric DOH concentration
$c_d^m$
. Error bars represent the standard deviations for the different experiments in each mixture.

(a) Initial film thicknesses (
$h_0$
) as a function of the monomeric DOH concentration (
$c_d^m$
). (b) Ratio between the final and initial rim velocities (
$u_{\textit{rf}}/u_{r0}$
) as a function of the initial film thickness
$h_0$
.

At higher DOH concentration, we observe dynamics similar to that shown in figure 6(a) for the solution
$c_s= 28.2$
mM and
$c_d= 0.35$
mM (
$c_d^m=3.69\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M). At early times, the rim velocity
$u_{r0}$
is found to be in good agreement with the Taylor–Culick velocity, as shown in figure 6(b). But after few milliseconds, the rim slightly decelerates and reaches another constant velocity
$u_{\textit{rf}}$
. Initial opening velocities are found to be in good agreement with the Taylor–Culick prediction for all the solutions (see figure 6
b), except for the smallest DOH concentration which is discussed below. For monomeric DOH concentration higher than 3
$\unicode{x03BC}$
M, the final opening velocity
$u_{\textit{rf}}$
deviates from the initial one, but does not clearly depend on the DOH after the transition, and
$u_{\textit{rf}}\approx 0.8 u_c$
.
Regardless of the rim behaviour, the aureole nonetheless follows the same behaviour as previously described. During the few first milliseconds, the front velocity is constant, proportional to the Taylor–Culick velocity, as predicted by an insoluble behaviour, then it slows down and stabilises at the rim velocity; see figure 6(a). The ratio of the initial velocity to the Taylor–Culick velocity
$u_a/u_c$
increases with the DOH concentration (see figure 6
b), which suggest an increase of the elasticity. Note that in the decelerating regime, the final aureole length dependency on
$u_r$
cannot be properly studied, as the opening velocity does not evolve significantly due to the increase of the initial thickness (induced by experimental constraints), and to the rim deceleration; see figure 7.
Such a transition towards a lower velocity differs from the deviations from the Taylor–Culick prediction commonly reported in the literature. Mysels & Vijayendran (Reference Mysels and Vijayendran1973) showed that drag forces become significant at high retraction speeds, leading to a quasi-instantaneous (
${\lt } 1$
ms) reduction of the constant velocity predicted by Taylor and Culick. This drag force can account for the low opening velocity observed in figure 6(b) for the lowest DOH concentration, which is associated with the smallest film thickness (
$\sim700$
nm; see figure 7
a). However, it does not explain the measurements at higher DOH concentrations, where the films are thicker. Petit et al. (Reference Petit, Le Merrer and Biance2015) also reported deviations from the Taylor–Culick velocity. First, they demonstrated that the presence of an aureole decreases the opening velocity, with a stronger effect as the surface elasticity increases. Second, after approximately 10 ms, they observed that this initial velocity begins to decrease as the aureole, constrained by the finite size of the film, reaches the edges of the supporting frame. In our configuration, we verified that the aureole measurements were performed before it reached the frame. Other departures from Taylor–Culick behaviour have been observed when viscous effects, either in the film or in the surrounding medium, are non-negligible (Deka & Pierson Reference Deka and Pierson2020; Sanjay et al. Reference Sanjay, Sen, Kant and Lohse2022). However, these studies are beyond the scope of our experiment because in our case, the Ohnesorge number
$Oh = \mu /\sqrt {\rho \gamma _0 h_0}$
, which quantifies the balance between viscous and inertial–capillary forces, is always small (
$Oh \lt 1$
). To our knowledge, the transition that we report has not previously been described in the literature.
At this stage, the origin of the deceleration remains unclear, but a clear correlation between the deceleration of the rim velocity and the initial thickness is observed; see figure 7(b). As shown in figure 6(a), the rim decelerates when the flapping instability appears, suggesting that the rim deceleration could originate from the drag induced by the flapping film, similar to that numerically observed for air-sheet retraction in water by Jian, Deng & Thoraval (Reference Jian, Deng and Thoraval2020). Nonetheless, influence of the physico-chemistry cannot be completely ruled out as the initial thickness increases with DOH concentration, probably due to an increase in the surface elasticity (Seiwert, Dollet & Cantat Reference Seiwert, Dollet and Cantat2014), as shown in figure 7(a). A more dedicated study would be required to properly unravel the origin of this deceleration, which is clearly beyond the scope of this paper.
4. Modelisation of the steady aureole profile
In this section, we focus on the new steady regime arising at longer times where the aureole size is constant. To model this process, the natural variable change
$q=x-u_r t$
is applied, with
$u_r=u_{\textit{rf}}$
. The key ingredients are summarised in figure 8, where the monolayer compression is being balanced by a desorption and diffusion of the surfactant.
Scheme of the surface and bulk exchanges, where colour gradient represents the surfactant concentration within the film.

4.1. Mass and momentum conservation
As the aureole length
$L$
is small compared to the rim position
$x_r$
(see figures 4 and 6), the opening can be modelled in one dimension in the
$x$
direction. The aureole dynamic arises from a Marangoni stress at the interface, which can be balanced by inertia, capillary and extensional viscous stresses. When the film thickness
$h_0$
is much smaller than the aureole length
$L$
, thin film equations can be used. This approximation remains valid provided that the Reynolds number
$Re=uL/\nu \sim 10^4$
, which compares inertial and viscous stresses (with
$\nu$
the kinematic viscosity), remains small compared to
$L^2/h_0^2\sim 10^6$
(Chomaz Reference Chomaz2001; Eshima, Deike & Stone Reference Eshima, Deike and Stone2025). As
$Re\gg 1$
, viscous stresses can be neglected. The magnitude of the capillary stresses to inertia is quantified by the dimensionless inertial Marangoni number
$M=\gamma _0h_0/(\rho U^2 L^2)\sim 5\times10^{-7}\ll 1$
(Chomaz Reference Chomaz2001). Consequently, the aureole dynamics is governed by a balance between inertia and Marangoni stresses.
Thus considering a thin film element of thickness
$h(x,t)$
and velocity
$u(x,t)$
in the
$x$
direction, and surface tension
$\gamma (x,t)$
, the mass and momentum conservation can be written as (Frankel & Mysels Reference Frankel and Mysels1969; Chomaz Reference Chomaz2001; Bussonnière & Cantat Reference Bussonnière and Cantat2021; Eshima et al. Reference Eshima, Deike and Stone2025)
where 2 in momentum conservation stands for the two liquid–air interfaces. It is assumed here that the drag force responsible for the rim deceleration is applied solely at the rim, and that the momentum in the aureole is governed by the Marangoni stress. If we now consider a steady aureole in the rim framework, then the different variables depend solely on
$q$
. The partial derivatives are given by
$\partial /\partial t=-u_r\, \text{d}/\text{d}q$
and
$\partial /\partial x=\text{d}/\text{d}q$
.
The film thickness is rescaled by the initial thickness
$\beta =h/h_0$
, the velocity in the film
$u$
by the opening velocity
$U=u/u_r$
, and the surface tension by the equilibrium one
$\sigma =\gamma /\gamma _0$
. Using the dimensionless variables
$\beta$
,
$U$
and
$\sigma$
, the dimensionless mass and momentum conservation in the rim framework become
\begin{align} -u_r\frac {{\rm d}\beta }{{\rm d}q}+u_r\frac {{\rm d}\beta U}{{\rm d}q}&=0,\nonumber \\ -u_r^2\frac {{\rm d} \beta U}{{\rm d}q}+u_r^2\frac {{\rm d}\beta U^2}{{\rm d}q}&=\frac {2\gamma _0}{\rho h_0}\frac {{\rm d}\sigma }{{\rm d}q}. \end{align}
Recalling that
$u_c^2=2\gamma _0/(\rho h_0)$
, and introducing
$r=u_c/u_r\geq 1$
, these equations simplify to
$ {\rm d}(\beta -\beta U)/{\rm d}q=0$
and
${\rm d}(\beta U-\beta U^2+r^2\sigma )/{\rm d}q=0$
. It is clear from these equations that the two quantities
$\beta -\beta U$
and
$\beta U-\beta U^2+r^2\sigma$
are conserved in the problem. Once evaluated outside the aureole, i.e. at large
$q$
, where
$\beta =1$
,
$U=0$
and
$\sigma =1$
, we obtain two simple relations linking the thickness, velocity and surface tension:
Finally, one obtains algebraic relations, functions of the dimensionless thickness, for the velocity and the surface tension:
These remarkably simple algebraic equations allow us to know directly the velocity and the surface tension just by measuring the aureole thickness profile. Note that in the case of a non-decelerating rim,
$r=1$
, the surface tension equation simplifies further to
$\sigma =1/\beta$
.
4.2. Monolayer equations
In order to overcome the theory for an insoluble surfactant, the dynamics of surfactants at the interface and their desorption from it must be considered. Marangoni stresses are induced by the surfactant compression at the interface, and are given by the Marangoni elasticity
As described in § 2.2,
$\varGamma =\varGamma _s+\varGamma _d$
allows us to model the two-component system as one. The Marangoni elasticity is given by (2.7). Note that here, we assumed small deviation from the equilibrium surface concentration, which will be discussed later. In the dimensionless form, this equation becomes
with
$\varSigma =\varGamma /\varGamma _0$
and
$E=e/\gamma _0$
.
The monolayer compression is assumed to be partially relaxed by a desorption of the surfactant from the interface. The amount of surfactant released into the bulk for a certain compression is governed by
which is a linearisation of the adsorption law as detailed in § 2.2. Let us recall that
$c=c_s+c_d$
and that it corresponds to the bulk concentration in the subsurface, i.e. the volume in contact with the interface. The exchange length
$h_\varGamma$
is given by (2.11). Using
$C=c/c_0$
, this equation in dimensionless form reads
4.3. Bulk–surface exchanges
The relation between the surface compression and the relaxation mechanism is given by the surfactant conservation at the interface as
where
$D$
is the monomer diffusion coefficient, as discussed in § 2.2.4, and
$z$
is the coordinate normal to the surface (figure 8).
In the dimensionless form – except for
$q$
, as the relevant length in
$x$
is not a priori known – by introducing
$Z=z/h=z/(\beta h_0)$
this equation reads
This equation can be rewritten in term of the surfactant concentrations solely,
$\varSigma$
and
$C$
, using (4.5) and (4.7):
Note that here, nonlinear terms are conserved as they arise from the mass and momentum conservation, and solely the physico-chemistry has been linearised at this point.
4.4. Advection–diffusion equation
Once desorbed, surfactants are transported in the thin film, which is governed by the advection–diffusion equation. Similar to mass and momentum conservation, the three-dimensional axisymmetric problem can be simplified to a two-dimensional one by recalling that the aureole length
$L$
is small compared to the rim position
$x_r$
. Moreover, the diffusion in the
$x$
-axis can be neglected compared to the perpendicular one (in
$z$
) as
$h_0 \ll L$
, which leads to
where
$v$
is the transverse velocity, which can be expressed as
$v=-z\,\partial u/\partial x$
considering liquid incompressibility and a plug flow. This equation can be reformulated in the rim framework
$q$
and in the dimensionless form (except for
$q$
)
This equation governs the concentration field in the thin film in the steady regime. It is worth noting that the first term on the right-hand side corresponds to the diffusion, but here, it occurs on a deforming frame (
$\beta$
term), which tends to slow down diffusion as the film becomes thicker. The second term corresponds to the convection in the
$z$
direction, which tends to concentrate surfactants close to the interface. These two terms are opposite as
${\rm d}U/{\rm d}q\lt 0$
. Using (4.5) and (4.7), the equation can be rewritten in term of surfactant concentrations:
4.5. A solution limited by diffusion
The aureole with soluble surfactant dynamics, in the steady regime, is fully described by (4.12) and (4.15), which link the variables
$\varSigma$
and
$C$
. However, these equations are highly nonlinear, partly due to the fact that the film is thickening, and diffusion occurs on deformable media. To solve this problem, we focus on the boundary with the film at rest, where we can neglect the nonlinear terms. Small perturbations
$\Delta \varSigma =\varSigma -1$
,
$\Delta C=C-1$
are introduced, and the two equations are written in the dimensionless form (except for
$q$
) as
with
$\ell =u_rh_0^2/D$
. To be consistent with the problem,
${\rm d}\varSigma /{\rm d}q$
has to be negative, which imposes
$r^2E\gt 1$
. Recalling that
$E=u_a^2/u_c^2$
, this condition is equivalent to
$u_a\gt u_r$
, i.e. the aureole front need to be faster than the rim. It is therefore the aureole existence condition similar to the one identified by Frankel & Mysels (Reference Frankel and Mysels1969) for the insoluble case.
Equation (4.17) combined with the symmetrical boundary condition at the film centre gives
$\Delta C=A\text{e}^{-\alpha q}\cosh {(\sqrt {\alpha \ell }Z)}$
, with
$\alpha$
a constant. From (4.9) one obtains
$\Delta \varSigma (q)=h_\varGamma c_0/\varGamma _0\,\Delta C(q,1/2)$
, and using (4.16) yields a transcendental equation for
$\alpha$
:
\begin{equation} (r^2E-1)\frac {2h_\varGamma }{h_0}\frac {\sqrt {\alpha \ell }}{2}=\tanh {\left (\frac {\sqrt {\alpha \ell }}{2}\right )}. \end{equation}
This equation has a solution only for
$(r^2E-1)2h_\varGamma /h_0\lt 1$
, which corresponds to the condition for the existence of a steady aureole, where
$h_\varGamma$
quantifies the ‘solubility’ of the surfactant. If
$2h_\varGamma \gt h_0$
, then surfactants released during the compression significantly modify the film bulk concentration, modifying its equilibrium, while for
$2h_\varGamma \lt h_0$
, the amount of desorbed surfactant is small compared to that contained in the bulk, and the film can keep absorbing surfactant. Note that
$h_\varGamma \rightarrow \infty$
corresponds to the insoluble case, and no solution exists in the steady state since the aureole continuously grows over time. We see here that a constant length aureole exists only for small enough
$h_\varGamma$
, i.e. only for highly soluble surfactant, or for thick films.
In the transcendental equation,
$\alpha$
is the inverse of the characteristic length
$\ell _d$
over which the aureole evolves. The full solution for
$\ell _d$
is calculated and plotted in figure 9. Notably, (4.18) has a simple solution when
$(r^2E-1)h_\varGamma /h_0\lt 0.3$
(
$\tanh{(\sqrt{\alpha\ell}/2)}\approx 1$
) given by
It is clear that this length arises from the balance between the compression velocity (
$u_r(r^2E-1)^2$
) and the diffusion time (
$h_\varGamma ^2/D$
). Then the length diverges close to the critical point as shown in figure 9.
Evolution of the characteristic aureole length
$\ell _d$
normalised by
$\ell _{d0}$
as a function of the parameter
$(r^2E-1)h_\varGamma /h_0$
.

The surface concentration is finally given by
$\Delta \varSigma =\Delta \varSigma _m\,\text{e}^{-q/\ell _d}$
, where
$\Delta \varSigma _m$
is the maximal surface concentration, i.e. that at the boundary with the rim. Using the mass and momentum conservation equation (4.5) and the relationship on the elasticity (4.7), the velocity flow in the film and the film thickness in the rim framework
$q$
are given by
with
$U_m=r^2E\,\Delta \varSigma _m$
an unknown constant corresponding to the flow velocity at the boundary with the rim, which depends on the surfactant properties. Note that these solutions are obtained in the linear regime. The nonlinearity of the advection–diffusion equation would tend to increase the rate of change of the variables as the film thickening slows down the diffusion, and that vertical advection (in
$z$
) tends to concentrate surfactant at the interface; see (4.14). To properly capture the aureole profile in this regime, one would need to simulate the equation by also taking into account the nonlinearity of the physico-chemistry, but this is beyond the scope of this study.
(a) Dimensionless thickness (
$\beta =h/h_0$
) and (b) velocity
$U=u/u_r$
profiles in the steady regime as functions of
$q=x-u_rt$
for
$c_s=28.2$
mM and
$c_d=0.25$
mM (
$c_d^m=2.67\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M). The two colours correspond to the experiments presented in figure 4(c) (red for
$h_0=0.8\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m, green for
$h_0=1.3\,\unicode{x03BC}$
m). The lines (resp. shaded areas) represent the mean profile (resp. standard deviation) in the steady regime. Dashed lines indicate fits of the theoretical predictions (4.21).

5. Comparison with experiments
5.1. Aureole profiles
Figure 10 shows typical thickness and velocity (calculated using (4.5)) profiles observed when the rim remains at the Taylor–Culick velocity (
$r=1$
), for the same solution but with two different initial thicknesses. The profiles have been averaged over the duration of the steady regime
$\sim5$
ms corresponding to
$\sim200$
profiles. The solid lines (resp. shaded areas) represent the averages (resp. standard deviations). The velocity exhibits a clear exponential decay, highlighted by the log-linear representation, as predicted by (4.21). Moreover the experimental profiles are well fitted by the theoretical predictions (4.21), as shown by the dashed lines. The linear model surprisingly holds up to relatively large thickening (up to
$\beta \approx 2.5$
). For higher compression, experiments deviate from the linear theory, and exhibit an even steeper increase close to the rim. It should be noted that the standard deviations are increased close to the rim due to the flapping instability.
For the SDS–DOH mixture
$c_s= 28.2$
mM and
$c_d= 0.25$
mM (
$c_d^m=2.67\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M), characteristic lengths
$\ell _d$
, extracted from the fit of the velocity profiles (4.20) as a function of the rim velocity; a linear fit is indicated by the black line.

(a) Dimensionless thickness (
$\beta =h/h_0$
) and (b) velocity
$U=u/u_r$
profiles in the steady regime as functions of
$q=x-u_rt$
for two different SDS–DOH mixtures:
$c_s = 37.6$
mM and
$c_d = 0.57$
mM (
$c_d^m=4.14\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M) in red, and
$c_s = 28.2$
mM and
$c_d = 0.54$
mM (
$c_d^m=5.74\,\unicode{x03BC}$
M) in green.

The characteristic decay length
$\ell _d$
(slope in figure 10
b) is extracted for all the experiments performed with this solution (different initial thicknesses). This decay length is found to be almost linearly related to the opening velocity on the limited range accessible in experiments (see figure 11), as predicted by (4.19), further validating the developed model. Note that for this case (
$r=1$
), we verify
$(E-1)h_\varGamma /h_0=\sqrt {\ell _dD/u_c}/h_0\approx 0.2\lt 0.3$
and approximation of (4.19) holds.
Figure 12 shows the thickness and velocity profiles for two different solutions where the rim decelerates. The experiments have been chosen for their similar opening velocities and slowing down (similar
$r$
). Regardless of the physico-chemistry, both velocity profiles exhibit a clear exponential decay with the rim coordinate
$q$
. Profiles are also well fitted by (4.21), as shown by the dashed lines, validating our new model even in the decelerating regime. The exponential decay length
$\ell _d$
differs for the two solutions, highlighting the influence of the physico-chemistry on the aureole (as
$u_r$
and
$r$
are comparable); see (4.19). Unfortunately, due to experimental constraints, the opening velocity in the decelerating regime does not vary significantly, proscribing us to directly probe the dependency of the decay length upon it.
5.2. Physico-chemistry measurement
The exponential decay length corresponds to the characteristic aureole length derived in the model (4.19). Its measurement thus provides access to the physico-chemical parameters of the surfactant monolayer, namely the Marangoni elasticity
$E$
and the exchange length
$h_\varGamma$
. However, since both parameters enter into the expression for
$\ell _d$
, one must be determined independently. As demonstrated by Petit et al. (Reference Petit, Le Merrer and Biance2015), in the insoluble regime, the initial aureole front velocity is given by
$u_a=\sqrt {E}u_c$
, so that
$E$
can be directly extracted from the measurements of
$u_a$
. The method used to accurately extract the initial front velocity is detailed in Appendix C.
(a) Marangoni elasticity
$E$
as a function of the DOH concentration. Black circles are for the present study (averaged on each SDS–DOH mixture). Coloured curves correspond to the theoretical predictions from (2.7) expected for three different
$\varGamma _\infty$
values (identical to figure 2). Data from the literature are added:
$\square$
for Frens et al. (Reference Frens, Mysels and Vijayendran1970),
$\star$
for Florence & Mysels (Reference Florence and Mysels1974),
$\diamond$
for Vijayendran (Reference Vijayendran1975). (b) Exchange length
$h_\varGamma$
as a function of the DOH concentration, determined using two different diffusion coefficients: the monomer diffusion coefficient
$D=D_m=5\times 10^{-10}\,$
m
$^2$
s−1 (grey circles), and the micelle diffusion coefficient
$D=D_M=8\times 10^{-11}\,$
m
$^2$
s−1 (grey triangles). Coloured curves correspond to the theoretical predictions from (2.11) expected for three different
$\varGamma _\infty$
values (identical to figure 2).

The measured elasticities for the different solutions are presented in figure 13(a). In addition, elasticity of pure SDS solutions above the CMC is extracted from previous soap film bursting studies (Frens et al. Reference Frens, Mysels and Vijayendran1970; Florence & Mysels Reference Florence and Mysels1974; Vijayendran Reference Vijayendran1975), using the same method. Our measurements at low DOH concentrations show excellent agreement with these earlier results, supporting the validity of our approach for determining
$E$
. The Marangoni elasticity of SDS solely above the CMC is found to be
$E \approx 2.3$
(or
$e\approx 92$
mN m–1). Figure 13(a) shows that the elasticity of the monolayer increases with the amount of DOH, which is consistent with previous observation made with soap film bursting (Florence & Mysels Reference Florence and Mysels1974) and oscillating pendant drops (Wantke, Fruhner & Örtegren Reference Wantke, Fruhner and Örtegren2003). The measured increase in elasticity due to DOH is also in agreement with the measurements made by Poryles et al. (Reference Poryles, Lenavetier, Schaub, Bussonnière, Saint-Jalmes and Cantat2022), based on slower soap film compression/dilatation. The solid lines in figure 13(a) represent the prediction of (2.7) for different values of
$\varGamma _\infty$
used to fit our surface tension data; see figure 2. Both predictions and measurements increase with the amount of DOH, and reasonable agreement is obtained for
$\varGamma _\infty$
between 7 and 8
$\unicode{x03BC}$
mol m
$^{-2}$
.
With the elasticity measured, the second physico-chemical parameter
$h_\varGamma$
can be extracted based on the measurement of the decay lengths and (4.19). For the non-decelerating rim,
$h_\varGamma$
is given by the slope of the decay length
$\ell _d$
as a function of the opening velocity
$u_c$
; see figure 11. However, for decelerating rim experiments, the length
$\ell _d$
depends on the ratio
$r$
, and this method is no longer applicable. For consistency, the exchange length
$h_\varGamma$
is instead extracted independently for each experiments using (4.18), which gives
\begin{equation} h_\varGamma =\frac {1}{r^2E-1}\sqrt {\frac {D\ell _d}{u_r}}\tanh {\left (\frac {h_0}{2}\sqrt {\frac {u_r}{D\ell _d}}\right )}, \end{equation}
and then averaged for each SDS–DOH mixture.
Figure 13(b) presents the exchange length
$h_\varGamma$
for the different solutions, assuming a diffusion coefficient of the monomer (grey circles,
$D_m=5\times10^{-10}$
m
$^2$
s−1) and that of micelles (grey triangles,
$D_M=8\times10^{-11}$
m
$^2$
s−1). Here,
$h_\varGamma$
slightly decreases with the concentration of DOH, as predicted by a generalised Langmuir adsorption. Experimental values tend to align with prediction, corresponding to
$\varGamma _\infty =9\ \unicode{x03BC}$
mol
${\rm m}^{-2}$
for
$D=5\times10^{-10}$
m
$^2$
s−1, corresponding to a relaxation by monomer diffusion. Although a proper order of magnitude is found for
$h_\varGamma$
, our experimental measurements are not fully consistent between each other as they lead to different
$\varGamma _\infty$
values. The discrepancies that we observe may be attributed to experimental uncertainties or limitations in the theoretical assumptions, and are discussed in the next section.
6. Discussion
6.1. Experimental and model limitations
Experimental uncertainties, such as inaccuracies in the measurement of
$E$
, may contribute to the discrepancies that we observed in figure 13(b). However, since we recover values consistent with previous studies, we believe that this parameter is correctly measured. Imprecision in the measurement of
$h_\varGamma$
could also be invoked; however, as
$\ell _d$
is extracted from the slope of the velocity averaged over at least 100 profiles, we believe that the extraction method is robust.
This inconsistency in
$\varGamma _\infty$
between the
$h_\varGamma$
and
$E$
measurements could also be explained by the different assumptions of the model. Let us first recall that all equations have been linearised. Nonetheless, the experimental profiles are found to follow the predicted exponential decay up to
$\beta \approx 2$
, suggesting that hydrodynamic and physico-chemical nonlinearities remain small within this measurement range.
Another assumption of the model is the generalised von Szyszkowski–Langmuir equation for SDS–DOH co-adsorption, which neglects surfactant–surfactant interactions at the interface. These interactions might become important in our system due to the significant monolayer compression. A more advanced model based on van der Waals adsorption could be used to better describe the monolayer, as proposed by Kralchevsky et al. (Reference Kralchevsky, Danov, Kolev, Broze and Mehreteab2003). However, this would substantially increase the complexity of the physico-chemical modelling, and is beyond the scope of this paper.
Third, surface relaxation was assumed to be driven by monomer diffusion, which is questionable, as discussed in § 2.2.4. Indeed, micelles could absorb a non-negligible amount of monomers through micelle growth or formation. However, micelle dynamics is expected to enhance surface relaxation by enabling faster monomer removal from the interface, as micelles act as monomer reservoirs. This would lead to a higher effective diffusion coefficient, a larger
$h_\varGamma$
, and therefore an even greater discrepancy. The influence of charges on anionic SDS was also neglected in our modelling. Although the faster diffusion of counterions might influence SDS transport, the overall behaviour is still expected to remain diffusive (Leaist Reference Leaist1986).
Finally, a possible relaxation mechanism could involve direct desorption of micelles from the interface, a process observed in fast adsorption dynamics (Colegate & Bain Reference Colegate and Bain2005). The SDS and DOH would then diffuse away from the interface with the lower micelle diffusion coefficient
$D_M = 8 \times 10^{-11}\,\mathrm{m^2\,s^{-1}}$
(Stigter, Williams & Mysels Reference Stigter, Williams and Mysels1955). The corresponding values of
$h_\varGamma$
obtained using
$D_M$
are shown in figure 13(b), where a more consistent value of
$\varGamma _\infty$
is observed. Nonetheless, it should be noted that these points cannot be directly compared with an adsorption law assuming no micelle activity. Nevertheless, we retain them to illustrate the influence of the diffusion coefficient on the measurements.
At this point, no clear conclusion can be drawn regarding the origin of this discrepancy. Overall, the experimental measurements suggest that surface relaxation is slower than that predicted by monomer diffusion alone. However, the measured values of
$h_\varGamma$
remain fairly close to the predictions of a simple co-adsorption law, which should motivate further studies using simpler physico-chemical systems (e.g. a single species below its CMC). Note that this model can easily be extended to monolayers exhibiting a desorption barrier, as detailed in Appendix D, to enable measurement of the desorption rate.
6.2. Transition from insoluble to soluble regime
A simple transition criterion from insoluble to steady soluble behaviour can be established. The length of the ‘insoluble aureole’ increases linearly in time as
$(u_a - u_c)t$
, while at later stages, the aureole size is set by the characteristic decay length
$\ell _d$
. For the sake of clarity, let us assume here that
$u_r=u_c$
, that
$(E-1)h_\varGamma /h_0\lt 0.3$
, and that the transition time
$\tau$
corresponds to the time at which
$(u_a - u_c)\tau =\ell _d$
, which gives
Remarkably, this transition time depends solely on physico-chemical parameters. Transition of the aureole length
$L$
, shown in figure 5, indeed occurs at the same time regardless of the opening velocity. In our experiments, this transition time is of the order of 1 ms, consistent with bursting times probed in the earlier studies. This implies that an aureole of a film of 1 cm width bursting at 10 m s−1 evolves in the insoluble regime predicted by Frankel & Mysels (Reference Frankel and Mysels1969).
The transition length is given by
$u_c\tau$
. For films or bubbles smaller than this length, an insoluble behaviour can be applied, while for larger length, desorption needs to be taken into account to properly model the aureole. It can be seen that thicker films (
$u_c\propto 1/\sqrt {h_0}$
) are more likely to exhibit this soluble behaviour.
For a rheological point of view, reliable measurement of the Marangoni elasticity can only be performed for time smaller than
$\tau$
, which highlights the difficulty in directly measuring this parameter as it requires equipment with high temporal resolution (
$\sim10$
kHz).
6.3. Steady aureole existence
The theory predicts a criterion for the existence of the steady aureole regime:
$2(r^2E-1) h_\varGamma \lt h_0$
. The left-hand side is an intrinsic property of a solution that represents the thickness over which a surfactant diffuses during the film bursting. The factor 2 reflects the two interfaces. If such thickness is smaller than the film thickness, then diffusion occurs on an apparently infinite reservoir, and the aureole keeps desorbing over its entire extension.
On the contrary, if the film thickness is smaller than the characteristic one, then the diffusion layers from the two interfaces will significantly overlap, i.e. the film will behave as a finite surfactant reservoir and saturate. In this case, we can expect a significant decrease of the desorption rate, potentially leading to a new equilibrium between the surface and the bulk as described by Prins, Arcuri & Van den Tempel (Reference Prins, Arcuri and Van den Tempel1967) and Couder, Chomaz & Rabaud (Reference Couder, Chomaz and Rabaud1989). If such an equilibrium is reached, then surface tension is thickness-only-dependent, which is the key assumption made by Frankel & Mysels (Reference Frankel and Mysels1969) to derive the self-similar theory of an insoluble monolayer. The difference here is that the link between thickness and surface tension comes from the finite reservoir (new equilibrium with the bulk). We can therefore speculate that for
$2(r^2E-1)h_\varGamma \gt h_0$
, aureoles first slow down due to desorption, then reach another constant velocity, higher than the rim one, and evolve in a self-similar manner, with the film bulk being in equilibrium with the surface. This behaviour has been observed in solutions with higher DOH concentrations. However, as it involves a different theoretical framework, it will be discussed in a subsequent study.
6.4. Towards high-frequency measurement
Modelling the adsorption of soluble surfactants remains a challenging task, as only equilibrium surface tension is generally accessible using conventional techniques (Franses, Basaran & Chang Reference Franses, Basaran and Chang1996). Indeed, pendant-drop, rising-bubble, Wilhelmy-plate, and Du Noüy-ring measurements are typically limited to frequencies 10–100 Hz. Maximum bubble pressure and capillary wave methods provide access to slightly higher frequencies (
$\approx100$
Hz–1 kHz) (Langevin & Monroy Reference Langevin and Monroy2014), but remain too slow to probe soluble surfactants with characteristic dynamics of the order of 10 kHz.
This limited measurement range proscribes discrimination between different sets of fitting parameters, as illustrated in figure 2, where several adsorption parameter sets capture the equilibrium surface tension equally well. We anticipate that aureole dynamics paves the way towards higher-frequency probing, enabling a better understanding of adsorption mechanisms. In particular, this approach allows measurements of the Marangoni elasticity, which provides stronger discrimination among model parameter choices (see figure 13). By further improving the proposed model, a reliable exchange length may also become accessible, providing valuable insight into fast surfactant adsorption and transport processes.
Finally, aureole dynamics is reminiscent of studies based on flowing soap films, in which an object is inserted or a laser is shone onto the film, leading to the formation of a Mach cone (Kim & Mandre Reference Kim and Mandre2017; Zhao & Xu Reference Zhao and Xu2024). In these studies, reliable cone-angle measurements are performed approximately 5 mm downstream of the object at flow velocities approximately 5 m s−1, so that the imposed compression has approximately1 ms to relax, which is longer than the relaxation time scale of soluble surfactants. The elasticity probed in these experiments is therefore likely the film (or Gibbs) elasticity (Couder et al. Reference Couder, Chomaz and Rabaud1989), corresponding to a regime in which surfactants have sufficient time to equilibrate with the underlying thin film, rather than the Marangoni (insoluble) elasticity measured in the present study. This interpretation is supported by the fact that the elasticities measured in flowing films are smaller than the equilibrium surface tension (
$E\lt 1$
), so that no aureole can form at such low elasticity, whereas aureoles are observed during the bursting of soap films made from similar surfactant solutions (Lhuissier & Villermaux Reference Lhuissier and Villermaux2009a
).
7. Conclusion
Bursting of large soap films shows significant deviations from the classical insoluble theory of the aureole. While the initial stage follows insoluble behaviour, after few milliseconds, the compression region stops growing and reaches a constant size. It is shown that this deviation arises from surface relaxation, where the surfactant desorption flux balances the compression induced by the rapid bursting.
A model of these steady aureoles is developed under the assumption that the desorption flux is limited by the diffusion within the thin film. The theory accurately predicts the experimentally observed exponential thickness and velocity profiles in the aureole. Through measurements of the characteristic aureole length, this model also provides access to two key parameters of the monolayer: the Marangoni elasticity and the exchange length. The physico-chemical values obtained from bursting experiments are in reasonable agreement with prediction based on a simple co-adsorption law. This study paves the way towards high-frequency surface rheology, which is relevant for soluble surfactants that form monolayers evolving in the order of milliseconds.
The steady aureole regime identified in this study has a limited existence domain. Indeed, the film thickness needs to be large enough for the desorption to proceed over the entire aureole, i.e. the film acts as an infinite reservoir. For thinner film or less soluble surfactant, we suspect another unsteady regime, similar to the one identified from the insoluble theory, to arise as the film saturates and behaves as a finite reservoir.
Beyond these physico-chemical considerations, the bursting of liquid sheets and bubbles plays a crucial role in aerosol generation, such as in ocean–atmosphere exchanges (Deike Reference Deike2021). As shown by Villermaux & Clanet (Reference Villermaux and Clanet2002) and Lhuissier & Villermaux (Reference Lhuissier and Villermaux2012), droplet formation results from a cascade of instabilities, and the droplet sizes are closely linked to the flapping instability, which is triggered and governed by the aureole. We believe that this simple model can be extended to derive a direct link between the physico-chemical properties of the film and the aerosol size.
As a last remark, we experimentally uncover a new type of rim deceleration where a thicker film results in higher deviation from Taylor–Culick prediction. This deceleration occurs a few milliseconds after the film bursting beginning, and seems to be synchronised with the start of the flapping instability, suggesting an excess drag induced by the out-of-plane motion. We foresee that this observation will motivate further studies on the subject.
Acknowledgements
We thank I. Cantat and T. Lenavetier for fruitful discussions. For the purpose of Open Access, a CC-BY public copyright licence has been applied by the authors to the present document and will be applied to all subsequent versions up to the Author Accepted Manuscript arising from this submission.
Declaration of interests
The authors report no conflict of interest.
Appendix A. Two surfactants exchange length
The equivalent exchange length for the two-species system is given by
The two exchange lengths
$h^{s,d}_\varGamma =\left . {\partial \varGamma }/{\partial c_{s,d}}\right |_{c_{d,s}}$
can be evaluated from (2.3). The remaining unknown value is the ratio of SDS to DOH released from the interface during compression. This distribution is given by using the uniform compression of the interface, and both species are compressed equally:
where
$\varGamma _{i0}$
represents the initial surface concentrations. The SDS and DOH surface concentrations are given by
with
$h^{s,d}_{\varGamma _i}=\partial \varGamma _i/\partial c_{s,d}$
. The relation between
$\Delta c_s$
and
$\Delta c_d$
is obtained using
$\varGamma _d/\varGamma _{d0}=\varGamma _s/\varGamma _{s0}$
, leading to
and the released amount of the different species is given by
$\Delta c_s=a\,\Delta c_d$
with
\begin{equation} a=\frac {h^d_{\varGamma _s}\varGamma _{d0}-h^d_{\varGamma _d}\varGamma _{s0}}{h^s_{\varGamma _d}\varGamma _{s0}-h^s_{\varGamma _s}\varGamma _{d0}}=\frac {c_{s0}^m}{c_{d0}^m}, \end{equation}
where
$c_{i0}^m$
is the initial monomeric concentration of the
$i$
th compononent. Then the concentration ratios are given by
$\Delta c_s/\Delta c=c_{s0}^m/(c_{s0}^m+c_{d0}^m)$
and
$\Delta c_d/\Delta c=c_{d0}^m/(c_{s0}^m+c_{d0}^m)$
, and the equivalent exchange length is
\begin{equation} h_\varGamma =\dfrac {\left .\dfrac {\partial \varGamma }{\partial c_{s}}\right |_{c_{d}}c_{s0}^m+\left .\dfrac {\partial \varGamma }{\partial c_d}\right |_{c_s}c_{d0}^m}{c_{s0}^m+c_{d0}^m}. \end{equation}
Space–time diagram of a typical aureole dynamic recorded in white light interferometry with a zoom on the bursting beginning in the inset.

Appendix B. Aureole dynamic using white light interferometry
We also conducted experiments using white light illumination. The light is incident on the thin film at a fixed angle, and the reflected light, which has interfered within the thin film, is recorded using a high-speed colour camera (Photron Fastcam SA5). Figure 14 shows a typical spatio-temporal diagram of the aureole. Each colour corresponds to a specific thin film thickness; the film at rest appears green, corresponding to thickness approximately 1.5
$\unicode{x03BC}$
m.
The aureole front is more clearly visible in interferometry than in the fluorescence technique, and appears in blue–pink colours. It is evident from the figure that the aureole front decelerates and eventually stabilises at the opening velocity. Although front detection may be more accurate in white light interferometry, the colours in the aureole region become grey at large thicknesses, which prevents any reliable thickness measurement. This limitation justifies the use of fluorescence measurements.
Appendix C. Measurement of the initial aureole front velocity
The graphical representation of the aureole shown in figures 4 and 6 is not enough to measure the initial front velocity. Indeed, during the milliseconds following the opening, the aureole might not induce a high enough thickening to properly detect the aureole position. Moreover, the measurement of the initial slope was found to be dependent on the threshold in thickening used to detect the front, suggesting that different thicknesses have different speeds.
Velocity
$u_d$
extracted using
$x_d=u_d t$
as a function of the thickening level
$\beta _d$
. The hatched area represents the noise level.

To correctly extract the initial speed
$u_a$
independently of the measurement parameters, the following method is applied. For each time, the aureole front position
$x_d$
is detected once the thickness is higher than a prescribed thickening
$\beta _d$
. This process is repeated for every frame up to a certain time
$T_d$
, and the points are then fitted using
$x_d=u_d t$
to extract the velocity
$u_d$
of the thickening level
$\beta _d$
. For
$T_d\leq 1$
ms, the measurement becomes independent of
$T_d$
, indicating that desorption is negligible during the first millisecond, and
$T_d$
is fixed to 1 ms hereafter.
The initial velocity is then extracted for different thickening levels
$\beta _d$
. As shown in figure 15,
$u_d$
linearly decreases with
$\beta _d$
. For thickening threshold lower than 1.05,
$u_d$
is scattered due to the background noise of the fluorescence technique, and the aureole front is no longer correctly detected. Finally,
$u_a$
is extracted from the extrapolation of the slope of
$u_d$
as a function of
$\beta _d$
, for
$\beta _d\gt 1.05$
, in
$\beta =1$
, which corresponds to the true aureole front velocity.
Appendix D. A solution limited by a desorption barrier
If the surfactant desorption is limited by a barrier, such as in the case of low concentrated ionic surfactant, then more complex molecules or surfactant interact at the interface. Let us assume a simple Henry’s law to model the desorption:
where
$k_d$
is the rate of desorption. Using the same approach as for the diffusion limited case, we rewrite this equation in dimensionless form in the rim frame, and use (4.5) and (4.7) to produce solely an equation on
$\varSigma$
, leading to
Once linearised, the stationary aureole in the barrier limited regime is governed by
which has the same solution as for the diffusion limited case
$\Delta \varSigma =\Delta \varSigma _m\, \text{e}^{-q/\ell _b}$
, but with a characteristic length given by

































































































