Salman Bashier's The Story of Islamic Philosophy is an admirable effort to broach, as the title suggests, the use of stories by the philosophers in the Islamic tradition. The author focuses on Ibn Tufayl's sophisticated and insightful work Hayy ibn Yaqzan and, in the process, incorporates discussions of the relevant features of the philosophies of Plato, Aristotle, Plotinus, al-Farabi, Avicenna, al-Ghazali, Ibn ʿArabi, and others. The author exhibits the depth of his reflections on the issue at hand when he claims that continuity exists between philosophical reflection and mystical insight (pp. 6, 12). He maintains that although rational discourse has limits and cannot attain the highest state of enlightenment and illumination, the philosopher can draw on (symbolic) narratives, “stories” as it were, to supplement rational deliberation (p. 8). Elsewhere he introduces the Platonic notion of dialectic to point out how reason can assist in the ascent to mystical perfection and insight (pp. 138–39). But how is this dialectic different from the dialectical method of the “rationalist thinkers”? Bashier aims to clarify this point in the closing pages of Chapter 6 and in the conclusion, but his comments are meager and ultimately unsatisfactory. In the conclusion, Bashier asserts that although “reason” has limits, we need to “ascend to higher levels of intellection” (p. 139). Is intellection the same as reasoning? If so, how can reason have limits and not have limits? If not, then the whole thesis of continuity (between philosophy and mystical insight) is jeopardized. Bashier addresses this concern by drawing from William Chittick's work. That is a good place to look, but Bashier's suggestive appropriation of passages from Chittick's Sufi Path of Knowledge (pp. 138–39) does not succeed in resolving the previous paradox.
Bashier's approach to the primary and secondary sources is didactic. He readily traverses disciplinary boundaries and claims enthralling connections between various texts and traditions. For instance, he maintains that there are connections between Gilgamesh, Ibn Tufayl's Hayy ibn Yaqzan, Ibn ʿArabi's al-Futuhat al-Makkiya, The Theology (attributed to Aristotle), and A Thousand and One Nights. However, these connections are never laid out explicitly and critically. In the introduction, we are told that in Chapter 10 the author will provide insight into a relation between these texts. In Chapter 10, the author engages in recounting the Tale of Buluqiya. References to the other texts are thrown in as the author tells the tale, but when we get to the end of Bashier's retelling of the story, the chapter ends abruptly. It is not clear what it all means and whether the chapter has fulfilled its purpose. In general, it would have been helpful to be told how the various discussions fit within the overall argument of the book. In other words, Bashier presupposes that he has provided the reader a roadmap of the book when in reality he has only scantily described it in the introduction and conclusion.
The book contains many references to “illuminationism,” a form of mystical Islamic philosophy rooted in Avicenna's work and developed by Ibn Tufayl and Ibn ʿArabi. However, the author overlooks the indispensible contributions of the philosopher Shihab al-Din Yahya Suhrawardi, a contemporary of Ibn ʿArabi. Suhrawardi wrote philosophical treatises and composed “stories” in the tradition of Avicenna's Hayy ibn Yaqzan. Along with Suhrawardi, the rest of the later Islamic tradition influence by Suhrawardi's illuminationism is ignored. I should also emphasize that the author misses out on the importance of Avicenna's The Treatise of the Bird, the third in the cycle of stories composed by Avicenna and the one that is relevant to his influence on Ibn Tufayl. The author also overlooks a considerable portion of the contemporary scholarship on the philosophical and mystical tradition (illuminationism) inaugurated by Avicenna and culminating in the work of Ibn Tufayl and Suhrawardi. For example, and here I just mention the most prominent, Henry Corbin is referred to scantily, and Seyyed Hosein Nasr's relevant work is completely bypassed. This is all the more startling, as Corbin and Nasr are also targets of Dimitri Gutas' attack on the tradition of Eastern/illuminationist philosophy tracing itself to Avicenna's later work. But Bashier only registers Gutas' attack as it bears on Ibn Tufayl.
This book brings to view the often-overlooked literary aspect of the tradition of Islamic philosophy and makes some contributions in coming to terms with it in a historical and multidisciplinary way. However, the presentation is not as clear and coherent as it could be, philosophical nuances are glossed over, and some of the central texts and scholarship relevant to the project are woefully neglected.
