Even before the World Wide Web popularized the Internet, optimists proclaimed its potential to provide denizens of mass societies with unprecedented power to access information and to communicate with one another, as well as with elected representatives and other public officials. Ordinary citizens could organize, educate themselves regarding matters of governance, and express their views—individually or collectively—to public policymakers. Ideally, low communication costs would empower even resource-poor groups to participate effectively in civic affairs. The possibilities seemed promising.
Others also recognized the Internet's democratic potential, but they expressed caution, skepticism, or outright pessimism regarding its potential. Their expectations ran from established institutions molding the Internet “to fit traditional politics” to creating “individuated information environments [that foster] group polarisation” to dystopias that included “political turmoil and civil unrest” (p. 9).
Supporters of various projected trends assembled examples that bolstered their predictions, but the Internet's changing technologies, expanding databases, and growing numbers of users constantly altered the parameters. In short, “assuming that the Internet possess[ed] any deterministic propensities” became a “teleological trap.” Nevertheless, “that does not mean that no relationship between the Internet and democracy can be advanced” (p. 9). Indeed, Stephen Coleman and Jay G. Blumler aim to propose an achievable plan for using the Internet to implement an electronic commons that will encourage civil deliberation among citizens, as well as between citizens and governmental decision makers.
The introduction and early chapters elaborate the authors' concepts of democratic citizenship and informed deliberation. They also explain how commercial media have produced a style of communication about public affairs that discourages effective representation and exacerbates citizens' distrust of government. Finally, they foreshadow how the Internet's communicative capacities could contribute to a benign democratic resolution of these problems.
The authors begin by examining a paradox. People around the globe increasingly express support for the concept of democracy, but they also express increasing dissatisfaction with their ability to engage or influence decision makers who determine and administer public policy. Decreasing rates of voter turnout suggest that democratic citizens are withdrawing from political participation.
The problem is not a failure to communicate. The problem is a deficit of genuine political deliberation. Commercial mass media foster distrust of government and discourage political participation by emphasizing conflict and scandal instead of the substance and consequences of political issues or public policies. Meanwhile, public officials profess their desire to represent citizens' interests, but they make only sporadic efforts to provide infrastructure necessary for meaningful exchanges between themselves and their constituents.
Coleman and Blumler argue that direct representation is a necessary corrective: “Direct representation entails an ongoing rather than episodic political conversation, inhabiting trusted spaces of everyday communication rather than … official zones of electoral manipulation” (p. 80). Direct representation can use the Internet to engender dialogues that impart information and foster mutuality between citizens and their representatives. Free-ranging dialogues, conducted civilly, should produce representatives who can truly speak for their constituents. This contrasts with direct democracy, which demands that citizens decide everything. Direct representation also avoids the artificiality of most models of deliberative democracy, where participants usually focus on one policy or a narrow range of issues. Best of all, the Internet's communication capabilities make direct representation technically feasible.
Technical feasibility, of course, is not the same as inevitability. Will citizens take on the commitment to participate? How well have projects that resemble direct representation fared in the real world? Were the results more like those predicted by the optimists or by the pessimists described at the beginning of this review? Coleman and Blumler devote two chapters to an evaluation of the outcomes of government and citizen-initiated projects (e-democracy from above and from below) in the United Kingdom and other nations. The final chapters use these findings to shape proposals for increasing Internet-enabled direct representation and to speculate on the likelihood that governments will adopt them.
The results were mixed regarding the proportions and representativeness of eligible citizens and public officials who participated, but in most cases majorities reported positive experiences. Participants generally viewed their involvement in citizen-initiated projects more favorably than did those who participated in projects that governmental officials initiated. Moreover, several citizen-based projects continued to operate well after their original tasks had been completed. Some even expanded their functions. The authors also cite several studies, including a nationwide survey they commissioned, in which majorities expressed their willingness or desire to become more involved in political decision making, particularly at local levels of government. Respondents to the authors' survey, however, expressed concern that public officials really were not interested in their input, and that “their participation would be inconsequential” (p. 186).
Although Coleman and Blumler caution that citizens' responses to survey questions cannot be taken at face value, they nonetheless find that the data support the idea that public policies can stimulate democratic participation. Policies will work, however, only if citizens perceive that their inputs are not restricted to a predetermined set of options and that political decision makers will acknowledge and respond to their recommendations even when they decide not to adopt them. The trick is to create a highly accessible “online civic commons [invulnerable] to the claims and tactics of vested interests seeking to buy out, shut up, drown out or override the voices of the public” (p. 170; see also pp. 9–10, 39, and 165).
How can this be done? The authors suggest that a publicly funded independent entity like the BBC be charged with creating and managing the space. The space would perform civic functions, such as informing people about pending laws and regulations and teaching them about civil discourse. It would also invite bloggers and interest groups of all stripes to link to or—better yet—congregate within the space. If national governments would not support such a public space, then peering arrangements might be made among independent public forums, underwritten by local governments or foundations.
Coleman and Blumler have produced a brave and provocative proposal for an online civic commons that could revitalize democratic citizenship. They recognize, however, that its adoption would require concerted efforts from public officeholders and grassroots activists, as well as greater commitments of time than have been customary of late. Knowing that “the short history of e-democracy is littered with failed projects … and thoughtful dialogues that led nowhere” (p. 195), leads to a modest conclusion: “If the civic commons is a feasible and sustainable project, it is because thus far no better way has been found to gather the public together, not as spectators, followers, or atomized egos, but as a demos capable of self-articulation” (p. 197).
Scholars and researchers concerned with political communication or democratic theory will find that this book addresses important theoretical and empirical questions. Its paperback price also makes it attractive as a textbook or supplement for graduate or advanced undergraduate courses in relevant disciplines.
Readers may find a few minor irritants. The authors frequently use long, passively voiced sentences to express complex ideas, and they present their statistical analyses inelegantly. Lastly, the text follows British spelling rules.
