Students of party politics have at their disposal a disproportionately large literature on the populist radical right (PRR), if compared with the actual electoral success. Cas Mudde aims to make a threefold contribution to this literature. First he provides a state-of-the art discussion of key aspects of the literature. Second, he critically assesses some of the most accepted truths about the populist radical right and gives his revisionist account of the various topics. Third, Mudde offers innovations to various aspects of the PRR by taking a pan-European approach.
One of the most significant contributions from this book is Mudde's focus on conceptualization and classification of the PRR. He develops a minimal definition of PRR parties, moving from the core concept of the nation to nativism. The term nativism is defined as an ideology that “holds that states should be inhabited exclusively by members of the native group and that nonnative elements are fundamentally threatening to the homogenous nation-state” (19). This reviewer agrees with Mudde that nativism is better suited than nationalism as it excludes liberal forms of nationalism and includes both racist and nonracist arguments, showing that exclusion of groups can be made on a cultural or religious background as well as ethnicity.
As Mudde points out, the concept of nativism is especially important from a pan-European perspective. While this is true, and Mudde is to be given credit for his attention to conceptualization, I miss a more in-depth discussion of the pan-European approach. While the author correctly points to the increasing closeness of European countries, mostly due to membership in the European Union, parties still operate in very different party systems and social contexts in Eastern and Western Europe, as Mudde acknowledges when he writes on different variations of the convergence thesis coming from the Kitschelt-Ignazi debate. Another example is Mudde's typology of enemies. He gives attention to three special enemy types: the Jews, the Rom, and the Muslim. There is a distinct difference between Western and Eastern Europe, especially concerning the first two groups, as the ethnically based racism against these groups is much more prominent in the Eastern parts of Europe. In my view, this highlights the need for a broader discussion on the decision to carry through a pan-European analysis.
Having said that, Mudde makes a great effort to come up with a maximal ideological definition of nativism, authoritarianism, and populism. He has done remarkable research on party ideologies and he should be credited for his choice to concentrate on what the parties themselves see as their ideological core.
From this definition, Mudde proceeds to the classification phase. As he acknowledges, a full agreement on party classification among scholars is nearly impossible to achieve. His exclusion of the Norwegian FRP and Swiss SVP is most problematic to me. My few criticisms aside, Mudde contributes greatly by giving attention to an area that has been mostly neglected in previous research, and he provides a thorough conceptualization and classification of the PRR.
The second part of the book takes a critical look at some of the established opinions about PRR parties. His typology of enemies displays the role of nativism, as both in-groups and out-groups can be defined as enemies of the nation. The typology of enemies is useful when having a pan-European perspective, although with the previously noted objections in mind.
Mudde also challenges previously accepted truths about PRR parties. Despite the fact that the number of women involved in these parties may seem extremely low when compared to the entire population, it is not very different when compared to other parties. In fact, the number of women with nativist attitudes is not much lower than the number of men. However, there is a gap between men and women when attitudes are translated into votes, a gap yet to be fully explained. Mudde suggests a different socialization of men and women leads to lower political efficacy among women, which leads to a more conservative—for established parties—voting pattern for women.
The author also confronts the perception that PRR parties are neoliberal in their economic policies, a thesis put forward most notably in the seminal work of Herbert Kitschelt and Anthony McGann. Mudde argues that PRR parties use their economic program to put into practice their key ideological position and to expand their electorate, dismissing Kitschelt's “winning formula” of “extreme and economically rightist, free-marketeering” (120). Mudde shows convincingly that nativist ideology is the central element in the economic policies of PRR parties of today. The Danish DFP has, for example, marketed itself as a welfare-friendly party carrying forward the legacy of social democracy. However, following the nativist perspective, this only applies for members of the nation. The author also says in addition to not being neoliberal, PRR parties only pay secondary attention to the economy.
In the third and final part, Mudde tries to explain the emergence of PRR parties. He argues that research has paid too much attention to demand-side studies. Most countries have what he describes as a fertile breeding ground and that this clearly cannot explain the differences in electoral support. Mudde thinks that supply-side factors are better suited to explain the presence of PRR parties. He divides these into two different sets: political opportunity structures, which are external to the party; and the populist radical right party itself. Here he adds a new component to the literature by arguing that the external factors are most effective for an electoral breakthrough, whereas the internal party factors are those that secure consolidation of support. Mudde validly distinguishes between external leaders, who are crucial in the breakthrough phase, and internal leaders, who are better at party building and consolidation. He shows how a combination of skills is the most successful strategy. The author joins the emerging consensus on the importance of party organization in this subfield and holds the argument that the party itself should be included as a major factor when explaining the success and failure of PRR parties.
Despite some critical comments on the pan-European approach, Populist Radical Right Parties in Europe is an impressive piece of work that fulfils the goal Mudde initially set forth for the book. The book is at its best in the initial chapters on conceptualization where the author gives a solid contribution to a somewhat neglected area of the research. Furthermore, the book gives a state-of-the art overview of the literature, a critical review of accepted issues, most notably the male dominance and neoliberal economic agenda, and a set of explanations based on supply-side factors with the PRR party itself as the main explanatory factor. Overall, the book is recommended both to academics and nonacademics with an interest in party politics.
