This book is a study of Jerusalem during the 1830s. It intends to clarify and analyze the social, political, and legal setting of Jerusalem during that period of Egyptian rule in Greater Syria (Bilad al-Sham). The local archives of the Islamic Court (Jerusalem's Sijjil) are the main source of this study. The book looks at the application of law by the Ottomans and by Muhammad Ali's regime as reflected in these archives. The focus of the study, therefore, is the relationship of the Muslim community of Jerusalem with the Ottomans and then with the Egyptian regime.
The book includes seven chapters and appendices. After the introduction, the second chapter attempts to illustrate Jerusalem's society and administration until 1831. Chapter three is devoted to the military invasion of Bilad al-Sham and the reaction. The remaining four chapters deal with the policies of Muhammad Ali's regime in Jerusalem and its hinterland. A special chapter (five) is rightly devoted to the events of the 1834 rebellion and its repercussions.
The importance of Muhammad Ali's rule over Bilad al-Sham has drawn many scholars to delve into studying khedival policies and systems of administration. The first and foremost among them is Asad Rustum, whose pioneering and monumental works include his unpublished PhD dissertation, Syria under Muhammad Ali (Chicago, 1923). Since that time, many others have treated this subject: suffice it to mention the Ph.D. dissertations of Y. Hofman (unpublished, 1963), Latifa Salim (published, Cairo, 1983, 1999), and William Polk (published, Cambridge, 1963). Others have published articles or chapters of books dealing with different aspects of Bilad al-Sham during the 1830s. Rood's detailed account is one of very few published studies in English that address the nature of Muhammad Ali's regime in Palestine.
Appropriate primary and secondary sources were used thoroughly in the preparation for writing this book. In addition to the sources consulted for producing her Ph.D. dissertation in 1993, the author read newly published works in English from the past decade. However, it seems that not enough effort has been made to benefit from similar publications in Arabic. It is adequate here to name a few of them for illustration. One example is the abovementioned book by Latifa Salim. Another is my book, History of Palestine during the late Ottoman Period, 1700–1918, published in Arabic in Beirut (1999). A third is the four-volume series by al-Tabba

, Ithaf al-A

izzah, published in Gaza (1999). These and other studies in Arabic could have provided relevant data and insights to the author no less than some of the English sources upon which the book relies.
The main thesis of this study is that Muhammad Ali introduced revolutionary changes in the system of administration and control during the 1830s. His regime brought, according to the author, a fundamental change in the traditional social and political systems that were long established under the Ottomans. There is almost no field in which the author does not find great transformations, including demography. Furthermore, the different aspects of change were neither temporary nor confined to Jerusalem and Palestine: “It is undeniable,” she states, “[that] Muhammad Ali introduced a new kind of military regime in the Arab world” (p. 197). According to the author's conclusions, the imposition of khedival control in Palestine irreversibly changed the nature of local politics in Jerusalem and Ottoman Bilad al-Sham. This and other overarching conclusions, however, are made without sufficient substantiation.
It is unfortunate to note that the book contains several factual errors, inaccurate uses of terminology and concepts, as well as speculative statements. The study focuses on the Muslim community in the city of Jerusalem, but sometimes it refers to the rural shaykhs of the Nawahi (subdistricts) of Jerusalem and Nablus. More than once, those shaykhs are mistakenly referred to in the book as umarā

(princes). No differentiation is made between the military elite (aghāwāt and bekāt) of the city and the rural shaykhs. Two of them, Abu-Ghush and al-

Amru (Hebron), are labeled mistakenly as Bedouins (pp. 61, 124). The Samhans who led the Qays faction north of Jerusalem are defined as allies of Abu-Ghush, the leaders of the Yemen faction (p. 124), when in fact they were rivals. In addition, when the rebellion of 1929 in the Nablus region is mentioned, the leaders, according to the author, were the Tuqans from their citadel of “Sanur” instead of the Jarrar family.
Speaking of citadels outside the walls of Jerusalem, the author labels the summer houses of notable families (qusūr) as citadels (p. 111). The Nahiya (subdistrict) of Hebron is mislabeled on more than one occasion as the Sanjak (district) of Hebron. The same mistake is repeated with other nahiyās or cities (p. 44). Lastly, whereas transliteration of Arabic names and terms is generally done well, it is not difficult to find mistakes in this area, too. For example, the chief architect (mi

marbashi) is erroneously transliterated as mi

marpasha, and on the same page (p. 58) the bailiff (muhdirbashi) is erroneously transliterated as muhdirbasha. These small but irritating inaccuracies mar what could otherwise have been a more solid volume.
The rebellion of 1834 is the most interesting and challenging single event about which the author could have contributed more to our present knowledge of the subject. However, the fifth chapter, which deals with this rebellion, does not add much to our knowledge of this historical event and its implications. To begin with, this chapter suffers from poor organization of the material and speculative statements. Moreover, mistakes and inaccurate use of information and terms are not infrequent throughout its pages. One has to wonder, for example, why the author titled the chapter “The Rebellion: Summer 1834,” when according to her own chronology it erupted in late April. More disturbing is the choice of sources on which this chapter relies. The author relies heavily on Western and secondary sources such as Abir, Gihon, and the Missionary Herald, while neglecting the documents of the Sijjil in Jerusalem and the Egyptian Royal Archives in Cairo. Closer consultation of the documents that Asad Rustum published in his four-volume series al-Mahfuzat al-malakiya (which is listed in the book's bibliography) would have helped greatly. Altogether, this is a timely book that addresses a very important theme. It could have filled a very important vacuum for English readers, but it suffers from unsystematic use of the existing original sources.
