By surveying and documenting outdoor cultural objects, the authors of this book seek to inform communities about the significance of their public art objects and to provide a starting point for people to value such artworks as expressing what is unique about their experience and understanding of Queensland, Australia (p. 7). However, this begs the question of public value. People in colonial times (nineteenth century) gave private subscriptions to have public monuments and memorials erected, and currently, Queensland has a Public Art Agency whose enabling legislation makes it mandatory for all public works projects to fund public art works associated with and integral to new construction, as part of the “Art Built-In” program. Queenslanders clearly like monuments!
Changing tastes about what constitutes a memorial is at the heart of this book. Queensland, named after the reigning Queen Victoria and established in 1859 as one of the British colonies of pre-federated Australia, had an Anglo-Irish population who sought to memorialize their British rulers in the nineteenth century and then to commemorate their fallen in the Great War for “King and country.” Tom Griffiths in his Hunters and Collectors (1996) has described the antiquarian imagination in Australia and the recognition of natural features in the landscape as our national monuments, but then “in search of classical soil,” pioneers and soldiers were memorialized. The huge loss of young men is reflected in the war memorials erected throughout Australian country towns and is especially poignant in the west of Queensland, in places like Winton, where over 75 per cent of the district did not return home “from foreign shores” after World War One (1914–19).
Monumental Queensland is a survey of a range of artworks: traditional statues, monuments, memorials, mosaics, murals, sculpture, fountains, stained glass windows, architectural friezes, contemporary public art–often sculpture and corporate art in building foyers—and the persistent category of eccentric objects—Big Things—much beloved by the Queensland public and tourist promoters. All these artworks are located outdoors and publicly accessible.
The surveyed works are arranged in chapters reflecting governance, frontier, pioneer life, war, work, commerce, leisure, government spaces and places. The authors assert that a major function of outdoor cultural objects (their term for public art) is the construction and articulation of identity (p.8), but identity in the cultural landscape comes from the interaction of people with their environment resulting in distinctive patterns of settlement. It also comes from language, art and song depicting such places. Roads, bridges, settlements placed and developed in relation to ridges and valleys, rivers and swamps are all outdoor cultural “objects” in the broader perspective of a cultural landscape.
Outdoor artworks might articulate a specific identity of a place such as the large statues of big bulls on all the approaches to the City of Rockhampton, the beef capital of the north, but they are transient markers of this symbolism as public values change, or the industry represented declines. Of more interest is applying a heritage management framework to these objects as their immediate social value passes into historic or aesthetic value and they are revalued for these new qualities! Should the bulls remain as monuments to bad taste and tourist promotion, and the hubris of the meat industry, and as an historic reminder that beef was the mainstay of the regional economy for a century after gold mining declined? Meanwhile the actual cultural landscape of droving routes and traveling stock reserves disappears along with their windmills and tanks and the stock saleyards and railway trucking yards. These layered components of the landscape give a much broader view of the impact of the beef industry on the landscape than a statue of a bull, balls and all.
Gibson and Besley attempt to overcome the high art/popular art paradigm by constant reference to cultural objects analyzed by themes, some with a historical basis, some with a place base. However, they continue to see the objects as art which ignores the social value of their construction as part of community identity either in the historical past or in current commemoration or promotion. Public monuments by their very nature are part of a designed landscape, for example, many war memorials were designed as part of a park or public space. The authors use landscape to mean context rather than the geographically determined area.
Heritage legislation with its essential first step of assessment of significance offers protection of significant cultural objects related to place. Many classic monuments are already listed on heritage registers and so offered protection, such as war memorials, explorers'cairns, and buildings like the Boonarga Memorial Hall. This latter “monument” commemorates the eradication of prickly pear (Opuntia stricta, a Caribbean plant introduced in the early 1800s as a hedge plant which overran northern New South Wales and central Queensland between 1900 and 1930) by the Cactoblastis moth. However, the authors assert (p. 165) that heritage legislation needs to be adjusted to protect post-war icons like the “Big Pineapple” and other quirky public art which give variation and peculiarity to Queensland identity. This is incorrect—such objects can be considered for their heritage values if someone wants to nominate them. Heritage, however, is widely perceived as old or nostalgic, rather than based on aesthetic, historical, social, scientific or spiritual values exhibited in the place or object in its setting.
This excellently illustrated and designed book certainly demonstrates how some Queensland communities have used outdoor cultural objects as signposts to their local stories and to define their identity. But it is in the nature of a descriptive catalogue of selected cultural objects rather than as part of a detailed analysis of cultural landscapes which exhibit a layering of historical events. In a State as large as Queensland (1.7 million square kilometers in area stretching from 9° S to 29°S, and having a coastline of 9,800 kms), there is much regional variation, although this is not illustrated by the public artworks chosen. Nor is the case made for public artworks to be protected as part of local and regional heritage—again this would have required a deeper understanding of the historical processes which shaped modern Queensland. Despite legislation to promote public art and to conserve cultural heritage, there is little public understanding of the layered history and its evidence as heritage in the cultural landscape.
