Heilbron's biography of Galileo is an erudite reconstruction of Galileo's scientific work, particularly well contextualized in the frame of the early modern cultural panorama. Written with enviable style, Heilbron has succeeded in addressing his work both to hyper-specialized Galileo scholars, all of whom are given the chance to discover new aspects and a wealth of novel details, and to generally interested readers, who have the opportunity to fully immerse themselves in the intellectual life of the Renaissance.
Chapter by chapter, the biography unfolds in a crescendo. The first chapter deals with Galileo's early education and indulges, but without exaggeration, in a reconstruction of his psychological profile which may, however, give rise to methodological disputes among sensitive historians. The second chapter covers the subjects of Galileo's scientific education, the first steps of his career as a mathematician, up to the beginning of his mechanics project (De motu) during the Pisan years after 1589. This is a very technical chapter which, however, contains remarkably original intermezzi in the Florentine cultural and literary context.
The third and fourth chapters focus on the eighteen years Galileo spent in Padua as a lecturer in mathematics. Although Heilbron does not neglect the relevant subjects pertaining chronologically to the first years of Galileo's stay in the Republic of Venice, such as his public and private lectures, or his activities as a designer and producer of mathematical and military instruments, the third chapter shows a certain lack of attention to the material conditions that allowed Galileo to take the first steps towards his own development of mechanics. Following a view that goes back to Antonio Favaro, the modern and peerless editor of Galileo's works and correspondence, the early Paduan years are considered to be more or less unrelated to the later published Discorsi. For example, Heilbron does not take into consideration the first manuscript of Galileo's Mechaniche, compiled, according to the critical edition of Romano Gatto (Le Mechaniche, 2002), in 1592–1593. This manuscript already contains the theorem of inclined planes, though without its demonstration. In general, the view according to which early modern theoretical developments in mechanics can be seen as being strictly related to the realizations, problems and challenges formulated in or emerging from the frame of practical activities – a research enquiry strongly cultivated during the last fifteen years in the history of science – does not seem to have relevantly influenced Heilbron's view on Galileo's scientific work on mechanics. This becomes particularly evident in the eighth and final chapter – ‘End games’ – where Heilbron discusses Galileo's Discorsi in an almost decontextualized way.
Chapters 5, 6 and 7 (‘Calculated risks’, ‘Miscalculated risks’ and ‘Vainglory’), on the contrary, present without doubt a genuine masterpiece of science history in its social, political, philosophical, theological and, above all, literary contexts. In these chapters the author retraces all the steps of Galileo's life and the consequences they had, from his first astronomical observations with the telescope in 1609; through the dispute on floating bodies in 1611–1612; the dispute on the nature of the comets, which produced Il Saggiatore in 1623; up to the moment when, as a consequence of the publication of Dialogo in 1632, Galileo, kneeling before the Inquisition, ‘rose without muttering eppur si muove’ (p. 317).
With extraordinary depth, Heilbron shows the results of extensive and profound research on primary sources which is able to offer the reader a comprehensive understanding of early modern logic, behaviour and mentality. Heilbron's impeccably neutral narration, interspersed with humorous moments, allows the reader the freedom to enjoy the scientific passion, the convictions, the misunderstandings and even (the understanding of) the injustices that constitute the prehistory and background of the most famous clash between science and religion. The book concludes with a rare post-history of Galileo's trial.
Although Heilbron's biography seems to underevaluate the context framed by the state of the art of early modern practical knowledge and the relation between such knowledge and the scientific theoretical developments, it discloses aspects and a variety of details that will positively surprise even the most knowledgeable historians of early modern science. In the preface Heilbron states that, unlike other biographers who ‘rush their gladiator [Galileo] prematurely into an imaginary arena filled with pig-headed philosophers and fire-spitting priests’, he begins with Galileo as a ‘patrician humanist’ and hopes ‘to have introduced something fresh by locating Galileo more firmly among Florentine cultural institutions than others have done’ (p. vii). By saying that he is focusing on Florence, Heilbron is being modest, as his fruitful research concerning the relations between Galileo and the cultural institutions goes from Venice to Sicily, always with comprehensive and original analyses and interpretations of the sources. By saying that he is focusing on cultural institutions, Heilbron is again being modest as this book is not simply a relevant biographical work on Galileo. It is a superb contribution to the understanding of the relation between science and literature and, in particular, of the position of literature in the power structures governing scientific practice during the Renaissance.
