With the publication of these editions, Bärenreiter has undoubtedly offered a wealth of new insights and interpretive possibilities to performers, particularly to those devoted to high textual standards and a nuanced, historical approach to Brahms's works for violin and piano, based on sources contemporary with the composer. All five of these volumes share one goal: allowing today's performers an approximation of the style and aesthetic practiced by the musicians in Brahms's circle. The entire set of scores is supported by a supplemental volume, Performance Practices in Johannes Brahms’ Chamber Music. Together these publications form a challenging and helpful resource.
As Brown emphasizes in Performance Practices, performers are now essentially disconnected from Brahms's performance tradition (p. 3). Already in the late nineteenth century musicians performing with Brahms and Joachim were challenged by the degree of freedom with which these giants of the Romantic period presumably played, and the extent to which they were able to ‘read between the lines’ of a composition in a manner unknowable to others, which according to reports in the 1880s already pointed to changing conventions (p. 3).Footnote 1 In fact, Brahms and Joachim's tempo modifications were too complex to mark into the score explicitly, which is why Brahms refrained from writing detailed tempo and rubato instructions into his scores (p. 3).Footnote 2
Although Brahms's performing conventions and those of members of his circle cannot be assumed to be identical – indeed, Brahms's own opinions are inaccessible for many issues – trying to reconstruct the practices of his extended circle is a valuable step toward better understanding pertinent performance conventions. According to Brown, before this approach to interpretation passed into extinction in the 1920s, traces of it can be heard in recordings of Joachim's students and members of his circle, such as Will Rehberg, Robert Hausmann, Marie Soldat, Hugo Becker, and Karl Klingler (p. 4). A prime example of what Brown gleans from his sources involves the ways in which tempo flexibility of various sorts functioned in this now-lost performance tradition. These included rubato per se, whereby the ‘stolen time’ was in fact returned in another place (by accelerating); tempo fluctuation in places marked as such (meno mosso, più moto, tranquillo, or animato); tempo modifications in places today not necessarily tied to tempo changes, among them ‘grazioso, espressivo, teneramente, or con anima; and lastly, tempo modifications today normally associated with dynamics’, such as opening and closing hairpins and messa di voce (p. 5).
Performance Practices includes sections on performance issues relevant to each of the three instruments in a piano trio. Brown, a violinist, covers violin practices including ‘nuancing the sound’ (vibrato), ‘expressive fingering’ (portamento) and ‘bowing’ (pp. 8–13). Brown's main thesis is that the Franco-Belgian school essentially overshadowed the German school of performance practice after the 1920s – when Joachim's students and members of Joachim's circle no longer exerted a strong influence on playing aesthetics. In effect, a ‘change in the aesthetic of tone production’ took place. Brown dives into several performance practice aspects, many of which he lays out in a manner easily translatable into practical instructions. Among other topics, Brown disposes of the myth that vibrato in Brahms's circle was a ‘vibrato or non-vibrato’ affair (p. 8). Rather, left-hand vibrations in various degrees of subtlety – more subtle than what we mean by ‘vibrato’ today – were but one manner of nuancing the sound, while the bow ‘played a much greater part in the creation of a subtle and varied tonal palette’ (p. 8). At the same time, the more conspicuous and continuity-emphasizing vibrato approach of violinists associated with the Franco-Belgian school, such as Eugène Ysaÿe, – which clashed with the vibrato applied in Brahms's circle – was certainly not congruent with today's vibrato standards (p. 11).
Some of the most striking revelations in Brown's discussion of vibrato arise in his analysis of early-twentieth century recordings by Joachim, which he discusses in reference to an overlooked report by a violin student of Joachim around 1900, Marion Ranken. Joachim's loose wrist, both left and right, Ranken noted, which was capable of producing vibrato effects ‘out of dead stillness’ of a non-vibrated tone, were sometimes most effectively combined with sforzando effects (p. 10).Footnote 3 Soft dolce passages, furthermore, were rarely the site for audible vibrato but instead hardly perceptible finger movements, which merely intensified the tone (p. 10).Footnote 4 Ranken's account, significantly, offers new insights on how Joachim used vibrato effects.
Da Costa's contribution to the Performance Practices volume addresses the piano; it includes sections on ‘melodic emphasis, texture and agogics’, ‘the evidence of recordings: Brahms’ contemporaries’, ‘the evidence in written sources’, ‘pedalling’, ‘Brahms’ damper pedal markings’, ‘damper pedal use by pianists in Brahms’ circle’ and ‘una corda pedal’ (pp. 15–26). Da Costa offers an in-depth discussion of general pianistic nineteenth-century performance practice issues and also proposes some specific examples concerning the piano parts of Brahms's chamber music, including the violin sonatas and Piano Quartet op. 25. Drawing, in part, on his monograph Off the Record: Performing Practices in Romantic Piano Playing (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), Da Costa discusses types of pianos and the styles of performers and composers contemporary with Brahms.
Wadsworth's contribution, ‘Brahms and the Cello’, reminds us of the importance of the cello for Brahms (p. 27). With the two cello sonatas and a number of chamber music works from trio to sextet (and of course the Double Concerto), Brahms notably contributed to the cello repertoire, even if, due to several circumstances, his relationship with the instrument is far less publicly known than his dealings with the violin. Wadsworth offers a refreshing discussion of Brahms's encounters with Julius Klengel and other contemporary cellists and musicians, which reveals at least part of the answer to the question why Brahms did not correspond as heavily with players about the cello as the violin: he was, in his younger days, himself a cellist, able enough to play one of the cello concertos by Bernhard Romberg, a composer of technique-oriented repertoire (p. 27).Footnote 5
Both Brown and Wadsworth give us a detailed idea about the styles of Brahms's preferred interpreters. We learn that Joachim, Hausmann, Becker – and Clara Schumann for the piano – had an understanding of Brahms's music and an approach to their respective instruments that was conceived by contemporaries in quasi-spiritual terms. Rather than getting sidetracked by increasingly powerful ‘sensual’ sound ideals, these players were able to bring out ‘the music itself’, as it were (p. 32).Footnote 6
Although details of exactly how music was performed and heard in its cultural context remain elusive, this volume helps the interested performer to imagine some of the particulars of chamber music performance in Brahms's sphere. Brown ends his epilogue with Richard Barth (1850–1908), whose playing Brahms valorized, and whose accounts about his experience with Brahms show that the early twentieth century was characterized by a ‘widening gulf between Brahms’ expectations and the rapidly changing realities of early twentieth-century practice’ (p. 33). Barth writes: ‘He wanted to know that all markings were scrupulously followed. If one knows Brahms's nature, one has to admit that probably no composer marked things as precisely as he, and that, for those who understand how to read it, everything that leads to the right conception and infallibly protects from all arbitrary mawkishness is in fact indicated’ (p. 34).Footnote 7 For Barth, a contemporary, understanding Brahms evidently already required a special sensitivity. The ideas and information to be found in this volume, if carefully applied, can certainly help decrease the gap that separates us from ‘understanding’ Brahms on these terms.
Sonata Movement in C minor from the F. A. E. Sonata WoO 2
The F. A. E. Sonata is a joint composition by Robert Schumann, Albert Dietrich, and Brahms, who composed the Scherzo, completed in 1853, but only published in 1906. The manuscript of the F. A. E. Sonata is titled: ‘FAE in Erwartung der Ankunft des Verehrten und Geliebten Freundes Joseph Joachim schrieben diese Sonate – R.S., J.B., A.D’ (‘FAE this sonata was written in anticipation of the arrival of the revered and beloved friend Joseph Joachim – R.S., J.B., A.D’). The sonata was first performed on 28 October 1853 intimacy of Schumann's house in Düsseldorf, for an exquisite audience – Gisela von Arnim, Bettina von Arnim, Robert Schumann, Johannes Brahms and Albert Dietrich. The story goes that Gisela von Arnim, dressed up as a flower girl, presented Joachim with the score, who then had to play the piece and guess the composer of each movement, a task at which he succeeded on his first attempt.Footnote 8
The new edition of the Scherzo includes a preface, performance practice commentary, score and critical commentary. The performance practice commentary, which follows broadly the argument laid out in the Performance Practices volume, is intended to clarify Brahms's performance conventions for modern performers. Articulation is addressed bar-by-bar. For example, notes with staccato dots, such as in bars 14–16, could be played in different ways. Brown explains that Joachim may have approached them like the opening – with a stroke ‘below the middle of the bow’ executed ‘with a well-articulated bowstroke’ (p. V). But there is one more possibility. Joachim may have used a stroke of a type often used by Ferdinand David (who, as Brown mentions, was Joachim's teacher), which would be executed by using ‘a short and sharp up-bow staccato starting close to the point of the bow’ (p. VI).
***
Completed in 1879 (op. 78), 1886 (op. 100) and 1888 (op. 108), the three violin sonatas emerged from Brahms's most productive period, which saw the genesis of the Violin Concerto op. 77 (composed in 1878 and premiered 1879), Piano Concerto No. 2 op. 83 (1881), Symphonies Nos. 3 and 4, and the Double Concerto op. 102 (1887). On a personal level the years from 1880 onward were characterized by a rift with Joachim over the latter's divorce from Amalie Joachim, which perhaps explains the moderate participation of Joachim in the performance history of the sonatas. Only in 1888, when Brahms composed the Double Concerto and dedicated it to his friend as a gesture of reconciliation, did the two musicians re-establish correspondence and personal contact, though the earlier intensity of their relationship was never fully restored.
The present editions of the sonatas (opp. 78, 100, and 108) provide what the digitally available editions (notably those available on www.imslp.org) used today by many young musicians do not offer: a performance practice and critical commentary, and a detailed introduction and preface with information on origins, processes of composition, pre-publication performances, publication, and early reception. In addition, they provide comparative discussion of instructions by a number of members from Brahms's circle and points for reflection concerning articulation, dynamics, portamento, tempo and rubato, fingerings, bowings, arpeggiation (piano), dislocation and use of pedal (piano), all based on historical evidence, and laid out in bar-by-bar detail for the entire sonata. The performance practice comments, in short, are valuable and at the same time highly user-friendly.
Sonata in G-major, Op. 78
The Sonata op. 78 is the only of the three sonatas for which the autograph (A) is extant. Thus, Brown took the first edition as ‘copy text’ and clarified ‘some details by reference to A’ (p. 34). For example, the autograph was consulted for clarification with regard to placement of opening and closing hairpins (first movement bar 144), the beginning or ending of slurs (first movement bar 211), the character instruction (second movement, bar 97), accent placement (third movement, bars 104–105), and even discrepancies involving a whole bar (third movement, bars 157–158), among other entries, which are addressed in the critical report (pp. 34–36).
Of all three sonatas, the G major offers the greatest number of contemporary sources relating to performance style. Several annotated editions prepared by members of Brahms's extended circle are compared in the performance practice commentary. Notably, five of these editions include metronome numbers; Brown adds another set of metronome numbers that were published in the Musical Herald by an anonymous editor (pp. IX–X).Footnote 9 As in the other two sonatas, Brown finds both similarities and discrepancies in tempo between these early editors, with little discrepancy occurring in the first (except for Schultze-Biesantz/Kähler) and second movements (except for Schultze-Biesantz/Kähler and The Musical Herald), and more in the third movement of the sonata (p. XI). Particularly fascinating is the tempo range in the first movement, from the average of minim = 54 (early annotated editions) to a much slower tempo used in the last 70 years, which resembles Schultze-Biesantz/Kähler, ‘whose approach diverges significantly from that of the editors with a known connection to the Brahms circle’. The tempo of the last movement, Brown argues, ‘has been problematic from an early stage’, as the tempos, which range from crotchet = 69 to crotchet = 104, offered in the annotated editions suggest. The lower tempo range ‘seems likeliest to reflect the composer's expectation’, according to Brown's detailed and well-supported argument. As in the Sonata op. 108, Brown finds the Peters edition (Carl Flesch and Arthur Schnabel) particularly useful as it contains many more metronome markings (for the piano part) than the other annotated editions (p. IX).
Brown continues the performance practice commentary by providing brief discussions about various performance aspects. With regard to the use of the piano's damper pedal, Brown explicates Brahms's markings in cases where they diverge from today's use. Rhythm and timing, furthermore, followed widely differing conventions and aesthetics (pp. XI–XII). With regard to slurring Brown makes the important point that Brahms's slurs are often unusually long, indicating ‘phrasing slurs’; dynamics, articulation, fingering and vibrato are again treated systematically, before Brown merges, as in the other two sonatas, into a detailed bar-by-bar performance practice manual (p. XII).
Finally, Brown considers some rare and highly informative critical reviews and violin treatises: A review in The Musical Times of Isolde Menges and Harold Samuel's performance of the sonata in 1933 (particularly enlightening for the Adagio); an excerpt from Moser and Joachim's treatise Violinschule (1905), and August Wilhelmj and James Brown's A Modern School for the Violin (1901); Ignaz Moscheles’s Studies for the Piano Forte op. 70 (1897); Philip Anthony Corri's L'anima di musica (1810); Louis Spohr's Violinschule (1833); Joseph Szigeti's A Violinist's Notebook (1965); and Auer's Violin Playing as I Teach It (1921) (p. XIX).
Sonata in A-major, Op. 100
With the Sonata in A major we confront a similar, if not slightly more advantageous, source situation. Part of the autograph of the first movement (up to bar 268) is extant, while the engraver's copy and proofs are lost (p. 31). As a consequence, Brown consulted the first edition while clarifying details in the first movement by referencing the autograph. The autograph raises a central issue concerning all three sonatas: the discrepancy of articulation and dynamic markings between the autograph and early editions. While the autograph is ‘rarely ambiguous’, Brown explains that Brahms did not meticulously ponder the correctness of markings in the first edition, assuming that the experienced musician would interpret the signs in the score correctly: ‘[Brahms] seems to have been relatively unconcerned about the exact placing of such markings in copies and especially in printed editions’, which caused difficulty for the movements for which the autograph was lost. The placement of crescendo and decrescendo signs (i.e., ‘hairpins’), dots, and the end of slurs caused particular difficulty due to disparities in early editions.
Brahms deliberately placed staccato dots inside the slur for portato and ‘outside the slur’ for staccato, but printed editions placed them often inside the slur. Brahms often notated the end of slurs ‘casually’ or not at all if, for example, the slurs were already marked earlier at a similar passage (p. 31). When no slur was marked, Brahms assumed, as Brown notes, what earlier pianists in the early 1800s had established: that legato was the ‘default’. Thus Brown added some slurs and articulation markings in the op. 100 sonata, where ‘they occur in parallel passages or where their absence, for instance in one stave of the piano part, appears incongruous’ (p. 31).
The performance practice commentary, which draws on annotated early editions by Leopold Auer/Rudolph Ganz (1917), Kneisel/Bauer (1918), Schnirlin/Kahn (1926), Flesch/Schnabel (1926) and Schultze-Biesantz/Kähler (1929), systematically covers aspects relating to 1) Rhythm and timing, 2) Dynamics and accentuation, 3) Dots and strokes, 4) Slurring and non legato, 5) Pedalling and overholding, 6) Arpeggiation and dislocation, 7) String instrument fingering, and 8) String instrument harmonics and vibrato (pp. IX–XI). The discussion concludes with a useful reference tool of a bar-by-bar performance practice commentary (pp. XI–XX).
Sonata in D minor, Op. 108
The source situation for the D minor Sonata is complex. The autograph and various early copies are now lost (p. 34). Thus, in this case the editor consulted only the first edition, the separate violin part of the first edition, and Brahms's personal copy of the first edition (today at A-Wgm), which includes the composer's amendments for the first movement. Despite the missing autograph and early copies – or perhaps even inspired by this lacuna – Brown has created an exceptionally rich edition with a performance practice commentary that is novel in its reference to hitherto little-used sources, most notably several annotated editions from the 1910s and 1920s: Leopold Auer and Rudolph Ganz (1917); Franz Kneisel and Harold Bauer (1918); Ossip Schnirlin and Robert Kahn (1926); Carl Flesch and Arthur Schnabel (1926); and Clemens Schultze-Biesantz and Leo Kähler (1929), all of whom, Brown points out, had some ties with Brahms's circle (p. VII). Brown explains that although Carl Flesch's fingerings are more modern than those one would have encountered during Brahms's time (as can be seen in Flesch's avoidance of open strings, which in turn, suggest continuity of vibrato), Flesch still employed several parameters that trace his approach to Brahms's tradition, namely his use of portamento according to the ‘“old” portamento tradition’ (p. VII). The comparison of these annotated editions supports several observations: although these texts differ from one another, they are more similar to each other in their conceptions of performance practice, than they are to our modern approach; and where they diverge from one another, the reader of Brown's edition may be inspired to decide whether to follow Carl Flesch's lead, or Leopold Auer's, or another musician's. Brown also refers to, and provides details about, a rediscovered copy from which Fanny Davies played the piece at a private occasion in London 1889, together with Joachim. Her fingerings as well as other markings – albeit brief and subjective, such as ‘not too much’ and ‘nicht eilen’ (do not rush) or ‘violent’ – represent a treasure for the performer due to their applicability.
Brown begins his discussion of performance issues with tempo and metronome markings. The annotated editions take rather different approaches to tempo. ‘Metronome markings of the first movement range from half-note = 72–84, with Schnirlin/Kahn indicating almost all this range (up to 80) as a possibility. Schultze-Biesantz/Kähler choose the slowest, and Flesch/Schnabel the fastest tempo, with Kneisel/Bauer in the middle (76). Even the slowest of these suggest a basic tempo significantly faster than most recordings’, which are ‘between 58–66’, Brown notes. The other movements, likewise, show divergences among the early editors. Brown finds the Flesch/Schnabel edition – which contains more metronome markings than other editions – especially representative. And although Brown claims that ‘there is no evidence to suggest that these tempos have any direct connection with Brahms’ practice’, they do mirror tempo and rubato approaches of performers around Brahms (p. VIII).
Brown adds a few particular comments on tempo, referring to ‘rhythm and timing’, ‘dynamics and accentuation’, ‘dots and strokes’, ‘slurring and non-legato’, ‘pedaling and overholding’, ‘arpeggiation and dislocation’, ‘string instrument fingering’, and ‘string instrument harmonics and vibrato’. Each of these topics is worthy of discussion, but here only two them can be reviewed: ‘string instrument fingering’ and ‘string instrument harmonics and vibrato’ (pp. VIII–XI).
In his discussion of fingering, Brown observes that while portamento has fallen out of fashion almost completely today, it is indicated in the annotated editions via fingering markings. Brown alerts the reader: ‘all shifts within slurs (except those utilizing an open string) were expected to be heard to some degree, both upwards and downwards’. One type of shifting was presumably not as respected in Austro-German (and thus Brahmsian) circles; shifting downward ‘and sliding with the finger about to stop the target note’ was looked down upon as ‘French’ portamento (pp. VIII–XI).
Brown notes that the use of harmonics – played by touching the string lightly at an exact point, which will make a higher pitch sound, rather than the fundamental frequency of the string – points to the ‘absence of continuous vibrato on the surrounding notes’. Surprisingly for today's performers, who often judge the sound of harmonics to be glassy, airy, straight, and moderately soft, performers of Brahms's circle were of a different mind, using harmonics even in loud passages and in melodies ‘mixed … with stopped notes’. Confirming the limited application of vibrato evident from the use of harmonics, Brown observes that – although no direct evidence survives ‘about Brahms’ attitude to vibrato’ – the performers he most admired ‘used it with considerable restraint’ (pp. VIII–XI).
Lastly, it should be mentioned that Brown's performance practice commentary on the Sonata in D minor not only includes evidence from the early editions annotated by performers, but also period criticism that pertains to performance of the sonata. For example, with regard to bar 24 of the first movement Brown lets Donald Francis Tovey, a close friend of Joseph Joachim, share his impression on performing this sonata with Joachim, thus offering a glimpse of how the piece was played when Brahms was still alive: ‘From Joachim I learned that at the first forte [bar 24] Brahms made a decided animato which he might as well have marked in the score; this of course implies that the tempo of the outset must be broad, though, of course, flowing’ (p. XII).Footnote 10 Brown explicates: ‘Tovey's words correspond with the description of the opening of the movement given by [Eduard] Hanslick in his review of Joachim's and Brahms’ performance on 13 February 1889: “The first allegro begins with a quiet expansive violin melody, in that apparently decisive, contemplative mood that tends to characterize the majority of Brahms’ opening movements. But soon we hear half-suppressed sobs from the violin and a violent assault from the piano; passion has broken through the deceptive calm and commands the field”’ (p. XII).Footnote 11 Brown concludes that the ‘sobs’ of the violin relate to the ‘figure in bars 3–4 and 7–8, and perhaps also those marked [by an opening-closing hairpin] in 11–12 and 17–18’ (pp. XII–XIII).
In sum, all five of these publications offer abundant material for reflection. Where possible, Brown draws sensible conclusions, derived from extensive research in numerous primary sources, but where necessary, he presents conflicting evidence so that the final choices and interpretive decisions remain with the performer who is thus more than well equipped to make informed decisions.
One brief comment on the durability and material quality of the editions of opp. 108, op. 100, and op. 78 seems warranted. The enormously informative apparatus – containing 44, 32 and 48 pages, respectively – is so generous that the stapled binding does not hold up. Perhaps a better solution can be found for forthcoming printings.
