The Korean War: A History explores historical memories of the Korean War from the perspectives of the United States, North Korea, and South Korea. As the first full-length study to provide a multidimensional examination of how people in these three nation-states have remembered this pivotal mid- twentieth-century conflict, the book marks a notable contribution to the historiography of the Korean War. Author Bruce Cumings, a foremost expert on the war, brings to the table over three decades of critically minded scholarship on the historical origins and consequences of this oft-underappreciated—and still-un-resolved—war. In doing so, he compellingly argues that an earnest, reflexive reexamination by the American public of what he calls the “forgotten” and “never-known” war is long overdue (p. xv).
Deftly shuttling back and forth across the eight decades that have spanned the start of the Asia-Pacific War (1931–45) to the present, Cumings interweaves his analysis of Korean War history and memory from the perspective of the three countries into nine chapters of varied length. Building upon earlier research for his seminal two-volume study The Origins of the Korean War (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1981; 1990), as well as more recent work on the ideological climate of early cold war America, the author elucidates in pointed fashion the pervasive ignorance of Korean political and social realities among key American actors. He also vividly illustrates their reliance on orientalist perceptions and paranoiac fears of communist expansionism in scripting poorly informed policies and strategies that not only brought devastating consequences upon most Koreans but also resulted in America's first military defeat of the post-1945 era. Failing to understand the complicated factors behind the war, most Americans have instead relied on a simplistic cold war framework to misrecognize it as nothing other than a valiant US response to presumed Soviet imperialism in Northeast Asia.
This fundamental point, which Cumings has argued persuasively in earlier studies, is bolstered in his most recent book by an illuminating examination of the ways in which McCarthy-era censorship shielded the American public from the numerous war atrocities perpetrated by U.S. and South Korean forces, including the indiscriminate massacre of unarmed civilians and scores of napalm drops in well-populated areas. Widespread knowledge of these and other repugnant postwar American military tactics in Asia, as well as public outcry against them, would have to wait until the Vietnam War, due in part to the heavy constraints placed on the American media beginning in 1951 and lasting through the end of the Korean War. In a similar vein, Cumings also treats the complicity of establishment social scientists, such as Karl Wittfogel, in the production of distorted representations of North Korea that were so common in cold war America—and that remain influential to this day.
Working against these deeply carved patterns of memory and amnesia, the author methodically recounts the atrocities inflicted by U.N. forces on North Koreans in an effort to render the country's enigmatic leadership of the present more historically understandable. Cumings also probes back further into the past to emphasize that most of North Korea's first leaders cut their nationalist teeth in the anti-colonial guerilla struggles in Manchuria in the 1930s. This pre-liberation experience sheds considerable light on the Northern leadership's antipathy for its collaborationist counterpart in the South, and its motivation to unify the Korean nation by invading the South in 1950. At several key junctures, he emphatically reminds the reader that the US military forcefully intervened in a Korean civil war that did not entail territorial encroachment by a foreign power. The US then invaded deep into North Korean territory in its own act of aggression following the recapture of occupied southern territory in the latter months of 1950. The standard American cold war lens, he argues, has long misrepresented these interlinked actions.
With respect to South Korean memories, the author offers a positive appraisal of post-1987 progressive efforts to uncover the suppressed truths of the war for the sake of domestic South Korean and inter-Korea reconciliation. Foremost among Cumings' examples is the government-established Truth and Reconciliation Commission. In pointing up such South Korean efforts, he urges the American public to engage in a similar effort in order to produce the “restorative truths” needed to bring proper closure to the countless perilous memories that remain from the Korean War and, by extension, the Asia-Pacific War (p. 203; for more on this topic, see T. Fujitani, Geoffrey M. White, and Lisa Yoneyama, eds., Perilous Memories: The Asia-Pacific War(s) [Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2001]).
The author gives due credit to these recent South Korean endeavors to come to terms with the past. However, some mention of the limiting factors in recent efforts at reconciliation—not least the retrogressive policies of the current Lee Myung Bak administration—would have provided a more complete picture of the country's contemporary memoryscape. By extension, this reviewer would also like to have seen the author incorporate a bit more coverage of official North Korean and South Korean memories of the Korean War into his narrative, for, as he has argued elsewhere, the ways in which the war is remembered has been foundational for both nation-states.
In terms of official memories, those of the U.S.—rather than the Koreas—are clearly the book's primary object of scrutiny. Cumings' cogent analysis of the U.S. perspective enriches our understanding of US actions in both the past and the present. In the book's penultimate chapter, he directly implicates the Korean War, and U.S. misperceptions surrounding it, in the emergence of the “permanent national security state” in the 1950s (p. 207). In doing so, he identifies the Korean War as a key factor in the major post-1945 shift in U.S. foreign policy to interventionism, of which the Iraq War is the most recent product.
Although Cumings organizes his incisive, multilayered exploration effectively, it is possible that at certain points readers may lose track of his larger argument, as well as the constructively critical spirit that animates it. For this reason, additional signposts may have been helpful in guiding the reader through the author's intricate argumentation as it relates to the complexities of Korean War memory. Notwithstanding this minor quibble, the author on the whole presents a pertinent and powerful case for a thorough rethinking of the war in America. I recently assigned this book for an undergraduate course on post-1945 Korean history. Among my students was a senior auditor who served in the U.S. military from 1954 to 1956. Having been shaped by a very different set of assumptions about the war, he remarked that the book had been the source of some “sleepless nights,” but that he appreciated the “new insights” that it had provided. While the author probably did not intend to deprive his readers of precious sleep, the auditor's comments do suggest that his latest work should produce the desired effect among some audiences. This book is sure to be informative and thought-provoking for general readers, as well as undergraduate and graduate students, with an interest in history and memory in modern Korea and East Asia.
