Jeremy Seekings and Nicoli Nattrass present an immense amount of quantitative and qualitative information regarding inequality in South Africa during the apartheid and post-apartheid periods. Their descriptive findings involve assertions that both support and challenge existing knowledge. For example, they conclude that during the apartheid era, there was significant redistribution of income by the state to poorer sections of the population; that apartheid “converted the state-imposed advantages of race into the market-rewarded advantages of class” (p. 379); the “deracialization” of class began not with the assumption of power by the African National Congress in 1994 but rather in the early 1970s; the end of apartheid has not led to a reduction but to an increase of inequality; the “distributive regime” that produces inequality did not really change after majority rule was achieved in 1994; there are now as many rich black South Africans as there are white South Africans; and that the most significant contributor to inequality is the high level of unemployment.
The authors attribute inequalities to what they call the “distributional regime,” basically the state policies that directly and indirectly impact the distribution of wealth, including labor market, economic growth, education, and welfare policies. In other words, the explanation for the persistence of inequality—and its consequences—is government's failure to devise policies that would properly address the “problem.” To most political scientists, such an explanation is insufficient. It does not push back the “Why?” question far enough. The question “Why do public policies fail to foster a reduction in inequality?” would necessitate an examination of politics. But the authors are reluctant to do such an analysis. They do not address the question of “why or how the South African state adopted some policies rather than others” (p. 48). They also acknowledge that they “say little about the politics of inequality” (p. 48). In a sense, the book cries out to political scientists for an explanation of the state's policies.
Seekings and Nattrass's work is organized like a collection of articles, each of which might be read independently of the other, with an introduction and a conclusion added. Virtually every chapter in their book is concerned with inequality, though most have an associated focus, such as social change, distributional regimes, unemployment, income inequality, social stratification, and the underclass. They are arranged in chronological order starting with the “Eve of Apartheid” and ending with “After Apartheid,” though the emphasis is on the associated focus more than the chronology. The result is that each chapter is not organized in a fashion that parallels the other, limiting explicit comparison. Nevertheless, the introduction and conclusion provide summaries of the insights developed in each of the chapters.
Some of the central findings—for example, that the end of apartheid did not bring about the end of class divisions or inequality—have been asserted previously by several authors writing from a Marxist perspective, such as Martin Murray (The Revolution Deferred, 1994) and Neville Alexander (An Ordinary Country, 2002). The most significant addition of Seekings and Nattrass is a variety of quantitative data and an assessment that focuses on the implications of inequalities. In other words, they provide an empirical base to support and extend several of the contentions of radical political economists.
The authors are aware of Marxist scholarship, yet there is some ambiguity in their perspective on such works. On the one hand, in places they debunk much of it. They say that Marxists focus too much on theory (p. 27); that Marxists have an “antipathy” toward quantitative research” (p. 27); that Marxists ignored the impact of education and welfare policies (p. 32); that Marxists “neglected to analyse more fully the ways in which the state shaped the overall growth path of the economy” (p. 32); and that Marxist scholars abandoned class analysis once they “moved into good positions in the post-apartheid state” (p. 29). On the other hand, they claim to build upon it. Indeed, in Chapter 7 (pp. 236–70), the authors delve into the Marxist conception of class as articulated by Eric Olin Wright (Class Counts: Comparative Studies in Class Analysis, 1997). In that chapter, they differentiate between Marxist relational and non-Marxist gradational notions of class. They show that inequalities do not correspond precisely with class defined in terms of the jobs held. Nevertheless, elsewhere it is difficult to distinguish between class and groups that they define in terms of inequalities. Whether this ambiguity reflects differences in the points of view of the authors, or whether it reflects uncertainty common to both, cannot be determined by this reviewer.
The authors frequently emphasize the tentativeness of their data and of the claims based upon the data. They use phrases like “the analysis remains preliminary” (p. 237); the “following analysis must be considered as exploratory” (p. 241); the analysis “is bedeviled by a lack of good data” (p. 43); and, surveys in South Africa “provide few data that allow us to demonstrate the consequentiality of class” (p. 44). Two conclusions might be drawn from such comments. First, the authors are meticulous in seeking data to support their findings. Second, the empirical basis for their findings is, in fact, tenuous.
Seekings and Nattrass view the persistence of unemployment as a deepening of inequalities—and as a problem that needs to be overcome. The solution they suggest is a social accord among the state, business, and labor that seeks to expand employment. While such a consociational arrangement might achieve the end they desire, a realistic portrayal of how this might be achieved is missing.
Although I have been critical of aspects of Class, Race and Inequality in South Africa, the book deserves applause as well. The authors bring to the reader an immense amount of detailed empirical data on issues related to inequality of importance to both political scientists and the peoples of South Africa.
