While the British Association for the Advancement of Science (BAAS) has long formed a subject of research for historians of science, Louise Miskell does a useful service by putting it in the context not of the reforms of the Royal Society or the foundation of disciplinary societies, but of other similar peripatetic associations and of the urban locations that hosted them. It is worth remembering that, for the civic leaders that welcomed them, hosting the BAAS was not so different from hosting any one of a number of institutions or, indeed, a member of the royal family. This book, then, considers the BAAS alongside the Royal Archaeological Institute (RAI, founded 1843), the Royal Agricultural Society of England (RASE, founded 1838) and the National Association for the Promotion of Social Science (NAPSS, founded 1856), with reference to the wide literature of Victorian urban history. While these associations aimed to bring both knowledge to the provinces and knowledge of the provinces to their fields, the annual meetings also gave town leaders the opportunity to put their cultural and civic assets on a national stage so as ‘to gain maximum kudos and visibility’ (p. 10).
Meeting Places focuses on the period from the foundation of the BAAS in 1831, through the heyday of all four associations in the 1850s–1870s, to 1884, by which time they were disbanded or undergoing significant change. As Miskell shows, each had different requirements of a host location and a differing sense of their audiences. While membership was open to whoever could afford the time and ticket, the NAPSS and, to a lesser degree, the BAAS made attempts to reach working-class audiences, with free evening events. The RASE was, of course, interested in reaching farmers and landowners – although its Agricultural Shows were by some way the most popular of all the events considered here, attracting tens of thousands of visitors, rather than hundreds or thousands of members – while the RAI appeared to be the least concerned with attracting numerous audiences. These choices and their missions determined the towns and cities which they visited. The BAAS achieved a degree of variety, in terms of geographical location and type, while the RAI focused on historic county towns in the south, the RASE on towns with good social and economic connections with their rural surroundings, and the NAPSS on the rapidly growing industrial centres that presented social problems of the kind that formed the core subject of their meetings.
However, as this study demonstrates, more was required, including plausible local organizers, sufficient civic and gentry support, a range of opportunities for excursions, and adequate accommodation for parallel sessions of papers, public lectures and ambitious soirées. Being chosen to host an association could, therefore, be seen as confirmation of having achieved a certain status and, as this became clear, local rivalries led to competitive bidding. Focusing on interactions between the associations, the hosts, attendees and the press, separate chapters explore the bidding process, the work that went into preparing for and running the meetings (negotiated with the central associations, but largely the result of local time, money and initiative), the experience of attending a meeting and, finally, the legacy left behind once an association had moved on. The close link with wider forms of civic display and competition is amply explored, with association visits correlating with, for example, the building of town halls, opening of museums, forming of societies, improvement of sanitation, creation of public spaces and provision of education. The sense that hosting meetings was part and parcel of such developments was well expressed by a journalist who saw the opening of Birmingham's new library in 1865 during a BAAS meeting as ‘not connected with the visit, yet associated with it’ (p. 145).
Much of the material drawn on in this book comes from local and national newspapers, which were as significant as the railways to the success of the model of the ‘parliament of science’. Archives of the associations and local bodies reveal the processes of selecting locations and hosting a meeting. Missing, perhaps, is a consideration of the ephemera created locally in order to administer the meeting and to show off the town, including tickets; programmes; maps; information about accommodation; lists of exhibits on display; and, crucially, guides that highlighted local commerce, industry, historic sites and natural features. While one such guide is referenced, many more were produced, including, from 1874 onward, the formalized annual BAAS Handbooks. All the images included in the book are from national illustrated papers and, as well as being little interrogated by the author, seem a missed opportunity not to explore the visual and textual records of the local experience.
Miskell notes in her Acknowledgements that the book began life in 2005, around the time that London was announced as host of the 2012 Olympics. It is a shame that this seems to have come too early for Miskell to have profited from the most recent studies of the BAAS. For example, although Charles W.J. Withers's Geography and Science in Britain, 1831–1939 (2010) is referenced once, its contribution to the historiography of the BAAS and geographies of knowledge is not discussed. Withers's chapter on the ‘Geographies of civic science’ contains much similar material and it would have been useful to see a response to the analysis presented there, including greater consideration of the political and religious geographies of reception. In this and elsewhere, there is, perhaps, too great a tendency to see the national associations and the local hosts as distinct groups – the ‘scientists’ and the townsmen – when there were, of course, overlaps, divisions and disagreements. Nevertheless, as this book, as other recent studies, shows, ‘To examine the parliaments of science … is to engage with issues central to understanding Victorian society’ (p. 4).
