In the course of less than 200 years, the indigenous peoples of a vast tract of the Andes, from south Colombia to central Chile and including much of modern Ecuador, Peru and Bolivia and north-west Argentina, were invaded and colonised twice, first by the Inkas of the south-central Andes who incorporated them into Tawantinsuyu, and then by the Spaniards. Many scholars have looked at one or other of these colonisation processes and the impact of the invader/coloniser upon local communities, but rarely both. In this book Steven Wernke has attempted to examine both and compare their impacts within a single study area.
His enquiry is focused on the Colca valley in southern Peru and, in particular, the area around Coporaque and Yanque in its upper reaches. His time frame spans the 500 years from the twelfth century to the seventeenth, embracing the Late Intermediate Period (LIP), the Inka occupation and the impact of early colonial processes of encomienda, evangelisation by Franciscan friars and the policy of reducción. However, given the wealth of archaeological and documentary evidence from the region, at each stage of his analysis he has been able to make community-level comparisons with districts lower down the valley, such as Lari and Cabanaconde. The main data utilised for each are concerned with settlement type and location, settlement patterns, land use, field location and community organisation and affiliation. Hence he is able to make very specific interpretations of the initial LIP cultural landscape and demonstrate the respective changes in settlement and land use under the two colonising powers. His approach has been enlivened by a careful use of geographic information systems (GIS) and a judicious use of appropriate statistical tests to enable understanding of significant land abandonment and even retrodict the cultural affiliations of which social group farmed what fields in prehistoric times, and from what settlement.
On the basis of settlement survey data, Wernke has located a hierarchical pattern of LIP towns, villages and hamlets generally situated in defensible positions or near to hill forts (pukara), with the urban centres more or less evenly distributed throughout the fields. The arrival of the Inkas saw changes in this pattern, with the establishment of new urban settlements in open positions and the abandonment of many of the previously occupied locations, indicating an imposition of Inka rule and a calming of LIP social tensions and warfare. Wernke notes that, unlike other provinces, there was no Inka capital and no imposition of imperial-style architecture, although the buildings in the new urban centres adopted lesser versions of classic Inka architecture. He suggests that this supports the view that the Inkas practised indirect rule through the local lords (kuraka). In terms of building types, this is confirmed by the insertion of a characteristic pattern of kallanka (what he calls a great hall) and plaza into these new settlements. However, the large site of Kallimarka displays the Inka ‘concept of cusco’ with a spatial association of kallanka, plaza and usnu platform (see Ian Farrington, Cusco: Urbanism and Archaeology in the Inka World (University Press of Florida, 2013)), which Wernke suggests was still under construction and may well have been designed to be the provincial capital. He implies that the change in settlement pattern was accompanied by improved agricultural facilities and intensification.
Wernke reconstructed social and political organisation using the information contained in late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century visitas. The Aymara-speaking Collaguas prevailed in Yanquecollaguas and Laricollaguas, while the Quechua-speakers occupied Cabanas. His reconstruction suggests that during the LIP they had been divided into moieties (upper and lower; left and right) with constituent ayllu. The Inka colonisation, he argues, saw a gradual imposition of both tripartite social organisation and the use of decimal units, which can be traced in the documents, including the establishment of specific craft-based ayllu.
Like much of the Andes, Wernke rightly notes that for the first decades after the Spanish invasion, Spaniards and Spanish government officials hardly reached the provinces and, apart from the imposition of encomienda, also through indirect imposition through the kuraka, there were no great changes in settlement pattern or society. This was in spite of the goals of the conquest: political and economic domination for the good of the Spanish crown, and the conversion of the native populations to Catholicism.
Wernke's field surveys demonstrated that the first Spaniards to arrive were Franciscan friars who, in the mid-1540s, set about the process of conversion by creating doctrinas and building chapels in six Inka centres. One of these, Malata, was chosen for detailed study and excavation. This results in one of the best chapters in the book, in which Wernke describes the differences in location and function of the Inka plaza and great hall on the southern side of the village, and the chapel with its yard and adjacent plaza and cross on the northern. His detailed plan enables him to compare and contrast the different paths to each centre, the nature of oversight of the settlement, and the movement of people from both the house of the kuraka and that of the priest. His field observations and GIS analyses provide a most interesting account of the social dynamics of conversion, which were clearly sponsored by the kuraka himself.
The Toledan reforms brought about further changes to the indigenous peoples; the foundation of reducción urban centres altered the settlement patterns of these three areas as members of various ayllu were brought together. These grid-planned, imposed settlements with plaza, church, cabildo and caja de comunidad were built on Inka sites, such as Yanque, while Corporaque was constructed on a new site. Comparing contemporary toponyms with the field names in the documents, Wernke has been able to state that the lands of individual ayllu were scattered to optimise harvest but were in conjunction with those of people from other ayllu. Thus the social landscape of Colca throughout this history was not a series of contiguous lands belonging to and inhabited and farmed by a single ayllu, but a palimpsest of ayllu members scattered over the terrain. The implications of this were negotiated by the kuraka throughout. Therefore, for some ayllu, the reducción brought little disruption to their farmland, while for many others their new settlement was at some distance from their traditional lands. Wernke's analysis of this, and of the subsequent abandonment of farmland, is neatly articulated.
Although this book is generally well produced, there are some issues which detract from its undoubted intellectual qualities and reflect poor editing. For example, there are several typographical errors (including the occasional omission of the square sign in a discussion of area), unusual or incorrect use of words such as ‘primogenitor’, extra words in sentences that render their meaning obscure and should have been deleted, and cited references that do not appear in the bibliography. The book is well illustrated, but many vital maps which appear to have been originally produced in colour have become difficult to read and interpret in the grey-scale published reproductions.
Nevertheless, this book is excellent in that it opens fresh perspectives into these fundamental episodes in Andean history. For everyone interested in Andean history and late-period archaeology, it should be compulsory reading.
