Eric Rauchway is a leading historian on the history of the New Deal. His latest book is not so much an intervention in the historiography as an attempt to reach out to a broader audience and impact the public debate. In a nutshell, Rauchway argues that the New Deal matters, primarily for two reasons: one, because it helped Americans to believe in a common purpose and created so much of America's infrastructure that it built an ideational legacy that still shapes the country; and two, because the principles guiding the various programs and agencies at the time should inspire policies today.
To show this, Rauchway takes his readers on a trip around the country. The first of the book's five thematic chapters sets off from Arlington National Cemetery in 1932–1933, when the Great Depression reached its climax. In this context, Rauchway revisits the conflict around the so-called Bonus Army: an impoverished group of tens of thousands of World War I veterans demonstrating in Washington, DC, to demand help from the federal government. In July 1932, President Herbert Hoover sent the police and the army to crush the movement, leaving dead two veterans who are now buried at Arlington. Hoover's successor, Franklin D. Roosevelt, in contrast, offered the protesters work relief and thus “gave Americans proof that democracy could still work” (p. 11). Proceeding in a similar fashion, chapter 2 opens with the Norris Dam in Tennessee, built in 1936 as part of one of the New Deal's most iconic projects, the Tennessee Valley Authority. Also again, Rauchway underscores the value of public work, “prefiguring the benefits and challenges of planning for clean and sustainable energy” (p. 41). From there, the trip continues to Window Rock, Arizona, and the Navajo Nation, then on to the African American neighborhood Hunters Point on San Francisco Bay, and finally to an undefined “street where you live,” to underline the New Deal's lasting impact across the country and as a call for New Dealish policies in our own times (p. 133).
While the book's main purpose is to intervene in today's political debate, this review focuses on its merits and shortcomings as a piece of research. The chosen approach is interesting and allows Rauchway to zoom in on a number of specific moments and places to make his case. Parts of the book build on archival research, and the whole text demonstrates Rauchway's impressive knowledge of the New Deal. Having said this, some of his interpretations raise doubts. The book claims that Roosevelt had a coherent, far-ranging plan for changing the country's trajectory. This view is controversial; Rauchway himself has argued that the “Roosevelt agenda grew by experiment” (The Great Depression and the New Deal [2008], p. 56). Moreover, the first chapters of this new book in particular make the New Deal appear much less controversial and more successful than most scholars would argue. Admittedly, chapters 3 and 4 are more nuanced; for instance, chapter 4 outlines the many discriminatory practices affecting African Americans during the New Deal. Still, there is often an upbeat tone almost reminiscent of Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. But even if one leaves this matter of interpretation aside, the book has weaknesses. The chosen focus on the New Deal's relevance to Americans’ daily lives is sometimes abandoned in favor of a history of political leaders and their institutions (e.g., chapter 5). For business historians, this book contains comparably little that is new about the New Deal. Rauchway mentions business resistance against FDR's policies here and there, but without providing much detail. The book makes next to no reference to those parts of business that actively supported and profited from the New Deal. Here too, Rauchway fails to provide a nuanced analysis fully informed by the state of the art.
Overall, this book is driven more by a political than a scholarly agenda. As such, it reflects the history wars in today's America, in which the New Deal has (once again) become a heated subject of controversy. While I agree with the author that FDR and the New Deal also hold important lessons for today, some chapters would have profited from a more balanced and fine-grained analysis—also as a step beyond the polarized political climate in the United States of our own times.
