This essay addresses the question of how the idea of liberalism and antireligious sentiment became associated during the Gilded Age. The subject of this essay—the New York Liberal Club, a debate and lecture group in New York City (1869–1877)—sheds light on the process in which liberalism, as an idea, outgrew its religious origins in early nineteenth-century America and more than ever became linked with antireligious sentiment. In the case of the New York Liberal Club, this development owed to the club's connection to social science and members' participation in the contentious debate over science and religion during the 1870s. In addition, it partly owed to club members' conception of liberalism as tolerance, open-mindedness, and a commitment to the free exchange of ideas. Because of this conception of liberalism, many club members saw liberalism and social science as a common cause, since both reflected a dedication to improving the world through free inquiry. Ultimately, these conceptions, as well as discourse at the club, led many observers in the public to incorrectly view all Liberal Club members (and liberalism itself) as in opposition to faith and religious belief.
In contemporary America, the association of liberalism with godlessness is ubiquitous. Ann Coulter's 2006 Godless: The Church of Liberalism is just one of the more well-known and controversial publications that echoes a century-old charge that liberalism is anathema to faith and God.Footnote 2 But as scholars of American religion and liberalism know well, liberalism and religion are inseparably linked in our history. And as we have learned from a rich historiography on liberal thought, there are and have been many liberals of faith.Footnote 3
Recently, this connection between liberalism and faith was explored further by Amy Kittelstrom in her 2015 The Religion of Democracy. In her book, Kittelstrom begins by wondering how the word “godless” became attached to the word “liberal.” Kittelstrom explores the religious roots of liberalism and argues that religion remained an important influence upon liberal thought into the twentieth century and that a “democratic approach to religion” and a commitment to individual moral agency forged liberal thought in America.Footnote 4 In Kittlestrom's view, early nineteenth-century liberal Protestantism served as the foundation for modern American liberalism. In the end, though, we discover little about the roots of the association of liberalism with godlessness.Footnote 5 Kittelstrom's opening comment simply teases us with the question of the larger process that has led to the widespread belief that liberalism equates with godlessness.
This study seeks to address the question of how liberalism and godlessness became associated. The subject of this study—the New York Liberal Club, a debate and lecture group in New York City (1869–1877)—sheds light on the process in which liberalism, as an idea, outgrew its religious origins in early nineteenth-century America and became linked with antireligious sentiment. In the case of the New York Liberal Club, this development owed to the club's connection to social science and members' participation in the contentious debate over science and religion during the 1870s.Footnote 6 In addition, it stemmed partly from club members' conception of liberalism as tolerance, open-mindedness, and a commitment to the free exchange of ideas. Because of this conception of liberalism, many club members saw liberalism and social science as a common cause, since both reflected a dedication to improving the world through free inquiry.
Dedication to free inquiry, though, was especially problematic in the debate over religion and science because it challenged club members and others to reflect upon the relationship of religion to a liberal worldview. The question at the heart of this challenge was this: could a person be truly liberal and open-minded while holding religious faith? By the end of the 1870s, club members were divided on this question and fell into two distinct groups. One group held to a vision of liberalism as a commitment to open-mindedness and religious tolerance, while another group conceived of liberalism as a commitment to free inquiry and believed that Christianity held back the human intellect and contradicted the liberal spirit of freedom of thought.Footnote 7 This split, which had been present among liberals for some time, was now explicit.
This essay builds on the work of historians of American social science and liberalism. Foundational to this essay is the work of Dorothy Ross, who has shown that liberalism and social science were intertwined and provided reciprocal influences upon each other during the last decades of the nineteenth century.Footnote 8 Like Dorothy Ross, I define liberalism as a philosophical tradition or “mode of thought” with intellectual roots spanning back to Ancient Greece and Rome. However, unlike Ross, I emphasize the religious roots of liberal thought in the American context. American liberalism, in my view, developed out of a broad set of values associated with a much older European liberalism. It was defined, however, in the context of a debate over religious tolerance in the last decades of the eighteenth century and the first decades of the nineteenth century.Footnote 9 For Ross, the new social science served as “the first major statement” of the “new liberalism.”Footnote 10 In her view, the social scientists' “liberal response” to the problems of post-Civil War America was largely influenced by a “crisis of intellectual authority” owing to the rise of modern science as well as the social and political turmoil associated with industrialization during the period.Footnote 11
This essay also looks to the work of Nancy Cohen, who recently demonstrated how a generation of liberal thinkers during the 1870s and 1880s, many of whom were professional social scientists, helped shape liberalism into the modern progressive political ideology we know today.Footnote 12 For Cohen, Gilded Age liberals were preoccupied with “problems and questions about society, economy, and state” that arose after the Civil War. Both Ross and Cohen, however, frame liberalism as a secular movement in which liberals were little concerned with religious reform and the developing debate over the relationship of religion and science.
I amend these interpretations by restoring religion's place within liberalism and by examining the liberalism of the Liberal Club as a submovement with its genesis in New England liberal Christianity during the first decades of the nineteenth century. During those decades, American Unitarians like William Ellery Channing argued for a conception of “liberality” that was tolerant of a relatively wide range of Christian beliefs. For Channing, “the word liberality expresse[d] the noblest qualities of the human mind, freedom from local prejudices and narrow feelings,” and the enlargement of “views and affections.” Channing saw a broad conception of Christianity as the “distinguishing feature” of liberality. He asserted that “the greater the variety of sentiments with which a system will harmonize” and “the fewer its fundamentals” the more worth it was to the liberal mind. Over the ensuing decades, this liberality and the idea of “liberalism,” took on their own career in the American mind as a contested concept. By the late 1850s, for a substantial group of radical religionists and freethinkers, the idea of liberalism was increasingly associated with a tolerance toward a wide range of heterodox religious ideas. For many liberals, this tolerance became embedded, “underneath the skin,” of the liberal understanding of the world. By the 1860s, liberal religious toleration rooted in Channing's concept of “liberality,” and combined with the discursive approach of the lyceum and self-culture movement, undergirded a liberal intellectual culture that was increasingly autonomous from institutionalized religion. The New York Liberal Club exemplified this autonomy.Footnote 13 I believe, as Leigh Eric Schmidt has written, that “liberalism cohered first in the 1820s as a radical form of Protestant Christianity that then over the next few decades readily edged beyond Christianity itself.”Footnote 14
I hope that this study will continue Kittelstrom's work of rediscovering religion in post-Civil War liberalism. I answer Kittelstrom's query by showing that liberalism, to an extent, became associated with godlessness because its ethos of free debate and free inquiry leveled the ground between competing ideas and belief systems. As a result, it caused tension among a diverse group of liberals (and others) who held differing religious views and ideas about the compatibility of liberalism, science, social science, and religion.Footnote 15
There has been no substantial or dedicated work on the Liberal Club. This owes partially to the fact that the club's papers were held in a private collection until the mid-1990s, when the New York State Library acquired them. These papers are mainly composed of a record book detailing meetings and club business from 1874 to 1877. Other papers include membership rosters, financials, circulars, poems, notes, and reports of club officers. Another factor contributing to the silence about the club in scholarship is that unlike Louis Menand's Metaphysical Club that was populated by the leading names in American philosophy, members of the Liberal Club were mostly middling thinkers and scholars who participated in the group as an adjunct to their professional and social activities.Footnote 16 Because of these factors, key studies of New York's intellectual history, such as Thomas Bender's New York Intellect and David Quigley's Second Founding, do not mention the group.
While Bender did not include the Liberal Club in his work, his study is especially relevant to understanding it. Bender's typology of intellectual cultures that existed in New York City during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries helps us understand the context that the club existed within. The club existed both temporally and physically in between Bender's civic and literary cultures, which he notes “coexisted with each other and interacted with each other.”Footnote 17 It included members of both cultures, and might even defy Bender's typology and divide between a civic culture in which individuals from many professional backgrounds engaged in intellectual life, and a literary culture that was much more circumscribed and dominated by men and women completely committed to intellectual life. It existed at that key moment when, as Bender points out, professionalization of the knowledge industry was remaking intellectual life as the new academics “looked toward new, disciplinary organizations” and worked through the new university model.Footnote 18
The Liberal Club, though, has been better covered in several studies on Gilded Age American freethought or irreligion, a literature that has been relatively limited over the last couple of decades.Footnote 19 The best and earliest account of the club appeared in Samuel Putnam's encyclopedic 400 Years of Freethought.Footnote 20 More recently, Roderick Bradford's 1999 biography of D. M. Bennett, the founder of the freethought journal Truth Seeker, included a few references to the Liberal Club.Footnote 21 Perhaps the most attention, though still minimal, the club has received in recent years is in Gillis J. Harp's 1995 Positivist Republic, in which Harp tracks the influence of August Comte's positivism on Gilded Age American liberalism.Footnote 22 Harp's study is important since members of the faction most hostile to traditional religion were influenced by positivism. Both Harp's study and my essay provide historical grounding for the polemical claim that liberalism is particularly hostile to religious faith.
Despite its absence in the historiography, the Liberal Club tells us a few things about American freethought and its relationship to religion. First, it confirms James Turner's argument in Without God, Without Creed that “in trying to adapt their religious beliefs” to new problems, the religious faithful created unbelief.Footnote 23 The question that eventually split the Liberal Club—about the compatibility of liberalism and religious faith—was indeed one made possible by the faithful's reconciliation of their belief with science and social science. Second, it helps us expand our understanding of freethought and its relationship to liberalism. Whereas chroniclers of freethought like Susan Jacoby have seen freethought as a “phenomenon running the gamut from the truly antireligious” to “those who adhered to a private, unconventional faith revering some form of God or Providence but at odds with orthodox religious authority,” I believe we should view freethought as a permeable and fluid idea that at times includes the more conventionally religious, too.Footnote 24 As this study of the Liberal Club demonstrates, the gap in physical and intellectual space between “liberals” and “freethinkers” and between the conventionally religious and the irreligious was often limited or nonexistent. All existed in the same space and at the same time.
THE LIBERAL CLUB
The New York Liberal Club was founded in September of 1869 on the one hundredth anniversary of the birth of Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt (1769–1859). That year, Americans from New York City to San Francisco celebrated Humboldt's life. Humboldt set the standard for scientists like Charles Darwin and influenced many others, including Ralph Waldo Emerson and John Muir.Footnote 25 Thinkers from Asa Gray to Edward Everett hailed his achievements. Louis Agassiz proclaimed that Humboldt “completely changed the basis of physical science.”Footnote 26 Darwin referred to Humboldt as “the greatest scientific traveler who ever lived” and “one of the greatest men the world has ever produced.”Footnote 27 Several years later, in a letter to the Liberal Club, Darwin admitted that Humboldt's travels prompted him to volunteer as a naturalist on the H.M.S. Beagle.Footnote 28 Amid the 1869 celebration of Humboldt's life, a handful of New Yorkers formally organized the New York Liberal Club and dedicated it to Humboldt's work. The club joined dozens of other social clubs that included tens of thousands of members that met in New York in the decade following the Civil War, a period when New York's intellectual culture was in flux as increased professionalization and specialization had begun to undermine a deeply imbedded civic intellectual culture that had flourished for decades.Footnote 29
The founders of the Liberal Club were a diverse group, including European and American scientists and thinkers. One contemporary source characterized Liberal Club membership as “consisting mostly of scientists and amateurs in science.”Footnote 30 Another hailed the club as “the ‘Broad Church’ of Philosophy and Science” in “which extremes meet, and conscious of their diversities, are studiously tolerant.”Footnote 31 The muckraking journal Woodhull & Claflin's Weekly touted it as “the people's Scientific Institute.”Footnote 32
One of the most notable founders who represented an enthusiasm for scientific inquiry as a way of uplifting society was philosopher and lawyer Thaddeus Burr Wakeman. For Wakeman, science was “truth,” as he declared in 1883 that “Theology is the past tense; Science is king.”Footnote 33 During the 1860s, Wakeman was a lawyer and an influential member of New York City's Comtean positivist intellectual community. Comtean positivists followed in the footsteps of French philosopher and pioneer of modern science, Auguste Comte, the first advocate of scientific positivism.Footnote 34 New York's Comtean positivists, as Gillis Harp has pointed out, were those thinkers who to some degree accepted Auguste Comte's political and religious ideas. Some of Comte's followers, such as Wakeman, adhered to Comte's “Religion of Humanity,” based on Roman Catholicism, in which science served as a substitute for divine revelation. More than a dozen Comteans joined the Liberal Club.Footnote 35
But the club was not merely populated by Comtean positivists. Religious belief and unbelief in the club varied greatly, reflecting the pluralism of a city that hosted conventional Christian churches, liberal congregations like those led by Henry Ward Beecher and Henry Whitney Bellows, and radical congregations like Octavius Brooks Frothingham's Independent Liberal Church. Club members included mainstream Christians, liberal Christians, spiritualists, agnostics, atheists, and those whose religious beliefs fell everywhere in between.Footnote 36 The club counted among its members a number of clergy. One of the club's most active clergymen was Baptist Reverend George W. Samson, who had been the president of Columbian College in Washington, DC, from 1859 to 1871. In the early 1870s, Samson removed to New York City, took up a pastorate, and served as president of Rutgers Female College.Footnote 37 He also joined the club, a decision that reflected his commitment to the pursuit of science and social scientific inquiry.
For club members, while scientific inquiry contributed to self-culture and the improvement of the individual intellect, it also enabled members to help uplift society and create a better world. Liberal Club members repeatedly voiced their commitment to the “steady growth of knowledge,” and pledged their devotion to the club as a place where “men of liberal ideas” could “meet and exchange their thoughts in an unbiased manner.”Footnote 38 The club, then, was part of a larger project aimed at creating a more intellectually tolerant and enlightened society.
Participation in the Liberal Club, too, served as an adjunct to members' business, professional, and civic endeavors. In this, the Liberal Club was an example of what Thomas Bender has referred to as “civic culture”—a pre-professional intellectual culture that contributed to the broader city and represented the unity between public life and intellectual life. At the same time, the club represented an enthusiasm for social scientific inquiry and reform—which were not yet separated as they would become with the professionalization of the social sciences by the 1890s.Footnote 39
Member Stephen Pearl Andrews was a great example of amateur social scientists in the club who saw inquiry and reform as unified. A close confidant of the suffragist Victoria Woodhull, he was a major contributor to Woodhull's Woodhull and Claflin's Weekly. Andrews helped break the 1872 Tilton-Beecher scandal that exposed Henry Ward Beecher's adultery. Like Woodhull, Andrews was a supporter of free love and a proponent of spiritualism. With individualist anarchist Josiah Warren, Andrews helped found the free love and individualist commune Modern Times on Long Island in the early 1850s. Andrews was also well-known for devising a “new scientific universal language,” which he called “Alwato.”Footnote 40 Alwato reflected Andrews's obsession with universal systems.Footnote 41 During the early 1860s, from his brownstone on 14th street, Andrews worked to create a system of world government called “Pantarchy.”Footnote 42 As a “new spiritual Government for the world,” Pantarchy would govern all aspects of human existence through the scientific and philosophical study of human social relations. But Andrews's Pantarchy was not the sociology of contemporaries like Spencer, William Graham Sumner, or Lester Ward. Pantarchy would be administered by a “Pantarch,” a philosopher and sage, who would benevolently distribute knowledge to all mankind.Footnote 43
After hearing Andrews speak on Pantarchy at the club in December 1869, one observer quipped that the club was a place for promoting “jaw-breaking words and impracticable theories” and “a system of government perfectly maddening” to most members of the human race.Footnote 44 Another visitor noted that Andrews's “preposterous claims [were] freely ventilated” at the Liberal Club. This, joked the visitor, “establishes the right of the club to the prefix ‘Liberal,’ beyond the possibility of successful contradiction.”Footnote 45 Despite the criticism, Andrews saw the club as an ideal place to disseminate his ideas. In Andrews's view, liberalism “fostered” tolerant spaces where intellectual innovation like the development of sociology was possible.Footnote 46 Here, Andrews saw liberalism and social science as natural allies. The Liberal Club, then, like the contemporary American Social Science Association, was an outlet for amateur scientists and social scientists—the “best men” and women—to inquire and exchange ideas on how to improve society and then to implement those ideas.
Professionally, membership of the club varied greatly.Footnote 47 The club included a number of clergymen like Samson, lawyers like Wakeman, merchants, clerks, cashiers, and salesmen. Members were also medical doctors, editors, journalists, teachers, professors, philosophers like Andrews, and professional writers.Footnote 48 Rosters from the 1870s list a slew of affluent people. Among the most well-to-do was former president of the Erie Railroad, Charles Moran, who joined soon after its establishment.Footnote 49 Membership of the club, then, represented the amateur and nonprofessional character of the social sciences during the 1860s and 1870s, and the club served as an outpost of enthusiasm for social science in New York City. As with organizations like the American Social Science Association, while nonprofessionals represented the majority of club members, professionals and educators took a natural role as authorities of their respective fields within the club.Footnote 50
Despite their diversity, for aspiring members of the middle class or those who had already made it financially, all members were part of a particular social class that could afford the luxury of intellectual pursuit and had the interest to do so. Intertwined with this intellectual persuasion was a unique sense of identity in which members believed their position was critical to the progress of society.Footnote 51 Members' pretensions and their sense of self-importance was not lost on observers, as one 1869 New York Times article reported the club's goal was to “afford ‘men of advanced ideas' an opportunity to enlighten the darker portions of the world.” Other reports were not as flattering. One observer noted that guests at a particular club meeting were “regaled with the usual amount of discussion, dogmatism and drivel and in the usual large proportions.”Footnote 52 Such criticisms were common, especially in the early days of the club. In the eyes of members, diversity of thought was an asset rather than a liability in their effort to promote social scientific inquiry. The official mission of the club was to allow “all sides to be heard.” “Every member” was “at liberty to keenly criticise the views of others, provided he concede[d] to them the same freedom as to his own.”Footnote 53 Members were to do so in a polite and “unbiased manner.”Footnote 54
In order to facilitate free debate, the group embraced a hybrid structure of the lyceum model and more exclusive debate societies, and should more accurately be described as a “colloquium”—a seminar and discussion, led by a speaker on a broad field of study.Footnote 55 Liberal Club meetings “generally consist[ed] of a lecture of an hour's duration, or less, by some member of the club or invited guest, followed by a debate by members in speeches of ten minutes or less, until 10:15; when the speaker of the evening again takes the platform and is allotted fifteen minutes to reply to critics. The club adjourn[ed] at 10:30 PM.”Footnote 56 Until the spring of 1876, weekly meetings were held on Friday evenings in Plimpton Hall at 30 Stuyvesant Place, right on the line between the East Village and Greenwich Village. This was an area alive with intellectual and artistic activity. Just a block to the south, on 2nd Avenue, the Palette Club, made up of German-speaking artists, held its weekly meetings.Footnote 57 On the other side of Broadway was Greenwich Village and New York University.
During the 1870s, meetings were often attended by between several dozen and several hundred people that included both members and guests. Sometimes meetings attracted up to one thousand people.Footnote 58 Membership ranged from several hundred during the peak of the club in the mid-1870s to less than one hundred in 1877. While most members were men, women were welcome to seek membership and female guests and speakers were relatively common. The diversity of membership was also reflected in lecture topics. Topics of weekly meetings between 1874 and 1877 were dominated by religion, science, sociology, art, and to a lesser extent politics and economics. In its ideal form, the club's liberal ethic and commitment to free inquiry was the foundation for an atmosphere of intellectual tolerance, exchange, and debate.Footnote 59
LIBERALISM TESTED
The club's liberal ideal was first tested in the wake of the September 1869 celebrations honoring Humboldt around the country. From the summer of 1869 into the winter of 1869–1870, Americans celebrated Humboldt's achievements. Infidels, believers, and those of all points in between sought to claim Humboldt as their own. The trouble, though, was that Humboldt's tour-de-force, Cosmos, “a work describing God's creation,” was in fact “cryptic about the creator.”Footnote 60 While this ambiguity enabled individuals with diverse worldviews to gather around Humboldt's legacy, it also led to intense debate over Humboldt's religious views. At the centennial celebration of the birth of Humboldt before the Boston Society of Natural History, Harvard professor Louis Agassiz claimed Humboldt as a true believer.Footnote 61 Agassiz's speech enraged some members of the German-American radical community who were certain of Humboldt's infidelity.
The same week that Agassiz gave his speech, at a meeting of German radicals to memorialize Humboldt in Boston, freethinker and scholar Adolph Douai asserted that Humboldt was indeed an atheist. Douai himself was an outspoken member of Boston's German radical community but also spent time in New York contributing to the German Freethinker's Society, the League of Freethinkers, and other similar freethought organizations.Footnote 62 In the controversy surrounding Humboldt, Douai charged that Agassiz had no right to claim that Humboldt was a believer. Hearing of Douai's charges, Agassiz responded by attacking Douai in the Boston press. Not to be outdone, Douai continued his assault on Agassiz.Footnote 63 In December of 1869, the debate spilled into the halls of the newly formed Liberal Club, when Douai (who was soon elected a member of the club) gave a lecture on “Glacial Formations of the Earth's Surface.” Douai ended his talk by ridiculing Agassiz's “absurd” argument that God was behind multiple changes in the Earth's geological formations.Footnote 64 Douai's paper was well-received and was followed by a brief discussion.
The year 1870 saw a continuation of the debates of late 1869 and further demonstrated the challenges members faced in maintaining their liberal space for debate and inquiry. Through February, members debated the compatibility of Darwinian evolution and divine creation.Footnote 65 This debate continued for the life of the club, featured a multitude of positions, and sometimes went beyond the bounds of polite discourse with members continually referring to the “absurdity” of each other's positions and often accusing each other of retarding the intellectual progress of society.Footnote 66 Such language and the fierce debate within the club had an impact on how others outside the club viewed liberalism. Observers seized these opportunities to condemn the Liberal Club as a group of infidels. Reflecting on a lecture Rev. George Samson gave at the club condemning Darwinism, the New York Observer and Chronicle, a religious weekly, hailed his lecture as a success and noted that “such lectures make the superficial free-thinkers pause.”Footnote 67
But despite heated moments, member's dedication to liberal tolerance and social scientific inquiry motivated them to negotiate the thin line between their own beliefs and prejudices and the liberal ideal. While some like Douai attacked the “absurdity” of views based on biblical creation, they also asserted their commitment to free debate. While Samson harshly attacked the “absurdities” of Darwinism, he also maintained his stated commitment to free inquiry and to the liberal ideal. Years later, after a group of Baptist preachers criticized Samson for his association with the club, Samson defended himself and the group and noted his lifelong commitment to scientific inquiry.Footnote 68 For religious liberals like Samson, the relationship between Christianity, scientific inquiry, and liberalism was complex; all three were intertwined and irremovable from each other. As a member of the Liberal Club, Samson had to balance his faith in Christianity, his enthusiasm for free inquiry, and his commitment to liberal intellectual tolerance.
BANQUET AT DELMONICO'S
Liberal Club members' stated commitment to intellectual tolerance was showcased every year at club anniversaries, which served to facilitate discourse, engage with the broader New York social scene, and to honor Humboldt and other scientific luminaries. These annual events were billed as “scientific soirees” where members celebrated the latest scientific and technological innovations.Footnote 69 One of the most memorable of these was held on the night of October 5, 1872, when Liberal Club members and their friends gathered at Delmonico's in New York City to celebrate the organization's third anniversary. The highlight of the night was an address by club president Horace Greeley.
As well as being president of the Liberal Club, Greeley was also running for president of the United States on the Liberal Republican Party ticket that fall.Footnote 70 Greeley's personality was well-suited to the Liberal Club as he was “naturally receptive of new plans for reform.” He prided himself on intellectual dynamism, and boasted that he hailed from New England, “that land in which every ism of social or religious life had its origin.”Footnote 71 Greeley was known for using his New York Tribune to promote many of the “isms” with which he flirted.Footnote 72 In this way, his membership in the club was a natural outgrowth of his intellectual life.Footnote 73
In his remarks to the Liberal Club at Delmonico's, Greeley denied accusations that members were atheists.Footnote 74 Rather than focusing on the potentially divisive subject of religion, Greeley focused on what united club members—an interest in science. Greeley announced that the club was “neither orthodox or heterodox in religion. It was simply a Club in the interest of science.” Beaming optimistically, Greeley asserted that “In all departments of industry and commerce, science was fast becoming part of the daily food of the people, of their discussions around the fireside and the family table.” He finished by toasting to “the men of science.” This was followed by yet another toast to “Humboldt and the Liberal Club.”Footnote 75
Greeley's remarks on religion and science highlighted the complex relationship between liberalism, science, and religion in the minds of many club members. Religion and science, Greeley's remarks suggest, were not necessarily contradictory, and a commitment to science did not entail atheism. Yet the very fact that Greeley had to respond to charges of atheism demonstrated that for many of critical observers of the club, debate over ideas that challenged Christian doctrine could be interpreted by some as a total rejection of faith. In a very important way, it was not scientific inquiry itself but the liberal ideal—open-mindedness and the spirit of free and unlimited debate—that gained the ire of some in the public. It was the way in which liberalism democratized belief and leveled the field for all ideas, at least in theory, and put radical ideas and settled ideas on equal ground that provoked backlash from critical observers in the public. In this sense, Kittelstrom's assertion that open-mindedness and religious tolerance helped forge modern liberalism is correct, yet that same open-mindedness contributed to the growing association of liberalism and godlessness as critics of faith and some liberals themselves questioned the compatibility of such open-mindedness and religion.
Public perceptions of the club and liberalism were also influenced by larger intellectual trends. During the 1870s, religious authority in the public sphere was a subject of increasing contention. Advocates of religious authority like Anthony Comstock embraced muscular attempts to assert the moral power of Christianity in American life. In 1873, Congress enacted the Comstock Act, which made it illegal to publish and distribute “obscene” material. At the same time, Comstock founded the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice, an organization dedicated to enforcing Victorian era social norms. Comstock's crusade for public morality joined other efforts, including the National Association, founded in 1863, which fought to secure a “religious amendment” to the United States Constitution. Soon, friends of the club like Victoria Woodhull found themselves persecuted by Comstock and derided for their so-called assaults on the moral virtues of American society.Footnote 76
The fight for public authority was a two-way street. Historians have shown that a variety of groups were purposefully trying to unseat religious authority at a number of levels in American society.Footnote 77 This period gave rise to groups like the National Liberal League, established in 1876, which to countering the call for a “religious amendment,” sought to promote total separation of church and state in the United States. Statements like F. E. Abbot's the “Demands of Liberalism”—a call-to-arms for liberals who opposed public religious authority—also furthered the idea that liberalism and Christianity were in conflict.
Also contributing to the battle for public authority was a trend of intellectual revisionism aimed at reimagining the historical relationship of science and religion as one marked by conflict. This trend was epitomized by the publication of John William Draper's History of the Conflict between Religion and Science in 1874 and Andrew Dickson White's “The Warfare of Science” published in Popular Science Monthly in 1876. These publications heralded the rise of what some historians have called the “conflict thesis”—which posits that religion has historically persecuted and held back scientific progress.Footnote 78 The Liberal Club, which was founded with the enthusiasm for unrestricted free debate, existed in a world of thought that was increasingly hostile to liberal discourse and fellowship between people who held diverse ideas about the relationship and compatibility of religion and science.
A NEW PRESIDENT
The election of biographer James Parton as president of the club in the spring of 1874 contributed to the increasingly shaky ground of liberal discourse and further promoted internal divisions in the group. Parton had been married to the late writer Sara “Fanny Fern” Willis and was an accomplished writer himself. Parton authored biographies on Andrew Jackson, Benjamin Franklin, and Horace Greeley. After Willis died in the mid-1870s, Parton, then working on a biographical sketch of Voltaire, became more engaged in social-intellectual pursuits like the Liberal Club. Parton had ties to prominent members of the Free Religion movement like Thomas Wentworth Higginson and Francis Ellingwood Abbot, and spoke at Free Religious Association events.Footnote 79 Now, the Liberal Club brought Parton closer to other freethinkers like Thaddeus Wakeman, who himself was becoming an indispensable leader of the postwar freethought movement.Footnote 80
Unlike previous presidents such as Greeley, Parton was not so concerned with negotiating and maintaining the precarious space members had created. Parton's conception of liberalism was informed by his commitment to freedom of thought—for Parton this meant “thought” free from religion—rather than commitment to unbiased debate. As president, Parton demonstrated an energetic and activist spirit when it came to promoting his vision of liberalism. For many, this activist spirit could easily be construed as antagonism toward religion. Writing in his diary in 1871, T. W. Higginson reflected on Parton's disdain for religion, noting that although Parton was very intelligent, he was “marked with prejudice & limitation.”Footnote 81
Parton demonstrated these traits in his inaugural address to the Liberal Club. By design, or perhaps by accident, this was the same night that George Samson was slated to speak. At first, Parton's speech reflected contemporary frustration over the corruption-plagued Grant administration when he spoke to the role of the club and other similar organizations in purging corruption from government, in moving society forward, and in acting as a counterweight to the forces of the “conservative reaction.”Footnote 82 But after urging action in the material world, Parton followed up with comments that challenged religious faith. Parton's agnosticism shocked the faithful in the audience and the public when he declared, “here we are, this human race of ours, tossed upon this round ball of earth, naked and shelterless, and sent whirling through space, why we don't know, and whence we don't know, and wither we don't know—that is to say, I don't know.”Footnote 83 Parton insisted that “there was no help for man but in himself.” Parton's view was illustrative of an age where, for many, humankind's place in the world was becoming decoupled from theology and from a mandated purpose and place in the universe. It was a reflection of the fact that modern science contributed to shaking the certitude of some liberals who a generation before might have believed the universe was governed by a beneficial moral order.Footnote 84
Parton's comments provoked a response from critical observers in the press. The Presbyterian weekly New York Evangelist branded Parton's comments a “humiliating confession.” The Evangelist asserted, “we do not remember for a long time to have met any disavowal of knowledge or belief, that was at once so frank and yet so saddening.” “Such a confession of ignorance, such an exhibition of the desolate condition and cheerless prospects of the class of minds which Mr. Parton, we have no doubt, fairly represents, does not call for bitter censure or harsh epithets, but for genuine pity and hearty sympathy,” the Evangelist chided.
The Boston Journal, a daily newspaper, took a similar position, denounced the club's “Liberal creed,” and argued that “the class of people represented by the New York Liberal Club” is “made up of that school of modern philosophers who make war, more or less openly, more or less actively, upon what they are pleased to term the religious superstitions of the day.” Members of the club, the Journal continued, were ready to lead their fellow men “up to their own serene hights of self complacent philosophy.” The Journal concluded, “It is not our office or aim to enter into religious discussions of any kind. But when the question becomes one between religion and no religion, between faith and universal skepticism, we cannot refrain from speaking.”Footnote 85 This dichotomy was, however, simplistic and far from accurate. The membership of the club spanned the entire gamut of belief and unbelief. But despite this wide array of views, Parton's comments contributed to the idea that the lines between religion and no religion, between belief and unbelief, were concrete and nonporous. Although it was not true for all, Parton's comments encouraged the growing conception in the public and among liberals that liberalism was contradictory to religious faith.
The controversy surrounding the Truman and Woodhull Trial of 1874–1875, and the Liberal Club's reaction to it, further fueled the perception that liberals were at war with religious belief. The trial came about after Mrs. Acseh M. Truman sued to recover allegedly misinvested funds from Victoria Woodhull's brokerage firm Woodhull, Claflin and Company.Footnote 86 Truman's chief witness was Joseph Treat. After being called to the stand, Treat, an atheist, asserted his right to affirm rather than take a religious oath. The presiding judge, at the urging of attorney for the defense, excluded Treat from testifying—noting that Treat's testimony could not be trusted. Without this testimony, Truman's case had little merit and the judge ruled in favor of Woodhull.Footnote 87
Several freethought periodicals followed the case and condemned the exclusion of Treat's testimony.Footnote 88 Treat's case soon prompted a discussion at the club.Footnote 89 On January 22, 1875, the club released its official position and resolved to fight to “secure the right of every man or woman to be a witness” in the State of New York.Footnote 90 Club members soon organized a fund to aid in litigation to secure this end. The resolution and the resulting fund likely held different meanings for different members. For some club liberals, the resolution was a measure intended to promote intellectual and religious tolerance in public, but for others, like James Parton, it was part of an effort to undermine the public authority of religion. The resolution is also important because it demonstrates that for many social scientists during the 1860s and 1870s, as Thomas Haskell has shown, “inquiry and reform were a natural and inseparable unity.” It was not enough that club members gathered to debate issues like religious oaths, it was assumed that debates could and should lead to an organized movement to implement findings.Footnote 91
The resolution was interpreted by critical observers in the press as sanctioning infidelity and undermining the fabric of society. Responding to the club's stand against religious oaths, the New York Observer and Chronicle, a religious weekly founded in 1833, asserted that affirmation was meaningless if a witness did not believe in God. “But if there be no god,” the Observer asserted, “there is no moral system which has any hold upon conscience, no occasion for remorse in view of falsehood: no fear of punishment if the crime escapes human detection.” The Observer claimed that “It were better to lose the information” of a few advanced thinkers, like “Mr. Emerson or Dr. Draper” than to “remove one of the great bulwarks of society.”Footnote 92 For the Observer, the club's position on oaths was just another liberal attack on religion like Parton's comments, and John William Draper's publication of the History of the Conflict between Religion and Science the prior year.
Starting in the spring of 1875, there was a sizable up-tick in the number of lectures discussing the confluence of modern science and religious thought. This increase owed to both larger trends outlined above, as well as the influence of Parton and other freethinkers. Lectures were still diverse and represented a wide variety of perspectives. The faithful, the faithless, and those in between were represented in relatively equal numbers. At least eight people connected to religious denominations or sects appeared as lecturers during this time—some gave multiple lectures. A similar number of freethinkers, agnostics, or committed “men of science” also appear in club records as giving religiously themed lectures. Despite this diversity, accusations that the club was a bastion of atheism were common.Footnote 93
By-and-large, though, the club was increasingly influenced by agnostic and atheist freethinkers and Comtean positivists. One these individuals was G. L. Henderson, a Scotch freethinker and Comtean. In the spring of 1876 the club moved its meetings from its longtime home at Plimpton Hall—against the recommendations of several members and officers—to Henderson's newly opened Science Hall. The new location was on 8th Street, just three blocks to the west, near New York University and Washington Square Park, an area that would soon gain fame from Henry James' s1880 novel Washington Square, and later, in several works by Edith Wharton. This was also an area undergoing a marked demographic shift that would lead toward an artistic and cultural renaissance in Greenwich Village during the early twentieth century.Footnote 94
Science Hall, noted Woodhull & Claflin's Weekly, would “be dedicated to the service of Liberalism.” At the dedication of Science Hall, Charles Sotheran, an officer of the Liberal Club, gave the keynote speech titled “The Struggle between Theology and Science.”Footnote 95 In his talk, Sotheran echoed the historical revisionism that was common during the period and argued that religion had historically held back scientific progress. Sotheran epitomized the trend of some liberals during the 1870s to associate liberalism with scientific inquiry and to emphasize conflict between science and religion, and between liberalism and Christianity.Footnote 96 For some members of the club, like Dorothy Ross's social scientists, “science began to appear not only as the most authoritative modern knowledge, but as a courageous source of free inquiry.”Footnote 97 Science Hall soon served as an unofficial adjunct to the American Social Science Association, which never successfully founded its own chapter in New York City. It also became a sort of headquarters for the New York's freethought movement, as it served as the meeting place for the Religio-Scientific Society, Comtean-styled Society of Humanity, and the office for the freethought journal Truth Seeker and its editor DeRobigne Mortimer Bennett.Footnote 98
Bennett, himself, was a part of the growing group of freethinkers at the club who conceived of liberalism as incompatible with Christianity. Bennett's liberalism was originally rooted in a liberal approach to religion, but by the 1870s he increasingly identified liberalism as contradictory to religious belief. Originally from upstate New York, Bennett was a former Shaker who embraced freethought during the early 1850s. In 1873, from his home in Illinois, Bennett founded Truth Seeker.Footnote 99 The following year, on a trip to New York City, Bennett became acquainted with Liberal Club member Stephen Pearl Andrews, and he decided to move himself and Truth Seeker to New York City. Over the next decade Bennett became a leader of the national freethought movement and Truth Seeker became the nation's leading freethought periodical. During this period, Bennett was also arrested several times for violating the Comstock Act—twice for distributing anarchist Ezra Heywood's pamphlet Cupid's Yokes, which criticized the institution of marriage and promoted free love.Footnote 100
The Liberal Club greatly influenced Bennett, Truth Seeker, and the national freethought movement. At first, much of Truth Seeker's content was religious in nature and geared toward those “holding liberal views upon religious and theological subjects.”Footnote 101 This changed as Bennett was influenced by his associations with Liberal Club members.Footnote 102 Starting in November of 1874, Bennett began to incorporate regular reports of the Liberal Club in Truth Seeker, sometimes printing entire lectures and minutes of club debates.Footnote 103 Readers far and wide wrote to the paper to voice their approval of Bennett's decision to print reports of meetings and to report that they had established liberal clubs in their own towns and cities.Footnote 104
DECLINE
Despite its growing influence among liberals and freethinkers, by 1877 long-standing problems began to undermine the sustainability of the Liberal Club. The contentious environment of the 1870s, the multiple and contradictory meanings that liberals and those in the public gave to the club's liberalism, along with numerous ideological divisions and personal animosities that had festered for years, began to tear the group apart. Amid this tumult, club officers tried to reassure members while reinforcing the mission of the group. Writing his annual report to the club as acting secretary for 1876–1877, Charles Sotheran reflected on the prior year's discourse. “Those participating therein,” he wrote, “have done their utmost to use their best endeavors in the cause of truth and shed the utmost knowledge on all subjects in whatever domain it may have been under discussion. No tyrannical and intellectual oligarchy can be said to exist or ought ever to exist in this Club.” Invoking the memory of Horace Greeley, Sotheran wrote that he hoped that the club would continue to represent “every ism in philosophy, religion, science and art” just as “the past years lectures have been eminently representative.”Footnote 105 Sotheran's comments, read in the context of his remarks two years earlier at the inauguration of Science Hall, demonstrate the complex nature of Sotheran's liberal faith. Sotheran held to the liberal ideal open-mindedness and tolerance, while simultaneously asserting that Christianity ran contrary to the liberal spirit.
Sotheran's optimism was not to last. In April of 1877, the election of Liberal Club officers turned into a competition that few expected. The day before the election, longtime member James H. K. Willcox, a professed Christian, organized a caucus of members opposed to the reelection of James Parton and other officers. Willcox nominated his friend, Simon Sterne, whom he worked with as editor of the short-lived New York Social Science Review to head the opposition ticket against Parton. Like Willcox, Sterne had been involved in the club since at least 1871. A lawyer, Sterne was most noted at the time as a spokesman for electoral reform in New York. During the mid-1870s, Sterne was one of a few prominent members of Governor Samuel Tilden's Commission to Devise a Plan for the Government of Cities in the State of New York. According to David Quigley, Sterne was “perhaps the most ardent proponent of suffrage restriction” on the Tilden Commission.Footnote 106 Sterne hoped that suffrage restriction would save democracy by stemming “the growing powers of uneducated urban voters.”Footnote 107 The Tilden Commission's recommendation, made in March of 1877, was to restrict certain voting rights across class lines and limit public works programs.Footnote 108
Sterne's decision to seek leadership of the Liberal Club, then, immediately followed the completion of his duties on the Tilden Commission and was most likely an extension of his life as a civic leader of the city and demonstrated his commitment to social scientific inquiry—something reinforced by his participation in the American Social Science Association for several years. What also likely provoked Willcox and Sterne was that James Parton was too prejudiced against religion and too cavalier on issues of government intervention for their taste. Ultimately, Willcox and Sterne were successful, and the opposition ticket won the election. The losing party, which included Parton, T. B. Wakeman, and the majority of the club's Comteans, decided to leave and form a new organization named the Manhattan Liberal Club.
The Liberal Club's schism became a topic of interest for New York's freethought and liberal communities. Soon after the split, the American Socialist commented that after the defeat of the “radicals” in the election, the club had become “too strait-laced.”Footnote 109 Truth Seeker offered a similar explanation: “the most Radical part of the old club will probably be embodied in the new organization, the old being too conservative.”Footnote 110 Truth Seeker later corrected, “The Liberal clubs, as clubs, are neither radical nor conservative,” and insisted that instead “the radicals predominate in the Manhattan Liberal Club, the conservatives in the New York Liberal Club.”Footnote 111
But the interested public wanted more information, and the American Socialist wondered whether the “convulsion” at the club “might have a deep significance as indicating some great crisis in the world of thought.” One letter to the American Socialist suggested that the fracturing of the club owed to multiple factors, but acknowledged that two factions had existed in the club: the “conservative Christian” (presumably the Willcox and Sterne faction) and the “free love” forces (presumably the positivist-led Manhattan Liberal Club faction). This, wrote the editor of the American Socialist, provided some clarity on the question but “readers could endure a little stronger light on it.”Footnote 112
Soon longtime club member and anarcho-individualist J. K. Ingalls wrote in with his version of the schism.Footnote 113 Ingalls noted that while the club “answered the purposes of a Lyceum,” that discussions and debates had nevertheless always been rife with conflict. Ingalls reported that personal antipathies mixed with sectarian strife led to the demise of the club. Ingalls asserted that Willcox, a Christian and a “martinet in parliamentary discipline,” proved a “thorn-in-the-side” to former president W. L. Ormsby and “disgusted” T. B. Wakeman. Wakeman, for his part, cared only for Comtean dogma like the Law of Three Stages, “relativity of all knowledge,” and knew “no rights but only duties.” These were ideas that Willcox and Sterne, who were greatly invested in the thought of Herbert Spencer, held in contempt. Ingalls reassured readers of the American Socialist that “there is no real partisan significance in the disruption. The extreme free-thinkers are about equally divided between the new and the old Club. Liberal Religionists and Spiritualists go with each division.” The only real schism, Ingalls noted, was that the majority of Comtean positivists went with the new Manhattan Liberal Club.Footnote 114 The real schism, though, which escaped Ingalls's observation, was the increasingly divergent conceptions of liberalism that club members held. The majority of Comtean positivists went with the Manhattan Liberal Club because for the most part they believed that Christianity contradicted a liberal world view.
After the split, both factions faced challenges. In August, in the midst of the Great Railroad Strike of 1877, William A. Croffutt gave a lecture on “Labor and Capital” before the “radical”-leaning, positivist-dominated Manhattan Liberal Club—which continued to meet at Science Hall. Unfortunately for Croffutt, he was “more to the side of capital than was pleasing to the majority of his auditors,” many of whom sympathized with the labor movement. The crowd manifested their “repugnance by hisses, ironical laughter, and frequent interruptions.” At end of the lecture, members denounced Croffutt and “described his views as cold-blooded, heartless, and irrational.”Footnote 115 At another lecture in October, member and minister Charles P. McCarthy lashed out at members who “spoke sneeringly of Christ and the Christian religion.”Footnote 116 McCarthy was eventually censored for his comments and later expelled for his “slanderous scurrility and abuse” at the meeting.Footnote 117
Unlike the Manhattan Liberal Club, the leadership of the New York Liberal Club maintained its promise to uphold liberal tolerance for all. The group, which met at the College of Physicians and Surgeons, soon accepted McCarthy as a member. In the fall, the club's president, Simon Sterne, addressing popular concern over the compatibility of liberalism and Christianity, asserted that “liberal views [are] not necessarily antagonistic to all accepted opinions on social and religious matters” and that the club “had not incurred religious antipathy.”Footnote 118 Sterne's group claimed to represent the original ethic of the club, in which liberalism was defined as a force of tolerance that could unify and uplift mankind through the inclusion of diverse belief systems.
Some liberals, though, like those at the Manhattan Liberal Club, as well as others around the country, increasingly defined liberalism in opposition to Christianity. One writer to Truth Seeker epitomized this view by asserting that “Liberal ideas and Christianity are not compatible.” The writer proclaimed that “to be a Christian is to blindly believe. To be a Liberal is to search and think for oneself.”Footnote 119 At a convention of freethinkers in upstate New York in 1878, another liberal declared, “It is only through Liberalism that mankind can be elevated higher in the age of reason, where we can look back to the age of religion or superstition as a lower, by-gone condition of humanity.”Footnote 120 During the 1880s, Robert G. Ingersoll, popularly known as the “Great Agnostic,” was regularly championing this conception of liberalism.Footnote 121 The association of unbelief and liberalism was widespread by 1900.Footnote 122
Despite Sterne's attempt to rescue the club from strife, the New York Liberal Club continued to suffer disruptions. In November, anti-Comstock crusader and medical reformer E. B. Foote Jr., offended a large group of medical students attending his lecture by condemning the medical profession for not promoting birth control and contraception.Footnote 123 The students soon launched a campaign to disrupt future meetings. This, combined with the contentious atmosphere of the period was perhaps too much for the New York Liberal Club and it soon disbanded.
The Manhattan Liberal Club continued to meet into the twentieth century, and continued to represent a conception of liberalism that was hostile to Christianity. The club represented a much more narrow set of beliefs and was influenced to a large extent by a somewhat dogmatic brand of Comtean positivism. Mainstream Christians were not nearly as welcome at the club's home “Science Hall” as they were before the schism. This atmosphere was a marked change from the original Liberal Club, and some former members, like George Samson, distanced themselves from ties with the “materialistic agnostics” who led the new group.Footnote 124
During the 1880s and 1890s, paralleling the rapid professionalization of social science, the Manhattan Liberal Club reoriented as a group more dedicated to reform than social scientific inquiry. The club attracted a new generation of radical activists and intellectuals including E. B. Foote Jr. and Emma Goldman. Goldman began to regularly attend meetings in 1894. T. W. Wakeman, now a famous antireligious reformer, remained firmly committed to the Manhattan Liberal Club. Wakeman made a name for himself as a president of the National Liberal League, allying with free religionist Francis E. Abbot. The Manhattan Liberal Club continued its close association with Truth Seeker, which soon eclipsed its competitors like Abbot's Index and at its peak counted fifty thousand subscribers, including Robert Ingersoll, Samuel Clemens, and Clarence Darrow.Footnote 125 Additionally, the Free Speech League, a civil liberties defense and advocacy group, was formed at a meeting of the Manhattan Liberal Club in the spring of 1902.Footnote 126
CONCLUSION
Despite the contest over the meaning of liberalism that played out at the New York Liberal Club, its contribution to the New York City's intellectual landscape, as well as to liberal and freethought circles around the country, was substantial. In the decade following the dissolution of the original Liberal Club, New York City's civic intellectual culture was populated by many new discussion clubs.Footnote 127 Where conventional debate clubs, lyceums, and other voluntary educational organizations had existed for decades, many of the new organizations embraced a commitment to social scientific inquiry and to the intellectual approach and structure similar to the Liberal Club. “These clubs were primarily united by a new spirit of inquiry into certain grave questions of public welfare,” Coleman E. Bishop wrote in the Chautauquan in 1886. “It is as if thinkers and reformers, men and women of antecedents and views the most divergent and antagonistic,” Bishop continued “had felt in common an urgent necessity for comparison of views.”Footnote 128
Bishop pointed to “The Colloquium,” founded by former Liberal Club member Stephen P. Andrews in 1882 as the first of all the new organizations that embodied the club's original liberal ideal of religious and intellectual tolerance. The Colloquium, whose members were primarily limited to theologians and philosophers, sought to “break down the social wall that rests on diversity of opinion: and then to cultivate toleration” for “the sake of mutual education.” The Colloquium, which sought to promote “the free exchange of ideas, particularly on religious subjects,” had been first suggested by former Liberal Club member Reverend George W Samson. Rabbi Samuel Adler suggested the name.Footnote 129 This approach, noted Bishop, had been embraced in the “symposium” style of certain reviews and was even adopted by the Chautauqua School of Theology. But “the parent” of the Colloquium and the first major club to showcase the new model, Bishop reminded his readers, was the Liberal Club.
Yet another offspring of the Liberal Club was the Nineteenth Century Club. The Nineteenth Century Club was organized by club member Courtlandt Palmer in 1883. Its members billed the club as a forum for “the fullest freedom of speech and the expression of the greatest variety in opinion.”Footnote 130 The club was less of an open forum like the Liberal Club before it, however, and it was geared more toward the affluent in New York's high society. Bishop noted that the “peculiar success of ‘The Nineteenth Century Club’ has made it the best known of all the new agents of agitation.” This was true; the club gained wide acclaim at home and across the Atlantic and included prominent members such as Andrew Carnegie, whom Palmer had met at Madame Botta's salon.Footnote 131 Of the polemic club scene in New York City, Bishop concluded “modest as it is now, organized agitation has in it the potentiality of radical change of public opinion and recast of our institutions.”Footnote 132
Not all of Bishop's comments were accurate. While the Liberal Club—and later the Manhattan Liberal Club—contributed to the robust character of New York's civic intellectual culture during the 1870s and 1880s, as Dorothy Ross and Thomas Haskell have shown, increased professionalization of the social sciences was making such forums obsolete. Like the American Social Science Association, which demonstrated a similar enthusiasm for social science and the ability of science to improve society, by the 1890s, social clubs as a place for free inquiry were becoming much less important. The influence of New York's civic intellectual culture—so well delineated by Thomas Bender—which the Liberal Club epitomized, was fading as professional scientists and social scientists dedicated their energies to the university and disciplinary organizations like the American History Association (1884), the American Psychological Association (1892), and the American Anthropological Association (1902). As inquiry was increasingly focused in the disciplines, groups like the Manhattan Liberal Club became much more focused on reform.
Ultimately, the New York Liberal Club represented competing conceptions of Gilded Age liberalism, as well as the broader process in which liberalism became increasingly associated with godlessness and infidelity. While club members were originally united by the spirit of scientific inquiry and religious tolerance, the debate over religion and science during the 1870s contributed to a growing hostility between members and elucidated two major contradictory visions of liberalism that had already been developing for decades. For many liberals in and outside the group, as well as critical observers, liberalism was increasingly anathema to religion. But for others who held to an earlier ideal, liberalism continued to represent open-mindedness and tolerance toward diverse approaches to belief and unbelief.
