Megan Ming Francis’ insightful review of Statebuilding from the Margins highlights many of the themes that excited me as Carol Nackenoff and I worked on our volume. We hoped that the chapters would bring to the fore submerged questions of American Political Development regarding the importance of ideas (not just institutions), non-elite actors (not just elites), movements (not just government institutions and organizations), and contingent and complex narratives of development (rather than schematic linear frameworks or descriptions subject to straightforward modeling). I was delighted that these themes attracted Professor Francis’ notice.
Professor Francis asks how to identify statebuilding from the margins, specifically how far the boundaries extend and what they include and exclude. I present some thoughts, but invite further debate, continuing to rethink how we conduct research in APD and what kinds of phenomena we should recognize as developments and institutions.
While the chapters illustrate a range of statebuilding efforts from the margins, even taken together, they do not provide a holistic definition. We hoped to redefine statebuilding, shifting the focus from elite actors’ agency in producing, in Karen Orren and Stephen Skowronek’s phrase, “durable shifts in governing authority.” Like Orren and Skowronek, we don’t advocate for a return to a teleological conception of development, but do consider how statebuilding can encompass more than shifts of authority. Rather, I am concerned with capacity, and tracing how state capacity can be increased or redirected. A focus on governing authority necessarily turns the analytical lens toward state actors and institutions, to observe from where and to where authority is being shifted, or if new authority arises, how state institutions construct and implement it. Capacity is trickier to investigate, and is particularly interesting during the Progressive Era. Our volume identifies moments when state actors built capacity in traditional senses by establishing institutions (Sullivan and Nackenoff) but also moments when private actors built capacity (Strach) and even exercised it in the state’s name with minimal investment or engagement by state institutions or actors (Pearson and Smith). States also have borrowed private capacity for state purposes, as Greer’s chapter highlights.
These examples all illustrate shifts in the kinds of things that states do or are expected to do, but do not necessarily touch directly on governing authority, nor can their timing be identified through shifts in authority. Yet many of these instances paved the way for more traditionally understood development recognizable as such to mainstream scholars. Focusing on capacity drives our attention to where it is created, and by whom, allowing for a broader understanding of who is building the state and how these architects are operating. Some were oppositional actors, some sought partnerships and engagement from state actors and institutions while remaining somewhat independent, while still others were absorbed within the machinery of the state. What brings them together as fit subjects for investigation is their efforts to identify and define public problems, whether or not they were wholeheartedly advocating for state-based solutions.
Francis’s own work illustrates how important these investigations are. She convincingly shows how presidential rhetoric and congressional policy agendas responded to the NAACP decades before distinct institutional change could be detected. The NAACP’s investigatory capacity brought into view problems previously invisible to the state. As Francis notes, failing to recognize these dynamics as developmental distorts our understanding of how civil rights expansion happened, and therefore our understanding of how the American state developed in the twentieth century. Dialogues like this one are a welcome way to correct these distortions, and to develop a richer understanding of American political development, and especially the role of initiatives from the margins that drive this development forward.
