This edited volume forefronts control and violence in Late Antiquity from the perspective of ‘small worlds’. This approach of microhistory examines ‘the prosperous but unglamorous individuals who had inherited or managed to commandeer control of a petty kingdom, in the form of a household, a church, a school, or a monastery’ (2). The volume proposes a shift in focus from the top one per cent elite to ‘the “middling” orders’ (8) — the next ten per cent. The fifteen case studies cover the fourth to sixth centuries, examining the creation of, adherence to, and the negotiation and rejection of social control.
Editors Kate Cooper and Jamie Wood have produced a carefully presented collection that draws on law codes, inscriptions, hagiographies, monastic rules and other patristic texts. It is divided into four parts, covering women and children (I), slaves (II), pedagogy (III) and issues of vulnerability and power (IV).
Part I, on women and children, begins with Julia Hillner's (15–38) investigation of confinement as a judicial measure for women. Hillner's extensive survey of the evidence argues that monastic confinement was especially beneficial for higher-status families, for whom it provided suitable punishment for their womenfolk without degrading the family. Vasiliki Limberis's contribution (39–58) on Gregory of Nyssa and his mother Emmelia analyses a widow's legal power over her children and her challenges in controlling a household. Limberis places Gregory's adolescent nightmare of a martyrial beating in its biographical context and examines its use in Gregory's preaching, where this was a positive manifestation of violence. Next, Jonathan Tallon (59–75) showcases social control in John Chrysostom's concept of πίστις/fides, which was reciprocal, as it was social and theological. By linking πίστις to household relationships (husband/wife, father/son, master/slave), Chrysostom decorated domestic hierarchies with notions of obedience that were linked to a Christian's relationship with God. Kate Cooper's essay (76–101) on Augustine's sexual ethics establishes the sanctioned sources of sex for a freeborn male citizen and reinterprets Augustine's treatment of his concubines, in opposition to analysis by Danuta Shanzer. Augustine's critique of adulterous men was ‘eccentric’ (99) but informed by his own life.
Opening the discussion of slaves in Part II, Chris L. de Wet (105–130) fills a lacuna in Kyle Harper's work on late Roman slavery, with a focus on doulological asceticism in Syriac sources. Chained ascetics emulated the concept of msarrqūtā — monastic shame — showing that ‘monastic ideals and ideologies reinscribed the hierarchies of slavery’ (130). Some ascetics may even have sought out slavery in preparation for potential capture in a restless region. The sixth chapter, by Lillian I. Larsen (131–50), builds on the works of J. Glancy, J. Harrill and K. Harper. Here Larsen collates evidence of slaves in and entering into monastic landscapes, calling for a more complex treatment of their experiences. Larsen, too, critiques ascetic mimicry of servile duties, while showing that there was no uniform approach to enslaved people in monastic settings. Maria Chiara Giorda (151–70) reconciles the notional prohibition of children in monasteries with evidence for their presence. Children were donated in mutually beneficial exchanges between parents and monastic communities, thus sustaining the monastic workforce. Children could be educated or trained, but were also vulnerable to (condoned) corporeal punishment and (condemned) sexual abuse.
Part III examines pedagogy. Blake Leyerle (173–87) demonstrates how Chrysostom enacted social control through positively promoting fear as a ‘deliberative state’ (174), especially to parents raising children. Chrysostom hoped that congregants affected by urban unrest would reflect on imminent divine judgement: ‘one becomes Christian by feeling fear’ (186). Jamie Wood (188–212) frames violence as a pedagogical tool used by Libanius and Basil of Caesarea. Violence — real, imagined and feared — helped students of rhetoric and asceticism alike to break away from their old selves and be remade into successful leaders in their respective fields. Violence is also central to Aaron P. Johnson's essay (213–31), arguing that ‘a text can seek to “violate” another's self-ascribed identity’ (214). Focusing on Eusebius of Caesarea's Praeparatio Evangelica, Johnson shows that Eusebius’ inclusion of his opponents’ views did not necessarily seek to inspire violence but also to deescalate it. Blossom Stefaniw (232–55) explores Antony the Great's and Athanasius of Alexandria's demonological instructions, illuminating their differing ascetic subjectivities. Antony's demons are immaterial, located within the self, while Athanasius’ demons are external and corporeal. A knowledge of demonology is ‘the first line of self-defence’ (243), while the different approaches reflect contextual challenges faced by the ancient authors. Melissa Markauskas (256–73) investigates coercive conversion against the backdrop of competing Christianities in North Africa, where catechists faced ‘depressing work’ (259) in preaching to potential but apathetic converts. Augustine offered such lower clergy practical strategies to boost the conversion efforts to Caecilianist Christianity, which was the ‘product’ (273) they were selling.
The fourth and final section, ‘Vulnerability and Power’, begins with James Corke-Webster's analysis (277–98) on the topos of young women choosing asceticism over marriage. Addressing a scholarly gap on Roman daughters, Corke-Webster argues that Gregory of Nyssa's account of his sister Macrina shows a harmonious Christian family unit in which asceticism binds a mother and daughter together, in contrast to earlier models. Gregory thus demonstrated that ‘Christianity need not destroy the household’ (298). David Natal (299–317) analyses Ambrose of Milan's use of his ascetic female relatives in building legitimacy for his weak episcopacy. His letters to his sister Marcellina created narratives of triumph around Ambrose's conflicts with the imperial court, while the female addressee depoliticised the contents. The final chapter, by Thomas Dimambro (318–36), illuminates an overlooked Syriac hagiography, Euphemia and the Goth. This text showcases the power and agency of female-only households in Edessa where Roman rule and law was welcomed — although locals also relied on one another for protection and justice, as Roman governance had its limits.
Overall, the volume's microhistories put the breadth and depth of ‘small worlds’ on excellent display. The overall theme of controlling petty kingdoms is, however, more strongly articulated in some contributions than others, as at times patristic conceptions of violence in the abstract take the fore (particularly in the third section on pedagogy). The volume is nevertheless well polished with consistently insightful essays, even if at one point Basil the Elder is, confusingly, labelled as Emmelia's wife (293). The pair nevertheless remind us that during the later Roman empire the middling sort they represented were engaged in complex negotiations of hierarchy with one another. The volume illustrates how such people enacted and envisioned social control, especially when the middling sort negotiated with each other. Less is said on the impact of these efforts on those of lower status. How we may reasonably bridge this gap (although perhaps we cannot) still needs further exploration. The volume, however, provides a fresh examination of the anxieties surrounding the exercise of control, while also providing a methodology, that of small worlds, for further lines of enquiry.
