In many respects, this book is one of the best that I have read on the ideology of today's extreme Islamists, especially for readers who are new to this subject. This is despite, or perhaps because of, the fact that the author is evidently not trained in either Islamic studies or Middle East studies. She relies almost entirely on English language sources but uses an extremely wide range of these, including considerable material from Islamist Web sites, and has pieced this material together in an impressive manner. Her limited expertise leads to a certain lack of depth but has perhaps helped her to see the main lines more clearly and to appreciate how to present them to a general readership.
In the first chapter, the author introduces the label “jihadi” or “jihadist” to distinguish the groups of which she is writing from other Muslims and even other Islamists. Habeck stresses, rightly in my view, that we must take very seriously their religious motivation and their own statements of it, something secular scholars may be disinclined to do. The core of the jihadist ideology is the conviction that the Muslim community is divinely meant to lead mankind but in practice is dominated and humiliated by unbelievers. Some jihadists, including al-Qaʿida, see this in terms of an eternal struggle between faith and unbelief.
Chapter 2 sketches the relevant ideas of Ibn Taymiyya, Ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab, Rashid Rida, Hasan al-Banna, Sayyid Qutb, and Abul Aʿla Mawdudi as background to jihadi thinking. Chapter 3 discusses the jihadi interpretation of the Qurءan, noting that it seeks to interpret as literally as possible and to apply its interpretation as broadly as possible, while at the same time being quite selective. Chapter 4 focuses on the teachings of Mawdudi and Qutb, especially their interpretation of tawḥīd as the exclusive rule of God's law and their claim that jāhiliyya prevails in today's world. It then discusses the continuation of these themes by later leaders, along with their rejection of democracy, liberalism, and capitalism.
Chapter 5 presents the jihadis' dichotomous view of the world in which the enemy, often identified with the Jews of the Qurءan or the Crusaders, is intentionally, unrelentingly, and comprehensively attacking Islam. Jihad is the response to this, and chapter 6 discusses the jihadi views of jihad, contrasting these with traditional fiqh and more “mainline” Muslim views today. Chapter 7 shows how they try to pattern their campaigns in detail after the example of Muhammad and how the apparent diversity of their strategies masks considerable similarly.
Chapter 8 argues that Osama bin Laden failed in his immediate goals, which were to recruit a large number to his cause and drive Americans out of the Muslim world, and discusses jihadi explanations for such failures. It closes with a few suggestions about how we should respond to the jihadis, of which the most interesting is that the “war on terrorism” should be renamed the “war on jihadis,” or the “war on the khawārij.”
The book is thoroughly footnoted and has an adequate glossary and index. It lacks a list of sources, something I would have found useful. In general, the author not only presents the jahidist ideology accurately in both its unity and its diversity but also shows its roots in traditional Islamic thinking and its divergence from this, and she makes clear that it is rejected by most Muslims. She might do more at a couple of points to show the plausibility of the jihadis' views in the Muslim world. Habeck gives the impression that following the Prophet's model in detail is important only for jihadis. In fact, however, many Muslims seek to follow the Prophet's model in detail in their personal lives, and this gives plausibility to the jihadis' efforts to apply it to their campaigns. The disjunction between the truth of Islam and the weakness of Muslims is believed not only by jihadis but by most politically aware Muslims, who are to that extent open to their arguments.
When one looks at the details, one finds some problems. I draw just a few examples from her treatment of Sayyid Qutb, whose work I know best. Habeck appears to interpret Qutb's claim that a society is jāhilī as entailing the view that its members are kaffirs (p. 66), a fairly common but erroneous interpretation. She also quotes Qutb as calling Westernizing Muslims “worse than unbelievers” (p. 166). The point is not wrong but the quote is not precise. The source says “unbelief” rather than “unbelievers” and speaks of “we” in a manner that softens its force (In the Shade of the Qurءan, vol. 2, p. 159). The author quotes Qutb's statement, “strike terror into the hearts of God's enemies” as evidence that he “clearly was advocating the use of terror tactics” (p. 132). However, in context, Qutb is echoing a Qurءanic passage he has just quoted and clearly intends that it is the open might of Islam that should intimidate the enemies, not terror tactics (Shade, vol. 7, p. 95).
The clear and forceful picture of jihadist thinking that this book presents, however, more than compensates for these and other weaknesses, and I would recommend it to everyone seriously interested in the topic.
