It is perhaps axiomatic that the fewer pieces of evidence we have for a given period, the more ink gets spilled debating its nature and meaning; and because of this absence of evidence we can fail to appreciate how often our own experience of theatre both informs and distorts our understanding of the past. This is certainly the case for the millennium between classical and late antiquity, a period spanned by the authors of two recent studies: David Wiles's Mask and Performance in Greek Tragedy: From Ancient Festival to Modern Experimentation and Ruth Webb's Demons and Dancers: Performance in Late Antiquity. Vases depicting masked performers can function more like Rorschach tests than hard evidence, and modern experiments with masks, or tragedies staged with a soupçon of ritual ambiance, can be both a help and a hindrance to understanding how ancient drama may have worked. Likewise, the preponderance of negative imagery from late antique (or early Christian) literature can heighten the awareness of our own fascination and revulsion with actors via the tabloid press. It seems that understanding the theatre of those times depends as much on what we think we can teach the evidence as on what the (admittedly) scanty evidence can teach us.
Both Webb and Wiles stand in contrast to traditional literary studies of ancient theatre, and both bring their own experiences as performers to bear. Whether through the lenses of mask work (as in Wiles's case) or dance (Webb's), their studies are grounded in a practical understanding of the dynamics of performance, the visual impact of the performer, and the varieties of potential audience response. Both operate in an environment informed by the work of Alfred Gell, whose theory of the dynamic artifact imbues works of art with a dynamism equivalent to live theatre, as well as by contemporary performance theory and the work of a sometimes-contentious British school of classical philology where theatre is often seen in terms of civic ideology or primarily as a literary event.
Webb's project is distinguished by the fact that she introduces us to a number of sources from late antiquity that are largely unknown to the general reader. Whereas Wiles can assume our familiarity with ancient drama and contemporary trends in England or France, on many occasions Webb has to provide her own translations and introduce entirely new figures into our historical narrative. In addition to this invaluable service, she has included brief biographical notes on these authors along with citations for further reading; graduate students of linguistic ability and in search of meaty research topics would do well to begin here.
The history of the Mediterranean world's attitudes toward theatre is one of surprising continuity. Webb discusses how the elite's disdain for theatre performers was transferred with ease from pagan to Christian intellectuals in the early centuries of the Common Era, and she points out how even today female entertainers in the Muslim world continue to face the social ostracism endured by their Roman-era predecessors (214–15). The language of invective may change, from Greek to Latin to Arabic, but the concerns about the power of the performer to unleash destabilizing forces among the audience remain the same and cannot be dismissed as mere superstition. Bishop John Chrysostom's sermons against the theatre (176–83) stressed the psychological impact of female performers, and Webb argues forcefully that the Christian emphasis on lustful thought (as opposed to action) is what drives the church's arguments against the mimes.
The power of the performer to move an audience through word, song, and gesture becomes one of the main themes of Webb's book, and she carefully sifts through a variety of contemporary studies—Zarilli's account of Kathakali training, Emigh's study of masked and street performance, and so on—to enhance our understanding of the discipline required for both pantomime and mime. Dance, as Webb reminds us, is a discipline requiring intense physical training and one where character development often begins with gesture and works inward from there (91–3). Seen in this light, the late antique audience's perceptions of a pantomime's debauchery and effeminacy can be repositioned as a testament to the dancer's skill and ease of movement (139–67). Likewise, the mimes, in addition to their uncanny ability to create realistic characters onstage, were renowned for their spontaneity and wit; the ease with which they undermined social and political norms was both a testament to their high degree of skill and one of the main reasons they were denounced for their demonic powers (119–35). Webb also corrects common perceptions of the church's animosity toward mimic satires of its rites, pointing out that so-called Anti-Christian Mimes were just as likely performed by Christian actors for a largely Christian audience (122–8).
To theatre scholars, some of Webb's observations will seem familiar and eminently practical, but Webb's audience includes historians and philologists who have yet to fully interrogate the primary sources with which she works. Procopius's outrageous pseudobiography of the Empress Theodora in Book 9 of his Secret History is a case in point; widely available for years in a Penguin paperback, this tasteless and misogynistic rant remains the only source on theatre taught in standard courses on the history of this period; Webb's deconstruction of this pathetic diatribe, and her account of the ancient sources Procopius cribbed in the process (see pp. 4–6 and 53–4 for starters) are long overdue correctives. This study marks an important change in direction for theatre historiography of this little-understood period.
David Wiles's book rejects the traditional chronological narrative suggested by his editors because “we understand the past only through the present, and the present through the past in a continuing dialectic” (12). True to this credo, his chapters create a dialectic of their own, beginning with a discussion of the conventions of classical and Hellenistic-era masks (15–70), moving on to the Renaissance, Enlightenment and a host of twentieth-century experiments with masked performance (71–179) before returning to considerations of how a polytheistic worldview would have created a very distinct reception for masks at the Great Dionysia. The tension between visions of the actor-as-marionette and acting-as-bacchic-possession permeates much of our own experience and informs the analogous tension among theatre historians between the rational, logocentric interpretation of ancient drama and a more polyvalent, polytheistic understanding of masked performance in antiquity. The nōh drama receives considerable attention here, not least because its spiritual roots are (potentially) analogous to those of Greek theatre.
Wiles moves with ease from literary sources to the stage and back, and situates the changing theories of mask work in early and mid-twentieth century French theatre in its own historical moment. Contemporary English mask work benefits greatly from contact with French artists, and Wiles's analysis of the virtues and shortcomings of Peter Hall's famous National Theatre productions is nicely illuminated by commentary from Greg Hicks, one of that company's featured performers. Those who are either contemplating or exploring mask work would benefit from Wiles's observations here, and his epilogue (286–90) contains some useful caveats against using masks as a pretext for artificial ritualization of Western performance.
Wiles returns frequently to the need for modern scholars to check their impulses at the door, informed as they are by our contemporary experience and intellectual milieu, when interpreting ancient drama and its audiences. His argument for a more polyvalent, polytheistic approach, in which masks at the Dionysia become a site where mortals make contact with the spiritual realm, is often quite persuasive. And he acknowledges that his ultimate argument is for a more balanced understanding of Greek tragedy, where we allow for the likelihood that many in the original audience engaged with the drama in a mystical, ritualistic fashion.
This well-reasoned argument occasionally digresses, however, into critiques of past scholarship for its overemphasis on literary sources. Literature, like the mask, had its place; so claims like “Greek religion had no equivalent textual point of reference, and its sense of the sacred was rooted rather in objects and places” (237) seem odd, given the canonical status of Homer and Hesiod's compositions in antiquity. The gods were everywhere and manifested themselves in all things, and Wiles is absolutely correct to point out that polytheists saw no contradiction whatsoever in recognizing both the actor and the divinity that operated within him onstage (258). But it's hard to forget that Athenian audiences were highly literate; to downplay democratic Athens's status as the preeminent city of logos, whose literature formed the foundation of Greek education for two millennia, is to create the kind of dichotomy that Wiles so eloquently argues against elsewhere. Likewise, his criticism of Simon Goldhill's highly influential essay “The Great Dionysia and Civic Ideology” is in many ways spot on (249–51), but Goldhill's arguments hinge largely on visual cues, not literary ones. Where Wiles demands we pay attention to the visual and spiritual impact of the mask, Goldhill demands we also pay attention to the elaborate preshow ceremonial, in particular to the young military cadets (the ephebes) who conducted public sacrifices to the wine god and who marched into the orchestra in uniform to sit on either side of the priest and idol of Dionysus. As Wiles's better self argues, there is no contradiction in admitting the vivid, simultaneous presence of civic ideology, theatrical art, and the divine on the same stage.
