Michael Crawford's The Fight for Status and Privilege in Late Medieval and Early Modern Castile, 1465–1598 offers a nuanced examination of the meaning of hidalgo status in that society. Crawford bases his study on lawsuits of hidalguía, in which individuals fought against municipal governments—he focuses on Seville—for recognition of their hidalgo status. This monograph explores how individuals and royal and municipal governments negotiated concerns about status and privilege in these disputes. As Crawford argues, considering hidalgos as a unified social class fails to elucidate the shifting and challenged nature of hidalguía; his work, therefore, emphasizes individuals’ active attempts to attain and maintain their hidalgo status (p. 8).
The first chapter, “The Constitution of Privilege,” examines the royal government's role in granting but also limiting or revoking privilege. While monarchs employed grants of hidalguía to reward supporters, municipal governments often contested these grants. Fernando V and Isabel I (1474–1504) accepted the municipalities’ right to challenge grants of privileges, but developed legal procedures that made the royal government the final court of appeal in matters of privilege. As Crawford notes, both municipal and royal governments had financial incentives to limit the number of hidalgos, as this status provided exemption from certain taxes. One of Crawford's great strengths is his effective examination of the interplay between economic, political, and social factors in the choices made by municipal and royal governments.
The second chapter, “The Economic and Political Value of Status,” considers how and why hidalgo status became contested in Seville. In 1515, the city passed new statutes, which instituted tax exemption for hidalgos, and prohibited non-hidalgos from holding major offices on the city council. Once recognition of hidalgo status became linked to specific economic and political privileges, more citizens attempted to obtain recognition of hidalguía (p. 44). However, Crawford argues, social and political motivations likely trumped strictly economic ones; as he points out, “the material benefit for the majority of recipients was modest, especially compared with the heavy cost involved in litigation” (p. 56). The visible, symbolic meaning of the tax exemption carried greater import than its financial reward.
Crawford's third chapter addresses how migration and resettlement affected claims of hidalgo status. Many families needed to prove their hidalguía anew when they resettled. In this chapter, Crawford also considers the attempts of several particular groups—Genoese, Basque, and converso families—to attain and preserve hidalgo status. Crawford's argument represents a refreshing change of pace for scholarship on Iberian conversos, as he argues that conversos in Seville rarely faced litigation over their hidalgo status, unless they had already lost social standing due to convictions for heresy (p. 100). Although he effectively employs anecdotal evidence, he could have strengthened this chapter by also presenting quantitative evidence; without numerical specificity, it remains unclear if members of these groups disproportionately experienced challenges to their hidalgo status.
The fourth chapter focuses on the lawsuits of hidalguía themselves, analyzing the rhetoric employed in these disputes and the impact of relevant procedural rules. Because the burden of proof rested on the claimant, municipalities as defendants often won by default. Here, too, quantification could have answered additional questions. Crawford has no shortage of cases—citizens of Seville “brought at least 387 complaints of hidalguía to court” in the sixteenth century (p. 103); according to the table on p. 113, 173 of these contain final rulings. Crawford presumably could have obtained some measure of the “degree of success of those who litigated for status” (p. 114) by calculating the percentage of successful lawsuits among those with final rulings.
The two final chapters focus on institutions central to disputes over hidalguía: the city council of Seville, discussed in chapter 5, and the royal chancery courts, the subject of chapter 6. Here Crawford examines how social networks, and the interests of these institutions and their members, dictated responses to laws concerning hidalguía. The municipal council of Seville ignored laws that might prejudice claims to hidalgo status made by its respected members. Chancery courts often issued rulings influenced on their relationship with certain municipalities, or their own economic interests, rather than the letter of the law.
Crawford has significantly deepened our understanding of hidalgo status in late medieval and early modern Castile. His study challenges views of hidalguía as a fixed identity, yet convincingly reveals the political, social, and economic meaning hidalgo status held for those who sought it. Although he acknowledges the significant degree of local variation in treatment of hidalgo status (p. 11), his Seville-focused study nevertheless provides insight into Castile as a whole, particularly in his chapters on royal policy and courts, but also in his careful analysis of lawsuits, and his interpretation of how Castilian urban elites understood hidalguía. While many have linked status with lineage, Crawford demonstrates that ultimately hidalgo status reflected, rather than constituted, political and economic power.
