
Henri Ellenberger’s The Discovery of the Unconscious (1970) traced psychiatry’s evolving attempts to map the unseen: Mesmer’s animal magnetism, Charcot’s hypnosis, Freud’s drives, Janet’s dissociations. Allan Schore’s The Right Brain and the Origin of Human Nature extends that lineage into our century with a radical reformulation: the unconscious is not a repository of repressed wishes but a right-lateralised, embodied, relational system born from the preverbal rhythms of infant–caregiver attunement.
For psychiatrists, Schore’s regulation theory integrates developmental neuroscience with the psychodynamic and attachment traditions. The unconscious is no longer reducible to data points or symptom clusters. It is lived, embodied beyond words. Shore maps how early relational experience sculpts the infant’s right hemisphere and thus future capacities for, and disruptions of, affect regulation, resilience and empathy we observe in borderline, narcissistic and other common conditions.
Where Freud mined hidden conflict and Bowlby framed attachment behaviourally, Schore’s 30 years pioneering work here locates the unconscious in the anatomised living neurobiology from the earliest infant–mother right hemispheres, attuned, or not, to learn safety, or danger, through affective exchanges.
In psychotherapy, these discoveries translate into a clinical ethos: the therapist functions as a regulating other. Change arises not through verbal interpretations but through preverbal, moment-to-moment right-brain communication channels, including gaze, facial expression, rhythm, tone and silence. These micro-moments of synchrony are the modern equivalent of Winnicott’s ‘facilitating environment’, where safety allows maturation in therapy as vitalities re-emerge.
Karl Jasper’s General Psychopathology (1913/1963) argued that psychiatry must hold together two complimentary tasks, erklären (objective explanation) and verstehen (subjective understanding). They still orient psychiatry’s compass. Schore traverses both poles simultaneously: through 10 heavily referenced (63 pages!) chapters he ‘explains’ early development through neurobiological data while inviting readers to ‘understand’ the lived intensity of affective experience. In this synthesis lies the essence of contemporary psychiatry, a profession both empirically grounded and phenomenologically alive.
Schore’s writing is dense, his interdisciplinary scope formidable. Clinicians unaccustomed to his formidable capacity to bridge neuroscience with psychoanalysis may find the detail overwhelming. His confidence in right-hemisphere dominance will invite heated debate. Nonetheless, his cumulative argument, spanning seven books, from his inception volume Affect Regulation and the Origin of the Self (1994), is compelling: human nature itself is shaped through co-regulated emotional life.
Schore’s insistence on the primacy of clinical face-to-face encounter is almost prophetic. In our digital era, dominated by screens, metrics and AI’s algorithmic empathy, the unconscious, he reminds us, is not virtual but visceral. The unconscious emerges relationally through the gaze that meets, tone that soothes, pause that repairs. Psychiatry too must reclaim this embodied relational space.
The book’s final chapters feel valedictory, a summation of three decades’ research and a moral appeal. Schore anchors psychiatry’s unconscious in the earliest human infant–carer relationship, the prototype of all future therapeutic dyads. Developmental trauma, attachment disorder and affective dysregulation are reread not as discrete syndromes but as failures of mutual regulation. Conversely, therapeutic alliance and repair are portrayed as the recreation, a second chance, for conditions of safe and secure attachment, a neuropsychological and ethical act of recognition.
Schore’s contribution thus reframes psychiatry’s oldest question, what it means to be human, in developmental and relational terms. If Freud’s metapsychology was organised around instinctual drives, Schore’s meta-neurobiology is organised around dyadic regulation. The movement from drive to dyad signals a paradigm shift: from intrapsychic conflict to interpersonal synchrony, from repression and dissociation to regulation, from interpretation to presence.
Ultimately, Schore’s closing message resonates beyond the consulting room. The survival of our species, he implies, depends on preserving the right-brain capacities – empathy, repair, attunement – that sustain civilisation itself. The reward for the reader who persists through the book’s density is profound: a re-enchantment of psychiatry with the texture of human relatedness.
In the lineage from Freud to Bowlby to Schore, the once buried unconscious has completed its migration, from the hidden recesses of drive to the lived textures of human relationships.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.