Loren Eiseley likened the scientific enterprise to building an invisible pyramid, where the results from countless pieces of original research are aggregated into a monument to human intellect, ingenuity, and effort (The Invisible Pyramid, 1970). Eiseley may have been paraphrasing Poincaré's observation that “science is built of facts the way a house is built of bricks: but an accumulation of facts is no more science than a pile of bricks is a house.” Theory provides the blueprint for creating knowledge from empirical observation, whether one wants to build pyramids or houses.
A common critique of research in public policy is that it has produced many bricks but no pyramid, or multiple pyramids of varying designs, or even a mixture of pyramids and houses. Twenty years ago, contributors to an exchange in Policy Currents (the former newsletter of the American Political Science Association Public Policy section) despaired about the lack of consensus regarding the study of public policy and whether the problem was that there was too much theory or too little. More recently, the Oxford Handbook of Public Policy described the study of public policy as “a loosely organized body of precepts and positions rather than a tightly integrated body of knowledge” (Robert E. Goodin, Martin Rein, and Michael Moran 2006, p. 5).
Perhaps theoretical parsimony, or even theoretical consistency, is too much to expect from a field where practitioners come from different disciplines (e.g., political science, economics, public administration), reside in different academic units (e.g., academic departments, schools of public policy, schools of public affairs, schools of education, schools of public health), and address widely different questions using different methods. But this heterogeneity in training, questions, and approaches begs the question: Does public policy exist as a distinct field of inquiry in the same way as, say, electoral behavior, political theory, or comparative politics?
Kevin Smith and Christopher Larimer step onto this stage with an ambitious goal: to make sense of the field of public policy by providing a comprehensive, integrative assessment of the theories informing all subfields of policy studies. In The Public Policy Theory Primer, the authors have three aims: 1) to provide a coherent and organized introduction to the field of policy studies, 2) to provide an integrated vision of the field of policy studies, and 3) to contribute to, rather than just report on, professional academic public policy research.
Smith and Larimer succeed admirably in their first goal. The academic study of public policy is dissected into seven subfields—politics and policy, policymakers and policymaking institutions, policy process, policy analysis, policy evaluation, policy implementation, and policy design—with each subfield defined by a set of core research questions. Individual chapters describe the development and content of theories addressing the research questions at the heart of each subfield. Smith and Larimer's classification system for public policy studies is sensible and comprehensive, arguably the best scheme for organizing the field of policy studies in print. Perhaps the only thing missing from their introduction to the field is an explicit recognition of scholarship attempting to develop theories guiding the choice of policy instruments, which is well developed in both economics (e.g., see Thomas Sterner, Policy Instruments for Environmental and Natural Resources Management, 2003) and public administration (e.g., see Lester Salamon, The Tools of Government, 2002; Christopher Hood, The Tools of Government in the Digital Age, 2006).
Smith and Larimer also succeed in their second goal. Their vision of the field of policy studies is descriptive, explanatory, evaluative, and integrative. The descriptive character of their vision is described in the previous paragraph. The vision is explanatory because it accounts for the heterogeneity of theoretical perspectives in the policy field. Policy scholarship is heterodox not simply because researchers focus on different subfields of policy studies but because policy scholars come from different disciplines, are housed in different academic units, and employ different epistemological frameworks. The authors' treatment of this last source of heterogeneity is especially noteworthy. Their juxtaposition of the rationalist and postpositivist approaches to an understanding of public policy is clear (i.e., jargon-free), sophisticated without being technical, and evenhanded. Moreover, they emphasize the perspectives of rationalism and postpositivism throughout most of the book, rather than the traditional practice of applying it only to policy analysis. The vision is evaluative because Smith and Larimer do not simply describe the core theories of policy studies; they assess them with a critical eye, highlighting logical inconsistencies, conceptual ambiguities, and tensions between theoretical expectations and empirical evidence. Finally, the vision is integrative because it illustrates how theory development in the various subfields of policy studies is complementary, and it helps to develop a coherent picture of how scholars make sense of the policy field.
Smith and Larimer are not the first authors to attempt to reconcile disparate theoretical perspectives within public policy. Most previous attempts take the form of anthologies, which commonly make little effort to knit these readings into a compelling narrative of the purpose and contributions of policy research (e.g., see Stella Theodoulou and Matthew Cahn, Public Policy: The Essential Readings, 1995). Less frequently we find volumes providing summaries of theories describing one or more facets of policy studies (e.g., see Paul Sabatier, ed. Theories of the Policy Process, 1999). Even these works fall short of the contribution made by Smith and Larimer in that they 1) typically offer these theories as competitors, making little effort to integrate them into a coherent understanding of public policy, and 2) neglect (by design) broad swaths of policy scholarship that focus on analysis, evaluation, or design. In his book jacket commentary, Bryan Jones sums up Smith and Larimer's contribution here as a tour de force that will be the standard reference on the topic for years to come. Jones is correct, as usual, and I expect that over the next decade, nearly every graduate student in political science and public affairs will be introduced to the field of public policy through the book under review.
Smith and Larimer are less successful in attaining their third stated goal. The Public Policy Primer could contribute to professional public policy research in one of three ways. First, it could report the results of original research testing one or more of the theories so ably summarized and critiqued, but the book contains no original research and little original content other than the taxonomy of policy studies provided in the first chapter. Second, it could provide a systematic synthesis of existing research in order to assess, for example, the weight of the evidence regarding the predictive value of various policy typologies or the theory of punctuated equilibrium. The book takes a different approach, employing the results from previous research in an illustrative manner. Third, the book could contribute a new theory that spans multiple subfields of policy studies. Although the authors provide a useful but brief discussion of the potential embodied in behavioral economics and cognitive psychology for refining policy theory, they derive no new theoretical insights or predictions from this research.
Given the skill, effort, and success displayed in attaining the first two goals, attaining equal success with the third may be too much to ask. While this book does not provide the reader with any new bricks, it does offer a set of blueprints for building a fine house that can accommodate the extended family of policy scholars. It is nice to finally have a place we can all call home.
