This book entitled People with Intellectual Disabilities: Towards a Good Life? poses the question as to whether this goal and all that it implies has ever been achieved, and focuses upon the direction of policies and theoretical debates engaged in by academics and others across the globe over the last forty or so years. Ultimately, any meaning attributed to ‘a good life’ presents a normative view, based on values not on facts.
The authors state that ‘a good life’ is synonymous with a journey and correspondingly appear to doubt the degree to which many people with intellectual disabilities are able to lead a good life. The book is summarised by the authors as an attempt to come to grips with a series of questions ‘that are of great concern to us’ (p. 8) including ‘What are the implications of the idea of a good life for the lives of people with intellectual disabilities?’ and ‘Can and should all people with intellectual disabilities lead the same kind of “good life”?’ This may be a worthy path to follow but unfortunately, in my view, it fails to quite live up to expectations towards pursuing enlightened solutions.
The book is effective in posing questions and therefore is a stimulus to reflection, but its central argument seems somewhat elusive and the overall discourse fragmented. An example of this lies in Chapter 2 entitled ‘Thinking about a good life’ which attempts to deal with questions relating to how a good life is interpreted in Western societies and covers ‘the use of reason’, ‘pleasure, virtue and duty’ and ‘happiness; the never-ending quest?’ (p. 40). These are obviously important concepts, but are given, it would seem, a fairly superficial treatment throughout the text and there is no overarching theme pulling the narrative together, presenting a conclusion frustrating to this reader which begins ‘Humanity seems to be on a never-ending journey in which a good life remains a sought-after but elusive goal’ (p. 47) and so on. The authors then argue that a good life should be focused on the individual and a continuing emphasis on the place of reason and reflection in shaping one's own life, and yet there is need for constraint if people are to live together safely and in harmony (p. 47). The book appears to be making the case that a good life may be more virtuous, spiritual and aesthetic than one which is socially valued, and more importantly is, for example, consistent with such principles as normalisation and social role valorisation which allegedly have influenced service provision and policies this process. Other writers, for example Race (Reference Race2007: 228–30) have tried to demonstrate the fluidity of forces interacting and impacting on the lives of individuals with intellectual disabilities. This author's model which comprises ‘input from shapers of values and experts’, political ideology, government funding, the ‘culture of services’ and ‘services’ desire and ability to carry out policy’ conveys the complexity and dynamic nature of the service systems and presents a more circumspect appraisal of how services etc. impact on the lives of people with intellectual disabilities. Returning to the book, one of the authors (Marie Wolfe) suggests that for her ‘a good life’ is framed around having a home, a job and relationships, which are all eminently desirable and feasible. This portrayal is similarly consistent with ideas developed in a series of influential documents focused on provision for people with intellectual disabilities around the concept of ‘an ordinary life’ and published by the King's Fund Centre (see for instance King's Fund 1980, 1984, 1987, 1988).
Chapter 4, ‘A good life in policy’, begins to examine values relevant to defining a good life which underpin current disability theories, ideas and discourses, along with the contribution which they may have made to the lives of individuals with intellectual disabilities. The authors attempt to deconstruct some of the conceptual and theoretical perspectives, and to argue that the dominant theoretical frameworks of the late twentieth century as applied to practice have not addressed systematically the idea of ‘a good life’ for individuals with intellectual disabilities. However, the presenting analysis of theoretical perspectives is rather brief and incomplete leaving an unfinished and hence distorted picture. Concluding this particular chapter: ‘In all the policy rhetoric about the lives of people with intellectual disabilities a good life rarely features’, and that ‘The failure to define further what an ordinary life or a life like any other might mean leads in [the authors’] view to a focus on the concrete and material in people's lives’ (p. 78). Had they explained a little more coherently how they might expect that the concept of a good life ought to feature in policy discourse and policy outcomes then the argument might appear much sharper. Essentially the components or concepts comprising this adage require unravelling and expansion.
On a positive note, I believe that we do need to be challenged to reflect on what ‘a good life’ entails and this book certainly contributes to this process. My personal view is that it would benefit from deeper analysis − possibly underpinned by empirical research − and a more interlinking structure to reinforce the argument. I am not sure also of the target audience, perhaps not academics, policymakers, students or practitioners; and I feel that it should be the role of the authors to explain this point. Containing such uplifting sentiments as: ‘this book has been an exploration for us’ and ‘it provided us with an opportunity to rethink more long-held assumptions and beliefs’ (p. 171), it may seem slightly churlish to remark on the noticeable unoriginality of some of the book's content. In keeping with the tone of unoriginality, I refer readers to that memorable song of Tony Bennett (1963) similarly pursuing ‘The Good Life’ which goes: ‘Oh the good life, full of fun seems to be the ideal. The good life lets you hide all the sadness you feel . . . It's the good life to be free and explore the unknown, like the heartaches when you learn you must face them alone etc.’ If a so-called ‘good life’ is about integrity, freedom and exploring the unknown, then I am for it.
