Sarah Igo, a professor of History at the University of Pennsylvania, has written a rich, compelling study of the development of surveys and polls in the United States and their role in the creation of the mass public. Concentrating on Robert and Helen Lynds's Middletown community studies of Muncie, Indiana, the development of market research and political polling by George Gallup and Elmo Roper, and the human sexuality surveys of Alfred Kinsey, Igo has demonstrated not only how these works have reflected but, more importantly, molded American culture. She persuasively argues that these instruments played a significant role in the transformation of American society that they were supposedly just measuring dispassionately. Her central question is “(i)n what ways is a society changed by the very tools employed to represent it?” (p. 4). In the United States in the modern age, these have been such empirical methods as graphs and percentages, and their development has been intimately connected with the growth of a mass culture.
Social surveys were hardly new; they were a central aspect of social reform at least since Charles Booth's Life and Labour of the People in London (New York: Macmillan, 1903). Robert, an unordained minister, and his wife Helen chose Muncie as the average American locality because of its low percentage of foreign-born population and by consciously ignoring its significant number of African-Americans. Armed methodologically only with Robert's two graduate classes with Wesley Mitchell, the Lynds and a small research staff pioneered what has become modern survey techniques in searching out ordinary residents and submitting them to intensive and meticulous interviews as well as quantitative analyses of the community's institutions. Whereas Chicago sociology had studied the particular and the deviant, the Lynds sought the average.
In one of Igo's most astute points, she notes that one of the most surprising aspects was the willingness of the people in Muncie and later throughout the country to undergo invasions of their privacy and often, indeed, to demand it. Even as people in Muncie reacted negatively to the criticism of them in Middletown (New York: Harcourt, Brace, and Co., 1929) they gloried in their designation as the representative or, in their take, the ideal American city. Quetelet's statistical search for the average man was transformed into a Middletowner's boast “I am just an average American from an average American city where civilization is at its best” (p. 98). As letters culled from collections of all three surveys noted, Americans simultaneously insisted upon their more complete knowledge yet thoroughly accepted social science techniques and even knowledgeably critiqued them at times.
Igo places these surveyor techniques squarely within the development of a mass society in which the averaged American became the non-ethnic, non-regional Everyman. Even more than today, social critics and ordinary Americans feared the loss of the individual into a standardized aggregate. Yet, the polls and surveys that seemed to most deny their individuality fascinated Americans primarily because they were about them. Igo found innumerable examples in the Gallup and Roper files where the respondent furiously denied the validity of the polls because no one had questioned them. Conversely, while Kinsey certainly received angry letters about alleged rates of homosexuality, masturbation, and female premarital intercourse, most were full of relief and thanks for identifying their behavior as normal. Becoming an averaged American offered potential for fulfillment as well as alienation.
Ironically, all three of Igo's case studies could not predict typical Americans. By moving their study from South Bend to Muncie to avoid foreign-born inhabitants and by eliminating African-Americans, they had assured the atypicality of their study. Gallup and Roper's surveyors found it difficult to locate and interview working-class and minority respondents, and many felt it was unimportant to include such individuals. The collective inability of any of the polls to predict Truman's 1948 re-election reflected such biases. Kinsey, while collecting over 11,000 detailed interviews, rejected probability sampling techniques, because he feared most of the selected individuals would refuse to respond. Those surveyed were often acquaintances of earlier respondents, volunteers, or members of overrepresented groups such as prison inmates and college students. As several scholarly works and even a recent film has noted, the results reflected Kinsey's beliefs and personal behavior and have not corresponded to later studies. Moreover, none of the surveys employed African-Americans or other minorities, and Kinsey refused to hire female interviewers even for Sexual Behavior in the Human Female (Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, 1953).
One significant historical change that these surveys reveal that Igo does not note is their ability to note and measure social change. The Lynds's theoretical turn from sociology to anthropology stemmed in large part from the inability and unwillingness of American sociologists to deal with change even in such a rapidly evolving society as the United States. Middletown in Transition (New York: Harcourt, Brace, and Co., 1937) and all the succeeding Middletown studies were made possible in large part by the Lynds's careful listing of the various questions and techniques they used. Muncie has become significant not so much for its representative quality, but because it has become a social laboratory for social scientists and historians to trace attitudes and behavior over the past 80 years. Similarly, market research and opinion polling were instituted in large part as means of determining shifts in American attitudes and beliefs, permitting one's clients to respond quickly. In 1947 Kinsey established the Kinsey Institute for Research in Sex, Gender, and Reproduction, which has continued to examine sexual behavior for the past 60 years
Proficient in social science theory and techniques, well-read in cultural and political history, indefatigable in mining numerous understudied archives, Igo has demonstrated the cultural significance of social surveys as social science technique, social theory, and cultural history. Her significant work has transcended its apparent unambitious beginnings to speak persuasively and creatively on some of the key issues of the twentieth century in several disciplines.
