Murray Forman's One Night on TV Is Worth Weeks at the Paramount: Popular Music on Early Television reveals the richness of the musical culture that was seen and heard on American television during the 1940s and early 1950s. Forman's wide-ranging and insightful historical research makes audible the alternately dissonant and harmonious intersections of music and television in the years before MTV, the Beatles, or Elvis Presley. Forman's deft analysis of historical materials amounts to a considerable contribution to our knowledge of postwar American popular culture, and the book's theoretical concerns bring television studies, American studies, and popular music studies into a productive dialogue.
One Night on TV fills a historical gap in the various disciplines in which it intervenes. Scholars of popular music have too often fallen prey to what Keir Keightley has called a “boomer historiography” that tends to romanticize the rock ’n’ roll moment at the same time that it disavows rock's commercial status.Footnote 1 Forman addresses such a bias head-on, framing the book in terms of Elvis Presley's iconic 1956 television appearances. Speaking back to John Lennon's famous statement that “before Elvis there was nothing,” Forman carefully lays out the diversity of musical performance that could be found on television in the 1940s and before. Television's “presentational power” may have been “more fully realized in the period after rock ’n’ roll's emergence,” Forman writes, but “transformations of musical performance and broadcasting conventions were already under way” by the time Presley made his small-screen debut (6). While many historians of popular music have taken a “rock-centric” approach to television, television studies scholarship has tended to focus on the rise of MTV in the 1980s and related historical narratives about postmodernism or the industrial moment of cable television. Forman's study brings to light a fascinating history of the visualization of music on television well before video killed the radio star. By making good on his promise to place music and television “on equal footing” in his analysis of their conjoined histories, Forman has found an approach that addresses these shortcomings in television studies and popular-music studies, and makes important contributions to both.
Forman begins with a chapter on the “prehistory” of music on television, in which he shows the role served by musicians during early television experiments of the 1930s and 1940s. This chapter includes a fascinating discussion of the American Federation of Musicians (AFM). The AFM's recording ban of 1942–44 has recently received insightful historical analysis,Footnote 2 but Forman moves into new historical territory in his examination of AFM president James C. Petrillo's 1945 ban on union members making television appearances, which lasted for three years (36–37). The AFM ban sets the stage for chapter 2's coverage of musical “pioneers” on television, in particular amateur shows that flourished in part due to the lack of union talent available to television producers. Forman's analysis of how television musicians navigated the dangers of overexposure and television's ravenous appetite for material provides a useful point of comparison to the experience of the comedians examined by television scholars like Susan Murray and David Marc.Footnote 3
Forman's next chapter takes as its point of departure the idea of “television before television genre,” and the discussion of genre that follows is theoretically informed and makes use of canny historical research. For example, Forman examines the generic categories used by the Emmy Awards between 1948 and 1954 (122–25). In the following chapter on performance, Forman examines how television production demanded that musicians revise their attitudes and find “alternative methods of preparation, rehearsal, and performance.” For one thing, musicians were discouraged from their tendency to play to the studio audience, which was thought to “break an essential contract with TV viewers” (178). Musicians faced both opportunities and risks when adapting their performances to the new medium: they could reach large audiences (see the book's title), but also risked damaging their reputations with fans and fellow musicians. Forman's exploration of how performers negotiated a novel medium provides a useful historical point of reference for our own current era of media convergence and cross-platform synergy.
Forman's final two chapters examine questions of race and musical performance on television. African American musicians found opportunities in the new medium that were welcome contrasts to “the subservient role of the female domestic or the male servant on TV's drama or comedy programs” (233). Forman's analysis ranges from integrated amateur programs to the all-black casts of some local programs, and from pioneering but understudied performers like Bob Howard and Hazel Scott to well-known stars like Sammy Davis Jr. and Nat “King” Cole. Forman concludes that black musicians were “highly engaged in liberating the airwaves and challenging the attitudes and practices” of early television (272). The final chapter on Latino musicians is one of the highlights of the book. Framed in terms of the World War II-era “Good Neighbor” policy and the battle between music publishers, Forman considers a remarkable range of Latino musical culture, including Desi Arnaz's conga playing on I Love Lucy (1951–60), and the “mambo-mania” of the mid-1950s. Television, Forman writes, “constituted a territory or a reservation where Latino identities might be witnessed but where they were also isolated, contained, or safely bracketed from the moral and aesthetic values of the dominant mainstream” (296).
Several themes emerge across One Night on TV's diverse chapters. One has to do with the performative challenges of the new visual medium. It has become a truism that, particularly in the decades since the debut of MTV, popular-music culture has been powerfully visual. Forman shows how, already in the 1940s, “music's aural qualities were regularly subordinated to the scopic pleasures offered by handsome male and beguiling female performers or to the spectacular production numbers that quickly became television staples” (31). Musicians struggled with this new visual emphasis, and often resented the need to develop “visually excessive” television shticks, referring to them dismissively as “funny hats routines” (176, 223–24). A second, more implicit, theme of the book concerns the relationship between the television studio and a range of other performance spaces. At various points in the manuscript, Forman touches upon television's economic impact on nightclubs, the replacement of musicians and jukeboxes by television sets in bars and taverns, the relative economics of television and touring, the use of nightclub settings for TV broadcasts, and the regimes of ethnic caricature to be found on the vaudeville stage and on television. This fascinating lattice of reference to performance spaces might have been further developed, perhaps through reference to work on the history of the nightclub and cabaret, or recent work on cinematic spaces.Footnote 4
The book's conclusion, of course, is the place where one might expect that kind of theoretical synthesis to occur, and Forman's concluding chapter is, in fact, a little disappointing. Forman closes with a return to the opening frame of Elvis Presley's iconic television appearances, and then to the Beatles. This is all well and good, but what follows is a rapid-fire overview of music and television since the 1960s, which includes references to Donny and Marie Osmond, Don Kirshner's Rock Concert, Saturday Night Live, cable television in the 1980s and 1990s, Glee, American Idol, music on YouTube, and music-based videogames like Guitar Hero. Forman wrings insights from all of these topics, but after the careful historical analysis that came before, the conclusion can feel a bit like running through the Louvre. Furthermore, because Forman has made such a convincing case that “before Elvis” there was indeed something, the reader craves a stronger summary of the key aspects of the early period of television on its own terms. It is a testament to the persuasiveness of argument that the reader wants to linger on the early period rather than push the fast-forward button.
Such small complaints about the conclusion are dwarfed, however, in comparison with the larger achievement of One Night on TV. At one point, Forman praises the singer Peggy Lee for a 1954 appearance on The Colgate Comedy Hour that managed to incorporate diverse musical styles in a “sublime” performance that was in perfect sync with the televisual medium (207–8). One Night on TV stands as a similarly assured performance, one that speaks to diverse scholarship in the fields of American studies, television studies, and popular-music studies, and reminds us that television has always been tele-audio-vision.
