In this book, Matthew E. Carnes seeks to explain why the provisions of Latin American labour laws differ across economic sectors and among countries, why the content of these laws has remained remarkably constant despite far-reaching processes of market-centred economic reform since the 1980s and, more broadly, how law and public policies can create persistent divisions among workers that in some instances worsen socio-economic inequality. He argues that differences in labour law provisions are due principally to variations in the distribution of skills in the economy and in the collective organisational strength of unionised workers. Of these two factors, ‘skill distributions are the key to understanding long-term labor law configurations, while the political-organizational capacity of labor explains the short- and medium-term changes and developments in particular labor law measures’ (p. 71).
It is not surprising that the content of labour legislation varies across countries. Nor is it unexpected that better organised, more politically influential labour movements generally succeed in securing stronger collective rights than their weaker counterparts do. It is much more novel to highlight cross-sectional differences in labour code provisions within a particular country, which Carnes attributes to variations in worker skill levels. He makes an especially valuable contribution by demonstrating that the strength of individual labour protections (those legal provisions governing such matters as the hiring, dismissal and workplace treatment of individual workers) and the strength of collective labour measures (those provisions regulating unionisation and collective bargaining by unions) do not always vary together. His empirical contributions include a systematic comparison of the content of both individual labour contract laws and collective labour laws across 18 Latin American countries from the 1980s through the 2000s.
Attention to the impact of structural economic factors on labour law content is a significant advance beyond the unidimensional ‘political incorporation’ explanation of labour law adoption proposed by Ruth Berins Collier and David Collier (Shaping the Political Arena: Critical Junctures, the Labor Movement, and Regime Dynamics in Latin America, Princeton University Press, 1991). These elements account well for some of the legislative provisions (for example, those distinguishing between blue-collar obreros and white-collar empleados) adopted in different Latin American countries in the early twentieth century, when workers in leading economic activities (mining and petroleum production, railways and shipping, early manufacturing industries) often shaped labour codes in ways that reflected their particular market-based bargaining advantages.
Although economic factors certainly played a role in the early development of labour law in the region, and some reforms since the 1980s have sought to address such labour market shifts as growth in the informal sector by expanding provisions for short-term and probationary employment contracts, Carnes's reference to structural economic conditions to explain continuity or change in labour law content is not always persuasive. It is, for instance, difficult to accept – and certainly none of his empirical materials directly supports – his theory-deduced contention that, because ‘Over the medium to long term, skills condition the feasible set of labor law measures’, ‘out-of-equilibrium outcomes will not last long’ (p. 36). At times, Carnes too quickly (and selectively) asserts structural economic factors as an all-encompassing explanation for complex legislative outcomes. For example, even though he highlights political and ideological motivations in his discussion of General Augusto Pinochet's radical reversal of the enhanced collective labour rights granted by Chile's Salvador Allende, Carnes concludes that the Allende reforms were short lived because they disrupted ‘the congruence of the labor code with the ongoing structural economic features of the country’ (p. 124). Similarly, he attributes organised labour's recovery of various Peronist-era legal privileges under the presidency of Raúl Alfonsín to Argentina's ‘relatively skilled labor force … the ongoing organization of workers in key sectors, combined with the development goals of the nation’ (p. 175), without any in-depth investigation of the specific political and economic factors underpinning this development.
The author's principal focus is, quite appropriately, on the domestic economic and political sources of labour law. However, Carnes might also have explored more fully international influences on both the formulation of labour laws and continuity in their provisions over time. The architects of early Latin American labour codes sometimes drew heavily upon the experiences of Western Europe and other Latin American countries in designing domestic legislation, and formal adhesion to International Labour Organisation conventions (which, when formally adopted, have treaty status) may constrain efforts to weaken worker protections in some areas. Moreover, proposals to downgrade significantly the protections offered by domestic legislation may become the focus of cross-national labour rights mobilisation in countries that are members of the Mercado Común del Sur (MERCOSUR), the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and post-NAFTA free-trade agreements with the United States.
Carnes notes that labour law enforcement is a persistent problem throughout much of Latin America, especially where workers employed in the informal sector are concerned. Indeed, where strong legal defences of employment stability are effectively enforced, employers may find it financially beneficial to promote various short-term and informal hiring arrangements. Yet in considering the reasons why formal labour legislation in most Latin American countries has not changed significantly since the 1980s despite radical industrial restructuring and intense international economic competition, Carnes does not sufficiently consider the possibility that business interests in some countries have found less need to promote labour legislation ‘flexibilisation’ because of their ability to evade the provisions of existing laws.
This book is well-written, clearly argued and systematic in its analytic approach, combining both statistical analyses of labour law content across 18 countries and historical case studies of Argentina, Chile and Peru. By examining labour law across the region and over an extended period of time, Carnes makes a valuable contribution to the study of Latin American labour affairs.
