While the Internet promotes cross-border accessibility, it also generates increased conflicts between jurisdictions. As a result of the Internet's amorphous nature, legal uncertainty abounds with respect to which state has jurisdiction to adjudicate disputes arising from Internet activities that potentially transcend borders, which jurisdiction's law to apply, and the enforceability of judgments issued abroad. Dan Svantesson's second edition of Private International Law and the Internet is a timely reference tool that offers a comprehensive overview of Internet-related private international law issues, and in-depth comparative analyses of such issues in a variety of notable jurisdictions. Apart from an update of legislative developments and case-law since this book was first published in 2007, this second edition has also expanded its jurisdictional analyses to include China. Additionally, Dan Svantesson has also included a section dedicated to geo-location, which, he proposes, has utility in resolving the Internet-related private international law issues he identifies in his book.
In setting the stage to discuss how Internet activities warrant a change to the current state of private international law rules, Svantesson employs a very organized approach under which each chapter builds upon the preceding chapters. Overall, Svantesson strikes a good balance in apportioning attention to the background of the subject, critical discussion of the issue, and suggestions for change. In the early chapters, he discusses various Internet activities, their associated characteristics, and their impact on rules of private international law. As with many things, the Internet presents a double-edged sword, with its users enjoying the benefits of borderless connectivity while it opens itself up to the difficulty of resolving cross-border disputes. The author's proposition that the challenge of finding a straightforward resolution is dependent on the construct of private international law rules then leads him to identify desirable qualities that good private international law should implement.
In the middle chapters, Svantesson provides a broad-based comparison of private international law across seven jurisdictions, namely, Australia, England, Germany, Hong Kong SAR, China, Sweden, and the US. The jurisdictional analyses are conducted with a focus on the key areas of cross-border defamation, contracts, and trademarks, and set out the relevant rules in each jurisdiction. Finally, in the later chapters, he includes a discussion of the relevant rules that have arisen from international co-operative efforts to facilitate the resolution of cross-border conflicts. He provides summaries and excerpts of conventions and treaties that have had an impact on private international law issues, before presenting his Model Conventions for defamation and contracts.
In conclusion, Svantesson's Private International Law and the Internet is a useful primer for academics, lawyers, and those who seek a foundational grounding of the issues that arise when adjudicating disputes stemming from Internet-related activities. While he has highlighted the need for private international law to be further modified in order to adequately address the jurisdictional conflicts Internet-related activities raise, he also recognizes the need for current legal practitioners to navigate the present grey area that is the crossroads between the Internet and private international law. Accordingly, as an aid to those in need of immediate help, Svantesson provides in the appendices handy checklists flagging particularly important issues relevant to drafters of online agreements, potential litigants, and potential defendants.
