Constructing Citizenship significantly expands earlier ‘postrevisionist’ analyses on political culture in two ways: it incorporates the rural worker, as well as the peasantry and the schoolteacher, into the discussion, and it demonstrates how transnational spaces add another dimension to the construction of nationality. The author deftly applies transnationalism, postrevisionism, ‘new’ labour history and cultural citizenship to analyse how and why rural workers and peasants, coffee planters and government officials construct nationality and citizenship along the Mexico–Guatemala border to meet their own needs. The principal argument is that peasants and rural labourers ‘used changing definitions of citizenship both to combat the intense oppression they experienced and eventually to gain access to revolutionary reforms’ (p. 2).
This study of postrevolutionary state formation and its relationship with shifting and multivalent forms of citizenship is loosely framed around three historical periods that are linked to major transformations in Mexico. A few times the organisational components of state-building are lost in the midst of constructing citizenship, although this does not ultimately distract the reader from the author's major argument. To make Soconusco ‘Mexican’, Porfirian officials as well as revolutionary generals between 1880 and 1920 had to establish national boundaries, promote capitalist export agriculture, encourage white European immigration and accelerate state formation by allying with local elites. This well-known top-down, racist vision of national integration was contested, contends the author, by workers who sought alliances with federal officials and employed ‘weapons of the weak’ to challenge coffee planters’ control over debt servitude. In the early postrevolutionary period (1920–34), the Mexican revolutionary state's inability to implement labour or agrarian reforms meant that the rural poor made little headway in challenging land tenure and labour relations. Nevertheless, the author shows how Mexican and Guatemalan rural workers began to construct their own identity by claiming Mexican nationality in order to demand the land rights and minimum wage guaranteed under the Constitution of 1917. The final period encompassing the years from 1935 to 1947 witnessed the passage of key federal labour, agrarian and educational reforms, an increasingly depressed international coffee market and the state's sequestration of German-owned fincas. These external factors energised the rural poor to challenge coffee elite hegemony more successfully.
Controlling workers, enforcing borders and maintaining a viable coffee plantation economy became more difficult in the 1930s, as Presidents Lázaro Cárdenas and Jorge Ubico strove to centralise federal power in their respective countries. State officials, planters and workers alike sought to control definitions of citizenship to meet their own particular needs in the transnational region, where workers, smuggled goods and ideologies were crossing the border with increasing rapidity. On both sides of the border the state sought to tighten border and worker control by imposing a modern Mexican-ness and Guatemalan-ness based on mesticisation, language and ‘modern’ dress. Meanwhile German planters on both sides of the border manipulated their own nationality and that of their workers to retain control over their land and labour resources, ensure themselves the protection of the state and undermine labour activism.
Building upon state formation studies on Chiapas, Sonora, Michoacán, Puebla and Yucatán, Nolan-Ferrell contends that the growth of the federal bureaucracy under President Cárdenas brought only limited rural reforms to Chiapas, but it jump-started the Mexicanisation of the rural poor. Her extensive research in a broad range of national, state and local archives in Mexico and Guatemala and her oral histories provide wonderful examples of the agency and rhetoric of the rural poor. Unlike these other states, local campesino and labour activists developed direct alliances with federal bureaucrats, due to the absence of caciquismo, the presence of strong planter resistance and the compromised position of middle-level officials. At certain times it is difficult to discern whether illiterate indigenous workers were actually initiating petitions, land invasions and strikes on their own, or whether Cardenista activists were instructing them on how to do so. By and large negotiations with Agrarian Department officials were more productive than those with newly formed regional labour and peasant organisations in achieving the first surge in provisional land resolutions in the late 1930s.
Not until the author's discussion of transnational community identity based on place, space, shared experiences and nationality in chapter 4 does the reader begin to comprehend the real heterogeneity and genuine agency of the rural poor in their claims to revolutionary rights. They are not simply rural workers and peasants, but rather resident peons, temporary workers, processing plant workers, minifundistas, sharecroppers and tenant farmers petitioning for land grants, the right to unionise, and increases in depressed wages. The author relies on Rogers Brubaker and Frederick Cooper's concept of the relational identification process to explain the construction of citizenship, based on shared work, kinship and community experiences. Conflicts over access to land within and outside the coffee fincas often pitted resident peons or peasants against temporary workers living in independent communities. Compared to central Veracruz, where coffee processing took place in urban beneficios far from the fincas, with a different seasonal labour force, Soconusco's labour system exacerbated far more tensions between peasants and workers.
A specific focus on the 1941–6 war period is particularly significant because the author is recasting the commonly held view that President Manuel Avila Camacho's shift to the support of agricultural production led to the slowing of rural reform. In the Soconusco coffee belt, grassroots organisers perfected the rhetoric of revolutionary justice and claims to Mexican nationality. Mexico's entrance into the war and its seizure of all German properties undoubtedly weakened the coffee elite and strengthened campesino resolve to demand lands owned by foreign enemies of the state. What is most revealing is that the state labour arbitration board was now much more responsive than the Agrarian Department to negotiation, and supported the formation of a regional collective contract for all coffee workers. Nevertheless, intra- and inter-community conflicts between peasants and workers hindered rural labour unity and the implementation of major structural reforms.
What clearly distinguishes this book from earlier studies on Latin American state formation is its fascinating transnational analysis of Guatemalan and Mexican worker rhetoric and agency. Although the legacy of constructing citizenship along the border is almost absent in today's younger generation, the author hopes that Central American migrants, Lacandon colonists and Soconusco residents can acquire the same sense of empowerment and legitimacy to negotiate a new form of the postrevolutionary state.
