No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
Claire Culleton's study of working-class women in First World War Britain is an ambitious project that aims at a “comprehensive analysis of the complexities that conspired to link women's lives, their work, and their writings” (8). The book is positioned as a study that redresses what Culleton views as the marginalization of working-class women's experience in historical and literary studies of the period. She attempts, therefore, to write a history “from below” that provides both historical analysis of the experience of working-class women who labored in Britain's wartime industries, and an analysis of their culture, as revealed through the 1970s oral history testimonies of the Imperial War Museum and the literature they produced for factory newspapers. She states that she will tie this experience and its “costs” to changes in British society that “no longer permit[ed] sentimentality of hearth and home ( . . . )” (2). Culleton notes that the book is aimed at specialists on the subject and general readers. The analysis presented in the book, however, falls short of the author's stated goals and adds little to the existing scholarship on working-class women in First World War Britain.
Claire Culleton's study of working-class women in First World War Britain is an ambitious project that aims at a “comprehensive analysis of the complexities that conspired to link women's lives, their work, and their writings” (8). The book is positioned as a study that redresses what Culleton views as the marginalization of working-class women's experience in historical and literary studies of the period. She attempts, therefore, to write a history “from below” that provides both historical analysis of the experience of working-class women who labored in Britain's wartime industries, and an analysis of their culture, as revealed through the 1970s oral history testimonies of the Imperial War Museum and the literature they produced for factory newspapers. She states that she will tie this experience and its “costs” to changes in British society that “no longer permit[ed] sentimentality of hearth and home ( . . . )” (2). Culleton notes that the book is aimed at specialists on the subject and general readers. The analysis presented in the book, however, falls short of the author's stated goals and adds little to the existing scholarship on working-class women in First World War Britain.
The first three chapters of the book provide an overview of working conditions and negative public reactions to women's factory labor. Culleton's analysis relies on the scholarship of Gail Braybon, Angela Woollacott, Gareth Griffiths, and Jane Lewis. Culleton views factory work during the First World War as marking the beginning of working-class women's “social and cultural autonomy” (22), and she therefore attempts to examine why women wanted to work in wartime industries and to stay in their jobs after 1918. The content of these chapters, however, does not reveal this concept of women's autonomy. Furthermore, she attempts to deal with numerous topics, such as women's political apathy, unionization, women's training for skilled work, male worker hostility, and dangerous working conditions in such a brief space that it does not permit her to fully develop the historical contextualization of such issues or to fully answer the questions she poses. With regard to why women wanted to remain in their jobs after 1918, she cites the skills women learned through their “mass entry into skilled work” (33). This statement is problematic, since the majority of women working in munitions industries were employed in unskilled jobs as a result of the process of dilution, a facet of the wartime labor force examined by Braybon and Woollacott. Her examination of women's work experience in these chapters also needs to make differentiations among women new to the workforce and those for whom war work was just another kind of labor outside the home. Culleton's conclusion concerning the impact of wartime labor on working-class women, that they derived a “sense of achievement and agency outside the confines of the home” (32), is a conclusion arrived at as well by other authors on the subject.
Although Culleton's presentation of wartime working conditions and the public disapproval of their work and spending habits breaks no new ground for those familiar with the subject, she does offer an interesting line of inquiry with regard to her brief discussion of Irish women's labor in British factories. Here, Culleton seeks to describe the difficult position of Irish working-class women, who were perceived as unruly and dirty by their British co-workers. Culleton calls attention to this neglected area of research, and poses fruitful lines of inquiry for analyzing the conjunction of ethnicity, class, and gender in war and for making important distinctions with regard to women's wartime experiences.
Culleton, a professor of English, also reveals an interest in revising scholarship on the literary culture of the First World War, and she attempts to do so by “revising [Paul] Fussell's portrait of a literary landscape dominated by men” and by “moving the frame away from middle-class women” (7). This interest in literary analysis is represented in chapter four, which presents the most original analysis in the book. Culleton conducts a textual analysis of factory newspapers and magazines produced by working-class women. She argues that these writings were “political manifestos” (102) because through their literary production, the women writers criticized their working conditions, lamented the loss of co-workers, spoke out against injustice in the workplace, and communicated their frustrations with the war effort. Written in response to male soldiers' trench newspapers, the women's newspapers and magazines represented literary modernism. Culleton focuses on versions of “The Walrus and the Carpenter” and Kipling's “If.” The women's versions demonstrate women's appropriation of this literary form to express their wartime experience in a way parallel to, yet distinct from, that of male soldiers at the front.
The remaining chapters of the book provide limited discussion of the Defense of the Realm Act (DORA), the links between women's factory work and pronatalism as it emerged during the war, and postwar demobilization. With regard to the virulent pronatalism that developed as a reaction to mass slaughter on the battlefield, Culleton tries to show the connection between the social construction of women's factory labor as a maternal and sexualized activity, and the subsequent attempt to urge women to “no longer fill the wombs of shells but to fill their own wombs instead” (149) in order to make way for returning soldiers. Her analysis here is not particular to working-class women, for she offers evidence that this kind of pronatalist rhetoric applied to middle class women in the factories as well. Women's work was constructed as sexual intercourse, with women “mastering” large machinery and working with phallic objects, all as part of a “perverted and deviant maternal act” (161). Such rhetoric facilitated demands to remove women from the workforce when the war was over.
The tone of Culleton's writing is often indignant. She expresses a sense of moral outrage at the treatment of working-class women in the workplace, particularly with regard to the lack of attention they received for their work-related ailments, such as TNT poisoning. For instance, in concluding her chapter on the often dangerous working conditions existing in wartime factories, she declares that “had more attention been paid to these issues, instead of focusing on what the women work, purchased, or drank, literally hundreds, maybe even thousands, of women's lives might have been saved ( . . . )” (73). She also decries the lack of proper scholarly attention to the issue of why working-class women's maternal morality rates rose, and rather dismisses the findings of J.M. Winter, who attributes the rise to the influenza epidemic of 1918. Culleton instead speculates that “a scandalous area of neglect,” (164) meaning the lack of attention to women's working conditions and the dangers thereof, is rather to blame. Unfortunately, such assertions serve to work against her goal, as stated in her conclusion, that she wishes to move beyond the “new mythology” (170) of women portrayed primarily as victims of war.
Culleton strongly champions the cause of these working-class women in this project. The book does point to areas of women's agency, such as the factory newspapers, that deserve greater scholarly attention. A more in depth analysis of those sources would have been welcomed, as would a more developed discussion of the complexities of ethnicity as represented by the case of Irish working women. In those two aspects, Culleton is able to make a contribution to our understanding of working women's experience during the First World War. Overall, however, the book lies uneasily between literary text analysis and a fully contextualized and dispassionate historical study.