Not long ago in Lima I was approached by a young woman I knew as an employee in the house where I was staying, who asked if I would buy some costume jewellery that she was selling to friends and acquaintances during her spare time. I agreed to buy an inexpensive pair of earrings and expressed interest in seeing the catalogue of items she had to offer. Although I had carried out research in the past on women in Peru's informal sector, this rather hidden area of work had never before caught my attention.
Direct sales of products by companies like Amway, Avon and a host of others are a widespread phenomenon in the era of neoliberal globalisation. The evident flexibility of hours and conditions of employment are often appealing to women who are balancing family and work and who have few desirable alternatives. In Guayaquil in Ecuador, women (and some men) are attracted to a transnational corporation, Yanbal, and its sales of make-up, jewellery and perfume, by the glamour of luxury goods that are affordable to many, and by the middle-class appearance they are encouraged to adopt on the job when selling these goods.
A number of analysts have sought to challenge the advantage that such work confers, suggesting that direct sales companies seek out vulnerable populations and gain their profits through terms of employment that require hard work without formal benefits and secure incomes. In Making Up the Difference, Erynn Masi de Casanova acknowledges the downside of such employment, but offers a more complex account of the ways in which women navigate the world of direct sales. The result is an important and engaging book that should be read by all who are interested in gender, family and employment in Latin America – and particularly by those interested in this growing area of work that straddles the formal/informal divide.
After introducing her book's topic, Casanova presents seven substantive chapters that take up a range of questions from a feminist sociological perspective. In part I, two chapters examine the challenge for women in direct sales to ‘multiply’ themselves and meet the demands of work, husbands and children. Her interviews with 34 Yanbal directors and consultants included women whose husbands either opposed or were supportive of women's initiative to go out and work, some expressing jealousy of the women being on the street to work, and others (often reluctantly) showing appreciation or even assisting their wives, who were contributing to household budgets. While her sample size is small, the fine-grained analysis of particular women's lives lends authority to this qualitative research.
Part II devotes chapters to representations of racialised beauty in Yanbal's highly effective catalogues, the Yanbal image and expectations of sellers' professionalism, and the use of prizes as incentives to women to sell more. This emphasis on the power of image, not only to sell products but also to shape the labour force, complements the earlier chapters' attention to the everyday conditions of Yanbal workers. Moreover, Casanova's discussion of this area of employment as ‘care’ work and of the role of the body in selling Yanbal products places the book in productive conversation with current feminist theory and research. Her findings demonstrate that, notwithstanding the imagery, personal transformation is modest and climbing up the career ladder is the exception rather than the rule.
In part III, Casanova asks the provocative hypothetical question: what would these workers be doing if they weren't selling beauty products? Although the question is impossible to answer with any certainty, raising it allows her to argue that direct sales is a key part of the mosaic of economic activities that many women depend upon in order to get by. In the final chapters, deeper insights into the workings of direct sales support Casanova's contention that even if sellers experience tension in managing the demands of Yanbal along with their domestic responsibilities, the increasing numbers of women and men who participate are not simply the dupes of global capitalism but are often finding ways to use direct sales to improve their lives and livelihoods.
This sociological case study is especially successful in presenting rich narratives from women's lives, drawing on a close ethnographic study conducted during the past decade. Casanova shows that to understand the labour process of this largely female workforce it is necessary to follow the movements of women over the course of their day, from early rising to meet family needs, to reviewing the Yanbal catalogue for specialised knowledge of the company's products, to the hours spent in locating customers to make sales and collect payments. Casanova resorts to neither an exposé of corporate capitalism nor a celebration of women's ingenuity (though she considers elements of both) in this area of employment, which is open to virtually anyone willing to engage in the long hours and hard work of direct sales. She offers a nuanced and thoughtful interpretation, set in the context of Ecuador's recent history and economic development. Furthermore, in her reflexive preface and appendix, she positions herself as a gringa from the United States married to an Ecuadorean whose aunt is a Yanbal sales director, appreciating both the opportunity and the tension this may have produced.
Finally, Casanova's work unsettles any easy notion that Yanbalistas are middle-class housewives making easy pocket money for household extras, a view expressed even by the Ecuadorean president, Rafael Correa, who stated that raising taxes on the goods they sell would not have much effect on su platita, the little bit of money they earn. Her rich ethnographic account offers a vivid alternative to this view, revealing lives that are not as glamorous or high-paying as advertised, nor as incidental to household incomes. Making Up the Difference shows these direct sales workers to be individuals who are struggling in the face of inadequate employment opportunities, and in doing so are gaining self-esteem and making essential contributions to family earnings. Casanova's keen attention to gendered economic strategies, cultural norms and material conditions makes this a most welcome addition to the scholarship on women and work in Latin America.
