The editors are at once accurate and overmodest in their assessment in the Introduction about what this volume on Balthasar accomplishes. They are accurate in their view that while the volume has a wide topical and disciplinary range, it is not absolutely comprehensive. They are accurate also in their assertion that while multiple voices are represented, not every possible voice is put in play. They also are right in understanding the volume to present rather than explain Balthasar. Still, in this ascesis lurks the danger of underselling a volume that instantiates the not always compatible qualities of being distinguished and useful. Despite or rather because of the multiple soundings of Balthasar's work its symphonic character comes into view. Each sounding – which is also a sighting – manages to render transparent some aspect of the overall Balthasarian phenomenon. Almost all of the essays persuade that they are the fruit of serious engagement with the texts of Balthasar and fundamentally respectful – if not uncritically so – of his oeuvre as a whole. Moreover, with few exceptions each essay accomplishes its task of illumination with economy, lucidity and grace. Finally, there is the soundness of the principle of organisation. The fourfold division of labour into the theological topics in Balthasar's work, the disciplines that he engages, the compendious outlines of each of the three parts of the trilogy, and reflections on his contemporary theological significance make sense and contribute immensely to the coherence of the volume.
Although each of the four parts is important, nonetheless some are more equal than others. Part One is obviously first among equals since it contains just about half of the essays of the volume (nine). It has as its bookends Larry Chapp's admirably concise and probing essay on Revelation and Geoffrey Wainwright's piece on eschatology in Balthasar. In different ways both essays manage to bring out the close relation between Balthasar and the theological tradition on these topics as well as his relative uniqueness. Fully appreciating Balthasar's embeddedness in the tradition, Chapp makes a convincing case that, with respect to overall theological orientation, Balthasar should be considered to be irreducibly contemporary even as, or especially as, Balthasar makes a decision to throw aside the apologetic stance of much of modern theology and articulate a theology that argues from rather than towards Christ as the ‘concrete universal’. Within the revelation-eschatology frame it is obvious that the real focus – as it has to be with Balthasar – is christological and trinitarian. Mark McIntosh and Rowan Williams have the unenviable task of offering synoptic accounts of Balthasar's Christology and trinitarian thought respectively. If it is true that in Balthasar's work the threads of theological topics constitutionally tend to interweave, this is even more true of Christology and Trinity. Both McIntosh and Williams perform admirably. McIntosh provides a developmental account of Balthasar's Christology beginning with Balthasar's early work on Nyssa and Maximus and stretching to the trilogy. The essay essentially makes two contributions. First, it emphasises how the dynamic categories of mission and obedience contribute to an understanding of the person of Christ. Second, the essay highlights how this understanding shapes, informs and constructs the self who comes to participate in the divine life of the Trinity. With typical eloquence Williams explores the trinitarian dimensions of Balthasar's thought. Recognising with McIntosh that, in Balthasar, christological and trinitarian thought mutually implicate each other, Williams focuses on the Trinity to the extent to which it provides the horizon of Holy Saturday. He does more, however, than provide a trinitarian frame for Christology. He shows clearly how Balthasar moves from the economic to the immanent Trinity, raises the issue of divine passibility, but does not pace Moltmann settle it. If the world ‘enriches’ God, it does so in such a way as not to compromise the axiom that God is fully God without the world.
The essays that follow are devoted to ecclesiology, mariology and theological anthropology. In their fine essay on Balthasar's concept of the church, Nicholas Healy and David Schindler offer an interpretation that is at once trinitarian in its widest dimension and focally christological. Calling on a variety of texts, Healy and Schindler argue that Balthasar's ecclesiology is fundamentally eucharistic and thus the opposite of the regnant liberal view of an organisation subject to sociological or political interpretation. Since the church, for Balthasar, is the church of saints, and a reality constituted by Mary's amen, it makes sense that essays on the saints and on Mary follow. David Moss's essay on the saints proves convincingly that Balthasar's embracing of the saints is no mere concession to popular piety, but rather a recognition that ‘saints’ are theological sources. They effect, enact and perform theology to the extent to which they express and participate in the paradigmatic obedience of Christ. Although they overlap thematically and render similar criticisms, Lucy Gardiner's essay on Balthasar's avowal of Mary and Corinne Crammer's essay on Balthasar's sexual difference represent studies in contrast. After a subtle, far-reaching and largely sympathetic presentation of the symbols and theology of Mary in Balthasar's work, Gardiner concludes by raising questions about Balthasar's understanding of sexual difference, and inviting discussion as to whether its shortcomings are repairable within the horizon of Balthasar's thought. By contrast Crammer argues from the conclusion that Balthasar is profoundly mistaken on this account. Such position-taking is not in itself surprising, since Balthasar's view of sexual difference is highly controversial. Still, given its profound lack of sympathy for Balthasar, Crammer's piece strikes a discordant note.
Although the coverage of the theological topics covered in Part One is large, there are lacunae. For instance, Part One lacks any express treatment of creation, or for that matter of nature and grace. As with Balthasar himself, however, these themes tend to get snagged in the threads of the other topics. Moreover, they are referred to from time to time in the other three parts. The topic of creation is central in Fergus Kerr's treatment, in Part Three, of the relation of Balthasar's thought to philosophy. In what essentially amounts to a three-way conversation between Balthasar, Aquinas and Heidegger, Kerr judges that no matter how close Balthasar hugs the Heideggerian shore, in the end he supports Aquinas's distinction between essence and existence. Similarly, Oliver Davies broaches the topic of the relation of nature and grace in his treatment of Balthasar's theological aesthetics in Part Two. He recognises that Balthasar wants to avail himself of the analogy of beauty to explicate divine glory, while disciplining aesthetics through Christ, who is the prime analogate of aesthetics, and through whom we can espy trinitarian love as the ultimate horizon of reality. By contrast the other two essays in Part Two on Theo-Drama and Theo-Logic respectively articulate Balthasar's christological and trinitarian centre. In his account of Theo-Drama Ben Quash emphasises how the hypostatic union represents at once the coincidence of infinite and finite freedom, obedience and spontaneity, and how it opens up the trinitarian stage that embraces all of reality. Although Aidan Nichols obligingly says something about the more philosophical first volume of Theo-Logic, it is evident that his real interest lies in Balthasar's trinitarian thought as this is articulated by Balthasar in the second and third volumes. This essay complements perfectly Rowan Williams's essay in its focus on the trinitarian horizon of the kenosis of the Son and on the role and nature of the Spirit.
The remaining essays in Part Three, which concern Balthasar's relation to the disciplines, are uniformly of a high standard. Brian Daley's essay on the relation between Balthasar and the church fathers manages with the minimum of fuss to be extraordinarily comprehensive. Daley sums up elegantly Balthasar's understanding of Nyssa, Maximus, Irenaeus, Deny and Augustine, while making the point that Balthasar is ever the interested reader who reads with one or more eyes turned towards the present. Obviously, Balthasar's retrieval of patristic sources goes hand in hand with a hermeneutic of scripture that is just the opposite of the contemporary hermeneutic practice. In his essay on this topic Tom Dickens paints the portrait of Balthasar as intervening in contemporary hermeneutics, even as he appeals to older, more holistic and more christologically regulated models of exegesis. One of the most interesting essays in the whole volume is Ed Brock's essay on Balthasar and literary criticism. What makes this essay so fine is that Brock traces Balthasar's actual literary criticism of writers such as Claudel, Bernanos, Eichendorff, Goethe and Shakespeare. This interpretive procedure, which keeps Balthasar's more general reflections on aesthetics in brackets, has two benefits: on the one hand, it encourages literary critics to read Balthasar and, on the other, reading Balthasar's literary criticism can point beyond itself towards an aesthetic, even a theological aesthetic.
Edward Oakes's essay that brings the volume to a close echoes the Introduction. Its overt form is that of a prognostication of whether an emergent Balthasar will stay the course, but in very Balthasarian fashion it refuses the charge. But if one cannot know, one can hope. And it is obvious where Oakes's hopes rest. No volume would be complete without comment on the relations between Balthasar and Rahner, on the one hand, and Balthasar and Barth on the other. Karen Kilby's essay on the relation between Rahner and Balthasar essentially takes the form of a redress. She wishes to correct the influential picture of a titanic battle between two essentially incommensurable theological paradigms. She approaches her task from two angles. The first involves getting beyond the somewhat inflamed rhetoric characteristic of the transcendental and Balthasarian camps with respect to the relation of nature and grace to uncover the continuities. The second involves correcting the foundationalist stereotype of Rahner. In his essay on the relation between Balthasar and Barth, John Webster faces just the opposite difficulty to Kilby. If the difficulty for Kilby is that Balthasar and Rahner are presumed to be further apart than they are, the difficulty for Webster is that Balthasar and Barth are presumed to be closer than they actually are. Webster judges with Barth against the prospect of mediating analogia entis with analogia fidei, no matter how much the former is revised and refined.
This volume is much more tightly wrought than is usual for a collection of essays. This coherence is enhanced both by the organisation of the text and by the tone of the pieces. Where criticism occurs, it rarely jars. At the same time this volume provides a valuable service in admitting criticism and not indulging in haliolatry. If there is a growing consensus about Balthasar's general importance for theology, there remains considerable debate as to how important his work is, and even more concerning whether his style of theology represents the future. The very conflict of interpretation verifies Balthasar's own dramatic interpretation of history in which value is seen only from a retrospective point of view, or perhaps ultimately only from an eschatological point of view.
