This volume is part of the “Ancient Philosophies” series created by the University of California Press as introductory textbooks for college students. The clarity and energy of Professor Desmond's prose are well suited to this task and the book is a pleasure to read. Any professor of philosophy, political philosophy, classics, or intellectual history intent on introducing the philosophy of Cynicism in the undergraduate classroom would do well to consider its adoption.
The considerable virtues of this volume are accentuated by the same scholarly trend that has transformed the study of other classical authors such as Xenophon, Plato, and Aristotle: the disintegration of the stifling authority of nineteenth-century scholarship. As recently as the mid-1980s, for example, the failure to include a detailed rehearsal of nineteenth-century academic debates was ground for dismissal of any attempt to understand the texts of ancient authors (e.g., Myles Burnyeat, “Sphinx Without a Secret,” New York Review of Books, 30 May 1985). Desmond's presentation of the large group of authors known as the Cynics is all the more accessible because he can present them as they presented themselves rather than placing them in pre-made categories (4) or displaying an “intellectual fixation” (13) with merely historical origins and genealogies. According to Desmond, the Cynics have been let loose from the “dog-house” (4), and this makes scholarly reassessment possible. More important for new students, however, these classical writings are now potentially as captivating as they were for their original audiences.
Another virtue of Desmond's approach to a group of authors that spans from presocratic Greece through the later Roman Empire is the systematic economy of his presentation. The opening chapter on “Ancient Cynics and their times” (9–76) presents snapshots of thinkers that introduce their intellectual contribution to the Cynic movement and in many cases some of the charm they must have had for their listeners. Thinkers such as Diogenes, Crates, Bion, and Menippus were famous for their merciless debunking of customary beliefs and practices in the name of a life of natural freedom. They were not cynical, in the modern sense of “crass pessimism,” but Cynical in their willingness to question received opinion (even on the most sacred topics) with the plain evidence available to human reason. In this respect, according to Desmond, the intellectual efforts and outlook of the Cynics are eerily contemporary. They were courageous in the face of the claims of religion, they flatly condemned slavery, and their assumptions about the powers of human reason gave their investigations a scientific quality similar to our own. Desmond goes even further in his appraisal of Cynic relevance for us (following L. E. Navia) in summarizing their intellectual exhortations: “live simply, scorn unnecessary desires, do not follow the slavish crowd but speak the truth clearly in righteous war against untruth and, most of all, cultivate the virtue of philanthropia [love of human beings] and learn to love others now, for it is from this that everything else will follow” (236).
It is very difficult for contemporary readers to disagree with Desmond's final assessment, but the historical picture of Cynicism provided in the book's opening chapters leaves this reader with serious reservations about attributing these sentiments to the Cynics themselves. First, the history of Cynicism is a “mad jigsaw puzzle” (8), and Desmond's efforts to indentify unity in such a wide variety of thinkers likely goes too far. Generalizing the trajectory of a school that spans such a wide swath of time almost necessarily leads to oversimplifications that appear too familiar to us. It is hard to imagine a pestering, barking, snarling, cantankerous, and preachy individual who takes pleasure in shamelessly flouting all that society holds sacred nodding in calm agreement with the conclusion that above all we should learn to love each other. There may have been individual Cynics who held this view, but Diogenes, Crates, or Menippus? The issues regarding general claims are further compounded by the principled decision of many Cynics to avoid writing altogether (10, 79). Desmond's attempt is noble, but much of the later chapters of this book depend on the explication of a philosophy whose “original is lost amid a hall of mirrors, a kaleidoscope of shifting and proliferating images” (39). Surely it is the amorphous character of the subject which allows Desmond to trace the Cynic legacy from antiquity through medieval Christianity, and finally to all who resolutely “do their own thing” (209).
My negative assessment of Desmond's broad attempt to present the unity and relevance of the Cynical tradition is not meant to deter from the use of this book in the classroom. Indeed, the historical and thematic sections could prove to be very valuable for teachers and students who have a sense that the happiness promised by intellectual freedom is a real possibility. The single-minded effort of the Cynics to distinguish the natural from the conventional, the necessary desires from the unnecessary, and to cultivate a mind that is truly free, can serve as a powerful introduction to the perennial questions addressed so directly by classical philosophy. For example, why is it that the single-minded effort of the Cynics resulted in such a sporadic legacy, while that of Socrates—through the works of Aristophanes, Xenophon, and Plato—survives almost completely extant? According to Desmond, Socrates was very similar to the Cynics except they were much more assured in their skepticism. “They seem to know that ideas and traditional customs are all corrupting, that nature and the external world cannot be understood and that all one can know is the present” (16, emphasis in original). If Desmond is correct, however, why was it the Cynics who were compelled to evangelize their teachings? The unmistakable common thread running from the early Cynics to Ancient Rome is the moralistic character of the Cynical enterprise, even when attacking traditional morality (e.g., 89–95). Would they be so preachy, pestering, and barking if they truly knew that reason could only understand the present? Perhaps greater attention to this issue would serve to uncover an aspect of the search for freedom the Cynics themselves missed.
In order to address these deeper issues concerning the intellectual consistency of Cynicism, readers will have to go beyond Desmond's current effort. Surely, however, this is exactly the type of reaction an introductory text should provoke. Cynics should serve as powerful evidence to students that they are not alone or first in their search for a life free of delusion. Desmond has done a service by making their thought more accessible.
