No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
Keivandokht Ghahari argues that the political language of modern Iran is shaped by three major discourses: “national-modernist,” “socialist,” and “Islamic.” This study, which is based on her Ph.D. dissertation, undertakes an analytical examination of three influential journals—Kaveh (1916–22), Iranshahr (1922–27), and Ayandeh (1925–28)—which represented the dominant currents of “national-modernism” during the years marked by the emergence of Reza Shah (1925–41).
Ghahari uses the term “national-modernist” for this dominant ideational pattern based on her identification of notions of “nation” and “progress” presented in the three journals. Each called for a strong central government to create a unified Iran by means of a strong army and “education for all.” For the “national-modernists,” the creation of an Iranian nation-state represented the fundamental prerequisite for Iran's progress; they believed that only through these means could the political independence and territorial integrity of Iran be maintained.
Considering the hegemonic significance and the changing meaning of these terms in Iran's political discourse, Ghahari perceives her work as “a contribution to the research of Iran's modern political culture.” Her work does fill a gap in contemporary research. It is a successful discourse analysis of a period of Iranian development that until the Islamic Revolution was so emotionally charged that it virtually precluded dispassionate research. Ghahari's work is therefore an example of the increasing professionalism of Iranian social scientists who have learned to deal with their own history in an increasingly detached manner. Her book is even more remarkable for its empirical focus on the socio-genetical and psycho-genetical driving forces of this history, with the emphasis placed on the latter. Nevertheless, her examination lacks the appropriate conceptual precision. For instance, Ghahari describes the “setting of conditions” under which the aforementioned journals were published. She points out non–Iranian challenges to Iranian nationalism such as colonialism, Pan-Turkism, and Pan-Arabism, and carefully highlights the “dangers for Iran's political independence” as observed by the “national-modernists.” But she does not have a concept of the dynamics of self-esteem in inter-state relations. That said, one has to acknowledge that Ghahari's work offers excellent empirical proof of the relevance of the inter-statial dynamics of self-esteem between the established colonial powers and the weaker semi-colonial Iranian state. She examines “national-modernism” as a thrust of assimilation among sectors of the professional bourgeoisie, which was indeed a function of their “identification with the aggressor” and which could be understood as a defensive strategy adopted by Iranian intellectuals, who then became the carriers of nation-state building process between the Constitutional Revolution (1906) and the Islamic Revolution (1979).
Indeed, the modernization of the Iranian state took place as a result of the identification of parts of the Iranian establishment and the professional bourgeoisie with the colonial aggressor. They tried to achieve the sovereignty of Iran through “progress,” by which they meant modernizing the Iranian state and society according to the model of the more powerful states. Ghahari's careful content analysis of the axiomatic creeds and value preferences of the “national-modernists,” as well as of their socially and culturally critical diagnoses of Iran's developmental problems, constitutes the main component of her book. The normative image of Iran's social reality, which stems from the “national-modernists”’ desire for self-assertion as proud Iranians vis-à-vis the colonial powers and the emerging “Pan” movements in the Middle East, is Ghahari's primary interest. Essentially, she examines the changes in the needs and desires of parts of the professional bourgeoisie as they were manifested in the axiomatic creeds and value preferences of the “national-modernists” as a prerequisite for the emergence of an authoritarian modernism.
The examination of the constraints steering the behavior and sentiment of the “national-modernists” is a practical de-mystification of Iran's recent history, which is often understood as the history of an “autocracy” affording no further explanation. Ghahari's analysis reconstructs how and why its emergence was discursively prepared by elements of the professional bourgeoisie, who perceived the “iron fist” of Reza Shah as necessary to enforce and promote progress, which in itself was seen as the unalterable precondition of Iran's sovereignty under the perceived double pressure of inter-statial power balances and the efficacy of the clergy having a far-ranging influence on the Iranian masses’ behavior and sentiment.
The book is organized into four chapters. In Chapters 1 and 2, Ghahari analyzes the general historical background, then the establishment of the three journals she studies. The “dangers for the political independence and integrity of Iran” are examined in Chapter 3. Through content analysis of these journals, Ghahari elaborates what they have in common and what distinguished each from the others. In addition, she analyzes the ways in which each of the three journals explicated “political independence through nation-building” and “political independence through progress”. The differences between them are shown by their different emphases on institutional and habitual dimensions for the development of Iran. Quite remarkable is the highlighted importance of “mentality” and “social habits” as problems of development, which the “national-modernists” believed they could solve through massive education programs. In Chapter 4, Ghahari concludes by assessing the effects of the national-modernist ideology and providing a short survey of its further development in the more recent history of Iran.
Ghahari's book is not only a contribution to the de-mystification of recent Iranian history; it is also an excellent empirical contribution that provides the basis for efforts toward a theoretical conceptualization necessary for explaining problems of modernization in less-developed societies. Therefore, it will be valuable not only to Iran specialists but also to scholars dealing with problems of social development in general. Had the author utilized the results of her excellent empirical study for a more substantial conceptualization, she would have complemented her profound analysis with a corresponding synthesis. Unfortunately, that is still far from common in the present atmosphere of institutional separation between “empiricists” and “theorists.”
Michael Fischer assisted in the translation of this review.