During its 71-year rule the Partido Revolucionario Institutional (Revolutionary Institutional Party, PRI) had mediated access to the plazas by the drug-trafficking organisations (DTOs) in return for kickbacks and a restraint on violence. Mexico's political openings disrupted these long-standing arrangements, requiring drug lords to assert their dominance through force and fuelling a spike in violence. In 2006, following hotly contested elections and with his legitimacy tainted by allegations of fraud, President Felipe Calderón ordered the deployment of more than 40,000 troops to break the DTOs into smaller and more easily defeatable entities. The criminal groups responded to the offensive by shifting their alliances, diversifying their criminal portfolios, intensifying the recruitment of marginalised youths and stepping up the fighting. Government forces have killed or arrested thousands of suspected traffickers and seized significant amounts of illicit substances, weapons and money, yet few convictions have been obtained and the drug flows continue unabated. Meanwhile, corruption, money laundering and social exclusion have been tackled with much less enthusiasm. As homicides, kidnappings, extortions and forced disappearances surge, the trauma is spreading, particularly in drug-trafficking hotspots such as the US–Mexico border city, Ciudad Juárez.
Drug trafficking in and out of Mexico has sparked a torrent of journalistic texts, but relatively little academic writing. Howard Campbell's ethnographic study of the El Paso/Juárez corridor, though focusing on earlier periods, could not be more timely. This collection of oral histories of drug traffickers and counter-drug officials examines the border narco-world through the eyes of first-hand participants. In order to decode their experiences the author coined the term ‘drug war zone’, a concept that refers to a geographically and culturally circumscribed space that links drug producers, smugglers and consumers to their counterparts in law enforcement. Campbell, an anthropology professor in El Paso, was able to research this secretive and perilous world by targeting his interviewees through snowball sampling. Setting moral judgment aside, he explores who the traffickers and anti-drug agents are, how they operate, why they chose their respective activities and how these affected their lives. Divided into two parts, the book combines each account with an introductory note that adds an analytical touch to the revealing but rather descriptive histories. The chronicles in turn are framed by an introduction and a conclusion that offer a perceptive view of the narco-culture, the DTOs' organisational complexity, the meanings of drug killings, and the ways in which the infrastructure of Ciudad Juárez facilitates rather than impedes drug trafficking.
The first section of the volume presents drug smugglers, sellers and users as well as victims of narco-violence, whilst underscoring both historical and contemporary aspects of drug activity in the El Paso/Juárez area. Through the collage of interviews Campbell traces the changes that Mexican drug trafficking underwent during the 1970s and 1980s, from small-scale and more localised factions to the larger and technologically more sophisticated groups that dominate today. In doing so, the author sheds light on drug-smuggling techniques and distribution networks on both sides of the border. One conspicuous tale, charting the ascent to power of a former female drug boss, offers snapshots of the glitzy lifestyle and gendered dimensions of the male-dominated drug world. Another story that stands out concerns a heroin addict and dealer who grew up among relatives involved in petty drug trafficking and decided early on that he wanted to follow their career path. The account is noteworthy for demonstrating not only how the family can provide a path into the drug trade, but also how police and judicial corruption makes this business possible. Taken together, the chapters in the first half of the book emphasise that in places such as Ciudad Juárez marginality and unemployment create a steady supply of low-level drug operatives. More significantly, they show that smuggling and vice are so ingrained in the border culture that they are considered an inevitable fact of life rather than deplorable acts.
The second segment of the book addresses the practices and reflections of drug enforcement officials, mostly from the United States. Here Campbell issues a scathing criticism of US drug policy, which has traditionally focused on eradication and interdiction and has long been informing international drug policy. The author fittingly condemns this approach to drug control as wasteful and counter-productive, since prohibition has not only failed to stop the flow of illegal drugs but has in fact created a hugely profitable market for illicit substances. Aside from supplying insights into drug-busting techniques, these chapters show that attempts to secure the US–Mexico border fully are futile, since smugglers rapidly adapt to changing circumstances. Similarly instructive is the story about a Juárez policeman, which points at the myriad ways in which corruption networks connect law enforcement and criminals in Mexico. What emerges from these accounts is the acute scepticism of US anti-drug officials towards the policy they are tasked to implement. The most telling chapter concerns a retired customs agent who joined forces with other former colleagues to call for a different approach to drug use and trafficking, one that promotes regulation over prohibition and medical care over incarceration. Lastly, an interview with a Mexican journalist, highlighting the DTOs' manipulation of news coverage, serves as a reminder that the narco-war is as much about military confrontations as about the battle of ideas.
Campbell's study of the El Paso/Juárez drug war zone is well researched and accessibly written. Given its anthropological nature, the work does not lend itself to generalisations, but its real strength lies in the author's exposure to insiders in the narco-world. In rich detail Campbell shares insights into the drug trade's impact on communities and individuals, drug-related corruption, the nexus between social exclusion and delinquency, the functioning of the DTOs, narco-culture and Mexico's insertion in international crime networks and global power structures. A comprehensive bibliography allows readers to pursue these themes in greater depth. Although the book may be more suited to individuals with an advanced knowledge of the Mexican drug industry, it constitutes an invaluable resource for anyone seeking a greater sociological understanding of drug trafficking in Latin America. Ultimately, Campbell's analysis not only reveals the drug war zone as more complex than it is generally depicted, but can also serve to stimulate a rethinking of current anti-drug policies.
