Recreation of historical events is a common community experience. In Panama, for example, every 25 February the Kuna re-enact their 1925 revolution in which they gained autonomy for their comarca. E. Gabrielle Kuenzli examines another similar theatrical expression in Bolivia in her recent book Acting Inca (University of Pittsburgh Press, 2013). Typically these plays are more a reflection of contemporary community concerns and dynamics than an accurate depiction of historical events.
It is through this lens that anthropologist Jean Muteba Rahier expertly uses a local expression of the Catholic celebration of Epiphany to examine the evolution of socio-economic dynamics in rural Afro-descendant communities in Ecuador's coastal province of Esmeraldas. In Europe, Epiphany is celebrated on 6 January to commemorate the visit of the three magi to the baby Jesus. In Esmeraldas, the celebration is expanded to three days in which community members assume the personas of a white, Indian and black king, sometimes with one day dedicated to a commemoration of each of these kings. Rather than a recreation of a European religious tradition, in Esmeraldas the play becomes a reflection of how race, class and gender are currently constructed in a local community.
Rahier roots his study in dissertation research that he conducted in Santo Domingo de Ónzole in 1990. He contrasts this play with one that he had research assistants observe in the neighbouring community of La Tola that same year. He then compares those expressions with historical memories of the play in La Tola in the 1970s and a return visit to Santo Domingo de Ónzole in 2003. As a result, rather than a study of an adaptation of a European tradition to local Afro-descendant communities, this book uses the play as a lens through which to study changes in internal community dynamics.
A theme that runs through the book is how modernity changes tradition. In 1990, Santo Domingo de Ónzole was a fairly homogenous and relatively isolated community while La Tola was more diverse in racial and class terms, as well as more connected to the outside world. As a result, the play in Santo Domingo de Ónzole was larger and more dynamic than the one in La Tola. Some 15 years earlier when La Tola was more isolated and more homogenous, more community members took an interest in the play. Likewise, 15 years later, with the disruptions of outmigration and the passing of an older generation of women who organised the festival, the traditions in Santo Domingo de Ónzole had begun to fade. The incursion of evangelical Christianity also shifted the religious meaning of the festival.
Women played a dominant role in the planning and execution of the Festival of the Kings, and this aspect of the play opens up the potential for a fascinating discussion of the gendered dynamics found in Afro-Ecuadorian communities. Rahier casts the festival as a Carnivalesque inversion of the social order. Borrowing the terminology of anthropologist Norman Whitten's pioneering research in the area in the 1960s, he describes community members as engaged in a serial polygyny that privileges male sexual virility and mobility over female material interests. Men want their sexual freedom, while women are better served by commitment. According to Rahier, men see women as inferior. Their drinking and fighting provides them with opportunities to express their macho characteristics.
A sexual inversion allows women to satirise the sexual aggression and discrimination they face on a daily basis. Although Rahier does not explore the topic in much detail, the play can be understood through a Foucaultian lens as a safety valve for letting off steam before pressure builds to a social explosion. Underscoring this interpretation, women in La Tola, where the play had lost its importance by 1990, enjoyed greater economic independence due to commercial contacts with the outside world than their counterparts in Santo Domingo de Ónzole and hence did not need to let off steam to the same degree.
The immediate ethnic landscape also influences the way in which the community portrays the play. Santo Domingo de Ónzole is closer to a Chachi community, and as a result its play includes a significant indigenous component. In contrast, La Tola has less contact with Chachi communities and as a result they play less of a role there. La Tola, however, has more contact with the dominant mestizo culture, and those racial tensions are reflected in its play. Revealingly, the Chachi are portrayed as ‘coloured’ because in the community ‘black’ is normative and hence not seen as a colour. Nor do community members identify as Afro-descendants. Rahier contends that they have no sense of themselves as being members of an African diaspora, and that terminology such as ‘Afro-Esmeraldian’ or ‘Afro-Ecuadorian’ is a product of an academic construct that does not reflect local realities.
When Rahier returns to Santo Domingo de Ónzole, he immediately becomes the expert on how the play was traditionally celebrated and community members turn to him for advice and material support. Being forced into an active role as a participant in an event of his academic interest has led to no small amount of consternation on Rahier's part; his experiences underscore the reality that despite our best efforts, we are part of the world around us and we cannot separate ourselves from it.
