Whenever a new book on spirituality comes along, my usual response is to ask whether we need another one; or, somewhat more cynically, to employ my own rather meagre spiritual resources in asking God to put an end to all this spirituality business so that we can get back to talking about religion and the religious. But David Augsburger is an Anabaptist so there is a historical legitimacy to his desire to write on the subject, and he sets forth a view of spirituality that is intelligent, coherent and practical.
His basic argument is that the prevailing spirituality models today are either monopolar (concerned with the discovery of an unfolding self) or bipolar (concerned with the dual discoveries of depth of self and the height of the transcendent God). He presents a tripolar model (concerned with the journey into the human soul, the quest for communion with the divine and the commitment to love and serve the neighbour). He traces this third model to Jesus, its greatest teacher, model and initiator, notes that it has always had its proponents throughout the history of the church, but, as far as a collective movement is concerned, its most significant manifestation is in ‘the larger movement of the left wing of the Reformation known as Anabaptists, in the sixteenth century’ (p. 18).
The Anabaptists
have sought to live out a tripolar spirituality grounded in a restitution of the radical teachings of Jesus and his followers. The seriousness with which they have practised this three-dimensional covenanting with God is evident in their communion liturgy, which asks for a threefold pledge of loyalty and radical willingness to suffer for the sake of God and neighbour as the full meaning of remembering Christ's death. (p. 19)
He emphasises that tripolar spirituality is neither the invention nor the property of any one Christian group, but notes that emerging churches around the world, renewal groups in historic confessions, creative experiments in the practice of discipleship and parachurch groups involved in training persons in discipleship often turn to the Anabaptist movement for their inspiration and guidance.
He identifies eight practices of discipleship reflective of tripolar spirituality, and presents them as characteristics of what is involved in the dual act of following and knowing Jesus. They are radical attachment, stubborn loyalty, tenacious serenity, habitual humility, resolute nonviolence, concrete service, authentic witness and subversive spirituality. A chapter is devoted to each.
The opening chapter on radical attachment, which draws on the psychology of attachment (especially as reflected in the relationship of the mother and infant), emphasises that discipleship begins with the question, ‘Jesus, what do you want me to do?’, and proposes that imitation of Jesus the Christ is at the heart of discipleship. One forms, as it were, a ‘Jesus-Attachment’, and becomes ‘attuned’ to what Jesus does, to who Jesus is and to how he makes himself known. This feature of tripolar spirituality is also found in bipolar models of spirituality, but if the bipolar model centres on the self looking into the face of Jesus, the tripolar model gives greater emphasis to the claim that Jesus is to be found in the faces of others. Yes, look unto Jesus, but also look where Jesus is looking and follow his gaze. The other seven practices of discipleship are manifestations, as it were, of this central – and centring – practice of radical attachment.
Major emphases of the book are the vital importance of serving others, of loving one's enemies, of practising nonviolence and of not blindly and obediently serving one's nation. Anecdotal material is used to illustrate the practice described. As we would expect from a book on spirituality, each chapter concludes with recommendations for meditating on the practice described; several of these are hymns from the Aanabaptist tradition and some are ‘peditations’ – an innovative variation on the stations of the cross or the labyrinth in which one walks while reading a parable or segments of the Sermon on the Mount set to verse.
This is a fine book on spirituality, one that successfully challenges the common complaint that advocates of spirituality are usually weak on service, ethics, justice and peace-making. My single complaint is that this is a spirituality for those who are in a position to help others: he tells a wonderful story about an anonymous Good Samaritan whom he encountered as a young pastor in the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia (pp. 99–101). The Good Samaritan story is not, however, only about doing good for someone else, but also about accepting assistance from a person whom one despises. Is there a spirituality for those who have no choice but to accept the assistance of others? This form of spirituality could perhaps be teased out of the chapters on loyalty and humility, bur I think it deserves a chapter of its own.
