Ghosts pose a particular phenomenological problem. On the one hand, they appear — rendering themselves sensible to the bodies of the living (above all, through the sense of sight). On the other, they resist full disclosure — as at once related to but distinct from the embodied subjects who behold them.
In western critical traditions, the history of this problem stretches back to Homer. Already in the Iliad and Odyssey, we hear of epic protagonists wrestling with the shadowy ontology of the dead — nowhere more so than in the eleventh book of the Odyssey. The souls (psychai) who/which Odysseus summons up in this Nekyia prove to be wholly ambiguous: although seen and heard, they lie perpetually beyond any physical or figurative grasp. Particularly poignant is the moment when Odysseus comes face to face with the apparition (eidolon) of his mother, Anticlea. Odysseus tries three times to embrace his mother. But three times does her shady appearance slip through Odysseus’ fingers — ‘like a shadow or even a dream’ (Od. 11.207). ‘This is the appointed way with mortals when one dies’, Anticlea explains. ‘For the sinews no longer hold the flesh and bones together, but the strong might of blazing fire destroys these, as soon as the life leaves the white bones, and the spirit, like a dream, flits away, and hovers to and fro’ (Od. 11.218–22).
Patrick Crowley's compelling book explores the afterlife of such ‘phantom images’ in the Roman cultural imagination. In particular, he shows how ideas about ‘ghosts’ could be applied to the visual art: how the virtuality of the dead provided a powerful metaphor for thinking through the virtual reality of sculptural and pictorial imagery. The point was crucial to the pioneering studies of Jean-Paul Vernant, who discussed how the word Homer used for Anticlea's ‘apparition’ — eidolon — became a standard term for ‘image’. C. engages head-on with Vernant (31–6), just as he does with, inter alios, Kant (30–1), Herder (204–5) and Derrida (2–3, 204). Above all, though, he analyses the reception of Greek ideas among Roman writers, thinkers and artists. ‘How … could the shadowy, quasi-insubstantial nature of the ghost be conveyed through the obdurate materiality of stone and paint?’, he asks; ‘And how can pictorial strategies a once disclose and inform ways of seeing?’ (1).
To answer these questions, C. does two things. First, he starts out from the ‘basic premise that the ancient vocabulary for images and pictures in the broadest sense — whether perceptual, imaginative, or depictive — situate the ghost at the very heart of epistemological concerns about depiction and vision in classical antiquity’ (1–2). Second, he demonstrates how the insubstantial figure of the ‘ghost’ substantiates Roman cultural thinking about the status of images, and vice versa — ‘ut pictura phantasma’, in C.'s pithy formulation (29).
This is a book that will speak to all manner of scholarly interests. Although centred around Roman ‘ghosts’, C. deals with ancient ideas about representation at large, no less than cultural economies of seeing. There are four chapters, in addition to a wide-ranging introduction and envoi (on mirror images and ‘forms of spectrality’, 223). Along the way, the book touches upon a host of visual media — not just sarcophagi and reliefs, but also frescoes, mosaics, free-standing statues, textiles, frescoes, gems, mirrors and painted pottery. C. has an eye for intriguing and overlooked case studies (as with fig. 1.7, a first-century ringstone crafted from chalcedony, engraved with Prometheus crafting the first man, Pharenon). He is also expert in putting ancient visual materials into dialogue with literary texts — from the Elder Pliny and Quintilian (e.g. 144–6) to Augustine and beyond (e.g. 191, 210, 221–2). Particularly compelling is the way that C. weaves together the Greek and the Roman, flying in the face of a scholarly trend, especially prevalent in North America, of studying the two in effective scholarly apartheid. It is worth noting the archaeological underpinnings, too: issues of provenance and display are often decisive for interpreting individual visual motifs (as at 121–4, discussing the Charon mosaic in tomb 86 of the Isola Sacra Necropolis: fig. 2.10).
To my eyes, C. is at his most compelling when describing how attitudes developed within the ‘ancient Rome’ of his sub-title. In the latter part of the book, the figure of the ghost is used to trace the beginnings of a fundamental Kulturwandel in western art history: C. shows how late-antique ideas about Christ's post-resurrection apparition at once continued and overturned earlier Graeco-Roman epistemic attitudes to ghosts and images, no less than the visual practices that mediated them. ‘There is a marked shift in in terms of how this reflexivity takes shape in the cultural climate of the Second Sophistic when the fascination with Greek myth, philosophy, religion, and art played a crucial role in the shaping of an emergent historical self-consciousness in the Roman empire’, we are told (2). Ultimately, the book hints at a still grander subject: the rise of ‘mediaeval’ attitudes, modes of visual expression and forms of critical response — in short, the development of the ‘romantic’ as opposed to the ‘classical’. Hegel is one of the few western critical philosophers not to be discussed in the book, but to my mind, his ghost looms large throughout …
As is to be expected in a book as imaginative and stimulating as this, not everything will convince everyone. The thematic approach — oriented around particular case studies — sometimes comes at a cost to the integrity of the whole (especially in the first chapter, on ‘A grammar of ghosts’). There are also moments when the argument becomes obscured by associative leaps, or else tangled in points of detail. Still, for anyone interested in the status of the image in the Roman world, this book will be essential reading: in C.'s hands, the phenomenological challenge of experiencing or knowing the dead ‘ghosts’ into something still more epistemologically spooky — questions about the limits of pictorial representation, about the phenomenology of vision, and about the shifting role of the seeing subject.
