In Civic Passions: Seven Who Launched Progressive America (and What They Teach Us), Cecelia Tichi, William R. Kenan Jr. Professor of English at Vanderbilt University, provides a companion piece to her 2003 book, Exposés and Excess: Muckraking in America, 1900/2000. Each book highlights the linkages between the original Gilded Age and the present “new Gilded Age.” In Civic Passions, Tichi seeks to raise from relative obscurity seven progressive icons—Alice Hamilton, John R. Commons, Julia Lathrop, Florence Kelley, Louis D. Brandeis, Walter Rauschenbusch, and Ida B. Wells-Barnett—who helped to lift the United States out of the crises of the first Gilded Age.
In this volume dedicated “to Progressives Everywhere,” Tichi highlights the accomplishments of these past leaders in the hope that their citizen activism might inspire the progressives of today. Tichi concludes with the admonishment by Lathrop that “the new Progressives must refuse ‘the weary acceptance of apparent defeat’” (285). Contemporary scholars frequently draw attention to the original Gilded Age and responses by reformers of the Progressive Era, offering these insights as both inspiration and caution for potential modern activists.Footnote 1 It is also an established method to organize a book around mini-biographies, one per chapter, of influential individuals from the Progressive Era.Footnote 2
Tichi succeeds admirably in bringing the seven figures to life through the astute use of apposite details from autobiographies, biographies, and archival sources. Civic Passions is well-cited, though attributions occur only rarely in the text itself; at times, full sentences quoted from scholars stand alone without introduction or elaboration, the source given only in the endnotes. The deliberate omission of scholarly scaffolding from the text is jarring at times, though in looking carefully at Tichi's sources, it is possible to see how she deftly weaves captivating details from other sources into a riveting narrative. The body of the text reads more like literature than history. For example, John R. Commons “breakfasted on eggs and corncakes, potatoes and rhubarb, and coffee,” and Louis D. Brandeis's father read his letters “[a]s the blades of a high ceiling fan stirred the sultry Louisville air” (79, 164). “The brass cuspidor” that “surely caught Dr. Alice Hamilton's eye” at the National Lead Company captures the attention of the reader as well (29). Tichi heightens the literary experience through time shifts. She begins each chapter in medias res, catching her subjects in the midst of confronting major issues of their day. Tichi later provides flashbacks to “a personal, life-changing moment that crystallized his or her commitment to a career of civic progress” (xvi). The inclusion of these details is timed precisely to offer an understanding of these individuals' philosophies and contemporary perspectives and to set the stage for their ultimate activism.
Throughout the book, the Clarence Day family, as preserved in the writings of Clarence Day Jr., represents “the fixed views of late Victorian, Gilded Age America,” and is strongly contrasted with the visions of Hamilton, Commons, Lathrop, Kelley, Brandeis, Rauschenbusch, Wells-Barnett, and their compatriots. The continued references to the Days and their way of life serve as reminders of the contemporaneous American outlook against which Tichi's subjects felt compelled to rail.
At times, Tichi's interpretation of her subjects' relevance seems a bit thin. The chapter on Brandeis, for example, ends with two paragraphs that draw very heavily on the words of Philippa Strum, his biographer, without the sort of pithy details that make the rest of the book so engaging and more problematically, with little synthesis or assessment by Tichi herself. Tichi states at the outset that her subjects “stand as models of courage, innovation, intelligence, and the power of youthful energy harnessed for a lifetime of positive activism,” and these qualities are indeed evident in the lives of the individuals, but Tichi does not sufficiently develop this framework of analysis (xviii).
What she does provide are images of these subjects as palpable individuals, whose “lives and work speak to the present as if it were only yesterday” (27). At the end of Civic Passions, Tichi provides a list of suggested readings, noting the importance of “those who put these public figures on the public record” (287). Specialists wanting to understand the work and achievements of these seven more thoroughly would be well served by undertaking this additional reading. Tichi's book serves as a welcome overview, providing a rich sense of the immediacy and relevance of these activists' ideals and of the passion of their convictions.
