This volume is one more in a series that has appeared since 1974 and the first Bilad al-Sham conference at the University of Jordan. All conferences since have considered the geographical and historical affinities of that region, which was historically often part of larger imperial states from the Umayyads to the Ottomans. One of the continuing concerns of the organizers has been to overcome the idea that today's political boundaries are immutable and traceable to time immemorial. The result is a comparative perspective that enriches the historiography of this region. Students of late Ottoman and modern Middle Eastern history will profit from and enjoy the essays in this new volume.
The book treats the 19th and early 20th centuries, when the Ottoman Empire began a serious program of reform and when developments in world history brought that empire to an end by 1923, followed by its successors' independence by the 1940s. Displaying a coherence all too often lacking in edited works, these essays treat five broad themes: the Ottoman legacy, religion and cultural change, society and state building, the particular historical experience of Lebanon, and “From Early Resistance to Radical Nationalism in Syria,” namely, the roots of what became today's Syrian Arab Republic. This reviewer found the first two parts to be of greatest interest, but this is not to slight the others. Readers of this book, regardless of interest, will profit from all the essays here.
Thomas Philipp's important introduction concerns regional identities and regional political units in the early modern period. A fascinating analysis of the historical mental map of residents of Bilad al-Sham and of its subregions as it moved into modern times concludes that “. . .. Bilād al-Shām might have been a patchwork quilt of locally integrated regions, each with its own elites, and each independent from the other, but it all was politically still firmly embedded in the general frame of reference of the legitimacy of the Ottoman Empire” (p. 17). What changed in the 19th century was a greater regional integration under the auspices of the Tanzimat (a form of “recentralization”) and the acquisition of a new layer of geographical terms. Philipp discusses several later 19th-century Syrian historians who dealt with “Syria as a territorial entity throughout history, with a strong emphasis on the Phoenicians and the kingdom of Palmyra and hardly mentioning the Mamluk and Ottoman rule” (p. 25). This important shift in outlook had fateful consequences in the region during the 20th century.
Just as new geographical terminology and a new outlook came into being so too did new senses of the individual self. Fruma Zachs writes about cultural identity in the life of the intellectual, Khalil al-Khuri. She argues that the integration of Bilad al-Sham into the modern world economy produced a new bourgeoisie that, through print media, explored new circles of identity, Syrian, Eastern (as opposed to European), Ottoman, and Arab. Zachs finds much evidence that intellectuals defined themselves with fluidity and flexibility, in sharp contrast to the 20th century's unfortunate hardening of identities.
Stefan Weber links social change in Damascus with new architectural patterns, which he sees as barometers of changing times and as evidence of new habits and identities. He finds that the city's markets took on the form of the European arcade. The initiative here came from Ottoman governors, local municipalities, and individuals. Weber also stresses that in private houses, wall paintings of Istanbul predominated; this, he believes, is evidence of a continuing attachment to an overarching Ottoman identity: “The Ottoman capital was the main source of inspiration and symbol of modernization, like the steamboats in the Bosporus, flying the Ottoman flag” (p. 57).
The Tanzimat introduced municipal councils, new institutions that served to reinforce identification with one's locality. Jens Hanssen studies 100 members of Beirut's municipal council between 1868 and 1908. This collective biography is based primarily on Ottoman provincial yearbooks (salnames) and on the press. Under the Ottoman constitution of 1876, municipalities were endowed with important new powers. Even earlier, in the wake of the 1860 civil war in Lebanon (and the massacre of Christians in Damascus), the Ottoman government, under Fuat Paşa, imposed the 1858 Land Law on the growing city of Beirut in order to extract the revenues necessary to pay compensation to victims of the Mount Lebanon civil war. Another consequence of the land law's application was to extend urbanization beyond the walls of the old city and into the countryside, previously dominated by tax farmers. Hanssen finds that Beirut served as a magnet to attract new elites (he traces municipal council members' geographic and family ancestry to sustain this finding) and that “council members' privileged status generally preceded their election while a successful candidacy promised to turn social status into urban impact.” He concludes that “the municipality was a channel through which urban notables consolidated their control over the affairs of the city and the province and through which literary elites had the opportunity to influence the urban administration of their city” (p. 72).
As the cities of Syria grew, so did the educational opportunities they could offer. There was keen competition among varying educational systems—local, Ottoman, and foreign. Eugene Rogan takes as his starting point the view that European institutions indeed influenced the region's evolving educational systems but that “Europe's role was probably greater in setting an example of state education as a tool for shaping civic identity and allegiance than as a seedbed of nationalism” (p. 77). In Rogan's effective citations from Salih al-Tall's memoirs, we see evidence again of the fluidity of identities, both Ottoman and Arab. Damascus' Maktab ʿAnbar (an elite Ottoman high school), where al-Tall was a student, has had the reputation as a breeding ground for Arab nationalism. That reputation was founded on the memoirs of another graduate, Fakhri al-Barudi. Rogan believes that the latter, and his friends, constituted a minority of the student body. By reading the memoirs of both al-Tall and al-Barudi, Rogan concludes that “rather than a birthplace of Arabism, Maktab ʿAnbar was a powerful tool in forging a common Ottoman identity for Arabs and Turks alike in the last decades of the Hamidian era” (p. 81).
Three essays constitute Part II and concern religion and culture: Stefan Winter on the Nusayris before the Tanzimat, Itzchak Weismann on Sufi reformism and the rise of Arabism in Ottoman Syria (a subject he previously expounded on in a whole book), and James Gelvin on the lineages of nationalism in the region. Each essay breaks new ground. Gelvin's essay, in particular, tries to disentangle the cross-cutting trends in Arab nationalist thought, a topic of continuing interest in Bilad al-Sham.
Part III (Society and State Building) contains four essays by Stefan Wild, Najwa al-Qattan, Birgit Schaebler, and Abdallah Hanna. Here, too, are some interesting topics dealing with rapid and radical changes in people's conceptions of national boundaries, national identity, and the terrible experience of World War I.
Part IV, concerning Lebanon, has three essays by Ussama Makdisi, Maurus Reinkowski, and Carol Hakim. Makdisi revists the old controversy over the role of missionaries in Bilad al-Sham; he has much to offer the reader and shows particularly good understanding of trends in American historical writing on this subject. Reinkowski argues that understanding Ottoman policy in Mount Lebanon during the 19th century requires a comparative perspective that looks at Tanzimat reformers' efforts in other provinces and the ambiguous role of confessionalism empire wide. This Ottoman perspective is essential and long overdue; it is strongly supported by Ottoman archival material and other important sources. Carol Hakim, in turn, argues that there was nothing inevitable about the emergence of an independent Greater Lebanon in 1920; Maronite notables and intellectuals had entertained multiple ideas of a Lebanese polity, but once again, the Great War intervened and forced the outcome that in fact occurred.
Part V, with six essays, concerns resistance and national mobilization—primarily in Syria—between 1919 and 1958. This chronological chunk of modern Syrian history is increasingly the target of historians' attention. All six essays here shed new light on the northern Syrian revolts of 1919–21 (Fred Lawson), changing forms of consciousness in rural Syria from 1918–26 (Nadine Méouchy), the Great Arab Revolt of 1925–26 (Michael Provence), Zaki al-Arsuzi and the Alexandretta Crisis of 1936–39 (Dalal Arsuzi-Elamir), the League of National Action (initially a secret organization founded in the 1930s by students in European universities and well described by Khairia Kasmieh), and the evolution of political culture within the elite of Bilad al-Sham as reflected in the prolific autobiographies that date from the interwar period (Christoph Schumann).
This reviewer notes a welcome trend throughout this volume: the critical reexamination of idées reçues concerning geography, polity, nation, sect, and education. Much work, however, remains to be done on this exciting period of Bilad al-Sham's long history.
