John Arena's excellent book Driven from New Orleans: How Nonprofits Betray Public Housing and Promote Privatization is an unexpectedly gripping and much-needed account of the plight of public-housing residents in New Orleans, detailing the myriad ways in which Hurricane Katrina exacerbated the constellation of forces stacked against them. Where the federal government and city authorities, in collaboration with developers, had long levelled predatory eyes on public-housing projects in the city – branded “blight” by an increasingly dominant tourist industry – Katrina provided the opportunity to condemn the “big four” and, ultimately, Iberville, the last of New Orleans's projects. As Republican Congressman Richard Baker notoriously remarked soon after the storm, “finally we cleaned up public housing in New Orleans. We couldn't do it, but God did.” Far from suggesting that the demolition of public housing was inevitable, what is inspiring about Arena's narrative is its rejection of what it terms TINA: the idea, frequently voiced by former former British prime minister Margaret Thatcher, that “there is no alternative” to market fundamentalism.
Arena's story begins in the 1980s with the St. Thomas project, though the introduction provides various antecedents for what he characterizes as this latest round of “Negro removal.” As he shows, public housing was the child of the Depression and the progressive forces that sprang up as a response in the 1930s, but very soon it became linked to the state-subsidized “racially discriminatory suburbanization model” (xxx). Public housing became a way of dealing with the inner-city poor displaced by urban-renewal projects and highway construction after the Second World War. It has consequently been linked in the public mind with ghettoization, a principal organizing symbol for the antiurbanism that runs through much US discourse. But Arena's book paints a different picture.
While careful not to underplay the levels of poverty seen in the desperately underresourced and badly maintained projects, Arena points out that they were originally noted by the federal government not for their levels of poverty but for their potential for organizing. The much-maligned “density” of the projects – which became central to anti-public-housing rhetoric that centred on the need to “de-densify” the projects to make way for “mixed-income” developments – was precisely what cemented social relationships within the projects, opening the way for political activity. Thus what was eventually framed as the benevolent task of purging cities of the projects becomes another way of repressing not “blight” or crime or poverty, but dissent. As Arena explains, the administration of Lyndon B. Johnson paid particular attention to the kinds of collective action enabled by public housing in its attempts “to contain the black revolts sweeping U.S. urban centers in the mid-late 1960s.” Arena concludes that “the demolition of public housing communities at St. Thomas in New Orleans and across the country has destroyed not only badly needed affordable housing but political power, community identity, and neighborhood support systems, as well” (xxxiii).
As the most organized of New Orleans's public-housing projects, the privatization of St. Thomas involved a long struggle between resident–activists, primarily black women, and developers determined to get their hands on a piece of real estate sitting squarely in the midst of a riverfront neighbourhood marked for “revitalization.” Arena identifies two related factors in the ultimate success for developers. The first is the involvement of what Arena characterizes, following Adolph Reed, as the “black urban regime” that by this point was running New Orleans. Arena paints a picture of a cadre of black elites, beneficiaries of the civil rights movement, whose actions favoured big business against the interests of the working-class African Americans who remained their electoral base. The involvement of such figures provided cover for what was a racialized process that displaced the black poor. The second factor is the involvement of nonprofits, which Arena argues channelled opposition into consent, similarly providing apparently progressive cover for regressive and reactionary social policy. Thus, in the case of St. Thomas, residents opposing privatization were encouraged to set up their own nonprofit, which in turn was seduced by the idea that they would themselves run the “New St. Thomas.” While nonprofit arrangements like this seemingly offered the possibility of self-determination, they simultaneously removed the conversation about housing from the public sphere to the private, as well as placing tenant leaders in enviable new situations with financial incentives to sell out on the cause of social justice. Thus resident involvement in drafting the application for the euphemistically named HOPE VI grant – dreamed up by the Clinton administration as a way of replacing public housing with developments that would include only a fraction of the affordable units that previously existed – disarmed opposition while securing very little in the way of self-determination. The “New St. Thomas,” the name chosen by residents for the new development, was unilaterally renamed River Garden by developers.
Arena's extensive discussion of the role of nonprofits is a major contribution to understanding the demise of public housing, not just in New Orleans, but across the United States. Arena shows convincingly that while Katrina undoubtedly hastened the demolition of New Orleans's remaining public-housing projects in the storm's aftermath – by opening up a political context eager to reimagine the city as a “blank slate” – the process had begun long before the hurricane, and the post-storm scenario followed a similar pattern. Arena's own involvement in the campaign to save the Iberville project both immediately before and after Katrina tracks these continuities from the perspective of a participant observer. So while he partially endorses Naomi Klein's influential thesis about the role of shock and disaster capitalism in post-Katrina New Orleans, Arena insists that Klein's arguments must be mitigated by an acknowledgement of the role of cooptation and consent in the push towards privatization.Footnote 1 Here Arena shows the dilemmas of leftist politics within a neoliberal system, a system that has hijacked the leftist emphasis on agency and self-empowerment which is translated into self-help for those left unprotected by the state.
“Self-empowerment” in this context is precisely the demand that people pull themselves up by their own boot straps, signifying not liberation but rather the mechanisms of oppression. Given the fact that “betrayal” is a key theme for Arena, it seems important to emphasize that it is the “nonprofit complex” rather than those drawn into its net that emerges as culpable; this book occasionally drifts into a finger-pointing exercise whereby resident–activists are drawn as “collaborators” in a process that undeniably exploits them.
Arena's account of the betrayal on the part of the “black urban regime” enters into complex terrain and is, I think, less convincing. For Arena, black urban regimes across America have repeatedly sold out their working-class African American electorates because voters continue to rely on the notion of a common identity politics. Arena defines identity politics as “a postmodernism-informed worldview and theory of organizing that has risen in tandem with neoliberalism” (163). He argues against the disabling logic that suggests that only those who have experienced a particular oppression can fight against it. Such logic compartmentalizes social justice and assumes that politics can be derived from simplistically defined identities. But what is unacknowledged here is that Arena's text itself invests in a variant of identity politics in order to articulate this narrative of betrayal. The suggestion seems to be that the black elites running city hall have betrayed what should be their own racial allegiances. For Arena is not simply condemning those black politicians who relied on working-class African American electorates, but similarly identifies acts of betrayal on the part of those who relied on white majorities to achieve office. While Arena claims that his text is part of a critique of identity politics, this seems to be inconsistent with his dis-ease at the idea that black elites might be acting in their class interests rather than in response to their racial identities. As the text itself suggests, this is part of the paradoxical legacy of the civil rights movement, whose fight in the name of racial equality enabled social mobility only for a small minority of African Americans.
As the work of Michael Dawson shows, African Americans across the socioeconomic spectrum are more likely to hold views to the left of their white counterparts precisely because many are pulled away from their own economic interests in solidarity with working-class African Americans. But as Dawson's work also shows, conservative political ideologies that emphasize self-help have had strong footholds in black communities, rich and poor, since the nineteenth century.Footnote 2 The fact that both race and class are strong determinants in black political affiliations means that when it comes to questions of racial injustice, it is impossible to completely jettison identity politics in favour of class-based alliances, as Arena wants to do. Perhaps more importantly, the focus on the complicity of the ‘black urban regime’ obscures the fact that the post-Katrina neoliberal assault hit not just the black poor but New Orleans's black middle class, with the mass firing of approximately 4,500 predominantly African American schoolteachers.
Nonetheless, the fact that this book is so clearly and transparently informed by Arena's political outlook is part of what makes it so compelling. This is a meticulously researched and cogently argued account of the attack on public housing in New Orleans and the United States, and the squeezing of political dissent in a neoliberal age in which state authorities and “the nonprofit complex” have collaborated with business to plunder the public sphere. It is essential reading for anyone interested in neoliberalism, urban politics, and the ongoing disaster of gentrification and privatization in post-Katrina New Orleans. In peeling back the layers of neoliberal agency, Driven from New Orleans denaturalizes market logic to open up a political imaginary for “a society whose organizing principle is based on meeting human need” (226).
